Skip to main content
Loading video...

Venice Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 25:02

hey everybody today i'm talking about venice which is a one to five player board game designed by david tertzy and andrei novak this one takes around 90 minutes to play and this one is actually the first game of 2021 that i've played um this year so far so you know starting to get the new games in um and this one was released on kickstarter quite a while ago now there's been quite a few things preventing it from getting to the table but it's finally here and i've been able to play it now this one is also published by braincrack games and i believe this is the second game they've brought out since um they had a relatively successful hit with uh with ragusa a couple of years ago and i said this is the second line a game in that line of um of of titles so you can probably tell from the game box here the game is set in venice and it takes place on this big board here with all these different canals and different buildings dotted around each player is going to have a pair of these gondolas and a gondolier which you can see here is placed in the back of this boat like such you've got all these different buildings dotted around and you're going to potentially be placing your little kind of workers out on these buildings to get bonuses as you go and visit these different locations i should say this is the layout that's going to be much towards the end of the game you know this is actually particularly a two-player game that we've just finished um but yeah let's talk about the different things here because naturally with a lot of euro games there's a lot of things going on but the objective is to get victory points but you can get victory points in quite a few different ways so in addition to the main board here you're also going to have your own individual player boards

and these are going to do a good job of explaining or breaking down the different phases in the game and what you're going to do from from kind of part to part and you've also got two tracks here and these two tracks are quite important the first one being scrolls um scrolls are quite an important resource because they let you um kind of negate taking certain penalties which i'll explain shortly and they also serve as a kind of an extra resource to pick up and deliver to different locations because a lot of these or a lot of the ways you're going to be getting points in this game is by using these um order cards like so here where you'll have a certain criteria such as this one where it says um you know take two cubes uh two grey cubes and three orange cubes and deliver them to the consulate and if i was to do that then i would get eight victory points and six coins so that's going to be a big portion of what you're going to do and how you're going to going to be getting your points again by visiting these different locations picking up the relative items and delivering them to the appropriate place the second track here the intrigue track is going to be quite important because it can really make or break your game because the player at the end of the game who has the most intrigue is going to be automatically disqualified from winning so you always want to be making sure that you haven't got more um intrigue than everybody else so let's talk about how the actual game plays out and how these things are going to actually accumulate and how they're going to happen so the first option we're going to have is to play an influence card now influence cards are pretty scarce you're not going to get too many of them throughout the game but they let you do lots of different things and kind of break the rules and get bonuses but normally

suffering intrigue as a result of that so for example here this um this entry card bribe the foreman lets you move one of your workers right to the top space here which i'll explain shortly how powerful that can be and but to do that you're going to have to suffer intrigue which again is not a good thing the second thing you're going to do is to move your gondolia so moving your gondolia is going to be how you're going to traverse the board so as i said you've got one gondolier but you've got two um you've got two boats themselves so and the first thing you're gonna do is to actually stay in the same boat from from round to round you're gonna have to pay a fee of three coins so you can't just keep staying in the same boats if you can't afford to do so and from then on you are going to kind of map out your turn or what you're going to do so the first thing you're going to do is you're going to have to move at least one space and but the first space is free and as you can see from all the different kind of canals here you've got coins dotted got dotted throughout and these are going to be the fees you're going to have to pay to travel down that particular canal so this first spot here would be free but if i wanted to go to to here for example then i would have to go you know that'd be free i passed this building then i'd have to pay two and then i'd end up here for example of course i could just go down this way if i wanted to but let's say i wanted to pass this building now for every building that i pass i already have a worker on i'm going to get the bonuses for so for example in this one i drove past where i've got my yellow worker i would be able to take two scrolls and be able to take an orange cube and if i was to do that i would place an

orange cube in my boat um in order to basically work towards an objective and then whenever i stop i am going to take the um the relative bonus there as well um as you can see here some of the buildings are actually painted onto the board i mean for example this saint mark square we can get two coins and draw a couple of intrigue i'm sorry draw a couple of order cards but let's say i was um i ended my turn uh here which relates to this building if i didn't have a worker there then i would deploy one and get the bonus but if i did have a worker there then i would move my worker up to the next spot and get both the bonuses if i if i wanted to that is but that's also going to tie into a bit of interaction because if a another player's piece was here like so and then i moved my my um my worker up it would actually push the guy um already there onto the next spot meaning that when they go there next then they are going to get a um a better bonus than what they would do if they didn't if i didn't push them up there are a few other restrictions and things you have to bear in mind when traveling for example whenever you sail past another player's boat or another player's color then you are going to have to either gain an intrigue or pay a scroll to not take an intrigue and that is going to apply to the other players too you can pass your other boats as well and if you do that you can swap cubes between the two so that's the way you can kind of jockey your different resources to work towards those orders so the second or the third thing you're going to do is to move your manned boat which means you

resolve meetings and past workers and that is basically triggering the different buildings on the way um and the fourth thing is to hand in a mission that's optional so if you have a completed a completed order you can take a almost a bonus action to cash in that order and when you cash in that order not only are you going to get the rewards depicted you're also going to get an ongoing bonus or maybe an instant bonus and you've got three opportunities to do that so as you can see from my example here i've already completed three objectives and then from then on these are going to give me um going to give me rewards for example here this one says when you complete a mission i may pay two coins to draw an influence card or if i lose if i choose to lose three intrigue so if i lose three intrigue on my turn i get to gain uh two victory points and then uh for every second scroll i gain on a turn i gain a coin now if i ever gain more than my three i can choose to replace these ones and just put my other completed missions to the side face down like so which can be important because whenever you go to certain spots um for example to draw more order cards then i have to pay tax for each mission i've already completed so it's got a slight little catch-up mechanism there where if you are running ahead on missions you're gonna have to pay a bit of an additional fee to um to take more now i should say what triggers the end of the game um is this track here so you've got this kind of um council track which is going to be another way to get points um again it's kind of just uh just your standard track with whoever's the highest gets points um more or more points than the people

below them um or when the order deck runs out and the uh the order deck is going to kind of fluctuate on the number of players there is so you know in a two-player game i think there's only nine cards um and as it gets more and more there's going to be a few more cards in the deck um and as i said here the the um the final thing is to activate and advance the building that you end on or where you dock which is when as i said you either deploy a new worker on that spot or move it along to the next quadrant so let's take a look at what some of these buildings do so all of these buildings in the first quadrant you're going to take a resource and i should say the resources or at least the the resources that boat can contain are limited to five but you can kind of swap in and out the ones that you want um but yeah you've always always got to bear in mind that you are limited to a strict value of five and as you can see here they fit the boats pretty nicely and there's and the other options are kind of things like you know gaining money or gaining intrigue um well as you do with both here uh you can gain point gain coins and gain points uh you can pay scrolls to gain points you can you know get get intrigued or all the other players gain an intrigue you can draw entry cards um you can climb the track you can even build these bridges which are these things here and these bridges are useful because not only do they um make it free to travel from one spot to another but when another player has to sell through those bridges they have to gain an intrigue or when you sell through those bridges you actually gain a coin rather than spend a coin

and so yeah the buildings are all pretty similar or at least not wildly different to each other but sometimes they specialize in different things such as losing intrigue as i said building bridges climbing the track um and all different things like that so yeah that's pretty much how the game is going to come together as i said it's going to end when somebody reaches this spot on this council track or when the order cards or when the final order card is drawn the game marker is going to go to the um to the end endgame trigger marker here where you're going to play two more rounds before the final scores are evaluated any excess resources can be used to um basically uh negate any influence you've taken so i think it's four coins can move you down and influence that's move you down an intrigue and two scrolls so i could pay like if i had two scores here i could pay them both to move my intrigue down further which again is extremely important because if you have the most intrigue then you are automatically going to lose so let's talk about some of the mechanisms in venice so first off i tend to really enjoy pick up and deliver games i think i'm somewhat in a minority there i know it's not the most popular of um of mechanisms but i think venice does that quite well you know it's pretty simple pick up deliver where you've got to just collect your cubes and move it from one and place to another um however there are things to bear in mind uh not only strategically because you want to plan your routes by being able to afford those routes but also tactically because if you want to go by particular spots and maybe where you've got workers deployed so you can get those bonuses and um kind of resources and bonuses on

the way then you're going to have to bear in mind that you're going to have to take the intrigue which is not only going to be a decision for yourself but also a decision that might be a net gain by giving more or other players um intrigue because you know if i have a bank full of these scrolls that i could potentially choose to or afford to take that intrigue more than my opponents do which will give them intrigue and not me so that's quite an interesting decision there and kind of an extra wrinkle while planning the routes to build towards these um to build towards these deliveries you've got some pretty standard um track uh you know euro track here you know whoever gets the highest gets the most points this is very standard um the building mechanism i think is really clever i do like this um a fair bit you know where you initially you know you only get the one bonus but as you end up docking them more and more you're gonna get more bonuses and not only that you've got that additional wrinkle of when you move up you've got a bear in mind that you could be giving other players a bonus by pushing them up and i like the fact that you know you only move up when you end there but you get the bonuses when you just do a drive by and that can create some pretty um you know pretty strong turns if you go past a certain region like for example here if i drove if i sail past these three buildings that's quite a few um quite a few resources in one turn um and you can probably get quite a bit done as you deploy more and more workers onto the board and i also quite like this this slight engine building aspect here as you complete more missions you get to um plug these powers into the bottom which will give you ongoing effects and that's really nice you know just they're not they're not overly game breaking but they're still worth having and can give you a nice little kick when

you want it to so and that kind of ties into the decisions as well because you do have to manage your resources quite carefully here money can get quite tight if you want to keep taking ambitious tones by saving further and further across the board and of course you know you're always going to be having to decide whether you want to move your um move your gondolia from one boat to the other um you're gonna have to automatically do that unless you pay that um that fee of three coins which again is gonna keep digging away at your bank balance so yeah there's quite a few decisions here um you know what route you're going to go and what buildings you're going to invest in um and all things like that so it's not a it's not a game where you're just going to wing it you do have to plan your turns accordingly what you're going to do so you can be efficient so yeah there's there's some decent decisions here um although it's not massively taxing and what you are what you want to do you know i think pick up and deliver games do a good job of um you know i've given you something to work towards not only strategically but tactically as well um the time investment of the game i think the game takes around 90 minutes to play i think maybe at the higher play account it's going to take maybe or quite noticeably longer than that but there are certain things that are tinkered depending on that play account such as the you know the deck being um being extended et cetera so yeah just bear that in mind that if you want to play constantly at a five play account then it's going to go beyond that 90 minute mark um uptime is you know decisions are they they can drag down quite a bit and sometimes you can find yourself um

you know drifting away on other players turns because if they have a particularly um you know significant turn here like say i wanted to travel my boat here you know i have my gondolier here and i wanted to travel down this road here and um and end here for example then there's quite a lot of housekeeping and fitness on the way not only in terms of you know are people going to pay the intrigue on the way um am i going to pay the scrolls to negate that i'm going to have to bear mind how many coins are going to have to pay on the way i'm going to have to bear in mind the buildings i'm going to trigger and and of the bridges as well so there's quite a lot of minutiae that kind of bulk things down from turn to turn in these particularly um hairy or hairy turns replayability um you have got some some modularity here in terms of you know the buildings are going to be in different places um i don't think that's going to make a huge difference um to be honest um but probably because you are tend to react to what the current situation on the board is and you know if i can't get a grade cube here then you know it's not like there's only three different types of resources anyway so the chances are there's going to be another one um you know not not so far away which is going to help you a bit better because you don't have to take the intrigue by going somewhere where somewhere else is so i don't think there's a tremendous amount of replayability here there is quite a few order cards but they all do different things or very similar things but give you

different power so i suppose from game to game you can use these different powers to different effects but i i don't think the replayability is tremendously good in this game to be fair um because it very much it feels like you're doing the same thing from game to game um interaction is is quite interesting it's a bit of a double-edged sword as in terms of the um of the different bonuses and things you can get so i love this um this building mechanism i think this is really clever um that's a kind of a passive interaction when you want to deploy there you can potentially push someone along and give them a kind of a passive boost that's really clever um the intrigue is okay um i don't mind that but as i said it kind of bogs things down if you go through this particularly long or very cluttered canals and that could potentially be a bit of a a bit of a fiddliness as well as you said i won't take the intrigue for the first one i'll pay a scroll instead but for the second one i will take an intrigue and everyone's doing this at the same time and it's just it's just a little bit fiddly um but there's also some other interaction as well where if i was to dock somewhere and then another person docks after me then like like so then for every person who docks after me i would get a uh get a point for and sometimes you'll find that more than one person comes to the same canal or to the same dock and end up getting quite a few points that way so another bit of interaction there and of course you've got the competition of the track itself which is pretty standard fare to be honest with a game like this so i i do applaud the um the intrigue mechanism and see what they're trying to

go for here but i think maybe it's not as executed as well as they would have hoped for um aesthetically i think the game looks decent um i particularly love the box i think the outbox artwork is phenomenal um the game itself looks it looks good i think i think it looks fine the symbology is pretty good to be honest um there's a few little few little fiddly bits that don't you might have to just check the rulebook for um but i think that the board itself looks fine you know this kind of bird's eye view of venice the board i should say is double sided so on one side you've got a kind of a brighter daytime board and this time this side is the night time board um but functionally exactly the same just a slightly different aesthetic um so yeah i don't i don't mind the way the game looks i think it looks quite nice and it's quite photogenic i suppose in terms of the wooden pieces you know they all look really good the bridges look really nice um the cards are okay i mean the the artwork isn't the best on them and they're a bit bland looking but i haven't got any real complaints about the actual look or the actual artwork etc graphic design of the game where i do have a problem is in terms of the components themselves and not not the quality but the functionality of the components so this is a this is actually a two-player game where i've used these kind of bots to represent a third player which is going to be the the uh what you're going to do to compensate for the uh for the two-player game um but you can probably say even from a three-player game here or two-player game story with three with two uh three pairs of boats the

board is very cluttered like say for example i wanted to have a third play come to this dot here it's just completely sprawling across the board and you know there's not enough space for people to dock and it just doesn't look right it becomes i said cluttered and just too much in uh too small of arrows it's almost like the either these components are too big or the board is too small um additionally there's a huge oversight in terms of these buildings where when you place these workers they completely cover up the symbology on the board so you can't actually see what bonuses you've got you're going to have to constantly move them to have a look what you're doing and that is to be honest a really bad design choice um it would have been so much better if they made these towers a bit bigger maybe had a lip on them where you could put your um where you put your workers or maybe just do a little track around the outside where you could put them but in some places that's just not feasible as it is because you'd be going onto the scoreboard or well in this example you know if you wanted to move them off the um off the little tile you'd have to go to the next one so yeah i think there's some really simple oversights that have been made here that could have been easily rectified and um to be honest it can be a bit of a bit of a bug bear throughout the game the cubes i like the way they fit into the boats but they're extremely fiddly um they don't they're not quite as satisfying as they could have been i think the gondoliers are okay i think they fit in the boats quite nicely but as you've probably even seen throughout this um throughout this little video you know the hard quite hard to pick up and put out put down and they're fiddly and they you drop them and

it's just i think if you've got kind of a heavy-handed player or people with particularly big fingers then um there's going to be some issues throughout which i know it's it's not a huge issue at least you know it doesn't affect the gameplay but they are going to just probably frustrate a few players and it just seems like it could have been an easy fix and i think that's a bit annoying to be honest um the setup and teardown time is not too much of an issue to be honest i'm just setting up these different tiles i'm giving you to play their starting resources so yeah you can get this game going in just just a few minutes and it's not the not the hardest game to explain it's probably on the lighter end of the medium weight euro scale so yeah not going to be too hard to get to the table and to explain to other players um the scalability i have a bit of an issue with the two play account here so if you want to play this purely as a two-player game or you're going to play this or your aim is to buy this as a two-player game then i would recommend not doing so because as i mentioned you're going to have to play with a third dummy boat or a pair of dummy boats um one of which labeled a one of which labeled b um like so and at the end of your turn you're gonna have an additional phase where you are going to use these cards here um and you're gonna draw two of them and you're going to pick one and that's going to move the other a boat or the b boat depending on the player from one location to another and you're always going to take the cheapest route and kind of give intrigue as you normally would um

but i always found that these choices were quite obvious and they didn't quite interact with players in the way you would want them to you know you'd normally just want them to dock where you are so you get an extra point or go past another player because they'll give them an intrigue so i think this is a bit of a i don't know it just doesn't quite work as well as i would have liked it to and again you it's always pretty obvious it doesn't have a massive impact on the gameplay but i think optimally it's going to be best at three players because you've got people doing their own thing and just passively interacting with each other um the if i was to play more than four or four or five players i think the game is going to be way too cluttered too much chaos and the turns are going to be extremely fiddly and convoluted um the center progression in the game is is okay i suppose as you're kind of building more and more workers onto the board and collecting more bonuses you sell from one place to another so you do have particularly more powerful turns at the end of the game um and you'll get a little bit of a kind of a route planning system going and of course you get these additional powers from your completed missions so it does have somewhat of a forward kind of engine building motion to it which um which is decent to be fair um and comparison wise you know there's there's quite a few pickup and delivery games out there um you know if you like games like fast sloths um the oracle of delphi then this is going to have some similarities to those um however i would say that this one maybe is a little bit more straightforward you know just going from one spot to another and i'm just dropping the cubes off um but that additional wrinkle of the intrigue does

differentiate itself from the pack so yeah overall um i'm a bit in two minds about this game um i like the idea of it and i think it's very close to being good however i have a few issues or quite significant issues with the production and with the fiddliness um you know there were particular rounds where i was going from one spot to another and it just became quite frustrating and annoying to you know to divide all to tally up exactly what we got throughout the turn and it just became fiddly and convoluted um i do i said i love the idea i quite like the i even like the idea of this intrigue i think it's it's efforts are good but the actual attainment and the end result doesn't quite pay off in the way i wanted it to and i almost feel a little bit disappointed by the game because i was expecting um a bit more from a david turtle game because he is a designer who i rate um but yeah it didn't quite hit the highs i wanted it to and again i feel i feel that down because this this kind of is a game i want to like because i love the idea of it i love the premise of it i think the game could have been great it had the ball been a bit bigger um and yeah it just it just didn't satisfy me in a way that i would have wanted it to it's don't get wrong it's it's fine it's it's a decent game probably better than the average game to be sure um but in you know in a market where there's so many games out there um i think maybe your game that's like this maybe a six or you know six and a half out of ten it's just not going to quite cut the mustard

in today's market and ultimately i think in a year's time uh venice isn't going to be talked about at all and that's that's a shame because again it's a game i wanted to like and um and yeah there's i've been waiting for quite a long time for it to hit the table so yeah unfortunately i cannot recommend um venice especially at a two-pay account digging wrong if you if you if it does appeal to you and it looks interesting then give it uh you know give it a try um but yeah it certainly won't be getting my uh endorsement um so that is a venice unfortunately yeah i can't i can't really um you know praise this one um but hopefully yeah you've got some value and understanding about how this game plays out so uh if you have enjoyed the review please hit like and subscribe my channel and check out my other videos too for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved