Skip to main content
Loading video...

Stamp Swap and the art of defying expectations - TCbH Review

Transcript 8:20

I should collect stamps let's get this out of the way up front when stamp swap was announced as the new title by iconic publisher ston Meer games I was all stamps but then once I actually got punching out those little cardboard Beauties and getting the game to the table I was like ah stamps the thing is that experience of initial frustration only to get to the Sweet existential Elation of putting those stamps into your Tableau isn't just some metatextual story about coming around on the theme it's actually something that mirrors the very nature of playing the game here let me explain stamp conon you're living it in each of three rounds cards equal to players are drawn dictating the shapes and face up or down orientation of stamps and special ability and scoring cards that are up for grabs then players take turns drafting six each applying whatever round effects are on the last revealed display card since every player has one category of stamps by default that you get bonuses for you go dog I want that sick ante eater or yo I got to peep me some Fox Glove but the thing is that this draft isn't going to dictate what you get to keep it's only dictating what you might possibly get to keep if you play your cards uh well um cards and stamps right of the six things you

secure which can be stamps cards or the first player token you can keep one thing guaranteed to be yours with the caveat that the super Shiny rare stamps can't be secured at this point then after you peek at any of your face down stamps to assess what their true value is you split the rest into two piles for everyone to augle over as you go into the swap phase starting with the first player they get to snag one pile from someone else to put into their Reserve after which that player's remaining pile goes to their reserve and then like some grand white elephant they get to snag a pile in turn and so on once swapping is done players assemble the reserved items into their Tableau then in one of the most brilliant and Innovative aspects of the game each player gets to put a ticket underneath one scoring category they haven't visited in a prior round immediately scoring points based off of the semi randomized condition within complete three rounds apply some finale scoring for a final Global category card and ranking with forever stamps along with the point values on stamps Specialists and exhibitor cards and most points wins see here's the thing stamp swap is a game that invites you to get genuinely super invested in collecting stamps but there's a whole lot that has to happen each round before you actually get what you get you have to display the stamps then draft them then you have to split them up in a super speculative way in hopes of getting to keep the ones

that you actually want to keep but inviting other players to grab a pile of yours so that way you can sooner grab something of someone else's you need to do a lot to get all the goods then finally sweet sweet assembly which in the end mayor may not be the stamps you wanted in the first place there are layers of removal from the part that you actually want to get to and those layers are gameplay and pretty good gameplay but they Veer pretty close to frustrating tedium if you were just looking to play some spatial Arrangement game and place some Ding Dang stamps there is some Brilliance here though even if it's an odd sort of cadence aside from the AFF forementioned selective scoring it's really cool that the specialist cards which Grant special powers ranging from being able to look at face down stamps while drafting to drawing extra stamps from the supply when you cut a certain way to being able to swap one of your daily takes with someone else's after all the swapping is done these cards are in effect so long as they are in your player area sure when taken in reserve they are permanently yours but even when part of the cut pile that may or may not be snagged by someone you still reap their effects this makes sure are some really interesting decisions and what you prioritize even if in a temporary measure again I've played so many games with so many structures and this Rhythm feels weird kind of stilted but by my third play it was starting to feel a bit

more natural and the visuals do a remarkable job of making the mundane feel exciting both authentic to the sort of old timey look on stamps while throwing in a lot of eye-catching and visually interesting details even if the additional measur ston Meer tried putting in for color blind and category distinction are just barely there then there's the ultra valuable and always coveted Shiny Gold rare stamps which is the only thing that can't be immediately reserved after drafting so if chosen as a face down stamp you got to be coy about how you make your splits to not draw attention but if drafted and split face up it'll be a radiating Beacon like marcelus Wallace's briefcase but maybe that's the perfect distraction this is a game that I came to mainly as a curiosity not really expecting much after I felt like the recent titles like rolling Realms and Expeditions by the same publisher didn't really work for me but this game hit surprisingly well with my group both being casual enough that I could take it to the local public game night and teach some newcomers as well as my 9-year-old and they could have a great time but there 's a little bit more of game design debonaire than your typical lightweight spatial Arrangement game that satisfied the more dedicated of the group one more thing I want to hit on is the solo mode by the always admirable otoma Factory Morton monrad

Peterson and code developed a surprisingly strong adaptation through their pinetta in spite of IIT you choose being a relatively social mechanism new cards show yours and pinetta's daily allotment so the drafting aspect is gone but with some fairly easy to follow rules you know what draws her attention and you arrange a larger and smaller pool after reserving your one held stamp for the round with a card drawn to account for fickle whims possibly offsetting the otherwise deterministic values she takes a group then arranges her own daily collection for a fairly even split you choose from hers and she gets points for her own scoring system it's not quite the same as the act of playing the base game but there's more strategic imp and goting than I expected not enough to recommend grabbing this as a primarily solo experience but a very admirable adaptation nonetheless it's a game that I would recommend for folks who like something a little bit quirky a little bit twe if you don't like drafting or I split you choose mechanics and I don't think this is going to convince you otherwise but a spatial puzzle games aren't your thing this still might be worth checking out especially because the tension comes from getting the stamps and the arrangement and scoring process is generally a bit more forgiving stamp swap isn't the game that I expected and in some ways I still feel like I'm fighting against the damn system to get the dang stamps that I want but ultimately I found that for me that was a big part of the appeel and it's a game

that I'm really looking forward to playing more of and that's our review but let me know what did you think about this game when it was first announced what did you think about the theme was it something you were super excited about or was it something you initially hesitant to and is there a seemingly mundane theme that you would love to see adapted into the world of board games put it in the comments and as always thanks for watching thanks for supporting thanks for being such a great Community you know that I've been Jack for the cardboard Herald

Progress saved