Skip to main content
Loading video...

Arkham Horror 2nd Edition: 20 years later, still a good game?

Transcript 1:25:08

hey everybody welcome back to the dungeon dive Daniel here I hope you're doing well and if you're not I hope you are soon okay in today's episode we are taking a look at Arkham Horror second edition the classic game of Lovecraft adventure of course this is from Richard lonus and Kevin Wilson and it was originally published in 2005 by Fantasy Flight games yes 2005 next year in 2025 Arkham Horror second edition will be 20 years old that's just crazy to think about that this game has been in my life for 20 years I was really hoping that Fantasy Flight during their press conference at this year's Gen Con would have announced a a game plan would have announced something to celebrate the 20th anniversary of this game maybe a 20th anniversary edition but they didn't so I kind of doubt that is going to happen but uh this is a game that I think is a pretty important game to our hobby Arkham Horror kind of ushered in this new era of Co-op and solo games that we are enjoying now and I often hear people say something like Arkham Horror is the game that got me into board games I hear that a lot I hear the same thing with games like settlers of kanatan and uh maybe Ticket to Ride or

pandemic I think it's that important for me personally it's the game that got me back into hobby gaming after about a 10year break so I moved up to Seattle and around 2003 or 2004 or so and my wife and I at the time we had a couple friends who we wanted to play some D and D or we thought we wanted to play some D and D but we didn't really want to put the work in none of us had owned D and D I had sold most of my games by that point just because I I kind of go through phases and uh but I remembered some games that I played when I was in high school that kind of scratched that RPG itch and a lot of the games we cover on the dungeon dive are RPG adjacent and so I thought uh t man yeah maybe Talisman will will give us that feel we won't have to put in the effort so I was like I'm going to go to a game store and I hadn't been to a game store in a long time and first of all let me tell you going to a game store between that 10e break game stores had changed a lot uh long gone were the days of your where where the game stores were dark and Dusty and games were sold in ziplock bags and the shelves were cramped and there was no space in the in the store to even move around no I went to Uncle's Games in Redmond Washington and it was bright and colorful and inviting it was big it was spacious the there had they had table set up for people to play there were families playing games in there it was a lot had changed and a lot had changed in the board game space as well so I asked the guy if he had a copy

of Talisman and um of course it had gone long out of print I never even thought about that that wasn't even something that I thought happened I don't know I guess I just thought Talisman would always around it kind of is now right but he said we do have this new game Arkham Horror it just it recently came in and he said you know it's a game based off call of cthulu and of course I knew what Call of cthulu was the fiction and the RPG I didn't played the RPG but I I knew of it for sure and uh he said you know it's kind of like Talisman you're taking a character you're moving around a map fighting monsters getting loot going on quests and I was like hey that sounds perfect signed me up I bought it I asked my wife to drive home so I could open the box in the car on the way home I was like a kid on Christmas morning and holy crap was I surprised so much stuff in this box everything the giant board the cards all the the monster chits you know everything felt so good the component quality was much higher than anything that I was used to from back in the day and I was really excited to get home because it was one to eight players and I thought wow that's kind of cool I can play one player I can actually play the game while I am learning it and uh that was easier said than done because learning the game from this original manual leaves a lot to be desired Fantasy Flight has definitely learned a lot about designing and writing manuals in the last 20 years and I really struggled to learn this game games had

become more complex than what I was used to and that led me to another Discovery and that Discovery was Board Game Gear I went online I was trying to find something about how to play this game and I learned about Board Game Geek so I went there I went to The Forum for Arkham Horror and I saw people asking and answering questions and I was like wow this is great this is a whole new Avenue a whole new thing to explore and then I went into the file section and that's when I discovered the uh esoteric order of Gamers AKA The Universal head rules summary uh uh pamphlet their their printouts and I instantly fell in love I printed out what they had and yeah I was able to learn the game just from this and all subsequent games whenever I got a new game one of the first things I would do is go to board game geek and see if Universal had had released one of their rule summaries because these things are so valuable I don't know why more companies don't just hire these guys to write their rules because they're very very good at it but there were other P there were other kind of player raids and things that you could download throughout the years and just uh the community around games at Board Game Geek was just something that was a really really new to me uh so let's take a quick look at the back of the box and read about what Arkham Horror is about the year is 1926 the place is Arkham Massachusetts gateways to places horrible Beyond imagination are opening

up all over the town releasing hideous creatures into the streets to stalk the night worse yet if enough these gates open up then a creature of unfathomable power will be user Unleashed on the world pitted against these overwhelming odds is a small band of investigators determined to beat back the uncaring forces of the universe they'll have to delve deep into the mysteries of the Mythos and use all of their skills weapons and spells if they want to even have a slim chance of success the Classic Game of Love crafting Adventure returns in a new addition after almost 20 years yeah there was almost 20 years between first edition in 1987 and second edition in 2005 and now again 20 years so we've been enjoying Arkham hor in some capacity for nearly 40 years wow that's that's so cool um Arkham Horror is an adventure game for 1 to eight players huge spread of players that's crazy and taking 2 to four hours probably closer to four but I'm sure the question on everyone's mind is is Arkham or still a good game to get into today if you haven't played it before is it worth the time is it worth the investment to uh to get something that is now considered vintage well hopefully I can answer that question for you and now let's get down to the table and take a look at everything you get and talk about the game and how it's

played one of my favorite things about Arkham Horror second edition is how quickly you can have the game set up and how quickly you can be playing there isn't a lot of setup time basically as fast as you can get the things out of the box you can start playing and that's one of the reasons why uh this is one of the only games that I have invested in one of those professionally made box organizers I think it is worth it for this game so the first thing you'll do is set up this giant imposing board this board is imposing just like the horror in Arkham City is imposing this is a big board I wish it had a double side that you can fold in half with a smaller version of this map on the other side for people like us who play on small tables but that's not the way it is it's especially hard when you in start introducing one of the sideboards from one of the expansions then it becomes really hard to play on a small table but this board you have the city of Arkham here you have an information track over here and I have some extra overlays that I have printed out and laminated from BGG we'll talk a little bit about those in detail in a minute and then uh down here we have all of our other worlds we have our other world track so in the city of Arkham we have different neighborhoods like North Side downtown East Town Rivertown the merchant District miskatonic University French Hill Uptown and Southside and those are the streets of the neighborhoods and then U off those streets like spokes are

the different locations such as in north side we have the train station the newspaper the Curiosity shop in Rivertown we have the General Store the the black cave and the graveyard at miskatonic University we have the science building the administration building and the library yes the or library with their restricted section where all of those esoteric Toms like the Necronomicon are stored away from prying eyes and here we have Southside with Ma's boarding house the South Church and the Historical Society in a future video I'm going to do my top five locations of Arkham City so I I am really looking forward to that and then we have all of our other worlds and these will correspond to Gates that open up in different locations Gates that the investigators have to investigate they might get sucked through into places like another dimension the abyss the city of the great race Yogo the Great Hall of celano the dreamlands the plateau of Lang and AR yes ARA the city where great cthulu lies dreaming as far as the locations go there are two different kinds we have kinds with a green diamond and a red diamond the green diamond these are stable spaces these are normally safe spaces these are spaces where Gates will not open at least in the base game and then here we have our red diamond spaces those are the unstable spaces those are are the spaces those are the really important spaces those are the spaces where uh Gates will open and one of the only

things you really have to do to set up this game is you have to take your clue tokens and you have to place one of those on each of the red diamond and that's kind of about it as far as the gates go or as far as the board goes I should say so after your board is set up and your Clues are laid out you get to pick your investigator you get to pick your hero you get to pick your class the character that you will be playing as and man this game comes with so much Variety in this area There are 16 different investigators to play as and I have a hard time coming up with another game especially at retail that gives you this much Variety in the heroes and each one of these is different they have different powers different stats and different starting items so the heroes the investigators in Arkham Horror are Mandy Thompson Jenny Barnes Kate winr Vincent Lee Joe Diamond Carolyn Fern Michael mcglenn Amanda Sharp Gloria Goldberg Harvey Walters Ashan Pete monor Ray Jack Bob Jenkins Sister Mary Dexter Drake and Daryl Simmons when I play solo I like to play Three Investigators I find that that is is a sweet spot and I often play with these Three Investigators here these are my ladies of Arkham it's Kate winr Jenny Barnes and Mandy Thompson I like this team a lot so each one of these investigators will have a certain power they will have certain possessions that they start the game with and they will have certain skills so each of the investigators will have six different skills and those are on opposing tracks

we have speed and sneak fight and will lore and luck if your speed is one if you're if you're slow then your sneak is high at five conversely if your sneak is low at two your speed is high at four and you will use these little markers here to keep track of the track of your of your certain skill values and those skill values will correspond to how many dice you get to add to your D6 dice pool when you make a check looking usually for fives or sixes in order to gain a success unless you are cursed or blessed and we talk about that in a minute each one of the investigators will also have a special power uh Kate winr she's awesome she has this thing called the flux stabilizer and that prevents Gates and monsters from opening up in the in the location that she is in super cool her home is the science building she starts with $7 two clue tokens and then one common item one unique item two spells and a skill and we'll go through those decks of cards in just a minute uh Jenny Barnes here she has an upkeep her special power is every upkeep phase she gains a dollar and she starts with $10 Jenny Barnes is your trust fund investigator she's a good shopper she's somebody you want if you want somebody to go to the Curiosity shop or to the general store to buy items to help the investigators do their thing and then we have Mandy Thompson Mandy Thompson's power is invaluable once per turn Mandy can activate this ability after any investigator and makes a skill check

that investigator can roll the dice used for that check super cool what a great way to mitigate luck she starts with $6 four clue tokens two common items one unique item and one skill and then each of the investigators will also have a certain number of sanity and stamina if you ever go down if you ever lose all of your sanity you have to go to Arkham Asylum to heal up if you lose all your stamina you go to the hospital to heal up however if you are in one of those other World locations and one of those goes to zero then you are devoured and the player will have to start a new investigator so each of the investigator also has on their skills the spread of numbers is different and so they specialize in different things once you have picked your investigator and and chosen all of your starting gear and your items then you will choose a great old one and these are basically scenarios these are game modifiers these make the game different and there are eight different great old ones in the base game here we have yakoo aatho yig cthulu hastur shab naroth narot and iqua and they range in difficulty I think cthulu is one of the harder ones yig and ithaqua can be one of the easier ones personally I like playing against aith because it makes the end game well end really quickly because in this game what you're trying to do is you are trying to close a certain number of gates that

will be appearing in Arkham City you have to close and seal with an Elder Sign six gates to win the game if you fail to do that then the great old one gets summoned and then you have to do battle against the great old one and if you defeat the great old one you also win the game however that final battle gets kind of boring because it's just usually ends up with rolling huge numbers of dice and it takes a lot of time and it's usually not very exciting so that's why I like to play against aith because as the lore States everything in existence is just a dream of aith and aith is kept in Slumber with these magical warbling flutes and when aith wakes up aatho stop stops dreaming and everything gets everything disappears out of existence and so when he wakes up when it wakes up the game just ends uh each of the great old ones will have a combat modifier that makes them more or less difficult to attack each of the uh great old ones will have a different way that their cultists interact with the board and interact with the players they will have some kind of special power usually some kind of immunity or a resistance and they will also have a way that they attack the players when that final confrontation comes they also have a doom track down here and each turn each Mythos uh phase of a turn you will add a doom token and if the Doom token ever reaches the last spot then that great

old one wakes up and you have to go on to that final confrontation so again it's just a lot of variety we have eight different scenarios eight different ways to modify the game 16 different investigators mix and match those and you have a lot of different ways to play this game and speaking of variety we have a ton of cards in this game yes there are many many decks of cards this is so cool I love all of these cards so let's take a look at them and see what you get so there are two decks of items uh the the best one the most unique one is the unique items and this deck is awesome I love drawing cards from this deck in this deck we will have things like the nameless Cults say that was a book I believe created by Robert E Howard uh there's one of our Elder signs our Elder signs help us to seal those Gates and not only do they help us do that but when you use an Elder Sign you can actually remove a token from the Doom track so that's a way to kind of mitigate some of that threat uh we have the ruby of ARA and there's another copy of the nameless Colts the lamp of alhazred we have the Necronomicon The Dread Necronomicon the King in Yellow a book created by Robert W Chambers uh just don't read past the second act of the play or you will go insane uh the sword of Glory so all kinds of really cool magical things esoteric things that you can get in this unique deck and then you can also draw items from this common deck and these are all kind of mundane items uh you might find some research

materials or maybe a daring er a bull whip some food if you need to eat some food to regain some stamina a trusty battle axe there a dark cloak that can help you evade your lucky cigarette case you can uh trade respiratory disease for a chance to reroll dice your shotgun your 45 automatic so all kinds of more physical based weapons not magical uh speaking of magic we also get a deck of spells now the spells in the base game are kind of lack buer I'm almost never excited to draw a spell in this game there are a few good ones but they often have a high cost you you you have to pay a certain amount of sanity and then do a successful lore check in order to cast the spell so I often find that the Spells just aren't worth it but sometimes they can be fun and they can come in and and help save the day but here we have things like the red sign of shmeel shmeel was a giant worm great old one introduced later on in the game but uh it was actually created by Brian Lumley we have the voice of raw the blind monster wither U mist of rele this is a good one this is one that I I hope to get often because it it allows you to evade monsters easier find Monster enchant weapon is also a good one because it can take your Tommy Gun and turn it into a magic Tommy Gun and that is always super super fun but you do get a good variety of spells and as the game progressed the Spells got more interesting especially in Eldridge horror the Spells got really cool

because they had different ways different outcomes uh we also have a deck of of skills and these skills will cor will usually correspond to one of the skills on your card on your investigator card and will usually give you something else to do such as the speed skill will give you a plus one to your speed but then you also get this special power so when you spend a clue token to add any speed check add one extra bonus die a sneak skill Lux skill sneak uh Sometimes some of these will maybe help you cast spells better so these are just things that you can augment your character with we also have a deck of allies so these are NPCs the monsters the great old ones the investigators they aren't the only ones wandering around the streets of Arkham you will also have some NPCs and you always want to play with a deck of 11 I have 12 here because one of these I think Oliver Grayson was a promo card but you always want to play with a subset of 11 because this deck can run out all 11 of these allies these NPCs can die and then that's it you don't have a chance to gain more allies but these allies are kind of like your skills and they will give you a bonus and usually some other kind of action that you can take so we have people like Anna caslo Professor Armitage there the head of the library at miskatonic University Ryan Dean uh Richard Upton Pikman so those are all of your NPCs and allies and then finally we get one more

small deck and these are the conditions these are the things that might happen to your hero to your investigator and they really kept this slim and that's one thing I like the condition deck in eldrich horror I think just got out of hand and it ends up being really hard to organize but there are only a few conditions that your investigator can suffer from uh they can become a retainer so basically get a job and they can earn some money during their upkeep they can become cursed or blessed very good very bad we'll talk more about curse and bless in a minute uh you might also become the deputy so you can go down to the police station just right over here and you can become deputized where you will get the revolver and a patrol wagon you can become a member of the Silver Twilight Lodge which is just over here that's a secret society within Arkham that kind of knows about the evil that's going on and then you can also take out a bank loan but you do have to repay your bank loans so that's all of your little hobbit cards as people like to call them I don't mind the small cards I think it I think it works but you also get a number of normaliz cards and we have two decks here so this deck here this is the Mythos deck and this is basically the AI of the game when the game fights back this these are the cards that tell it what to do they will tell you where a gate opens they will tell you which monsters move on which routes and some of these will be rumors maybe there is a serial killer that is

stalking the streets of Arkham killing off your NPCs uh maybe it's raining really hard and so it's hard to get around so some of these are you you discard as soon as you draw them some of them stay out and change the rules and change the way that the game is played for good or bad there are a couple of good ones sometimes you just have a nice peaceful quiet night and you don't have to add a gate no new monsters so it's always nice when you draw when you draw that card but a huge huge Variety in that and then we get into our encounter cards and there are two subset decks of counter cards one is for your other worlds when you go through those Gates and uh the other cards are for your locations in Arkham if you remember in my review for Arkham Horror first edition all of these location encounters were a roll of a D6 on a table but in this game it's cards and so the other worlds will correspond to different colors such as ARA is yellow and red so if you were in ARA you would have to draw a card from this deck until you drew either the yellow or red one and then check to see if ARA was mentioned and if it was you would do that encounter if it wasn't you would do the other encounter so this is a huge deck of other world encounters that you can have and then there's also many little decks of encounters for when you are in Arkham and each neighborhood of Arkham has its own deck of ENC counter cards each deck is seven cards and each

encounter card has three different encounters so there are 21 encounters per neighborhood and this is one way one area where the expansions really add a lot because I believe every single expansion comes with new cards to add to these neighborhood decks but we have our deck for miskatonic University and it's colorcoded to the street uh outline there so these are the miskatonic U cards and then depending on where you are if you are in the administration building the library or the science building you will have one of those encounters now what's interesting about these cards is they aren't discarded when you encounter them they are actually shuffled back into the deck in some ways that's similar to that D6 system from first edition because first edition you could just roll a two four times in a row and have a same encounter well the same thing goes for uh this uh these cards here you could have that same encounter over and over again but if you're playing to win the game you really want to avoid these most of the time and I think that's kind of a shame and we'll talk a little bit about that in a bit but even though you only get seven cards per neighborhood if you stacked all of these up it's a large deck of encounters and I believe there is enough variety here to satisfy most people okay and then finally as far as components go we have our chits and the chits are kept to a bare minimum I really like this it's not overwhelming you get some money so you get these cardboard chits for money one fives and T you get these here these are your doom tokens that you will put on your great old ones or the Elder signs that you

will put on the board when you seal a gate you will have some locked doors because sometimes different locations will become locked and you will no longer be able to encounter those spaces we have our first player token we have some tokens here to keep track of some exploration on the board and maybe some locations for certain side quests and then we have our sanity tokens our clue tokens clues of course can be spent to help mitigate bad luck you can spend a clue to add a d to your dice pool or you can spend five Clues to close a gate and seal the gate and that's really what you're trying to do to win so Clues are very important to use wisely and then we also have our stamina tokens and then we also have our our cardboard standies for all of the investigators I love that this game was kind of before the Miniatures craz so we didn't have plastic I know they eventually made minis for the investigators but I love that they just embraced this really really cool classic look of these standies and even in more modern games like eldrich horror and Arkham Horror second edition they stayed with the standies I'm not quite sure why they didn't stay with standies for Mansions of Madness I wish they would have because I I think the standies are a lot better than the minis and then our final stack of tokens are the gate tokens and so these are the gates that you will uh draw from the the pile of gates you'll draw from when you draw your Mythos card and the Mythos card will tell you to put your uh Gates out here on the board at your unstable spaces when an

investigator moves into that space they can investigate the gate turn it over and then that tells you which other world you go to the city of the great race it tells you the difficulty and it tells you which monsters are associated with this location so once you have everything set up there's uh there are two objectives there are two ways to win the game and those are to close to seal six gates in Arkham or to defeat the great old one when the great old one uh is summoned when they wake up and that is easier said than done but the game is played in phases and this is what kind of threw me for a loop when I first started to learn the game because I was more used to games where uh one player would take a full turn then the next player would take a turn the next player and so on around the table but in Arkham Horror second edition each of the players does the phase in order and if you want to speed up the game one of the way ways to do that is to play simultaneously during each one of these phases so the first phase is the upkeep phase and this is kind of like the initiative phase in in Dungeon Crusade this is the planning phase this is the phase where you look at the board you try to determine what you want to do and you can use your focus value here to uh to adjust your skill sliders so if you need a big movement you could adjust your skill slider so your speed is more than your sneak so you can move AC across the board and so the upkeep phase is the planning phase that is the strategy phase once that is done then

you go into the movement phase and the movement phase is where you spend speed to move either from one street to the next or from a street into a location as you are moving if you ever come across any of the monsters and this is one final component then you have to have combat combat can actually happen in any phase in this game there really isn't a dedicated combat phase and man I love these monster chits they are so cool you get so many so much of variety we have things like uh ghosts and warlocks and the hounds of tendal here we have the the in dimensional shamblers and uh the formless spawn and the here we have our basic cultists and our Haunter of the dark and each one of these will have a value that will tell you how easy they are to evade their sanity damage their toughness and their their stamina damage and sometimes they will have a special ability their toughness is how much damage you have to do to kill them and as you kill them you get to uh collect the chit as a trophy and if you ever end up with five toughness worth of trophies you can take that to a certain location and trade that in for a new skill you're like a monster hunter you can also take when you close Gates when you seal Gates you can take them as a gate Trophy and you can take these to a certain location to become blessed and that is a really

really good thing to do but after all of the uh investigators have moved then you go into the encounter phase and the encounter phase it depends on where you are if you are in the street you have no encounter if you are in a location without any text that's when you draw from the encounter deck if you are in a location with text you can either draw an encounter or do what it says on the space if you are down here off camera in one of the other worlds then you have another world encounter and so it's pretty simple you do the encounter you you encounter the space you are in and then after the encounter space then we go to the Mythos phase this is when we draw one of our Mythos cards this is where the game fights back this is where all the bad stuff happens Gates come out more monsters come out if a gate opens where a gate already is then we have a monster Surge and more monsters come out it can get very very deadly very very quickly this is a really handy uh sheet also you can find this on BGG and this just gives you a really brief and valuable snapshot of what you can expect from each location so I do recommend uh printing this out I use this all the time one of my favorite things about Arkham Horror is that it is an unthrottled adventure game and like secrets of the 2 my favorite game of all time anything can happen at any time and that can be good things or bad things I think that's really really cool a lot of

modern games kind of throttle your adventure they don't allow you to experience everything until you've played through a certain number of games certain things get unlocked certain cards get added to decks as you go through different scenarios or as you read enough pages of the narrative that's not how this game is you have access to absolutely everything on your very first turn and I think that is really cool you might draw that awesome sword on your very first turn heck you might start the game uh with a random draw of the sword of glory and that is so cool you might find the exact thing you need on that very first turn and have a really really fun game conversely you might draw one of the flying uh the flying polyps one of the worst monsters or maybe a shog goth maybe a shog goth appears on the board on the very first turn and so so having that unthrottled uh nature of this adventure just makes every single game so much fun I also love the dice pool system because it's very easy to conceptualize if you are have a speed of two you roll 2d6 it's harder to get a five or a six on 2d6 than it is on 3d6 it's very easy it's very easy to to explain and to uh to to conceptualize I also am very lucky that somebody donated to me uh some sets of these QQ dice for the for Arkham Horror and for eldrich horror and these are used instead of a five or a six for a normal success

you're looking for these green Elder signs if you're blessed then you're looking for blue if you're cursed then you're looking for red and so if I was just normal I would need Greens in order to have a success these are really cool dice I like them a lot another thing I like is how slim the deck of conditions are and I love these conditions right here blessed and cursed such a swing of luck and bad luck I love this system so much when you are blessed a a success counts as a four five or a six so you have a 50% chance of success on each D6 when you get blessed in this game you feel like a God among men in Arkham City you feel like you can do anything the world is your oyster it's like this great pressure is released leaved from your shoulders and I love it so so much I love being blessed it just feels great it feels like you finally have a chance to do all of the things that you need or want to do conversely when you get cursed only sixes count as successes when you are cursed you feel like you are a worm beneath the heel of great cthulu's foot and he is just smashing you into the concrete it's like you can't do anything it's so bad uh you have three Dice and you have to get a six and no but if you were blessed hey that's two successes there so just really cool these really the only kind of two main conditions are bless are

blessed and cursed but it adds a lot to those are really meaningful conditions I also love the big sandbox nature of this game and that goes along with it being an unthrottled adventure when you set up this game when you're taking that first turn it feels like you can do anything you can go anywhere and you do want try if you want to play to win you do want to focus on that win condition but if you don't really care about winning you can just go explore and have random locations and I all a Random Encounters and I also love the conflict in this game and the conflict starts from that very first turn Arkham Horror second edition is the game that introduced me to the mechanism of threat management that mechanism of the players needing to put out five fires with three buckets of water or having to juggle a whole bunch of plates or keeping a whole bunch of plates in the air I guess plate twirling uh the plate twirling analogy but in Arkham hor there are a few threats that the players have to manage in order to do well in order to win the major threats are well you have the great old one that the big boss you have the Doom track and you have the gates and monsters and those are kind of uh related those are kind of interconnected and then we also have the outskirts and the terror track and so these are all things that you want to focus on that you want to keep down that you want to these are all fires that you

want to put out so uh at each turn you will add a token to the Doom track so this is one threat you can remove tokens from the Doom uh Track by using Elder signs when you seal a gate if this ever fills up then the great old one wakes up it is summoned and you have to do battle with it one of the eight other main threats are the gates as more gates start coming out they will start bringing in more monsters you can only have a certain number of gates out and that's why I use these overlays because these overlays some of this information is printed on the board uh just off camera over there but these overlays from BGG have a little bit more information and so this tells you here the gates are that are open open to start the final battle if you're playing a three or four player game and there are ever seven Gates left open then that also triggers the end game that also triggers that final Conflict and so gates are another threat that you want to manage then we also have monsters as Gates start coming out more monsters start coming out there is a monster limit and a number of monsters that can be out on the board based off of the player level and if that ever if you ever go over that limit then moners start getting added to the outskirts there's also a track of outskirts a limit of how many monsters can be in the outskirts depending on how many players are playing and if you ever go over that then the terror track starts going up

and when the terror track starts going up different places around Arkham start closing and your allies your NPCs start dying so you can see that all of these threats all of these threats that the players have to manage are intertwined they're interrelated uh monsters deal with gates gates deal with the great old one monsters deal with Arkham monsters deal with the allies and so there are a whole bunch of fires that you have to put out and you have to manage those threats and there is this kind of concept that I think about a lot when I think about this game and that is playing to win or playing to have fun and I think for some people those uh will be more or less mutually exclusive uh for me they are more more mutually exclusive if you are playing to win you really only want to focus on closing Gates or powering up to fight the old one if you aren't doing either one of those things then you can have a wasted turn and there are a lot of distractions and I think the managing the threat of distractions is a lot more interesting than just managing this threat and by the threat of distractions what I mean is just doing the fun stuff on the board and if you focus on the fun stuff you may not be doing what you need to win the game and hey that's all right if that's the way you want to play that's the way I like to play and I think a really good example of that are these uh stable spaces and the unstable spaces so

the stable spaces Gates will never open here and clues will never appear here at least in the base game and so there isn't ever really a reason to go to the General Store to go to the library there's almost no reason to ever go to the library in this game you want to deal with the unstable spots because that's where the gates are that's where you will find Clues you really do want to avoid having as many Random Encounters as you can because most of these are bad but they're interesting they're narratively interesting I think interesting things happen and I think that eldrich horror and Arkham Horror Third Edition did a better job job of uh forcing the players to be engaged with every element of the game because to get clues in those games you have to go to those locations and have encounters and so um you know if if you just want to go to the General Store and maybe hope to get a cool weapon uh that may not be actually pushing you forward to one of your end goals and so you won't be playing to win and uh this game can suffer because it is cooperative it can suffer from that Alpha game if you're playing with a total badass player who's just controlling everybody uh just very calmly look them in the eye and say hey it's my turn I'm going to do what I want and just play to have fun because that's what I do and to facilitate that I do have one house rule that I play this

game with and that is to encourage people to have encounters at these stable locations and so every Mythos face when I draw a Mythos card when I add a gate when I add a clue I also roll a D12 and I don't have a D12 handy but I roll a D12 and I consult this chart here let's say I rolled a four or let's say I rolled a rivertowns right here on camera let's say I rolled a six then I would add a clue token to the street space of of this neighborhood now that never happens in a game of Arkham Horror to get that clue you have to have a successful encounter at one of the stable locations and so to get this clue I would actually have to go to the General Store draw a card from the deck the General Store do what it says and and successfully pass that test or do what it says in order to gain that clue so that house rule for me it encourages players to engage with what I think is the most interesting part of the game and those are the little stories that the game tells Arkham Horror does a really good job of telling stories and creating stories and I think those are two different things so there are two different ways to convey narrative in a game a lot of modern games especially Kickstarter games they like to tell their stories by having the players read hundreds of thousands of words in an adventure book often times on

Kickstarter they will advertise that you know this uh this game has more words in its Adventure book than uh war in peace or something like that and I often ask myself am I playing a game or am I reading a novel and for me I prefer games to tell their stories with brevity that's not to say that I don't like some games that have a lot of writing uh but usually when I want to read a lot to experience something I will just turn to one of the many books that I own but Arkham Horror does a really good job of conveying its Narrative of telling its stories with brevity with only a little bit of text for instance on the encounter cards you will only have maybe one or two sentences to read so you won't be stopping to read for minutes on end but what is here conveys a lot there's a lot of mood a lot of atmosphere a lot of horror I think it does a fantastic job that is especially true with some of the Mythos cards which will have different things different types of environments and uh different types of weather or different types of rumors that might be happening and you can kind of start piecing together a little story of what is going on in this city same goes for the counter cards in the other world uh there's only a couple uh two or three sentences to read on each one but it does a really good job of making you feel like you are in this otherworldly Place having these bizarre encounters another place that Arkham Horror Focus or another thing that Arkham Horror uses to tell its stories

is the art all of the art on the boards the art on the back of the cards the art on the old ones the art on the investigators and the art on all of the different little Min cards with all of the different items and things this art does such a great job of conveying the theme of this game the art asset library that the Arkham files games draws from is probably my all-time favorite library of art I think it Rivals the classic libraries of TSR and even Games Workshop and I actually like it more than either of those two art libraries I think it is fantastic and we're going to do an entire episode focused on the art but there is one major failing in this game and that is here in the credits of the rulebook they do not mention a single artist just what a slap in the face to all of the people who worked so hard to make this game look so beautiful so according to my research there are literally hundreds of artists who have contributed to the art asset library for the Arkham files games uh we I don't know if we'll mention all of them it could take me forever just to read them and I would probably butcher every name but on BGG they credit 10 different people who worked on this game so of course Andre fer uh he did the the art for the cover but then we also have

rafet hovitz Richard lonus Henning Lon Patrick McAvoy Kurt Miller Scott nley Vlad rissian Brian Sha ber and Kevin Wilson are all given an artistic credit on BGG I don't know how accurate that is I wish there was a more accurate representation of the artists who did all of this amazing work for this game but the art goes a long way in selling what what is happening on the table another way this game tells its stories is through uh the background of the investigators each one of these investigators has a little background story something that they were doing right before the game something that they are interested in at some point we'll also be doing a top five investigators of the base game and we're also going to take a look at the book that has all of the short stories written about each one of these investigators but as an example here let's read the little flavor text for Mandy Thompson Mandy came to Arkham several years ago looking for work as a researcher at miskatonic University since then she has worked with many of their University professors delving into esoteric tone filled with scientific information historical reports and sometimes even occult ramblings it was while reading an old book of prophecies last week that she first felt that she had stumbled into something big Mandy came to believe that certain signs and importance described in the book were taking place in Arkham right now Omens that indicated the return of a terrible

being referred to as an ancient one or a great old one uh which would grind the cities of man beneath its lome tread tonight the full moon has turned blood red which is in the final Omen of the return of the Ancient One slipping into the night and armed with her knowledge of the prophecy Mandy has decided to see if she can defy fate and stop these events from taking place that's really good that conveys a lot of information about the character of Mandy Thompson in only three paragraphs and then we can take a look at the great old ones and we can read about oh yes the great old ones have no information about them and this is another huge huge criticism I have of this game it's so hard for people who haven't read uh HP Lovecraft haven't read authors of the Lovecraft Circle haven't read Brian Lumley haven't read uh Clark ason Smith it's hard for people to know just what the heck all of these things are what is an aith how come aatho uh doesn't have a final Conflict why when he wakes up why do we just have game over what's an iqua what the heck does a cthulu do what's a Hast why is he holding this H stick there what's uh this guy with the name that we have to be very careful to pronounce shub nigero what's what's his deal but they don't have any really any information about the great old ones and so that's why I am introducing to this series what I am calling appendix M appendix Mythos I

know not very creative but uh I think it works and in the in the following segment of this episode we will look at short stories dealing with each one of the great old ones okay so welcome to the first part of appendix M appendix Mythos in this part we are going to be focusing on stories about the great old ones that come in the Arkham horr second edition base box and so there are eight different old ones eight different great old ones and I will be recommending 15 different stories and we we're we're going to approach those in alphabetical order starting with aith so aatho the blind idiot God the lore states that all of existence is nothing but the dreams of a slumbering azathoth he is kept in Slumber by the music of cosmic flutes and that's why there is no final Conflict with aith because if aith wakes up all of existence vanishes August derith kind of depicted a atho as the embodiment of nuclear energy of of a nuclear explosion and I thought that was pretty interesting especially when compared to another one of my favorite things and that's Twin Peaks and how David Lynch depicted the birth of Bob the birth of evil in episode 8 of the return as U being birded from this uh great atomic explosion there are some really strong Cosmic horror Connections

in David Lynch but the story that I chose for aatho is the sect of the idiot and that is written by Thomas latti and that can be found in the songs of the Dead dreamer which is a collection of Thomas lotti's short stories or it can also be found in this amazing collection called lovecrafts monsters which is edited by Ellen do dolo the great Ellen dolo who has done tons of editing editing on all kinds of Great Horror anthologies but this includes stories by Neil Gaiman joar Lansdale k Caitlyn AR Kernan gimma files lar Baron uh Nick MMOs Carl Edward Wagner and latti now leg Gotti as far as his philosophy goes his philosophical Outlook I think he was really close to Lovecraft but latti was even more of a pessimist he was even more of a misanthropic uh kind of Sourpuss or is he's not dead lagotti is still alive but in the story The the sect of the idiot he discusses a character who goes into this town and discovers a cult of aatho now aith is never mentioned by name in that story but the presence of aith can be felt throughout and that just kind of overriding just oppression of an aithan cult in this city is felt throughout and I think latti is a really good author to tackle a story by a about a great old

one like aatho okay next we have uh the great one himself cthulu great cthulu the namesake the call of cthulu the call of cthulu RPG cthulu Mythos fiction uh the most popular of the of the the great old ones so I thought about maybe picking something a little off the beaten path about cthulu because there are so many hundreds of stories that feature cthulu but I decided to go with the original and that is the call of cthulu by of course uh HP Lovecraft as kind of the the originating story story of the cthulu Mythos and it is a really really good story I know there are probably people out there who still haven't read it and maybe there are people out there who haven't read it in many many many years and I would encourage you to read it or to read it again and just kind of think about what it was setting up and what it was doing to lay the groundwork for this uh type of Mythos Fiction it's basically a noela in three parts the first part deals with a discovery of a statue and a plague of nightmares that's felt around the world and that first part reminds me a lot of my favorite work of weird fiction and that is a story we will discuss much later in another episode and that is the repairer of reputations by Robert W Chambers uh but then the second part deals with the discovery of the cthulu Cults all around the world so you'll get some really good information about how there are these Cults that are worshiping these great entities and then the third part deals with a dis the third part deals with a direct encounter

which is really rare but a direct encounter with great cthulu himself so yeah the call of cthulu is a fantastic story it's been published in all kinds of different books I read it here in the cthulu cycle so you'll be seeing the cthulu cycle books a lot in these episodes but these are the books that are actually put out by chaosium and edited by Robert impr price and with introductions by Robert impr price and I really do enjoy reading what price has to say about all of these stories so for cthulu I'm sticking with the original the call of cthulu it is an amazing tale okay next up we have hastur the Unspeakable one the feaster from afar the King in Yellow so hastur is really interesting because hastur is probably the oldest entity here in in in in the real world hore was created by Ambrose beer years before HP Lovecraft uh written about a little bit as a place in the King in Yellow by Robert W Chambers mentioned by Lovecraft but fully brought into the Mythos by August derith and so many stories have been written by about hastur the King in Yellow it's a very very important part of the Mythos now and uh there's the King in Yellow hastur and carosa those are all things that that are wrapped around this entity and the two stories that I chose were the return of Hast by August derith and more light by James blish so I went a little bit off the beaten path because we're going to be focusing on the king and

yellow the the book when we get to the king and yellow expansion but the hostor cycle from chaosium this is my favorite uh book of the of the of chaosium's cycle anthologies I love this Anthology so much it has so many great stories and uh the return of hore is really fun so August derth not the greatest writer but super important to the Mythos because him and he and Donald wandry they started our Arham house publishing and because of August derth we have these collections of Mythos fiction uh to read and and he really did do a lot of work to get the writings of authors like Clark ashon Smith and HP Lovecraft and Roberty Howard and Robert block and all of these great authors he published them in in their first book form because all of this fiction was published in old pul magazines and it probably would have vanished if it wasn't for Donald wandry and a derith and so August derith not the best writer but he's really fun he crams a lot of Mythos stuff into every single one of his stories and the return of hastur is no exception a really interesting thing about the return of hastur is that August derth mentions the Tuttle cult and the Tuttle cult is also mentioned in HBO's True Detective season 1 and if you remember True Detective season 1 has a connection to hastur to

carosa and the King in Yellow really really cool and then uh off the beaten path we have more light by James blush so blush was more known for his science fiction his great uh novel a case of Consciousness and a lot of his Star Trek novels and I think that more lik was his only foray into the world of cthulu Mythos fiction and it's really cool because in his story more light you actually get to read a bit from the King in Yellow he wrote out the play and he has a character who is reading the King in Yellow and slowly going insane as he is doing so so just two really fantastic Stories the return of Hur by August derth and more lik by James James blish okay next up we have Etha the W Walker the wendigo uh probably created by August derith and inspired by Alon blackwoods uh great story The windigo so for a long time iqua was probably my least favorite of the great old ones it's just kind of boring it's kind of a Sasquatch a wind too an abominable snowman I don't know it just seemed kind of normal and mundane but then I read the story by Brian Lumley in the horror at Oaken and others called Born of the wind and my opinion of ithaqua changed like overnight uh born of the wind is

possibly my second favorite weird fiction tale of all time right below repair of reputations you don't need to spend the money for the original copy of Arkham house a horor at Oak to read it though it has also been published in the taint and other novellas from Brian lumbley and it's been published in other books as well and holy crap born of the wind is just an amazing uh piece of fiction so for those of you who watched my primer you will know that Brian Lumley is my favorite author of The cthulu Mythos I just love his style there are very there are many different ways to tell a cthulu Mythos story some of those are cosmic horror I don't think Brian Lumley really works with Cosmic horror he is more concerned with the fantasy side the planetary romance side and uh he deals a lot with other dimensions and weird wacky things Brian Lumley can get Goofy and weird and bizarre and that's why I like Brian Lumley so much but born of the wind is straight up Cosmic horror it's grounded it's somber it's menacing and it contains a couple of really fully realized characters something you don't get too often in these kinds of stories and it also includes a really great female character who is depicted in a realistic and sympathetic fashion and that is definitely something you don't get especially in some of these more classic stories but born of the wind is kind of a lum's take on the dun witch horror but he's using iqua I don't want

to give too much away for those of you that know what happens in the dun witch horror you will know maybe you will get a hint of what I'm suggesting but yeah born of the wind is just fantastic every single page is amazing I love that story so much I've read it a handful of times and it will always for always be one of my favorite Mythos Tales okay next up we have narot the crawling chaos the fly the light the Haunter in darkness so in many ways U narot is the main antagonist in HP lovecrafts Mythos one of the great old ones and he is one of the only great old ones to take active interest in humanity he is the messenger of the outer Gods narot actively participates in the Affairs of humanity he spans time and space and the cosmos and enters into the dreamlands into into the Earth's dreamlands he is a also a major antagonist in Brian lumley's Titus Crow books he an alien god who wears many masks a trickster a Lucifer and Satan likee figure and because of narot te's active role there are a ton of great stories featuring this character and it was really really hard for me to pick but I picked four different stories and uh we'll see one of those doesn't really have to do with narot but it sets up a really interesting Trilogy and that trilogy is the shambler from the stars

the Haunter in darkness and the shadow from the steeple so the shambler from the stars is by Robert block yes Robert block the riter of psycho spent his early career writing a whole bunch of weird tales and a whole bunch of Mythos fiction and in the shambler in dark and then that's followed up by HP lovecrafts the Haunter in darkness which I read in the marot cycle and then that is and followed up by the Shadow from the steeple by Robert block those three stories are really playful and they do a really good job of showing how the authors of these stories mixed facts fact and fiction how they played with breaking the fourth wall and adding a little bit of Truth to their stories by referencing each other as characters by referencing each other's uh work of fiction by referencing the the things that other authors would create and also by self-referential by by by referencing their own works and it's really really cool so in the shambler of the Stars Robert block depicts a character who is basically HP Lovecraft HP Lovecraft gets killed by a star vampire and then in the Haunter in darkness HP Lovecraft depicts a character who is basically Robert block and he gets killed by an aspect of narot and he goes to investigate the starry wisdom cult the Church of the star

wisdom and we will revisit the Church of the star wisdom in a future episode because it's a really really neat cult it's a really neat sect but and then in the shadow from the steeple Robert block ends the trilogy by uh depicting a character who is probably Fritz lever who also comes in contact with n narot just a really really cool Trilogy of stories and then there's a final story in this the mysteries of the worm and this is a fantastic collection I highly highly recommend this collection actually both of these are really good but if you've never read Robert block Robert block was the youngest of the original Lovecraft Circle and as the youngest author he had kind of a different style than the other authors than Robert E Howard and and HP craft and Clark Ashton Smith and so on he had a little bit more of a youthful style a more playful style but the final story is called the bane of the black pharaoh and that's kind of a mini at the mountains of Madness but instead of it taking place in Antarctica it takes place uh in the Middle East and the character is going down basically a tunnel and the tunnel is surrounded by these uh these these sculptures these boss reliefs of the history the the the ancient history of mankind and how mankind has been entangled with all of these great old ones for eternity so really neat stories narot is an

interesting great old one and there are just a ton of stories to feature narot okay next up we have old shubby shub naroth the one that we have to be really really careful with how we pronounce but this is the black goat of the woods with a thousand young a fertility God or godess one of the more mysterious entities in the entire cthulu Mythos uh created by Lovecraft but uh Lovecraft never really spent a lot of time dwelling on Old shubby often mentioned and rarely detailed uh the story that I chose is a brilliant mix of cthulu Mythos Fiction with historical sword and sorcery and it's by an author who is really impressing the hell out of me the more I read from him and that is Richard tyy and uh the star the story is called the seed of the star gods and that can be found in this collection here sorcery against Caesar which sorcery against Caesar is all about tian's character Simon of Gita now tyranny is probably most well known as one of the co-authors along with David C Smith of the red Sonia novels the six red Sonia novels but his sword and sorcery character Simon of Gita it's a Jordan sorcery series set in biblical times and it's really cool man these stories are amazing they are so good and the story is the seed of the star God and that can also be found here in the

shub nigaro cycle from chaosium edited by of course Robert M price but man that story is so good so Simon of Gita he was an ex gladiator who was rescued from slavery by a wizard and then the wizard taught Simon of Gita magical spells and he's also a great sword swordsman and he goes around and he battles demons and the cthulu cycle deities and just gets into all kinds of awesome awesome adventures I love Richard El TIY so much I'm loving him so much that we are going to mention him again later when we get to yag soof okay next up we have yig the father of serpents and a great old one worshiped by the ancient cultures of meso America so the stories with yig have a little bit of a different flavor than the other uh the other cthulu cycle deities so the the two stories that I chose were the curse of a yig and that was written by HP Lovecraft with an idea provided by zelia Bishop and a newer story in the book of yig Revolutions of The Serpent and that is called Andrew Doran and the journey to the uh to the serpent Temple by Matthew Davenport so uh Lovecraft he was actually paid by other writers to write stories for them under their names so Lovecraft was actually paid to write HP Lovecraft pasti and the curse of a yig is a story that was that the idea was created by

zelia Bishop and they paid HP Lovecraft to write the story under their name as a ghost writer but then later on it came out of course that it was actually HP Lovecraft and so now they're basically published under HP Lovecraft but the curse of is pretty interesting so um Y is not always antagonistic towards man as long as you avoid hurting any snakes don't step on any snakes don't kill any snakes and you should be okay so snakes are also known to have a lot of Offspring and yig has a lot of Offspring The Children of of yig they are known so there are a lot of Cults around the world dedicated to yig just because of the numbers of his children and so yig also has the ability to turn his cultist into these half snake like creatures who wear human skin as disguises the curse of yig takes place in Oklahoma which is a weird setting for an HP Lovecraft story and because of the Mesoamerican uh kind of theming of yig and being in the jungles and being a little bit more adventurous in these kind of more adventurous locations like South America a lot of the stories with yig have a kind of Indiana field where they're going into these ancient uh temples these ancient South American temples and that's kind of what the Andrew Doran story is Andrew Doran and the journey to the serpent Temple is basically a story of Indiana Jones

versus yig so there aren't a lot there isn't a lot of fiction about yig but what's there is pretty interesting and our final great old one of course is yag Soo the all-in-one and the one in all the key in the gate or as Richard elney might say Yahweh and yes once again we are turning to the fiction of Richard El Tierney and that is with two stories uh the Lords of Pain and the Winds of Zar and then we'll also briefly talk about a story written by HP Lovecraft and E Hoffman price called through the gates of the silver key or beyond the gates of the silver key I should say let's start with that one so yog saath is kind of the Big Daddy of the CCD of the cthulu cycle d he kind of the main god um HP Lovecraft kind of I guess jokingly referred to these stories as yog soryy or yog sothy I've heard I've heard both I guess thank God August derth chose the cthulu Mythos a little easier to say uh perhaps the first appearance of yog sooth was in the case of Charles Dexter Ward by HP Lovecraft in which the entity is really only a word used in conjunction with the spell uh kind of a mere ingredient depicted in cabalistic Magic so yog sooth is like neur arthot is another entity that has been kind of one of the big antagonistic presences the an antagonistic presence in the

world of Lovecraft going all the way back to his dream Tales his tales inspired by uh Lord dunani and that's what beyond the gates of the silver key is we learn about Randolph Carter who was an Explorer in the earth's dreamlands and perhaps his final confrontation with yog Soo and then in the two Richard El Tierney stories Lords of Pain and Winds of Zar man I I cannot recommend this collection enough the yog soo cycle so chaosium never did a yog Soo cycle I think that was the only one of the main deities that they did not do a collection for and I'm not sure why but this company here ramble house they put out the yog soo cycle and this is a newer volume I think 2022 it came out uh yeah 2022 again edited by Robert impr price with a fantastic introduction all about yog sooth from Robert and press really really good this collection is amazing and the main story which is a novel length story called The Winds of Zar if you were to buy that uh as a single volume it goes for something like $300 or $400 because it's only ever been published One Time by the small company and I think fewer than a thousand were ever released so to have that here readily available is just amazing but both of these stories Lords

of Pain and the Winds of Zar they feature a character created by tyranny called David tagert and David tagert is a mysterious time traveling human who actually wants to work with the great old ones so they can destroy the entire universe and get rid of all the pain and suffering Lords of Pain the first story here is set during the aftermath of World War II in the Middle East against the backdrop of racism Nazi occultism and political Strife in Jordan and man it Lords of Pain that is the right uh name for that story because there is a lot of pain in that story and it all kind of emanates from yog sooth and then in Winds of Zar Winds of Zar takes place during The Exodus during the uh the biblical time of Exodus and it features David tager working to help free the Hebrew slaves from the clutches of an evil Sorcerer And pharaoh and they end up discovering that yog sooth is actually a depiction of a Yahweh and in that story Robert or not Robert in price but Richard El Cher establishes that uh Judaism and Christianity are really Cults that are dedicated to yog sooth under his disguise of Yahweh just really really cool I love the way that tyranny mixes in these kind of historical elements and it's super cool I cannot recommend this collection enough as a

matter of fact through all of these stories I I think that the three from TIY would be the ones that I I recommend the most and and of course the lumely one and those are all have been such fun I've had such a fun time reading all of this stuff for this episode so all right I hope you guys enjoyed this um this little detour into appendix M now let's get back to the game so Arkham Horror it doesn't just tell stories but it creates stories it creates memories it creates lasting memories what this game does best of all is it gives you these little dots and as players we get to connect these dots we get to connect them uh through the action that we are taking on the table through the things that we are actually doing in the game we aren't just reading about Mandy Thompson we aren't just reading about Jenny Barnes we aren't just reading about ithaqua we're not reading about things they did passively we are taking active roles we are actively participating in the story that is happening on the table and so many modern games lose that uh they they lose focus on that we are often reading about things our characters are doing rather than actually doing them and Arkham Horror second edition is completely focused on that action it's focused on that not a passive storytelling but in active storytelling we the players are creating the story and through that we are also creating these lasting memories and so many times I hear people talk about the things that

they did in these games as Jenny Barnes as Mandy Thompson as Kate winthrip as Daryl Simmons as Dexter Drake or maybe Sister Mary you start to connect those dots and you remember those things you create great memories at the table focused on the characters and also focused on the people that you were playing the game with but as good as this game is it does have some problems and I have mentioned quite a few of those problems up uh in the previous segments but uh in addition to introducing me to the term threat management I believe that this was also the first game that introduced me to the term fiddly this is the first game that I remember people uh being critical about because it was fiddly and I think one of the things that people think about when they think of something that's fiddly is these uh these skill sliders and moving these things around from one turn to the next I know they completely got rid of this ability to change your skills from one turn to the next in eldrich horror and in Arkham Horror Third Edition I like that some people don't because it does kind of take away one of the choices that you have to make but this system here that was implemented is just fiddly because I don't know if I've ever played a game of Arkham Horror where somebody at some point hasn't bumped the table hasn't moved these and then had to be oh man where where were my skill sliders at uh

I knocked my skill slider off so it's just something to keep in mind there are also a lot of decks of cards to keep track of there are what nine different decks of encounter counter cards 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 nine so nine different decks of encounter cards your otherworldly deck of cards your Mythos cards your skill cards your common item cards your spell cards your uh your unique cards a few uh cards for your different conditions so there's just a lot of stuff you need a lot of TBL space this game takes up a ton of table space just a ton it takes up almost my entire table I can barely just just barely put on one of the sideboards when I'm playing one of the expansions your characters will end up with a lot of cards as the game progresses so you need a lot of space to keep track of all of the things that your characters have going on so yeah you can end up spending a lot of time managing things being fiddly about things at the table and the games can also go on for a really really long time I've seen games go for over 4 hours I think the most people I've ever played with was five I can't even imagine playing with eight you would definitely need to take those simultaneous phase turns if you're playing with with with eight but I played with five I believe one time and we had two sideboard expansions and that took all day that took something like 6 hours it was fun but towards the end of that day uh we

were all tired we were all ready for the game to be over for sure there are also some there's also some fiddlin with those stat checks with those skill tests and just sometimes in how they work and it usually has to do with combat and that's because you have a fight test so a game so one of the skills say it might say make a fight test well a fight test isn't a combat check so if you're doing a fight test you don't add anything that adds to your combat checks however combat is a fight check and so you do add your fight dice to your combat checks and so that gets a little confusing sometimes especially when you start introducing some of the immunities or the resistances that the monsters or the great old ones might have the movement of the monsters you really do need to keep track of the colored border so we have black red yellow blue I think that's all in the base game but each one of those colors corresponds to a different way that the that the monsters move the blue monsters are flying monsters so they only really only attack investigators in streets and if there are no investigators in the streets then they fly off camera here and they go hang out in the sky off camera uh yellow bordered monsters they don't move red bordered monsters I don't remember what they do and black bordered monsters are normal each of the monsters will have certain um abilities such as being nightmares or physical resistant or if

you they might have some special ability against combat checks or they might be M have magical immunity so there's a lot of stuff to keep track of there's are a few little key keywords and it's not made any easier to keep track of all that because of the lackluster rule book which we have already mentioned in the in the introduction but yeah this rule book does leave a lot to be desired uh the back of the rule book does contain most of the information you will need it is actually a pretty good player Aid there but again I do recommend going if you're getting into this game now uh going into to BGG and downloading some of the really handy player raids that people have made especially the huge collection of player raids that Universal head has made and they cover everything they cover all of the expansions all of the upgrades and everything that you would need to play a game of Arkham

Harbor so yes Arkham Horror second edition it really is a game like no other even after 20 years I still think this game is important I still think this game is special there is is an intense feeling of anti of anticipation when I have this set up and I am ready to take my first turn I always ask myself just what the hell is going to happen in this game you never really know what's going to happen this is a game that has created superstitions around the game never ever ever mention that your game is going well if you do that the game is just going to take you and punch you in the face and a whole bunch of bad stuff will start happening it's like when you open this box you are unleashing this force of of of cardboard chaos this is a game that often people say the game knows the game knows it doesn't know it's just a big pile of stupid cardboard but it feels like there is some kind of Supernatural power in this game where you are doing well and then all of a sudden you turn the wrong corner and the game punches you down and unleashes a gate and three monsters and you just you lose you you lose control of things so quickly we had a Superstition where when we were rolling our dice we would say all at once you're a Dun one at a time you're doing fine so never roll your dice all at once you

will have a really bad score there no fives no sixes but if you roll one at a Time uhoh come on one at a Time come on Superstition don't let me down there we go see one at a time you're doing fine um yeah there are also superstitions about uh who which characters you play we always always had to have somebody play Jenny Barnes Jenny Barnes was just our our good luck charm when we were playing we felt that we always did better when we played as Jenny Barnes we always did bad whenever we played like with uh Mike Michael mcglinn I just I don't like Michael mcglinn I don't really like any of the characters that have one of their stats at a three this seven three spread is really difficult to work with because it's very easy to lose either three stamina or three Sanity on a single turn so there are a few characters that do have a three in one of their stats and those are really hard to deal with I don't typically like playing with those kinds of characters another thing of course that Arkham Horror did is help usher in this Great era of Co-op and solo games that we are enjoying so much now and of course I think pandemic really uh really bore the fruit of that effort but Arkham horr definitely planted the seeds and it was definitely an important step in this direction and yes to this day 20 years later I really think this is still a special game and yes I do think it's still worth picking up just the base

game you can get the base game they made a lot of these you can get the base game for not a lot of money I still see it go on eBay for under $50 and of course a lot of those copies are pretty beat up because this was a well-loved game this is a game that people played a lot of but some of that uh wear and tear I think are signs of Love are signs of respect respectful wear and tear you could say but I do recommend just picking up the base game unfortunately it's the expansions that are super super expensive but even some of those can still be found for under $100 which is a lot of money but the base game for under 50 bucks like I've seen it go for is great you will get maybe four plays a year and that's fantastic there are a lot of games that you own that you probably don't play four times a year you know just the base game I don't think it hands enough variety for you to play every weekend and have fun but if you pull it out a few special times a year you know maybe at Halloween or something like that or maybe in the dead of winter then I do think it is still a game that is worth investing your time in worth worth investing your money and then maybe you can take it easy over the years and maybe pick up an expansion here or there if you have the discretionary income so all right you guys well I hope you enjoyed my review of Arkham horor second edition we've got a lot more Arkham Arkham Horror and Arkham files coverage coming up on the dungeon dive over the next year take it

easy we'll talk to you later bye-bye

Progress saved