Wingspan: Asia - Discussion
Transcript
thank you some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocked and Brett and I are doing a no run through review for the newest expansion of wingspan Asia this has been a long time coming because I know that they had announced this uh a while back and their days are shut down and then Asia shut down yeah and then they had to just put uh push it off um but to be honest like I didn't think too much of this expansion whenever it was announced because I was like is this could be more birds it was to be expected whenever they did the Europe expansion the Oceana then this one and based off what I know of the size of the nesting box it's big enough to house additional expansions so I think they got what four more continents to do uh Mars yeah the yeah they're gonna go sci-fi um but the biggest difference of what this expansion brings I mean of course it brings in new Birds relatively similar mechanisms that you've seen of round end stuff and so there's nothing really special about that the biggest thing to talk about is it's duet mode uh which is a new way to play like the Standalone game of one to two player um and it's flock mode but we're not going to talk about the flock mode because I don't ever want to play wingspan with six to seven people and so I haven't flock mode is just the same with Asian Birds throwing no it adds in this um it does it does add in something of a player setup but yeah it's like like look at the setup
for flock mode like you have the four players and then you have this whole other weird thing for the three other players of where it includes like obviously you have the the board and stuff uh but then you have like a um a dial too I didn't look too much into it because I was like absolutely not I would never play wingspan with six to seven people um because you barely interact with each other yeah um I guess you can with like more once between turns but that would be like you can just play just play the burger man or please somebody lay eggs I've got yeah you've got to do that when someone else yeah exactly so this is gonna be primarily focused on I guess Asia and the duet mode so Brett what did you think of the duet mode um fine yeah um it's it's not a game that I particularly enjoy Bass but um so having this extra complication and extra stuff to consider for me just kind of slowed it down slightly not a lot but one more thing to think about do you want to play this bird here what Nest type is it what am I going to gain I know it it could be somebody that somebody does a lot of math in their head and it really slows it down yeah but I didn't especially because that's why I didn't win uh yeah it was still really close in the last game we just played by 10 point swing um and yeah so the duet mode adds in this like area control board that's not
really a control well it is because you take I know you're right it is not area control it is a uh in terms of um congruent areas right strategic locations yeah yeah I guess area control is the wrong phrasing so um so everyone has these yin yang um tokens and what what birds you play where you play them affects where you can place these tokens and the end game scoring objectives are about those tokens like the ones that we had this game was most of those tokens on food areas then total on the map and then uh tokens not on the edge of the map and then fewest on bonus spaces and paths that you have connected at the end of the game yes your largest contiguous grouping um or connected line is also a point so that replaces the end around scoring mechanism from the other game but everything else still scores the same exactly yeah so uh one thing I will say I mean I think I like the fact that the duet mode I think it's fun that it exists and I'm glad it didn't overly complicate like they didn't do some weird like oh well now these birds do this you know where it's like they like have to affect you know 800 Birds um it's just oh I played this gray wagtail here and because of that it has that kind of nest and I can take that it had some kind of extra strategy which I
guess is fine with a two player it would only complicated larger play this in flock mode no so good good decision to not allow more people because there's no theoretically there's no reason more people couldn't do it it's just it would really slow down turns we'll accept the fact that like if someone was able to get all of their spots filled there's not enough room well on this board they would have to oh yeah yeah and make it redesign it for more make a board for the amount of people yes but that would not be fun would you be miserable um so it's fine as a two-player game especially because the scoring objectives I think also fit well where it's just kind of like oh okay either you have the most or I have the most yeah uh I mean because in terms of yeah the end of wrong goals you got two more points than I did um like and then the duet tokens even really wasn't that big of a swing it was I got nine and you had four right so and so it does have that extra element of thinking of like okay I'm gonna go here because that's gonna connect all those and therefore I'm foregoing this end of end of round objective yeah um and I hope that that pans out yeah overall I never thought that there was a problem with the two-player game of wingspan anyway like this just has another layer it does to of complexity to consider that it works well for people who really strategize and really enjoy this game yeah I I I I I think it's great you know what's weird for those people
I almost feel like that this that the duet mode is mismarketed because wingspan is clearly over a million copies sold like I think um on the the dice tower has done like um they did best publisher like like top like the best Publishers and people were voting on it it was like a bracket tiering tournament thing I think stonemeyer won um probably largely because of wingspan it's just so accessible like yeah it's um yeah interesting it's interesting especially if you do take the time to read the bird facts like I love the fact that they are adding uh different cultural Birds yeah um and I would read a few like there was one that you played I'm like hey I want to read that yeah because that's uh that's a sexy bird but it's meant like this is a game that you could play with almost anybody yeah like yeah there's a few things where it's like oh okay I'm gonna play over here and then you have to go down the trail but overall it says Hey draw two cards and tuck them behind a bird yeah yeah each individual rule is easy and and you know almost anybody could play it and a lot of people obviously enjoy it well yeah very much love it so then it's like oh okay well then they have this this thing this extra Board of I feel like this might be a little much for most people who are wanting to play wingspan who like I could probably through a couple plays teach wingspan to my mom and there have been very few games like horrified and quacks have have been the two that have worked and
even horrified I'm like no just move but she was able to get quacks and horrified I'm pretty sure I could teach wingspan yeah after a few tries yeah after a couple of rounds it's pretty easy it just flows but I don't think I think this would be too much as an intro I would say yeah yeah either you're either you're a board gamer and you're looking for an extra Challenge and you find yourself in one or two um do you know anything about the solo mode does I don't uh I that's something I kind of want to find out just because I think the solo mode for regular ring span is is pretty good like it's not like amazing I'm not you know screaming it from the mountaintops um but oh it's it's gonna be in the automa book but it does say oh hey there's a one to two player Standalone so I'm assuming that it also affects this and I'll probably give that a shot okay but for two people want to strategize you know married couple or good friends or people living in the same area yeah it's it's all it's it's the same concept it's not overly complicated right it's another layer of thinking about it that only two people a simple game might go too quickly that that they can consider and strategize over yeah the uh well here's the other thing is so all the birds and stuff at least all the ones that we saw um and there's a decent amount that's added not too much like the Oceana one was like here's a new deck and you're
like oh my God this doesn't add like a bunch of birds but none of them seem to actually mess with this which I like because you can just get this expansion take these birds toss them into though yeah yeah there's nothing different about them not even nectar no on any of them they're just all the standard but yeah well Nectars were wild weren't they and I guess I think some birds specifically required it right that's what I mean but yes it's a standalone expansion to the base game yes compatible with any of the other expansions exactly so but then like in the Oceana expansion and the uh Europe they added unique end game scoring tiles because those that was a new way but they didn't do that here like the it's not like you have one side of the in-game scoring where it's like hey it's for the duet mode and the other side is not it's true all of these are only for the dreads so you're still limited um you still have to deal with the same end game scoring unless you are playing one or two players true but since the bird cards don't add anything new they're fully compatible with the old in-game rules the birds are yes yeah you're just not getting anything new of the end game scoring yeah round scoring yeah um and then the uh the end game goals like the the goal cards those are also not related to the duet mode right so it does just seem like that they're like hey these are the duet scoring but everything else is
compatible with the other expansions um and it does have rules in there if you're adding in the other expansions of how that's tweaked um but yeah other than that it's uh it's a new expansion to wingspan again kind of like other expansions if you don't like the base game I really don't think you'll like duet mode no here's more than I like exactly but yeah since so many people do here's a new fun wrinkle plus um I assume it's cheaper than the base game because it is its own individual game it is fully playable that is true it has its own box you're right I think it was like 40 30 or 40 dollars so it might be something people could try out see how they like it that's a good point yeah and then go yeah let's get everything else yeah 375 yeah let's get the nesting box yeah so yeah that's a good point I forgot yeah we did just like open the box and it's like hey here's the two boards here's everything you need to play yeah um you don't even have to do the duet mode right um because it teaches you the rules specifically teach you how to play um without the duet mode then there's a separate section it's like oh and your game scoring now here's the duet section yeah and they do also include um like almost like a setup step-by-step kind of like walk you through the duet mode cool so for play array and um player B uh so that's that's there I don't think it's needed but maybe that's that's just me well we played the base game so many times exactly yeah it isn't
um but yeah Asian birds are cool they look cool I like them they're neat throw them throw them in and that's just what I'm gonna do I don't foresee myself playing duet mode like again like I find I find a wing and it's weird coming for me because normally I like simpler games to have more elements of strategy right but I think wingspan is that sweet spot there is enough strategy of what you're doing ahead because the end game goals are already there and you can play the friendlier game of like you know I get the most points but you still get some points or you can play the most or Elite or whoever has the most gets all the points or none I just I didn't find this appealing like it was it was an extra layer but I was just kind of like it was an extra layer but still it was so simple that it didn't require any extra thought it was just another thing gotcha so I'm like well I guess I'm just gonna take all the birds and the gold cards and yeah there's there's so many spaces available that I didn't feel like there was any reason this guy I'm gonna go here because I'm afraid you might there was I didn't ever think that either but there was times where I played a bird because I wanted its ability and I happened and I so I played like the white-headed duck for example which is in the aqua or the wetlands area and I'm like oh cool I so I do its ability and look over and I'm like I don't have that Nest I didn't pay a I didn't pay a fish I didn't oh I actually can't go anywhere huh okay well I guess I'll go there did you really did you really hit that yeah there were times where like I just didn't that's what there one of the
times I went there was because I actually couldn't go anywhere oh I did not notice that um interesting but it wasn't ever something that I was like methodically like man because there's no way to keep track there's no way for me to know what I'm taking from you three was always an afterthought yeah I always played the bird and then what can I do with this exactly yes that's exactly where I was and because of that it's this actually more annoying than something that's like oh man okay so if he does this the 90 okay so I need to go there and then yeah yeah it's like no no it's not there uh but with that being said um on a scale of one to ten what would you give the wingspan Asia expansion considering as an expansion and a separate Standalone game yeah um because I really can't finally separate those uh I'm gonna go with seven okay but it kind of feels like I'm cheating a little bit almost seven and a half okay eight feels like too much but seven feels like it's a little bit better than that interesting interesting I'm actually kind of lower okay yeah I think I'm out of six of like I don't think I don't I don't think the duet Mode's bad right but I don't think even though it's like you said hey this is a trial like Standalone game you can't just buy this and play regular wingspan that's cool but you're getting less content yep like pay ten dollars more and you can get a full massive game of wingspan but then if you want the duet mode you have this weird
air weird play up half of a yin yang on it and then you get very little content like you're not actually getting you know any extra in-game goals you're you are getting more cards and that's why it's not like a three or a four it's because it's like well it's still wingspan the birds are still cool the in-game goals are still cool the game still plays the exact same but the unique thing of this expansion is this kind of whatever so that's kind of I'm like okay no sure gotcha six out of ten like if you love wingspan definitely get it yeah give the do it mode a try maybe you'll love it but um and uh flock mode is just wasted cardboard for those pieces because that'll that'll never happen so yeah I think it's still a slightly above average expansion because it's still wing span um but it's not like amazing I would honestly say get Oceana in Europe first gotcha because I like the nectar of Oceana in Europe and or Europe was just Europe is just more bird it was just so much it was just basically way more content yeah uh so I would get I would go Europe Ocean than this one okay but that's it everyone that's our thoughts on wingspan Asia let us know other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead
and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you