Gothic: A Shadow’s Quest (C+) Final Grade - Kickstarter Critique Clip
Transcript
Okay. Let's get a grade. And we as always with the intellectual property games, we split it right down the middle. How'd you do with fans? How'd you do with people like me, non-fans? Do I want it? I think if you're a fan, yes. Yes, yes, yes. You clearly you love Gothic. They have the rule booklet there. They have plenty of videos and they did do a decent job making the game sound fun. One to five players, you could be a the the GM running it. 45-hour main story. Kudos on that. I'm going to go with a third of a point grade bump up, by the way. I didn't do it earlier, but I I'm I'm I want to do it now because I feel like they did do a pretty good job towards the beginning. No, I'm not. I'm going to take it away. That 30 I'm not going to give them the third of a point grade bump up because I think it's immediately diminished by that stupid video that really should have been longer. It should have been longer for everybody. Should have been longer for your fans. Should have been longer for your non-fans. It should have showcased a lot of the cool stuff that you have like the the secret little decoder thing and then somebody doing the one versus all.
But I digress. Do I want it as a non-fan? Nah. I I mean maybe the standard. Maybe the standard, right? But I'm not really sold. And they could have sold me better, you know? Some quotes. Some some things. You some quotes and showing me the stretch goals and a better video, right? That really showcase like ah here's the oomph of it. Maybe showcasing me what Gothic was and then what it is now on the board. There's a lot of stuff they could have done here and I don't feel like they did. But as a fan, yes. No doubt about it. The price feels reasonable especially when you factor in that they have the the the bare-bones edition at 80, the acrylics edition at 110, and this edition at $200. So they they have all their bases covered. So can you do it? Split it down the middle? Not really if you're not a fan of the IP. And yeah, probably. You did a pretty good job if you are.
Can you do it? Yeah, I'm not worried about that. I mean it's thick Nordic. You saw that Wikipedia page we went down? They got video game money, which is substantially different from board game money. So, yes, this is not going to be the thing that CMON hides their head in the sand about. That was one of our biggest shames. We didn't ship it out. No. I'm not worried about that at all. And how much is it? Um If I'm a fan, it feels reasonable, right? It's like 80 plus the shipping, you're looking at about 100-ish dollars. And as a video game fan, you know, you might buy a $70 video game sometime. You get the the fancy version with like the the day one version with a bobblehead or some crap like that. You're you're easily spending 100 120 dollars on a lot of those things. So, I don't think the $80 price point, especially before shipping, is going to rock anybody's world with 100 plus standees and the fact that it's made by the company themselves, I think really helps IP fans a lot and also helps non-IP fans a lot, right? Because I'm like, oh yeah, is CMON really going to not ship this out? So, can you do it is yeah, I'm not worried about that.
Um even though I do believe this is their first board game. They've done so many video games. It's it's gaming. It's gaming. We'll we'll give them the nod. And then how much is it? If you're a fan, I don't think it's bad. If you're not a fan, I think they could swing you with that one, but it's still paying $100 for a standee version, it doesn't feel great. Doesn't feel great. Well, it comes with five minis, too. What? Okay, why don't you lead with that, too? Like, why don't you have the five minis there? I thought that would have been nice. Yeah, that's it. They did take have the long sexy scrolling shot, really, of the pledges. I don't think they had like a pledge area. Maybe that's what it is. Yeah, I think that it is what it is. They just had to buck the industry standard and just like, yeah, we'll just let the rewards section do the job of the pledge area. And this is one of those things I've talked about a lot.
It's one of those weird areas where it's like I think Game Found is amazing for forcing people to be like, all right, you have to have this over here on your story. But in doing so, I feel like sometimes people are like, "Well, since they already have that there, we don't have to do anything special with it." Like the stretch goals, perfect example. It's like they just vomit them all right there. But then again, Gamefound made them vomit them all right there. And and instead of just this being an awesome spectacular super fun trip through your stretch goals, a long scrolling shot, which is typically and has been for a very long time the industry standard of like, "Oh, at 100,000 we hit this. At 150 we hit this. At 200 we hit this." And you scroll down that and you get more and more excited as you progressively go. Whereas this it's like, "Do I want to click through 18 of them?" No. At least And And what's worse is I can't just I can't just hit the button and be like, "Oh, go to the next.
Go to the next. Go to the next." Yeah, I There's a lot of these little things that I feel like really could have used a level of polish here. I said it earlier, this feels like the rough draft of a a really solid campaign page, but they just didn't update it. Which is surprising. I wonder if they had some of the stuff in here. They had a set up video? Ooh, that's a how to play. I mean, they got a lot of stuff in here. Why would you get rid of all this? That feels like a poor choice. And this is what I'm talking about. People always take the wrong People take the wrong things from failed campaigns sometimes. If you were worried that your campaign page was going to be too long because that stuff, then shove that stuff at the bottom. Right? That's the whole point of this. If I want to get down to exactly blah blah blah blah blah, I can get it here. And cutting it out I don't think is great. Because especially if I'm a non-fan of Gothic, I feel like you get into the weeds a little bit, like quotes like some quotes like, "Oh, the deck building really worked well with the the sand block nature of the game." I don't know if it's deck building game. I don't know if it's a sand block game. But if I saw that quote, I'd be like, "Oh, deck building sand block, 600 plus cards?"
Like you see what I'm saying? There was There was so much lifting that could have been done with very easy industry standard things and they decided not to do it. And And as a result, I feel like this grade isn't going to be nearly as good as it could be. This one feels like it is a full point grade bump up from the potential of this campaign with just a little bit of cursory work. Just a little bit of work. And once again, I use cursory a lot. I hope I'm using it correct. I don't know cursive, but I do know cursory. Uh so, final grade is um See? Cuz here's the bottom line. I think if you're a Gothic fan, I don't think this is like blowing your pants off, right? I don't feel like, "Oh my god, I'm blown away. It's going to unless you do the research, right? If you do the research, and you're like, "All right, I went through the videos. I watched the gameplay. I looked at the rulebook. It's going to be super awesome." Then, yeah.
But if you didn't, eh. Ooh, that's a nice one. Look at that. So, this is the long sexy scrolling shot, but it's it's Is it all It's almost I almost missed it. It's too long. Like what There's just huge chunks of stuff in between. But, is this And this Oh, this is the standee. What in the world here? It just looks like you puked everything all in one spot. Cuz we were going through what's in the box, but now Oh, so you're saying in this box we have cardboard standees, in this box we have acrylics, in this one we have the miniatures. And all you had to do here was put the prices right there. And all of a sudden, I don't know. It's just weird. I'm going to go with a C. I think a C is fair. I don't feel like if you're a Gothic fan, that you're just over the moon about this. But you're probably just over the moon because there's now this really complex-looking, awesome-looking Gothic board game with tons of variability and special powers and cool minis and cool standees and cool acrylics. And they let you make that choice. And I will give them a third of point grade bump up for that.
So, we'll go C plus. Cuz I really do appreciate it. I personally think from a company perspective, you leave some money on the table by doing this. By by essentially saying, "All right, you can get this one. You can get this one. Or you can get this one." But from a consumer perspective, that's awesome. So, yeah. C plus. Let me know in the comments below what's your final grade for Gothic: A Shadow's Quest? And if you have a request for an upcoming Kickstarter project, please be sure to leave it in the in the comments