Bonsai: Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to war games on like we're doing a discussion over Bonsai uh which is a game about building trees B which is another damn nature another yeah there's there's too many uh right you know what I'm rooting for global warming now I'm an advocate for pollution nature games or apocalypse games we don't have to be for pollution just for global warming that's true just for the eradication of just nature in general yeah uh so this what this game came out last year right uh3 yeah cuz it was a Gen Con last year right um it's where it premiered I believe and I remember I remember seeing it all the time at Gen Con the tables were constantly full um and and it's cute yeah it's it's a cute it's a cute fun little little puzzle game right um pretty light yeah akin to kind of a lot of other games like not in in what it does like in terms of specifically uh just the light puzzlin of it it's not overly complicated I'd liken it to like King Domino yeah yeah yeah cuz I'm totally different placement but but the puzzle of figuring out how to ideally place things right yeah without knowing what your puzzle pieces are going to be in the future right it's kind of like right in the middle of king and queen Domino like I'd say queen Domino had a little bit more going on but King Domino doesn't have enough so this is like
right in the middle yeah strategy wise complexity you know what I was getting Vibes for um and it could just be because of the uh the hexagon pieces uh you've played this with me have you played Honey Buzz oh yeah I have not okay so it gives me honey Buzz Vibes cuz in situation it has a little bit more work replacement but honey Buzz has you taken um hexagon pieces and building out your own Hive right and getting actions from that right uh that's kind of the vibe I was getting from whenever you're building out your tree with the different the four different pieces um but yeah just and I think these games like these kind of filler games CU this took what 30 minutes something like that um at three which apparently BG has it at best best at yeah I would think this would be probably best at three um cuz four you're just not going to get your turns as fast and there's not much difference between a four-player game and a three-player game right what about a two-player game um it was fine but I will say um I like three probably a little bit better um probably the pool changes a little faster so I was thinking maybe at two you're almost guaranteed to get the cards you want and like three you're not that's one extra person that's like oh man I could really go for that you know fruit uh gold card and he took it that's two more people who have a chance to take it from me so more people take the
chance also um you can kind of optimize a little bit more so you can allow a car to go down because the chances are that someone's going to take that car from you is going to be Slimmer and even if they do there are enough of the same cards in the deck that you're probably going to get again so if you really need it um the only difference is these you're going to get more of these scroll cards and so you're going to get more bonus points um you know what's interesting you mentioned like waiting till like it it goes down uh this is one of the few tracks you know where it's like oh if you wait for a card that risk that the end the very end of it isn't necessarily the better spot nope um cuz it's like you need wood uh surprisingly for a tree and wood is not as common as I thought it was going to be like it can be of course there's Masters and stuff that's here's two wood I think that's where it comes is there's more the Masters like I think I have five Masters and all of them have wood and one has double wood oh man that's probably why I didn't have any cuz I had all the ones giving me leaves yeah that is actually true I had a bunch of ones giving me leaves so it could just be that the ones I happen to take were four leaves but cuz I was really jonesing for like wood at one point I'm like God do I have a [ __ ] erectile dysfunction where's my wood right like I need it to get more leaves right um and I think that's a sign of a good game cuz if you're just playing like where it's like yeah I'm going to I'm going to get the card that
I want I'm going to get the tiles that I want I'm going to play Som howow I want and it's like you know let's just not do this and just say we did yeah there's just enough in my opinion there's enough tension three players um to feel good and it's always the person before me who replaced cat here now in cat where it's like there's no way anyone's going to take that go card why would you take that go card there's no reason you don't even have any fruit because then I started collecting it that's that was the first card I took yep that's that's called uh proactive thinking and then mine very reactive it's like okay I got all my fruit see I thought I was going to do that cuz I took the assistance card at the very beginning of the game is like oh I'm going to go for every assistant I can find and then no one let me grabing assistant the rest of the game which is funny yeah cuz I went for uh these um Pottery what are they called these growth cards growth cards and then flowers which I end up getting three out but then uh yeah I I had all like yeah like all the points for what you had which is again I had a ton of Masters which I got this one early on like it was at the first car I was like oh that one's just going it kind of messed up what my plan was originally for that term but I was like H I knew it was already worth a minimum of six points I was like I'm going to get a couple more points from it and I like that I like that there's that the randomness of those objectives kind of like Isle of cat style it's like here's a bunch of
these objectives that you can either be like oh I happen to have a bunch of those let me get points or um or or start Play yeah you know get them away early and start building towards they kind a um variant to basically Shuffle these into the first third of the deck to basically help encourage someone to go a specific like so they're out and now I have them so I can start going for a specific path versus like oh I knew you took tons of assistance I'm just going to take that assistant bonus card away from you even though you spent a lot of the game getting assistance from yeah you know hate drafting where it's like okay you're getting no points but you not getting points is the same as me gaining points it's like right except I'm going to shoot you now in real life uh Brett what do you think of the game uh cute but but not simplistic there's enough strategy to really engage and you got to think you got to plan and then you got to realize oh [ __ ] I cheated yeah we all did except except the person who's been playing it every day since he got it like but but this as this as much as you've been playing balers Gate 3 right oh yeah just hundreds of hours of bonsai have you played the solo I have not okay cuz I'm not really a solo player I understand just just in case if anybody happen to know what it was like nope no idea how the solo plays I assume it's going to be halfway decent because this game wow
slightly interactive in the sense that you're losing cards to someone else pulling them realistically there's not much player interaction other than that yeah and and it should I will say so we were talking about how this is like has elements of honey Budz and all those it fits in that genre of canvas Calico verdant um all those FL uh Flatout games I think it's the Publishing Company um but I would say it's not as heavy as those uh canvas to me is way heavier than this is canvas is surprisingly deceptive you'll spend a lot of your time like okay if I do this combination this combination sh right and I have five so I have to make a painting I hate my art I hate it and then you you know kill yourself uh well then you win is what you find out is when you do like terrible art like what you think is terrible art then just for whatever reason wins you the game that's true it's like hey my art sucks but people love it um I will say that this game can have a chance for you to actually be completely shut out yep uh you could build yourself around a way to not while you play right and I mean to be fair you're entirely conscious there's a there's a move that I'm suddenly remembering from from a playthrough I watched that if you find yourself completely shut out there's something you can do oh good there might be you're allowed to remove tiles I think see okay yeah cuz I was I was
wondering if there was like but it's not long enough I don't think for that to be a serious problem yeah and to be fair you are entirely conscious of placing your own tiles so if your if you cover like don't cover up all your wood with leaves and then you don't have it out then it's like yeah well I guess I'm uh I guess I'm not playing anymore there are a few things along those lines there are a few things I can think of that would be both better and worse if it were a longer game yeah yeah so I mean like it's an engine builder but you really just start your engine going and then it's over honestly yeah if this game was like 15 minutes longer I probably wouldn't like it as much cuz there's not enough to do they found that sweet spot of like and it's done and you're like okay I don't feel unfulfilled like I got what I wanted um I built my tree it was like Brett was saying like oh we got quite a bit of game left and I'm kind of looking at the P like not really my head like well to yeah I mean one of the game left the game length I guess is technically determined by player agency uh where it's like it depends on how many cards you choose to take versus like okay I've built up enough of a pool to know cultivate but again not really because your cultivate can be you know 10 tiles you know you build up a pool and then you're like oh okay now I'm going to dump seven of them instead of it being like oh you can only do three right so you have this massive pool it just takes 10 turns especially if you've been
grabbing lots of cards you probably have lots of tiles and also you have tools or other growth cars so you can then play all those tiles so you cultivate at least for me is basically you might save one tile like you have one tile left over but you are dumping everything else it's actually pretty interesting cuz I only I never got tool cards like I was running with five tiles and I was like this might come back to bite me but I'm going to I'm going to play my I'm going to play my cards see how it uh see how it works out and I never felt behind you got a bunch of assistance didn't you Yes actually you know what that's fair that's how yeah I got I got three assistants that helped me pump them out so I didn't have to go after tool cards went for the tool cards honestly because they were at the spots I needed those tiles for and I was like I need those tiles so I'm going to grab it the tool cards aren't bad they're not going to harm anything right um but they're not super advantageous like I was ever running out kind of that is does that action have a name did you find it where you can remove so there's a note that just says in the improbability that this happens if you're an idiot you remove the least number of tiles from your tree to be able to place a wood card okay or wood token down oh you get like a free wood token or okay you basically so you do a cultivate and if you need to build continue on building wood and you can't you remove one tile at a time until you're able to place that wood in the spot okay and they go back to the General Supply so you lose those tiles
that you remove which I mean thematically is you because I'm pretty sure you have to trim Bonsai to get them to I I've never had a bonsai and I I'm not I don't a green thumb but I'm pretty sure you like trim it to like have it grow and stuff so it's like oh that's kind of cool you trim off like oh well I have to get rid of these three cuz I blocked myself somewhere else and okay that's what I had to cut off though now the fruit and the leaves and the flower died but that's going to allow me to build out right so never mind disregard you can't close yourself out cuz there are games where it's like oh I messed up well I guess I'm not playing anymore this is fun um any negatives on on the game I do I have one but it's more of a component issue yeah I mean so componentwise I like that they did the art that everything ties to what it's supposed to go to but the leaves are very very like you have to actually kind of look at where the wood touches the leaves and to me just bring that out a little bit clearer so there's a little more brown on it would help kind of tie all that together that's actually yeah the negative that I have is that you have all these icons like the flower with the leaves meaning that it has to touch a leaf and then the yeah like you said the leaves have to touch wood but it's not those specific sides right but then they have a token which is the fruit that it is those specific sides right and it's like well
that's just kind of weird that you would not have it matter for any of them except for one token well it doesn't really matter I guess I guess yeah it doesn't have to be that like you could do you can do that yeah there's no logic to not do it that way and to teach it that way well I also think is so um it's a good reminder it's a good reminder if you if you actually do it that way if you have these scoring help cards you could also just put those rules basically touch wood touch wood touch Leaf the two adjacent edges have to touch Leaf yeah onto these cards and again it's right there in front of you the scoring is all at the end anyway they definitely went the uh with I'm drawing a blank on it but where it's it's language independent where it's like hey anyone can play this which which I like having your tiles that way but let's just put this very simple rules right there on the card again this is your fifth playthrough I'm not needing this card anymore I know what the score points are like values are I don't need this anymore but for the first few rounds you go to a coffee shop with r you know a game group and you set this game up quickly I can now hand this to everybody everybody knows the rules I like the fact that it goes into clear detail what every Gold Tile is what every parchment tile is and what every specific card just does generically MHM so again you have a question I can literally just hand this to you and read the one page yeah no I I agree I think it it's just it's weirdly
confusing where it doesn't need to be yeah um for a game as Simple and Clean as is right uh there is one thing that I'm not sure that I care for um and it's actually a two-parter on the gold tiles the one thing I do like is I like the fact that when you meet a condition you have to announce if you want it and if you don't want it you can't take it right you can't like retroactively go back I like that because that's a risk kind of like hm can I can I can you get can I get more before some yeah before someone else for more points uh and if I can't I can't be like oh okay well I guess I'll take that I like that and I like the fact that you have to do it as soon as you meet the condition I think a lot of games should probably implement that right because it adds a level of extra strategy without adding complexity right the thing I don't think I care for and it because it is that you can get multiple goal tiles in one turn in one turn I think I think you you should still be limited to one because it kind of fits in that same like uh which one should I go for you know which one should I grab now versus and hope it's still there next turn well but the problem is then you can't say it would be hard to argue then the instant like cuz otherwise you're just saying like I can score either like if I get the wood and the leaves I was able pck those tiles cuz I needed to do it to put the fruit out yeah well now I only get one of those two even though I met both conditions and I can't do it the next turn because I didn't those condition you gave it up no well cuz you didn't
pass it I did because you have to choose it I can see that as as a rule is that you have to choose and you're not passing on the other one yeah but then but the argument is then the next round cuz technically you did meet the conditions of both and because you met the conditions you have to announce that right cuz otherwise you have to remember like so Brett passes on but then three turns down the road well he's met the condition but now everybody has to remember that he didn't just pass on that well there's that I was I was assuming it was just going to be the next round if I want to them both a memory of well he only passed out because of XYZ that was actually something that crossed my mind when I was going to play through is is is it how often is someone going to going to forget that I passed on that or somebody else that I passed on it MH and so well that's what I'm saying like cuz again them I wasn't thinking of those so I wasn't even noticing when I qualified yeah right and again and that's where like we start speeding up because like it's as soon as you would choose like a cultivate we would just move to the next play well technically you need to wait for a second because if you choose a um tile that might change what Seth's plan is cuz he might be like oh you're not claiming that I can jump in I'm going to cultivate and pop up like five you know leaves down now I can grab it and then you're like oh I'm done finally placing everything oh wait I I qualified for that yeah this game can kind of lean itself I think they probably we're we're probably not the audience that they're
aiming for we're not going to have game like people who play exensive games that are going to be like okay you cultivated I don't care about any of that so I'm going to start doing my turn and then but then there were times where it's like I'm done you start because I'm doing stuff and it's like back to Brett and he's still on the turn before and it's like and then you're and then like and you're still placing stuff and then I'm like okay I'm done I look up and then I'm like oh he must have gone right like [ __ ] did I skip you they're probably ating for more family where it's like oh okay yeah or or casual conversational people I'll take my turn I'll chat a little bit or the people like you're taking your turn and so everyone else is chatting while you're finishing your turn and then you finish and it goes to the next has enough strategy that you're like I'm not necessarily going to be chatting because it has enough puzzle element that I kind of care about what cards are coming out and what tokens I have so it's like it's not so yeah you know L fair that it's like oh okay oh is it my turn it's just like hm how am I going to play this and again maybe they're we're taking it way too seriously yeah but it can play on both levels both level true like canvas you can do the same thing you can concentrate every single move or you can just go I'm going to I'm going to take what I'm offered best I can yeah kind of in that same vein as Cascadia where it's like you kind of very much care about the positioning but it's not you're you're limited with what's what's out there right um this is actually a shocker like I I remember you bringing
it up uh yeah when it was at Gen Con and every time I walked by it I was like eh so like Year anyway yeah so that was my problem like Gen Con last year was this was one of the few games I was like oh I kind of really want that game um and mostly I've had bonsai trees I like growing bonsai trees they're super cool they're super cool it's kind of one of those fun like when I was working at office to have on your office desk you come in first thing in the morning you spray you take your M bottle you spray um like spraying like a cat yeah pretty much all right um Zach what the [ __ ] was that CU like legit like I had a one of those one gon um fish tanks and my bomai tray on my desk okay um and that was what my desk was cuz otherwise I was totally bored cuz we had no windows and you know we're in a cubicle and that was life don't die on me please you're you're my only reason for living that's weird cuz I've never mixed work and life well you're so crushing in a in a cubicle you're like I also had a Gundam next to it too a Gundam a Gundam like the little model Gundam yeah yeah yeah I got you I thought I also had a gun next to it that was the the empty Whiskey Bottle oh no anyway I'm looking I've seen uh what
is it DV yeah games um I've seen them many times as Publishers I think they're just one of those companies that brings a bunch of games over CU they have sleeping Gods on here like under under their list it's like okay that's uh they just must be one of those publishing companies yeah that grabs a bunch of games um but yeah I so whenever I was seeing they had like the how to play video uh on their tables I was like this is probably going to be like way too light um that was my fear but at the same time I thought the theme is going to get me enough that I'm going to probably enjoy it enough to play it once a month maybe once every two three months yeah and to me fits it I wouldn't want to play this all the time um because it doesn't have enough variability like right all those other games verden all like flat out games all of them have enough variety that you're going to get a new puzzle every time here have a game group that meets once a month that is on the lighter end of gaming and this game will fit well with it yeah um so on scale 1 to 10 what are we giving uh Bonsai I don't care who starts I'll go eight eight that same as me eight you know it also given an eight I think I think yeah right now it's an eight I could probably see it being a seven as time went on just cuz it's like it's it's like okay yeah like it doesn't have enough
replayability for me like a bunch of the other games that we've been talking about uh but and for being a cute little shocking shocking 30 minutes little strategy game this game is like what 30 bucks I don't remember think selling 30 35 yeah I had gift cards onest so I didn't pay attention gotcha so good price point like and it's a game about trees I think about it's a game about trees that isn't cancer like [ __ ] photosynthesis and I hate that game so much there's another game that was about trees that was similar to photosynthesis where you kind of it mattered where you were on the board for sunlight and stuff uh D to talking about but I can't think of it anyway that's Bonsai everyone let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful what every time dat this for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that sub subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top 10 or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you