Skip to main content
Loading video...

Dune Imperium Vs. Dune Imperium Uprising: A Buyer's Guide...Spice Up Your Game Collection

Transcript 25:49

hi everyone I'm tally this is farl and we are bard of it and Welcome to our buyer guide for June Imperium one of the hottest properties in board gaming of the last few years if you're here maybe you're wondering what the hell is June Imperium Uprising or maybe you're just thinking about what the differences are between the two versions of the game or maybe you're considering whether you should get the expansions but you're wondering how compatible they are with either version of the game well worry not we've got you covered we'll talk you through the history of Jan Imperium how it plays the differences and tell you about the expansions and how they fit into it all and then we'll tell you what we think of it all so if you haven't seen one of our bias gues before welcome we like to cover situations like this where it might be a bit confusing and we try to keep it mostly factual until the end where we give our opinion just so you get the information you need to know what to buy or what's best for you so we're going to time stamp all these little your segments so you can jump to what's relevant for you say if you already have Dune and you just want to know about the expansions or if you just want to know what we think and it would really help us if you would consider subscribing if you find this helpful or informative this time we didn't work with a publisher to make this but a lot of times we do and these kind of G uh videos are only possible sometimes with help because of the big amounts of content needed yeah uh and having subscribers really helps with that and most importantly you can always just

comment down below if you end up having any questions or want anything clarified and finally think about checking us out on threads because now we're there as well uh Board of it reviews Dune Imperium for one to four players from designer Paul denan and publisher dawolf arrived in late 2020 at a strategic deck building work placement mashup as was the style at the time in part it was a time with the at that time upcoming Dune movie using art based on the movie pretty much an instant Smash Hit It has Barrel up the board game geek top 100 and it is currently in seventh place at time of writing everything went quiet until 2022 which saw the release of two expansions the rise of X and immortality which were both very well received in 20123 there was then the announcement and release of Dune Imperium Uprising an updated Standalone version of Dune Imperium with several updates to gameplay and based a little more on the upcoming Dune part two movie it has a player count of one to four players along with a special six player team mode June Imperium is quite simply a race to 10 BP for the majority of games this will be the end game trigger and whoever has the most VP at the end of the round this is triggered will win otherwise the game will end after 10

Rounds each round plays out the same way and starts with players drawing five cards from their deck into their hands players then take it in turns to send agents out to work a placement spaces with the twist being that they also have to play a card from their hand that has a matching symbol to the space they want to send them many of the cards also have when played trigger effects so then players can take the action on the board or trigger the effect on the card in either order once out of Agents players will reveal showing any cards that they didn't play cards have a secondary effect at the bottom of the card which triggers when revealed many of the cards will have persuasion which is used to them buy new cards or maybe they'll have combat points combat is a huge part of June Imperium with players being able to send troops into battle to fight over victory points and rewards in short the player with the most strength will win the battle but combat points can also come from entry cards and reveal turns so there can always be surprises DP comes from a variety of sources winning a battle gaining influence of the different factions which is essentially moving up some tracks B cards and Intrigue cards intrig cards are fun little secret cards which have all types of effects on them which shake up the game and the combat this is a tense tight strategic race where you have to work hard every point you get and building a good deck is crucial to that

it also gets tighter the more players you have because you can't send your workers or agents to the same spaces where other players also have their agents so what's the difference between the two variations well in terms of core gameplay not a lot you're still going to be drawing five cards from your deck into your hand every round you're still going to be using those cars to send agents to work placement spaces and you're still racing for 10 VP however there are some subtle and some not so subtle changes to some mechanisms most of the available action spaces do remain the same with only a few being swapped out for entirely new actions while some others are just simply tweaked the starting deck is also exactly the same but the cards that you can purchase from the market are different as is the Intrigue deck we will also note that June Imperium is far more take that with Intrigue and Imperium cards having far more ways to affect other players say preventing them from going to a space or removing their troops from combat something new mechanistically are the spies which are tokens you can place on the spaces on the main board to allow yourself to go there if somebody else has already claimed the spot making that tight worker placement from the original that bit less harsh there's also an optional module involving contracts

which we're sure everybody will play with essentially you'll pick up contracts along the way that get fulfilled when you go to certain spaces and when you do you'll get some rewards the biggest most dramatic and most divisive change of all are the worms June Uprising now comes with worms which are a slightly stronger type of troop which can be recruited for combat they take a Fair bit of thematic work to unleash but they are worth it because they double the rewards that you get in the combat including victory points there's also a new way to score from combat as the conflict cards have symbols on them and they will go to the winning player and then when a player has a matching pair of symbols they can spend them in order to get a point lastly there's the addition of a team game where three players take on three players and everyone scores individually but their combined score will determine which team will

win June Imperium rise of X was the first expansion for June Imperium it adds a whole bunch of new content including new boards cards entry cards combat units and mechanisms there are three main elements Technologies dreadnots and shipping the Technologies are tiles that you can buy for spice which give you some speci powers and the dreadnots are a new type of combat unit which are slightly stronger than troops with the added bonus that they go back to your Garrison after a conflict instead of going back to your supply the shipping track is a track that you can go up and then drop down on gaining the rewards that you pass on the way down to make room for all of this you have two new boards one of which sits in the top right corner of the board covering up some of the spaces and another which sits separately shaking up the worker placement space faes some of the new cards do work in tandem with the new mechanisms but for the most part the cards can be thrown in without adding any of the other elements the rules also introduce an epic game mode where you play to 12 points rather than 10 giving players more time to work on their decks and creating some really big combinations doing Imperium immortality was the second expansion and this is going to add some new mechanisms it's going to add new Imperium cards new entry cards and a new sideboard

everything here is going to center around the TAC suit board and this comes with two different tracks one the tacu track this is just basically going to give you points it's almost equivalent to the influence tracks for the different factions then you have a research track and this is going to give you lots of rewards As you move along it many times it's going to let you send troops to the axotal tanks and here you can spend those troops when you have enough to do one of three things you could move on the taxu track you could buy taxu cards from a new deck that is kind of special and kept the side and full of weird wonderful things or you could just Garrison some troops While most of the playu deck cards are obviously going to play with the new mechanisms the rest of the cards like in Rise of are a nice split between cards that address a new mechanisms and cards that you would never know weren't there from the beginning one particularly interesting aspect that is introduced through the cards a new mechanism is the grafting mechanism where certain cards will allow you to graft that card to another card and they basically become one card in all senses so you can use either of their symbols to send an agent to a space and you'll get both the rewards for sending an agent to a space on both carts that's a pretty nice little thing and probably my favorite thing of all from this expansion is the family atomics token which is a token

you can use once per game to completely wipe the Imperium row of cards so if there's nothing there for you you'll get something better hopefully and I think this was something I was sorely missing in the base game interestingly pretty much everything can be combined with everything although it is much easier to combine the stuff from Dune Imperium into Uprising than the reverse because Uprising has more mechanisms however to combine the stuff from Imperium into Uprising all you really need to do is take out one or two cards which mention the menad because that's not in Uprising and you're pretty much good to go you're also able to pretty much interchangeably use any of the character cards between the two games surprisingly given that the expansions came out for Dune imp period they can both be used with Dune Uprising and minor changes are needed and also they can both be used together in either game if you're wondering immortality actually doesn't require any changes for Uprising whereas the rise of X has a few for example the new worker placement spaces it ads they do not have spaces for spies so you have to essentially pretend they are spies you also don't use the full board overlay you fold this one in half and it only covers some of the board however because this will cover one of the spaces that allows you to gain the contracts seen in Dune Uprising this means that you kind of start a little

bit different you start with a little special contract only for use with that expansion which allows you to gain expansions but otherwise contracts are the same the one area to be careful of when mixing and matching everything is the combat cards because the ones in Dune Uprising they have symbols that you're trying to match for points whereas in Dune Imperium and and the expansions their combat cards do not have these because it wasn't a mechanism yet so if you mix them up you're making it a lot harder to make these pairs and it could potentially favor one player over the other by pure Randomness so be careful of that but what's really interesting about this weird mix 2.0 everything is that you can basically make your own game from the component pieces of all the stuff you can create your own Imperium deck your own inry card deck and you can just include the things that you want and I find that super cool and as soon as we're done finishing this video I'm going to go and do that the first and maybe most important thing you should know is that Dune Imperium and dune Uprising are both games that should be played with three or four players optimally now it's fine to play it to and we've played a lot of two we enjoy it but you do require the use of an AI opponent because otherwise the combat will become Zero Sum the spaces in the board will be too open and it will just lose something without it and obviously some people might not want to facilitate playing an AI but it does

it does run pretty quickly you flip a card and send to a space Maybe put some cubes in the combat but just know that this game really shines when you have a full three or four players all fighting very tensely for those 10 points when it comes to complexity neither game is that bad if you have some experience with board games in fact kind of mechanistically it's a little on the lighter side because you have a very kind of standard worker placement mechanism and a very standard deck building mechanism just paired together however there is a lot to consider and it's kind of the you could say the game state where the mental load comes from but I definitely don't think it's a game that anyone should be scared of trying what you should keep in mind is that this is a brutal tight tense kind of experience it's quite interactive at times with players sometimes being able to directly affect other players impede their plans so you need to make sure you like that kind of high interaction if you're thinking about getting this when it comes to which version to get Dune Uprising is generally considered Superior to Dune Imperium because obviously it's 1.5 or 2.0 depending how you want to look at it they've taken what they've learned from D Imperium and feedback and Incorporated it it's got a whole new set of cards which are arguably more interesting it's got a more interesting worker placement system with the spies it's got new ways to get

points it's got altered spaces but one thing to consider is that in Dune Imperium it tended to be a bit tighter and more dramatic in terms of who won because it was generally much closer up until the final battle and that would be a big climactic decider whereas because of the worms and Uprising doubling points you often tend to get much more swing in where people are ranked and you often will get a winner from around where people might be on six or seven points and then they go into combat with worms they win they double their points they get some points from somewhere else and suddenly someone's on 11 points and everyone else is on six seven points when it comes to the expansions both are highly recommended and well-liked you'd be good with either and or both they are also great expansions in terms that they don't necessarily increase the complexity of the game but rather the decision space they kind of expanded out sideways giving players more options to go about the same exact goals and I personally really enjoy them the pure dirolf has a companion app available which covers both games this could be used to facilitate the AI in Solo or two player games but it ALS also includes varying game modes there is an arakan Scouts mode which throws in special events throughout the game to shake things up while the blitz mode shortens the game allowing players to gain Imperium Cards into their starting deck bet on who will win and even start off

with more resources and faction influence it's however not required for normal play not even solo to player play it's just there if you want it so now we're going to share with you what we think about the games so I think it's fair to say we quite liked it when we first played junor Imperium we thought it was like quite good maybe didn't um jumping with the hype that everyone else was giving it in the PR but we thought it was a very solid game but perhaps this is because we were mostly playing at two players do you agree yeah I think I remember enjoying it enough but not being wowed by it and I remember when it broke the top 20 on BGG and I was a bit like I'm not sure I buy that but I rewatched our review which was around the time it came out and we were pretty positive on it yeah uh and I think you're right I think we played a lot of two players and the game doesn't shine and the more we've played with more I think the more we've appreciated it but I also think that Uprising has really thrown it into the spotlight for us and really made us appreciate it more I just think the cards are more interesting and that's kind of a core aspect of the game obviously because you want to buy the cards I just find them much more interesting I think the new mechanisms are welcome ones the spies are

interesting I think the spaces have been changed for the better yeah I think we've been really addicted to this since we first got it and I agree I feel like the kind of different powers and the way that you can approach thing with the cards it kind of like lifts it up a little bit for me like elevates it although I will say in the first game or two I think I was preferring the first one because I wasn't so hot on the worms maybe we can talk about that it's a bit of a a contentious subject as we touched upon because basically they are pretty powerful because you can double your rewards if you use them in a combat and they're not easy to get points you do have to work for it get um influence with certain faction and you still have to kind of recruit them and go through some different yeah um steps to take to get the right resources and everything but once you have them they are very powerful and if you set yourself up right you could be getting like five or six points in a single round if you manage to double victory points which is a lot in this game um like we said everything does have to fall into place but what it happened for me you were doing it and I just found it a little bit demotivating basically because I was then so far behind after you've had a good round and it did kind of take the tension out of it a little bit whereas I think we both like games where it is a bit more tense and there's more of a tight race to the end and it could be anyone's game whereas with the worms you

know someone can go out in front and you don't have a chance really to catch up basically yeah so I think the the worms are just very very contentious overall because the original D Imperium was a very popular Tournament game you know people playing this a lot they're playing for money and I know the worms in particular have not been well received in terms of how they change up the game play but then there are a lot of other people who have played it a bunch and say after a certain point the worms aren't as powerful as they appear and you can count them so there's a lot of back and forth uh I think going on to probably another thing that we didn't like so much in Dune uh Uprising is for two players the AI players they they try and make them so that they're basically you have a a range of ones that act like a player and we kind of don't want someone this personal thing but we don't want someone to act like a player we just want them to get in the way a little bit and you know facilitate the gameplay for us to to go make it bit tighter uh and tended to have this ability in this one CU you can play with ones that that don't do that and they just kind of act like the original but they special poers always to throw troops in and so many times in a single game they would get ridiculous amount of troops in and we would only maybe win a combat like once twice a game each uh which you know we weren't even

competitive which isn't how it is in uh you could say when you play with three or four players I think what's important is is I think we can take a leave the worms with three or four players cuz it's players doing it but when yeah it's with this bot it was a lot more hard to take I think um but there are also a lot of people having house rules like I think a very popular one is to take when you have worms in the combat rather than doubling what you get you take whatever the third place offering is on top of what you get yeah and that might be something we do with the AI but I think with other players we're we're fine with it yeah I I got more used to it in the end I was like fair is fair it's just the first couple of games where I was still get into grips with the cards and the way that you can play here it was just a bit annoying yeah I guess it's just sometimes like not every conflict card will give you VP and some yeah okay it is good to obviously get spice or money or whatever other reward but obviously you're going for victory points so it could just be kind of a little bit luck if you can put a worm into the combat on the round where there's victory points you might be able to more easily with the hand that you have you know do it on a round where there isn't victory points in the combat so is a I don't want to say it's luck based because of course you have to curate your deck in the right way and but it is work and placement after all and somebody could just take the space that you need to go to in order to put a worm in and then you're like done for I think we touched on it a little bit earlier in the uh in the the video but I

think what we don't like most of all is the fact that in D Imperium the game were very tense and tight going very close to the wire and here it can just be a big swing not every game but it can uh but it sounds like we didn't like it but overall I think it was we really prefer this y so turning to the expansions we basically don't have so much to say they're both excellent we both really enjoy them we like how they make the game open up kind of laterally rather than making it more complex it just you you have the same exact goals and you play the same exact way it's just that now you have these alternate rootes that are got more options basically to go into yeah you can just ignore some of them if you really want like sometimes I didn't go down like the scientific track and you did you you can still absolutely win you can just kind of yeah lean into whatever kind of suits your deck I guess but it's not like you have to kind of interact with them all but you can if if you want yeah so honestly just if you look at them if they interest you I'd say just get them there's not a lot to say they just really are great expansions and I think final thing to touch upon is obviously what what should you get how should you go about it I don't think anyone Now is really going to recommend that you start with Dune Imperium I think you should always go with Dune Uprising it's it's a better reimplementation it's got better

aspects to it you can even use the expansions with it uh but if you already had Dune Imperium I would say there's an argument for getting this uh because you do get a lot of new content and it does improve a lot of things you get the six player game that's more of a personal preference I think I'm really looking forward to combining everything and I definitely think that we would still occasionally want to go back to do Imperium we actually did it very recently and had a couple games of it just the base game and it is a different feel and Cadence in some ways I think it's just like the way that you can approach things because of the kind of powers that are in there is just different right even though the core gamepl is the same it's funny because like I said when we first played this one I found the worm thing a little bit annoying and frustrating but then I got over it and I found this one like more and more interesting the more that we went through the deck the more we saw the different cards and actually when we went back to this one the other day it did feel a little bit more flat for me um so then that really solidified that I do prefer Uprising so I think that will end the buyers guide there we just want to say that we appreciate you watching we really hope it was helpful and if it was please consider subscribing because it helps us grow our Channel and it really does help us make more of these especially when we can lays with Publishers for the bigger ones if you have any questions do not hesitate to ask just write them down below and we will answer them if you have any questions about any of this and we just

really appreciate you watching we'll see you in the future with some other buyers guides or you can check out our already existing ones we're also on some social medias threads Instagram Instagram so check us out there as well if you want some less Long bite-sized Bard ofit type things see you bye

Progress saved