Skip to main content
Loading video...

Cat Lady: Review by All You Can Board

Transcript 12:59

hey everyone Carlo from all you can board and today I'm gonna be reviewing cat lady which is a two to four player card drafting game by Josh wood published by AEG it's a really fun little game I highly recommend you check out our how to play video I had to get a full rundown on the rules before we get into it alright so starting with first impressions of what you see here I got to be honest even as a big cat lover when I first saw the cover art of the game I wasn't sure how much you know strategy there would be or how fun the game would be it's actually a really fun game and has a surprising amount of strategy for something that plays so quickly I also have to give credit to Josh Wood who designed the game itself he also did all of the artwork including the box cover art all the cards and everything so you know you don't always find that in a board game so definitely a lot of credit to him especially considering this is his first ever game speaking of the cards I have one minor complaint even though I really do enjoy the kind of whimsical and simplistic art style the cats tend to look pretty much all the same for example other than the difference in the colors there's white black or orange cats summer even multicolored you know the way the way they're standing the look of the cat's face they all have the same kind of smile it kind of just looks like it's a different color filled in so it's a pretty minor complaint but I think it would help set them apart a little more other than just having the different name and the different color if they're

actually maybe you know one was playing with a toy in one or one was doing something else maybe even just the different different stance but other than that I think the simplistic and kind of light hearted kind of hand-drawn look is really fitting for this type of game some of the other components I mean we've got the food cubes they're pretty standard but I think realistically you wouldn't need anything more you know complex than this it would only drive the price of the game up I think these these do the job just fine and then you've got your cat token and your you know to two point victory tokens I think everything's pretty fitting for the game even though a lot of the mechanics in the way that the game is design feel familiar you know things like hard drafting and set collection you know a lot of these things have been done before cat lady combines them in a pretty unique and refreshing way that makes it feel like a you know a really fun game and something you haven't quite played before inevitably it draws a lot of comparisons to sushi go which is another card drafting and set collection game but personally I think what really sets cat lady apart and and makes it a little more fun in my opinion is this 3x3 nine card grid so essentially on your turn you are taking one row or column of three cards off the board and you're required to take all three of those cards so that is really the the meat of the game and that's that's where all the decisions come into play in terms of you know do you want to you might have two cards that you really want in a particular row you might really want that tuna and that catnip but in order to take those you might need to take a cat that requires two or three milk to be fed and you might not have any milk yet and it might

be you know kind of late into the game and you don't know if you're gonna be able to get the milk to feed that cat so do you take that risk and you know go after those two cards you really need even though you have to take one that you know might cost you a little bit in the long run or do you go for maybe a safer play that won't get you as many points but at least you're not you know putting yourself in a situation where you have to chase something particular so late in the game and that's really what what makes the decisions so interesting in cat lady and it's this cat token actually it seems like a pretty simple you know design thing but it's it's a great choice that kind of helps that whole nine card grid mechanic work so well throughout the course of the game because whenever a car row or column of cards is taken when you replace it with three new cards you put this cat token down to line up with that column a row - you know signify that the next player can't take those three new cards that came out on board so they can take you know a column or row going the other way they might be taking one of those new cards but they can never take all three and it kind of keeps things fresh because there's you know the order that things are coming off the board or going out you see a fresh three new cards and unless you have a spray bottle card you can't get those three new cards right away so it's a really smart little choice to include this token with the game I also really like how you're kind of managing the resources throughout the game you have your you know food tokens that you get and you have your cats in front of you and you don't have to decide until the end of the game which food is used to feed which cats so you know half way into the game you might have all this excess food and you're realizing I should probably be taking

more cats now because I have all this extra food that I've you know I can't do anything with on the flip side you might realize you have too many cats and not enough food and now you realize do you have to start chasing after food as the game is getting a little later on so I kind of like that there's a bit of resource management but it doesn't feel overwhelming you know someone maybe newer to board games or you know it doesn't want to put a whole lot of strategy in Twitter a whole lot of thought it's probably not very overwhelming to just manage what you're doing with your free for your food cubes to feed your cats with any game that's primarily based around cards something like cat lady there is inevitably going to be a certain element of luck but I think the balance of luck and skill is actually really good in cat lady because of course the order of the cards come up and in the order that they come out on the board is is random every game and you know the players are playing with are going to be playing differently and and all that they're just definitely a certain amount of luck and randomness to it but at the same time you're responsible as a player for how you're planning out your strategy so if you get to the end of the game and you have you know ten cats and three or four of them starve you know even if there wasn't a whole lot of food on board at the end and you felt like you got some unlucky draws you know maybe you took too many cats too early on so yeah sure he might have been a bit unlucky but at the same time if you had planned a little differently and maybe not taken as many cats you might not have put yourself in a situation where you really needed to rely on all that food at the very end of the game the last thing I'd like to mention in terms of the design of the game is the stray cat cards so there's 13 of them in in the entire game and you shuffle up the deck of 13 and you deal

out three randomly at the start of the game so for each game of cat lady you play there's going to be these three stray cats that are available to all players and after one gets taken they don't get replaced throughout the game so it's another little mechanic that just adds a little more variety of the game and another little thing just on the side where you can you know get cards in another way other than just from the grid I'd say the most important thing about cat lady though is just how fun it really is to play I mean it's it's quick to teach if you've seen our how to play video you've seen that you can give basically a full rules overview in just a few minutes anyone I've shown this to has really enjoyed it the very first time they've always asked to play it again I've never had trouble getting this game to the table I've introduced it to a variety of people you know even people who don't really like cats seem to really enjoy the game just because it's it's fun even some of the names of the cats and the artwork it's again it's very light-hearted I feel it's kind of the perfect game to either like start or end a game night with I like that there's very little downtime between turns even in a four player game usually after you've take you usually don't have to wait more than you know 30 seconds or a minute before it comes back to you again just because again on your turn all you're really doing is picking a row or column of cards and then it's the next players turn so the turns move pretty quickly there isn't a ton of player interaction but there is a little bit with things like the spray bottle where you're trying to maybe block someone else or you're moving the cat token after someone else has just taken a row or you know competing for things like costumes at the end of the game where you're comparing to see who has the most costumes or who might not have gotten any plus there's the stray cats that

you're kind of fighting over since there's only this the the three that are out for that game so in that sense there's enough player interaction that you you always kind of feel involved and you always wanted to kind of keep track of what other people are taking and what's available on the board speaking of the stray cats and I have one issue it's a pretty pretty minor issue but this guy here cow from my experience he's probably the strongest stray cat in the game and I find that anytime anyone has you know anytime the cow has been available as one of the three stray cats people tend to right away try and go for them and it's not like it's an unfair card or that it makes it an automatic win situation I've seen people lose the game with cow before but it's just the way it works with being able to feed it any number of food of any variety and the food just counts for two points each you're never gonna you know one of the rules in the game is that the player with the most leftover unused food at the end of the game gets a negative two points if you have cow that's never gonna happen because all of your excess food just goes on there you don't have to worry as much about having enough food to feed your cats you can just win the game with just cow and you know 20 food all on the same card so it kind of narrows your your strategy a little bit if you if you take cow and I have found that generally speaking a lot of the time whichever player gets that card does have a maybe a higher chance of winning so you know maybe as a house rule some people I know either play without it or or you know might just ask if other players want to reshuffle and

try different you know a group of three stray cats if cow comes up I also mentioned before the kind of resource management aspect I think that's part of what keeps it fun as well for new players is as I said before there isn't the whole lot to keep track if you're not kind of overwhelmed with what's going on but it's a nice little thing to do when it's not your turn you can kind of be shifting around your food and kind of seeing you know where it's gonna go to feed which cats to make sure that you have all your bases covered for the end of the game the last thing in terms of the fun of the game would just be kind of like the theme the artwork I think overall the whole package like everything just fits together pretty well in terms of you know again the the level of strategy in the game the luck versus skill the way everything is drawn the way the game moves really quickly I think overall it's just a really fun kind of like game is easy to sort of get to the table with almost any group another thing I really like about cat lady is the way the scoring works you never really feel like you're out of the game before it's over you know I have that complaint with certain games like let's say for example for one that everyone knows Settlers of Catan you know sometimes you're playing the game for hour two hours and sometimes maybe 20-30 minutes in you already know you have absolutely no chance of winning the game because you're blocked from expanding anywhere in catlady you're not keeping track of any points throughout the game and there's so many things that are determined at the end like you know your your endgame multipliers with the catnip or who has the most costumes or the the sets of the toys or how many cats you maybe let starve or whatnot so even if you you know don't feel great about how the game is going you'll never

really feel confident that you're out of it until the final points are counted and ultimately that really does help to make the game more fun when you always feel like you you have a shot you know rather than just feeling like it's kind of over halfway through even though cat lady plays it's pretty fun game at all player counts I tend to enjoy it most either with three or four players it's perfectly fine with two players but based on the fact that you're you know taking turns going around the board drafting these cards from the grid with two players the grid is changing less from turn-to-turn every time it's my turn for example because if I take three and then someone else takes three and it immediately goes back to me there's gonna be a lot of the same cards as when it was my turn before whereas with four players each time it comes around to me what's in front of me might be completely different so I think the game just you know adds a little more more variety and it's a little more fun with with more players I'd also like to say it's a really excellent travel game as you can see on its own the box is already very small I've taken this traveling before and you can even just put all the cards into one or two ziplock bags with the the food tokens and you don't even need to bring the box along it's very compact very easy to set up doesn't require a lot of table space the other thing is the replay value is really good the order that the cards come out from the deck is different every game so some games you might start off with a lot of cats available early on and not a lot of food or you know you might be seeing a lot of the toys early on or costumes and you never really know what what to expect overall I think the amount of strategy and is kind of

perfect for the the complexity and the length of the game and I think that's part of what you know makes it such a valuable game to anyone's collection is that you're gonna want to bring this out for a variety of occasions with a variety of groups of people again as I said before it can be perfect for either starting or ending a game night some people you might just get together play two or three rounds of this and that might be it but it's kind of you know perfect for what it is for a light kind of you know easy to learn game you won't find many better options than a cat lady feel free to check out our written review hit the subscribe button then check out so do all you can board comm thanks for watching

you

Progress saved