Skip to main content
Loading video...

Court of the Dead Mourners Call Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 23:13

hey everybody and welcome to chairman of the board today I'm going to be talking about courts of the Dead mourners coal which is a board game for 2 to 5 players it's a do to the map style game where you're going to be trying to control these different areas you're going to be drafting cards and using different abilities now the game I back the game on Kickstarter in 2018 due to those factors I like I like a lot of those mechanisms I just mentioned I also am quite familiar with the intellectual property that the game is based on I like the comics are like the law I like the artwork from the court of the Dead I think it's a really cool interesting you know interesting property but what most intrigued me about the game was this idea that there was these two kind of collective or communal objectives or tracks that people had to kind of manage in order to you know be as influential as possible on the board without hurting yourself and hurting others in in return I'll touch on that in a bit so let's talk about what the game actually kind of involves and mechanically what you're actually going to be doing so the game is kind of broken up into these eight different phases and they're pretty simple phases but there's kind of a lot of different individual parts that kind of formulate the game together so the first part of the game is you're going to basically roll these dice and you are going to whatever the result is you're going to divide this number of atheria into into piles and that atheria is kind

of going to be your fuel throughout the game but taking actions you can like buy new models with them you can buy new cards with them you can and do do kind of different stuff and so the idea is that the part of the first player who's going to be in control of death which is an individual model that lets you break a tie in the game which is quite a cool idea he is going to divide these these different piles of atheria into piles equal to the number of players plus one and the the kind of twist on that is that the person who divides up is going to be the last person who gets to pick the pile of Etheria now thinking about that I was thinking okay there's got to be something more to that because why wouldn't you always just divide them as equally as possible because if you're going to be choosing last you're obviously going to always be taking the smallest pile and it turned out that is actually how the game works which I was quite surprised about I thought there should have been another interesting twist to it now having said I should mention that you can choose not to take a pile of theory and take faction influence instead that influence is going to again give you more kind of power in the game to move your figures about and stuff like that and also you get points according to how high upon these different track you are because you've got three different kind of guilds in the or factions in the game the flesh guild the bone and the spirit faction and again they've all got their own individual tracks and the highest you are up this tracks depends on how many points you're going to get so instead of taking a pile of ethereal you can choose to take to influence of up

two different tracks or two of the same tracks I believe now again that's that's something that's okay that's it there's a bit more to it there but again I didn't really find in the game that that was ever really an option it was always take the ethereal and take the biggest pile of a theory possible what I would have liked to have seen is maybe you know make it more viable to choose the smaller part maybe you could make up for it maybe make up the difference between the powers in in influence or maybe I don't know maybe if you were death you got to I don't know do something else or something I don't know it's just needed to be something more to this now that being said when I said you divide the theory into powers plus one is because any kind of remaining atheria that isn't taken is put into what they call out the death Forge which is going to be one of those tracks I was relating to or mentioned earlier when at the end of kind of the phases you're going to basically tribute a certain amount of theoria to the gods and if you meet a certain threshold you get rewards and whoever bids the most gets points and stuff like that but I've touched on that in a second but first off yeah the first phase I was a bit kind of bit almost a bit disappointed with because I thought there should have been a bit more interesting decision though and we seems like it's going to be it's just a bit rinse and repeat there's not much thought or not not much choice that goes into it that being said this is very very small portion of the game and not really that import talk about just a little nitpick I had there I thought why not just roll the dice and divide it even as possible if

that's pretty much what you're going to do anyway so second off after you've done that you're going to draw what's called a wallows card now a Wallace card is going to give you kind of a short term objective in the game or for the round of the game the game typically lasts around three rounds basically in the game ends when you run out of these unity tokens which again are going to be points at the end of the game now these wallet cards are going to give you short term objectives such as maybe have a certain amount of influence and if you fulfill that you can reveal this card and do what it says on there it can give you like a bonus or a discount on something or something like that now these these are pretty cool I don't I don't mind these at all but I did find them a bit too I don't know a bit too leading if you know I'm probably being hypocritical here but the the idea that you are given this objective and you know if you don't stick to it then you're probably going to be out of pocket so I'd like to maybe I don't know maybe draw a couple of them or have a bit more kind of autonomy on what you're going to do in your turn rather than just sticking to the waters card now let me tell you don't you don't have to but you know you probably best to do it to be as you know as efficient as possible now that being said some of these are theory of some of these wallahs cards are different you get like artifacts and different stuff at this you also get like rakers and these breakers are kind of these monsters that attack different areas on the board and you have to get rid of them at the end of view at the end of your turn by having a model on

there and using an action to fight that model and basically it's just a pure roll off I think on a 1 2 or 3 you fail on a 4 5 & 6 you you beat the monster and you get the reward that's on the card which i think is normally immunity if you you can always also spend your atheria to up the kind of pit value of your dice as well so you've got a bit of mitigation there if you've got a lot of a theory your pretty sure you can um you can absolutely you know annihilate the bad guy like I said I would have liked and so there are also other Reap things down the line that you can do to fight lose rakers as well but again just the straight off role too of dice roll is it's just a bit it's a bit dated it's not much to it and it's just a bit flat in my opinion but again I'm more of a euro game a lot of these kind of Americanized dice rolling mechanisms are full a bit flat with me and this was just one of those aspects of the game that did fall a bit flat for me is those breakers okay so that's kind of the waters cards and after that we go into the draught which is a bit of a kind of a more significant moment of the game because you're going to divide up these these really beautiful tarot sized cards all with these different kind of court members from the from the court of the Dead property and those cards are you are you going to have an equal amount each and you're going to pick one pass the one pick one pass someone just as a you know tried and tested draft mechanism and they have all those cards

have two different abilities on them you can kind of do something or you can kind of maybe get theoria or you can get influenced or you can raise up one of these different tracks as I mentioned well some of them also let you like place one of the characters mal of estrus on one of the locations that let you kind of shut that location down and stuff like this so there's there's a lot of this cards are they're absolutely amazing artwork on them they're really beautiful cards absolutely phenomenal production on those almost cars but again I almost felt like all the abilities were so kind of I don't they didn't feel significant enough they didn't feel like oh I really want this one I was like I don't really care which one I pay because they're all alright you know and again they're all quite flexible as well because they all have two abilities on it you can choose I never really felt like one of those cards were like oh I need to have this one it's brilliant and then I you know I was never scared of giving anything away to my opponent to you know for them to use it against me or for them to have it which it's a bit disappointing right i I think we're drafting games you really need that feeling of I need to take this or I need to stop someone else from having it and this it didn't really have much of that for me that being said that you know some of the cards are quite versatile I mean you do get all the different kind of leaders relating order to the difference factions you've got as I said you've got the malla vest cross one that lets you shut a location down or stop someone's more on a card you've got the ones that you can take

death with so she basically be first player and break ties or break a tie but again I would have liked to have seen it just a little bit more powerful just feel like you're really exclusive compared to everybody else and again I didn't really get that with this and so after you've drafted your cars you've got your wallows cards you're gonna and you've got your theory you're going to be prepared to go into the actions phase of the game now the actions phase in the game is kind of the main portion of the game where you're going to take one action and pass to the next player and it was going to take one action one at a time until you kind of pass or what every pair of passes in a row basically now this is again I found this a bit flat because a lot of the actions you take are very insignificant I mean not all of them but most than the other I said you either buy a figure and pay someone to the board and buy that you raise what's called the Dredd script which limits how many options you can or how many people can go on each location again I've touched on that in a second you can reveal one of these mourners cards which have abilities on them where some of them are pretty cool to be honest some of the Manas cards are more interesting than the wallows cards and I think mourners cards or even more interesting than the the court cards so you can play one of those monitors cards you can play one of the one of the court cards you've just drafted you can move your figures around by spending influence depending on where you're going so but so there's a lot of things you can do but what I found on when your turn you the decisions aren't really

there it's more of a matter of what's the most sensible way of playing my cards in order because some might say I don't know some might rely on one card to be paid first before you get the maximum benefit of another and for me there was never really that what am I going to do next you know mentality is we know I was never overwhelmed with decisions I was like I doesn't really matter out or these four options I do first because they don't really affect each other and doesn't affect anybody else either and because you're taking one pre insignificant action at a time it does seem to drag on a bit you just kind of do it one bet wait for it to go around the table do your one little bit great for its Garant anyway it seems a little bit drawn out for me now it get it sounds like I'm being very very very negative here and in a way I am but it's just I'm just being honest and how the way I felt the game kind of felt and the vibe of the game just felt a little bit long a little bit drawn out in this action phase and just not enough kind of you know dynamic decisions not enough big you know big momentum swings and no big kind of crunchy you know nothing to stamp your authority on the game it's just very small little bits here get a little bit of influence here get a little bit of a theory move a figure or two it was never like you know berm I'm doing this you know deal with that and that's what you kind of want with a game like this especially with all the figures and all the production value because that side of the game is absolutely out of this world the production value is phenomenal on this game the cardboard the board looks amazing it's huge it is actually one of

the best boards I've ever seen the you know the the player boards are absolutely brilliantly all the coins you get really well made like metal pieces the figures are okay the models are okay I'm not much of a model man myself but these these do the job and they're pretty okay to to distinguish from one another but yeah I just felt like the action phase was just a bit drawn-out and you just feel like you want to do more on your tan so once all the players have all passed the turn and then you're going to go into the next phase which is what I call or what I mentioned with this celestial tithe then this is where there's a shot on the board and as you all the actions you've taken is kind of manipulate this board to go up or down and basically you need to tribute a number of a theory are equal to the number of players add a certain amount depending on where you are on the chart now this is done on a blind bid mechanism so you're going to take all the ethereal you've got left in your hand at the end of the game and blind bid and whoever's kind of what if you meet this kind of threshold whoever's bit the most gets quite a bit in unity whoever just contributed something gets unity if you don't contribute anything he kind of lose you lose something and the higher this kind of gets on the track you can you stand to lose more on this now this is actually one of the aspects of the game I quite like I like blind bidding and this does that quite well and so no real problem here at all and I - - I quite like it I like you know how much you're going to store or how much a theory you're going to carry over to your next turn how much you're going to use for the for the tithe and how much you're going to spend

on your action turn so this is about a part of the game that I actually quite liked now the next part of the game is the dreads gripped now this is the second kind of communal track now this track is extremely influential in the game because you basically there's a chart again and depending on how high you chart you want depends how many people can speed on each location so my styie three so if you can have more than three people in a set location they have to roll a dice and if they roll a one or two they're sent back to your player board which means you're gonna have to spend more time to get them out onto the board and again whoever's kind of got the majority in the area is going to get the benefit from that location and those location bonuses are maybe get you know get get unity or get more more ethereal or get influence depending on how many figures you've got or draw cards or stuff like that and the this part of the game was extremely I think it's quite it feels quite tense on paper and it looks quite tense of paper but when you've just gone through that really long action phase and then it's resolved by just rolling a dice within a split second you can take your models back off again that food was extremely abrupt and just felt very flat with my group I think every person who rolled and took the model bike was like oh my god I've just lost out it was like oh that's that's annoying it was just it was more annoying than it was tense or it wasn't a good kind of frustration is

what I'm trying to say it was very anticlimactic after all the long drawn-out action phase you can just get taken off in just a second that being said obviously it was somewhat the players fault that the track was so high and this players fault that they're being greedy by all trying to get the same prize but again after all the work you do to be taken just like that always a bit flat for me so yeah I wasn't too keen on that part of the game which is probably one of the bits that actually really drew me to the game didn't work the way quite I anticipated it to so after you've done that you go on to resolving the locations now this is where whoever controls those regions by having the majority of figures and them then they are going to get reap the rewards from those locations and also from the guilds as well because all the different figures you can recruit all have their own guild and they all kind of reap their own reward for having majority in that guilt you so again this felt like a bit like the court cards for me all the different locations didn't feel strong enough and they didn't feel unique enough to really want to fight over them I wasn't really fussed about where my workers went I just went where nowhere else nobody else went and I ended up absolutely annihilate the score because I don't know I just it just didn't feel nothing was really enticing nothing was like I really have to have that spot and I cannot afford not to have it there was nothing like that it was all like you know again a little little trickles up the boards and stuff like that and just not enough meat on the bones it was just very namby-pamby little decisions and it

just didn't feel right the gills were a bit better actually I think the guild influences was were a bit more interesting especially the one that lets you take the token that actually completely saves you from the dread scripts which is extremely powerful and again that's what you want you want those feelings that you have to have something if you don't have it you got a massive disadvantage and there was only like a couple of locations that felt like that for me and after that you kind of count how many unity there is left and if there's if there's any there left you go into the next round and then you clean up for the next round and go again so that's the kind of the flow of the game now I know I sounded very negative on that and I want to clarify that this isn't a bad game that's always not a bad game it's just not a particularly interesting game either now from a visual standpoint from the production standpoint this is out of this world it's one of the best looking games I've ever seen one of the best produced games ever seen it is really deluxe extremely luxury product and at the table presidency immense but the gameplay itself is just a bit meh very flat very mediocre for me I it's not like I must have met I am aware of Eurogamer so Sedna and these kind of games generally aren't my forte but that being said I love some games in this genre I really like to enjoy Eric language designs and this kind of I thought this was going to be more or that kind of theme but less kind of smashing more kind of thinking more political whereas it wasn't at all Eric

Lang has really kind of got their you know the the iron grasp on this genre because I'm sorry this game just doesn't compare to his designs Rising Sun and blood rage are way out the league of this product which I'm really disappointed to say actually so yeah decision wise it was just a bit flat for me the balance of the game was okay I mean everything seemed very reasonably well balanced but not on the point where it was interesting the the card drafting you know was a cave again the cartridge a bit boring said mechanically we worked fine it was a bit it was a bit as wit choppy in terms of being so divided into so many phases it would be nice if it had a more of a free flow to it but I can understand why it does kind of layout the way it does because they are very distinct phases but again they're all pretty simple with their own in their own kind of respect the game is kind of touted as lasting at about 19 minutes to pay and I have to say I think that is a bit of an understatement I think it will go generally go a bit longer than that and it feels quite a long game as well for what it is I think I took us about two hours to play and it felt it felt every minute out to be honest it did feel like quite a long game especially with the actions terms taking kind of feeling so long replayability wise you've got a lot of cards in there you've got a lot of wallows cards you've got a lot of mourners cards you've also got like hidden ulterior motives which you choose

the beginning of the game which give you points at the end of the game depending on how well you do so you've got a bit of variability there you can wish few different factions and get kind of different little benefits as you take cards and stuff but I think every game is pretty much going to feel the same because I said there's not enough differentiation in those seventeen court cards for me anyway so yeah repairability got no ruler just play again to be honest yeah sorry to say interaction wise the this some small take that in the game with some of the cars that I said to still still a few like influence point of somebody or for someone to pay to the tithe and get influence or sort of unity it's not like that and obviously you've got the kind of struggle of fighting over the different guild majorities and fighting over the locations but overall the kind of interaction wasn't great because I said if it's a draw on a location you both just sit there stagnant there was enough kind of I don't know enough kind of savvy and guile to get your way over the other players there was enough mind games or anything like that it was just very much you're gonna do what you're gonna do and just hopefully nobody else is on the spot you're in I said visually and aesthetically in production-wise out of this world good I don't want to touch them again I cannot fault how good this game looks and how well it is produced you can just see it for yourself is absolutely amazing and the theme wise as well it's good you get

all the characters from the Court of the Dead you know IP and there so you get all that all the big characters all the artwork or evil the smaller characters in the in the mourners cars and stuff like that so you've got a lot of a lot of the theme injected into this I love I love the way the game looks is as I said one of the best boards I've ever seen and it's like all that lovely kind of matte look on it but some of the areas are kind of shiny as well like the river it looks brilliant it does really look goodness huge as well and set up in to help tear down time is not too bad either so overall I have to say I was quite disappointed with this game I'm at this point now where every game needs to be absolutely amazing and this game just didn't quite cut it it was okay again it wasn't a bad game whatsoever it just was very flat not enough meat on the a bit one of those instances of all-star there no substance for me I'm sure there'll be players who do enjoy this as I said I am more of a Eurogamer and I prefer kind of mechanisms over over kind of visuals and theme and this one was kind of the other way round for me so naturally I was going to lean away from it and not favor the game but I'm sure that we people out there who enjoy it and I unfortunately I can't I can't recommend someone to go get it reasonably expensive for what it is and yeah I was left a bit a bit miffed layer a bit of flat and I generally don't feel that way about board games and this was

one of those exceptions that I didn't quite enjoy so that concludes my review of Court of the Dead mourners cool I hope you've enjoyed it I'm sorry to be so negative the game is going to get a mediocre verdict from me I don't give too many those out but unfortunately this is one of those if you have enjoyed the video please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too for ever else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved