Skip to main content
Loading video...

SHIVER ME TIMBERS (Reprint + Brand New Expansion) - Final Grade - Kickstarter Critique Clip

Transcript 5:20

Final grade. Shiver me timbers, the reprint was a brand new expansion. Do I want it? Yes, I do. I feel like you didn't do the greatest job of getting me there in a quick and concise manner at all. I feel like you're your decision to focus on your artwork, which by the way, looks like it could be AI generated like like it doesn't look special compared to the hundreds of other projects. And it just felt like instead of like this is you literally just talking about how you're a sandbox game and some of the stuff you can do in the sandbox game while showcasing artwork. And it's like you could have

And we will like your

If you want to if you want to talk about the expansion, it's easy. Mention what you could do in the original game and then just like and now with the Shiver Me Timbers, you can do this and it's a hundred of this and that. And it's just it felt like they had the opportunity and they just didn't. They were too busy just focusing on the original game. Like even in the description, they don't mention that it is a hundred like choose your own adventure style game. Like that's incredibly valuable. I just feel like the decision to do that. Do I want it? Yeah, but I felt like you really could have done it a lot better. Yeah. Can you do it? Yeah. Not worried about it. You got a hundred grand. You have a print run of the new game. You have a smaller print run of the second game. Your game does have some cool looking components, but you've already manufactured before. I'm not too worried about it. Can you do it?

Yeah. Not worried about that. And then how much is it? You know, 160 for the deluxe all in feels reasonable. Right? That feels fine. I have no problem with that at all. You got the shipping you're up to like 180, 190 for this sandbox asymmetric wild shift crafting game. Cool, looks good. And then we go to just the base game. I thought that was pretty reasonable, too, wasn't it? Oh my gosh, just go to your pledges. Where are you? Rewards, there we go. Uh 38 for the expansion, that feels fine. 70 for the base game, that feels fine. Like this has plastic minis that you're going to assemble. Honestly, that price feels pretty good. Like if you told me, "Oh yeah, it has it's a $70 game." I'd say, "Okay, well, it's $10 more than MSRP.

Tell me why." And you say, "Oh, it's got plastic pieces that you assemble as you construct your boat differently." I'd say, "Okay, we're done." Box check. How much is it? Feels fine. Across the board. So, final grade is solid. But I definitely feel like there's a lot to love and there's a lot to love more that they just didn't do. Like leading like this like the winner of that award. Like I want to go back to that main image. It's just how unnecessary the picture of the artwork is. I just can't get over it because you have so many other fantastic things to spotlight. And you're like, "We got to show her knee." Like do you can't even see the telescope, which is the one piraty thing about her. Other than that, it just looks like you wanted to showcase your 15-year-old daughter's awesome artwork that she did. Like, "Oh, look at this, she got an A on it." Take it to the side. Zoom in on the guard towers. Zoom in on the 100 the book that has 100 choices you can do. Zoom in on an unassembled ship that I am going to construct with my unique cast of characters as I get the ship in the bottle and the this and the that.

And instead, we have so much wasted space that I just I it's a third of a grade point point grade bump down to me because when I look at it, it is literally all of this space is just wasted nothingness that could have been used to do so much more. Oh, so but just zooming in on what you already have. It's the classic trying to put too much when you don't have enough room. Ooh, like that one. Look at that. They're zooming in like they their goal was to show you how massive and epic this game is. They're talking about the 22 stretch goals unlocked. The two expansions are free and contests with prizes. Sovereign Shogun by Faelanics. I just like to assume that you've watched the show before cuz golly gee willikers, you've earned yourself me covering you in the next two weeks. That I love that main image, but shiver me timbers yours I hate it. So, final grade is a C+.

If I'm a returning backer, you didn't make me feel special at all in any way, shape, or form, and you should. You should be. This is your only game. I am your brand loyalty. Get me to follow you to from Kickstarter to Gamefound. And it just didn't it didn't feel like you you Let's see what they're saying in the updates. I want to see what they have to say in the updates to see what it say Oh, there's only one person who commented. Never mind. All right. Final grade, yeah, C+. Let me know in the comments below what's your final grade for Shiver Me Timbers the reprint plus the brand new expansion. I

Progress saved