Earthborne Rangers - Board Game Review - Life's A Journey . . .
Transcript
hi everyone I'm lukor and you're watching the broken me this is a YouTube channel about board games where I give reviews top 10 and my honest opinions regardless of the consequences get on with it right sorry this has taking me a while folks earthborne Rangers we're finally here to talk about this game I wanted to look at this back in the start of August time but unfortunately the UK being UK got delayed with Kickstarter for filming and it didn't arrive until literally the day before I went to Essen and of course go to Essen there's an old week and then after Essen all the reviews I've been putting out so trying to get this played has been somewhat difficult to fit the time in but I have finally managed to spend the occasional day on what little spare weekends I've had recently to just knuckle down and go through as much of this game as possible so I can give it a review now obviously I have not played through the entire campaign of this it is a campaign game over multiple sessions so no I have not played it from start to finish but I believe I have played more than enough of this game to get a decent idea of whether or I'm enjoying it from a gameplay perspective and I am talking specifically from a solo perspective here I have played this multiplayer once or twice but that's mainly just to teach other players it and like the demos I've had this review is mainly for me playing it solo for about say half a campaign to say okay this is my faults so y let's get on with it it's about time earthborne Rangers is a campaign that stretches over 30 days each day
essentially representing a session of game time but what it is is that it's set in kind of a in a sense a futuristic setting with national parks and all the outdoors and everything where you are basically playing a Ranger and as a ranger you have these different abilities whether it involves like mystical abilities of being able to commune with nature and creatures or being like a fitness expert so you're really good at traversing the landscape or a tech whz where you got all these weird funky gadgets to help you map out locations and such and what you will do is that you will take control of one of these Rangers you will customize your deck of cards which has your own personal construction of cards that relate to your class that you've picked your personality that you you've also picked as well as a kind of like a profession that you've picked and so what you will do is you play through this story campaign that's almost a bit like games that I've talked about in the past like lands of Gia where it's fairly open world there is a story in place there are there is a plot mission to go to which will go through the actual story but there's also different locations and different cards to interact with and different things like side missions and stories where you can kind of just go off and do it at your own pace very much kind of kind of like a Skyrim type game you know you know where the plot is you know where to go for the plot but you know what if you fancy just going over there and helping somebody out with their little search and rescue mission then well you can go ahead what's it going to stop you the core mechanics of the game represent around your aspects which are awareness
Spirit Fitness and focus I had to lift those up to remember those and the idea is is that when you go into a location the location will set up based on a specific criteria of cards and the deck of cards called The Path deck will be constructed based on the location you're going to and the type of terrain that it is so grasslands Plains mountains that kind of thing each one has its own series of challenges and things for you to find you will then lay out your cards and you will have a hand of cards and you play them using this as effectively like a currency you spend these in order to play cards but they also represent your values for committing to skill checks so when I decide you know well I've got to Traverse and get past this for Bush you know this is a very light example but let's say like a really bad forny Bush or something that I've got to get past I might have to commit you know a fitness check in order to get past it well then I commit as many as I want from the uh discs that I have already I might be able to commit further cards from my hand that have the same symbology that you know reverts around that test each one has its own symbol and then what you will do is that you'll flip a card from this challenge deck which essentially gives you a modifier on the test itself if you succeed then whatever you committed represents your value for whatever like you know progress markers or tokens or you know damage or whatever it is you're doing now this game is very much more about exporation and you know seeing seeing the places and helping people out yes there are creatures and yes there are ones that you can technically harm but this takes a bit more of a pacifist approach where yes you can technically
harm something but it's not necessarily saying you're killing it it's more that you just get it to go away or it go you know or it dissipates you know unless it's some weird gribbly creature but no you are not going through this hunting deer and rabbits and all that sort of stuff it's not that kind of game if anything it wants you to take a much less violent approach to that kind of thing but the game can kind of carries on in that aspect and your deck represents your fatigue which is essentially how long you can play before your character tires out and you have to reset for the next day it's going to tire out at some point you can't avoid it it's just a case of how long it takes Reckless actions will use up more fatigue which means you're going to tire out quicker but if you play it safe you'll be able to go on a little bit longer and so it just is essentially a ticking Time Bomb for when the day ends and you have to say right that's it day over next gaming session you'll carry on in this fashion going through all these different locations and exploring all sorts of things I don't know how the campaign ends cuz I haven't got that far but so far you know I've I've got a decent way through it and so it's kind of like your adventure pick a character construct the deck tweak it over time go out explore do what you want to do on the road again s with me sh I can't wait to get on the road again okay so quite a lot to talk about there and you're probably getting Vibes of a lot of these similar campaign open World style games and two or three in particular do spring to mind recently I talked about a game called lands of gaer which was a very lightweight open world game which didn't really have a main plot per se you started off with a similar plot line but
then you could kind of do whatever you pleased in the hopes of just gaining more reputation this is not quite as open world as that is I mean yes there is an open world for you to explore but there is a limit on the stuff that you can find and obviously there is a main plot that you are technically supposed to go through at some stage so it's not quite as open expansive as that but it's not exactly far off and this one definitely has more mechanics going on than say lands of gausia so if you consider that to be the light family weight version this is probably maybe more of a gamer version but it's not terribly complicated other games it kind of gives a feeling of is you know to some extent is things like seventh continent which was entirely card based you know this is all card based all the locations and all your character stuff and all the checks you do and everything you interact with is essentially cards and a book for you know interacting with various people so it's like some story- based aspects so you're kind of talking things like you know seventh content would be a reasonable comparison but this isn't like a massive epic story like something like o sworn or tainted Grail or any of those sort games this is definitely more on a kind of you know I wouldn't even call it zenik really but it's just like it's more of a pleasant setting and a a Skyrim type feel go through it at your own pace do the side stories when you want to you want to gun through the mission the main mission plot at you know hypers speed than by all means do but you'll be tempted by other things to do around the place and like well you know what you know we could take a break to go check out this archaeological site yeah why not and you know those sort of things come into play
so lands of gaer seventh continent somewhere in between very quickly from an Aesthetics point of view this is entirely FSC certified this is basically all sustainable material so everything from the cards to the tokens to the Box the insert if you can call it that you know is all sustainable and so if you're definitely into that aspect when it comes to how games are made then you'll be pleased to know that this one is going to tick that box for you or else I'll turn you into a fing tree of course that comes at a slight price because you are sort of building to a budget at that stage these cardboard tokens are kind of normal but the cards themselves are decent enough I mean they feel sturdy just fine I am sleeving them as they go along so they're not the thickest card stock in the world but I wouldn't say they were poor quality either I mean they they do the job nicely you will probably sleeve the game like I am which kind of defeats the purpose of make being sustainable if I'm using plastic on it but how well I digress but you know the rest of it is still fine I mean the books are still decent enough quality these are not going to tear there's still plenty of information here the Box itself is a little bit on the basic side I mean I would have liked the Box lid to have used the cover that it originally did cuz when I saw the picture of this on the banners it had this bright blue vibrant really gorgeous looking picture and then we got this as the cover which honestly looks pretty bland if if I'm being honest but oh well that's a small gripe but you don't really get an insert in the Box either with this edion you
basically got this like cardboard thing that you assemble and it splits it into essentially nine cubby hols although to be honest that's kind of all you need because it's more than enough space for you to put the car s in specific spots that you need them to be you know at your leisure now you know you might maybe want to get some foam blocks and stick them in there just to keep them more upright because you know there's maybe a bit too much space in this box for what's in this game because there's only so many cards and even if you sleeve everything it's not going to take up a lot of space in there so if anything this is kind of an oversized box for what you're getting we just make boxes here in terms of art the art is mainly on the cards for say I mean you do have like you know a few cool things like a map showing you the entire sort of landscape that you can Traverse over but the artwork is decent actually on a lot of these cards I mean I showed this one in particular like with a little mountain landscape here and it's you know it's very picturesque it actually looks like somewhere I'd like to go hiking frankly the cards that you've got in your in your character deck you know I've got you know it's kind of glaring a bit on the light but you know they've got decent artwork as well uh although the artwork kind of chops and changes between two Styles you have the the very colorful like proper artwork and then you've got this almost kind of like silhouetted artwork which has like a kind of beigey background and it's all silhouetted rather than actually you know a piece of art I'm not sure why they chop and change between these two Styles I find it a bit jarring to sort of pick up one card that looks really gorgeous and then to pick up this other car which looks not bad but just a bit different you know I don't know why then
they just stick with one art style and run with it but that's a minor gripe so yeah it is built to a budget because of the whole sustainable thing but I don't think think the components here are bad they're just not necessarily anything to write home about in terms of variety there's a decent amount in this box I mean you can pick from one of four roles you know I've got the Seeker as my role but there's also a Shepherd engineer that kind of thing then you've got four specialities uh the sorry the shaper as a speciality Explorer conator whatever they do uh and you know you so you've got four particular classes and four roles and then you can also pick a personality type for each one which basically dictates some of these attribute cards that you start the game with and even when you have picked that your cards that you're allowed to put in your deck for our construction is depending on which aspects you have so you can have up to three in a particular aspect but you've got four of them so I've got three in Fitness so Fitness is my highest stat as a compromise my spirit sucks so I'm not very good at communing with nature but I can Traverse the landscape a lot better but it's not that you have to pick specific aspects because of your role you can do what you like you know I want to be a Shepherd who's also an Explorer speciality great do it have that combination and then the cards that you're allowed to have are dictated by your attributes so if you've only got an attribute of one in Awareness you won't be able to take any cards that specifically say awareness two or three so there's a lot of flexibility in how you construct your character and in a multiplayer game you're going to see four very different
styles of play going around unfortunately in Solo mode you kind of build your one character and then that's kind of it for the whole campaign although you do get to tweak your deck throughout the campaign at times which is pretty cool you can actually use cards sometimes that weren't in the classes you started the game with and I've already done that to some extent and I like it I like you know when those opportunities come around I'm sometimes like well I should be focusing on this but you know what hang on a minute I just want to go and do this because you know that you get to upgrade your deck with some cool card and there are more upgrades besides as you go through the game you will complete missions you'll get some you know some like Reward Points as they call it reward cards there'll be specifically named you'll draw them out of the box and then whenever you rest between uh days on the campaign you'll be able to bring those cards into your deck and go well I'm going to get rid of this one and replace it with this one and so there is an element of upgrading and that throughout the campaign and it's going to be very different every time you play it the theme in this game is very strong not watertight there are occasions where you might have to kind of stretch the boundaries a little bit particularly with the word harm because a lot a lot of the tests involve you having to deal har harm to something but it's not entirely clear as to what you're doing in regards to harm you know you're not necessarily killing a creature you just might like scratch it and it shoes off somewhere so you're like fine but then how do you harm a rock slide you know there's some of these bits that you kind of have to like get the you have to kind of invent what's going on a little bit at times but for the most part the theme the setting has done very well when I'm
playing this particularly if I put on some music uh board game music is a very good YouTube channel I use for that sort of thing seriously put the parks uh soundtrack from that on when you're playing this game man it fits so well but you know when you play it you're kind of immersed into this world and you're interested in exploring it's not just simply right I've got to do this Quest I've got to go save this person it could literally be that you've just gone to this random mountain and you're like let's have a look around there's a little creature there there a little kitty cat and oh hang on and I've come across another Ranger all right let's interact with you for a bit and that sort of stuff just keeps you immersed and keeps you engaged but on top of that I like little touches that they've put on these cards you've already got flavor text on the card to represent what you're doing so you know I mean what have I got here like a phonoscope headset and then it will mention like you tap the sensor at your Tempo and a Sight and Sound converge to aoke a scene in your mind Beyond which your ears and eyeing can normally comprehend that's the flavor text on a card so it goes into a lot of decent detail but what I really love I mean this is a small thing but it when you do a test it says the test and the difficulty but rather than just simply having the text it has the title keyword for the check so in this case Overlook but then in italics it says afterwards so Overlook in italics the surrounding Valley to choose a nearby location attach one card so it basically in italics gives you the formatic flavor of what you're doing before it talks about the mechanics that's a cool little neat little touch and it just adds to that immersion Factor yes it's not watertight there's a couple of occasions where you have to
kind huh you know how's that work but and know I really liked that when I saw it and I'm not aware of any other game that does that but if they do then Kudos it's just something that just helps me to keep me immersed and that's what this game needs to do if you play this solely as a mechanical Fest then you're probably going to be disappointed or not see much of the merits of it the theme is strong and you need to embrace it what the hell are you talking about the card play is a nice simple one but still engaging because you've got multiple rounds but you've got this ticking Time Bomb of your deck running out so you can only spend so long in an area before you might think well I need to get moving I to get moving cuz I'm starting to get too fatigued here but the skill checks and how you do these are a cool thing so if I want to play the trail mix I need to spend two Fitness okay fine but then on this turn it might be like well I don't know do I want to Instead try and Traverse this area well I'm going to need some Fitness to do that and so the whole thing becomes a balancing act between getting cards out and doing the tests which is a night nice little system I particularly also like the way the challenge deck has this thing at the bottom which again adds to the theme but it's a a symbol at the bottom a mountain a Sun or a weird little ranger symbol whatever and the idea is is every time you do a skill check you look at the bottom and then look at all the cards that are laid out to see whether there is anything out there that has the same symbol written on it and when it does they all trigger and this basically is the world kind of adapting and and interacting with you as you play so you
might have a bunch of you know a couple of Predator walls out there and it's like well you know if I do a skill skill check and I draw the Red symbol then that Wolf's going to potentially attack me and cause injury do I want to do a skill check do I take the chance do I deal with the wolf first or do I do a couple of skill checks suck up the injury and just deal with it later you know these little cool decisions that you make are not only F matically immersive but also work from an engaging perspective there's a lot of Airborne noises going on lately so if you hear anything I do apologize now I have talked a lot about some good aspects of this game but there are still a few negatives I do need to mention firstly is the act of repetition there is a travel aspect to this game where you're going from location to location and as I mentioned whenever you get to a new location you have to find a location card get the terrain that's associated with the path you took mix it up with maybe some random exploration cards from a valley deck or the proper location depending what you're doing all of these are mixed together into the deck and then you start from there this is what you have to do for every location you get to whether or not you even want to go there there so I might be wanting to get to the next stage of this Mission well okay that's three locations away so I know I need to get to this third place but I've got to go through two bits in between and I'm not interested in what's in those two bits right now so you still have to go right I'll go through this location find the location card yes I've been here before I know what it's like get the locations right Bo deck right go and then you have to spend a few turns going through the motions to get the
requirements you need to be able to exit the location and go to the next one then I go to the next one I've got to do the same thing again and then I get to the third one and then I get to focus on whatever it was I was trying to focus on you might argue that that's fine you know you're trying to explore the world and you're not too fussed about the mission at that time but still it does get a little bit repetitive every now and again of course the repetition aspect is also confounded with some of the terrain cards that you see so every time I go through the like Lakeshore area I know what's in the Lakeshore deck so I know what to expect I know how to deal with it and especially when I'm using the same character it's like look we've seen this before yes the cats come in if you get too many of them they'll overthrow you but there's a place that can get rid of them and so you there is an aspect of new stuff that you can find but most of the time it's essentially taking threee cards from this little deck here and adding them at random to the deck that you're doing for the location these are cool because I have not seen everything that comes out of this deck yet even though there's not so many cards in there and even if they do come out to the deck I haven't NE necessarily interacted with them so this aspect is cool but do I want to stay forever in a particular location just to find one of three cards in you know out of a deck of 20 30 cards to get where I need to go and this is actually more of a problem in Solo mode than it is in other players because the deck does not scale for players so if you play this as a four player game you have people four people drawing a path card every turn so you're going through that deck really
really fast and finding the stuff but in in the solo mode you're only drawing one card every turn so you might be in a situation where it's like right next card is it's one of those okay fine right right next day reset counters whatever right next card it's not that either right fine reset go play some car right next card right and you find yourself kind of stuck there just waiting for the card to hurry up and come out of the deck so you can interact with it there are some cards in the game that do allow you to scout ahead and find certain cards and believe me I am so glad that my character is kind of half focused on this because if it wasn't I think it would be worse but it does sort of bound into the whole aspect that there is an element of repetition and a little element of searching particularly in Solo mode that probably wouldn't be as apparent in multiplayer that you've got to contend with and you know I'm noticing that already halfway through a campaign by the end of the campaign is it going to great even more the rule books are also not as great as I would like I mean we've got this book here with all the different paragraphs of story that you can read and it's written well but we've already discovered Arata which is on the board game geek website and some of the Arata is game breaking there are certain bits of online Arata that you can find for this where if you have not read them in advance you will not be able to progress properly through the missions because it leaves out a key thing that it's supposed to give you that sort of thing should not apply in games like this I'm more than willing to you know give you some leeway when it comes to these
things because there's a lot of text there's a lot of story there's all sorts of things you can't account for every scenario but this is stuff that happens in the prologue of the game surely during pre testing somebody should have noticed that this was a problem and it should have been fixed tiny misunderstanding so my hopes weren't high but having to look up AATA before you start this game is kind of annoying because the Casual player isn't going to be aware of this I'm only aware of it because I know people who have played this game and I do my research Arch those who don't do their research are going to get caught up in this and it's going to drive them insane the rule book as well is not terrible but it's written more about how it tries to immerse you in the game rather than actually trying to explain how it works there's a decent Siz FAQ for this already and the book is not very good at referencing rules in terms of how to play the game once you've read through this book you should be able to know how to play the game for the most part but there are times where there are certain key rules that are just not mention that really should be and whenever I think oh hang on a minute how does this work with the Fast Travel when I tried to go back through the book and find it it's a bit of a nightmare cuz I'm like hang on there's playing a campaign card Anatomy I kid you not is halfway through the book that should that be a thing and then before card Anatomy you have additional Concepts um shouldn't card Anatomy come before then just saying you know fatigue clearing cards performing a test you know this is the stuff beforehand and then you've got
like the the phases and then I have to find out know whereabouts and travel do I do this bit ah it's you know it's not the worst rule book I've read but it's just it's layout is problematic and there were certain times where I thought I on a minute I've got an injury here so if I have to take fatigue every round this is going to me always so what am I supposed to do about it well apparently you don't carry those injuries over to your next day when you reset the game up the problem is the thing doesn't tell you this in the rules I had somebody had to clarify this for me otherwise I'd have been wanding around with like a cut arm or something constantly messing up my game it's an editor was badly needed to go through this and I feel like a 2.0 of earthborne Rangers could fix a lot of this but yeah you need to get an Editor to look at your Rob book guys you need to get this better you need to sort out the arator you need to you need to 2.0 this rule book because it hasn't broken the game for me although that's only because I did my research it could break the game for for others but yeah there's just a few too many mistakes and just a little bit of extra hassle that I had to go through to learn this that honestly for as not too complicated as the game is should not have been a factor I award you no points and may God have mercy on your soul so earthborne Rangers overall is enjoyable but I was gushing for this when I saw at the games Expo when I got into the demo I was like fantastic demo love this theme love this concept this is going to be this could be a 10 out of
10 game of the year for me not quite this game is very enjoyable though don't get me wrong but there are a few negatives that are starting to Great more and more as I play and you know some aspects of this game really shouldn't have been problems if they could have just fix those beforehand it could have really elevated this as well that being said the game is immersing me very good solid theme done very well you know the game play is still engaging what I do with my cards how I upgrade it as time goes on whether I go off and do side quest or do the main mission that stuff is all really cool you know so I do enjoy it but the negatives mainly stem around two aspects the repetition of going through the different locations and having to go through the same motions just to get from A to B is a bit like the padding that you had in um uh what was it called effer fields that um awaken Realms did same sort of deal that aspect yes I know it adds to expiration you might argue that you might see something new there but it's still essentially pad that is basically what it is and even then the different cards that I see in each Terrain in that I'm going to memorize by the time this campaign is done so if I was the player again I feel like I would have seen a lot of what this game has to offer already and I'm just getting the odd little tip bit now and again the only main change being hm I now have this deck with these different cards which is only going to be so good and also the rule book the other main problem because I'm still rules referencing at times when I play this and it's a nightmare to get a rules reference I don't know if
there's a piece of Arata I should be aware of I can't be bothered to check a list of arat all the time to see while I'm playing this but the fact that it's not the best rule book to begin with and the fact that there's a rter that's gamebreaking in the first prologue that's still a bit of a big deal people that really should have needed to be fixed but overall still enjoying the game and I am glad that I've been playing it and I do intend to see it through to completion and I'm going to enjoy it but I feel like it's just maybe just need a little bit more time in the oven or maybe just a few like other things like done to it but overall still enjoying it and maybe the rating could go up over time but for now it's getting a solid eight out of 10 I really do think it's a great game and I'm enjoying it but I thought this could have been 10 out of 10 levels here this could have easily just ticked every box that I had to make it fantastic I am enjoying it but I can't Overlook those aspects you know if I only reviewed this I have to say four or five plays like a couple of days in the campaign some of those negatives probably wouldn't have even been a factor I might even discover more by the time I've finished the campaign but getting through two you know getting through you know between a third to half of a campaign these things are starting to crop up and so I've got to be mindful of that but still enjoyable still getting my money's worth at an8 out of 10 great just not quite a distinction level so that's it for me on this episode of the broken meeple if you like what you see then please thumb it up on YouTube and thumb it up on Board Game Geek when review goes live on the site don't forget to check out more
content on the channel including all the reviews I've been doing for Essen lately it's insane how many I've been doing hopefully you've been enjoying them hopefully there's a lot of games for you to consider before Christmas or maybe into the new year depending on their release date so take care and remember regardless of where you want to travel in the valley next time it's still only a game so pick your path and bye for now