Skip to main content
Loading video...

Flashpoint: South China Sea Review

Transcript 28:33

thank you this video is sponsored by game Toppers turn your own kitchen or dining room table into a premium portable game solution at a fraction of the cost hey everybody Welcome to drive through review 756 today we're going to talk about Flashpoint South China Sea and this is Flashpoint series volume one so there may be other games in this series that are probably similar mechanics or maybe different mechanics and similar sort of weight this is designed by Harold Buchanan who also did Liberty or death one of the coin games that I'm a fan of what this game is it is a card driven game not unlike Twilight Struggle type of thing or 1960 that kind of the game uh but with a very kind of unique twist and take on it it's also a little bit uh more of a medium weight uh kind of game and it's also a take on a I would say very modern uh setting of this uh sort of the South China Sea with some of the other uh Asian countries involved and the US involved so one player takes the role of China the other one takes the role of the United States at least their governments and you were trying to do kind of area control and get you know position and standing in diplomatic and economic spaces as well as some Naval spaces uh in the sea yield you'll get a

look at that when we look at the board and it's all driven by cards and players have a hand of cards with events that you can play for the events or kind of like the Ops points kind of thing which we've seen before but it's a very different kind of way that the game tackles it and it is designed from the ground up to be a one or a 2 two-player game so let's go down to the table and I'll show you how it works I'm going to come back and tell you what I think okay I've got the game how it might look at setup here you can see a few things about this map you've got various different locations here these represent some different countries and you have these oval types of spaces here that are attached back to a country there these are kind of some Naval spaces there you've got some areas for reserves in the U.S up here at the top areas for Reserve pieces these cubes here for China up on the left along the bottom here you have different scoring cards and this is the only way to score points in the game is to activate these scoring cards so through the course of play players will be triggering these scoring cards in each of the three different rounds and then at the end of the game you're going to go through and just run through them all again and score them individually and then you're going to get points that way now the way the points work is very similar to Twilight Struggle as you get points you're going to start to go back and forth here so the United States gets points this marker starts to move that way China gets points that starts to move back if it ever gets to 15 points on either side that's an insta Victory otherwise wherever it ends up here that side will be the winner now as I mentioned in the

beginning let's just zoom out a little bit here this is all driven by card play so you have here your event deck and these are the cars that players will play you can see there's U.S cards China cards and kind of like neutral cards here and they have different operations values different modes which is a kind of a neat feature and then also a different event text so you can play it for kind of the Ops it can activate the mode do the event or there's even like a little scoring icon and so these different scoring icons match these cards here so if I played this for scoring I'd be activating the Indonesia scoring card here score that and then this will go face down until the end of the round when it gets flipped back up and then it can be scored again the next round so each of these can only be scored once so you get a hand of six of these cards every round and there's three rounds or three campaigns that's tracked here so you play the game three rounds and then whoever's most points is the winner uh if you played solo you've also got a little solo deck here and you'll flip this over sometimes sometimes you'll just play a card off the top of the deck and act as the solo AI and sometimes you'll have to flip this one to kind of decide you know where it places pieces and stuff I'm not going to go over the solar rules they're pretty simple I will make a mention though there is two Rule books there's two player rules there's a solo rules so if you wanted to buy this only for solo you can get rid of this book here and then you can just read this book because it'll teach you the whole game including solo rules if you don't want to play it solo you can just play it two player and just read this book and that's fine there's also a little Playbook which is

nice that GMT games does to give you kind of like uh backgrounds on the cards and some examples and tips and stuff like that so that's also included here now the way that you you try to win and try to get the points is by having area majority so let's zoom in here we talked about Indonesia so if you do the Indonesia card the scoring card here you'll compare all of the cubes here so right here right now they're tied there's one Cube on each side so if China had played it and it was looking something like this they had two economic cubes and one diplomatic cue tube then you should just look at the difference there so they have two more than Indonesia and then so in that point China would score two points some of the cards have little abilities here and it's worth to know some of these have a maximum number of points you can't get more than two points out of the Indonesia card but also this one does the scoring side moves one Cube from Reserve to available and you can see up here we have the available pool and the reserve pool so one of the benefits of scoring that is you can move that out there because to bring a cube from off of your kind of Reserve over here it's got to be in the available slot and then you can move it on to the board otherwise you have to spin actions to move it out of Reserve first and then you can move it out there now the other things that you might score is you might look at all of the economic impacts and majorities of the different countries there and so you would score the difference in countries not in pieces but you would look at each

country look at who has the majority and whoever has the most majority so let's say the U.S had majority in three of the countries and China had majority in two of the countries on the economic row then the US would be winning three to two and when we scored the economic card which we can see here they would score the difference in points there and then you can also score the difference here on these little Naval spaces here the China side is called CR the American side is called phonops so there's a scoring card there so your scoring here the different countries the overall you know Naval aspect of it the economic aspect of it and it's worth noting when you score some of these countries that have sort of these little offshoot Island spaces then you will total up all the cubes in here and in here if you're scoring Malaysia for example you throw up all the Malaysia cubes and then all the cubes that are attached to it here in the Spradley Islands so that's how you score and that's how you win so again you score each of these once per round and then at the end of the game you're going to flip all these cards back up and score them all again now how do you get cubes out here to get the majority well there's a few different ways to do it obviously you can play the cards for the event and that's going to just do I mean so many different things right all these different things now one of the main ways is you're going to play for the Ops points and you'll see here you have events that are sort of China related some that are kind of neutral and then some that are us related right so it doesn't matter what color the card is in

terms of the points you can just play the card and then do the thing now there is a nice set of player AIDS which I'll show you so on this side here you have all the things you can do with your Ops points which isn't a ton but it gives you the idea here now so you can see some of these the cost will go up so if you're going to place a CR and increase the tension then you see if there's any prerequisites here but you can see the cost to do that goes up so it costs you one not point two and then three and that's as the tension goes higher it's going to to cost more and if attention is critical then this is just not impossible to do at that point so this is a nice quick reference here and then on the other side there's two of these sheets though it gives you just kind of the quick round structure and all that kind of stuff so it's just very easy to reference all the steps that you might do you know draw the new cards flip the scoring cards face up and all that stuff and while we're talking about player AIDS there is a player Aid that is us on one side and China on the other so you can play as China or the US on that side so let's go back to talking about what you can do with the opp points the first thing you can do is just simply place an influence so if you have a cube again and you're available not in your reserve you can spend a point to just move it out there and put your influence on there now notice that you can actually lock these regions here and that will prevent the other player from doing that place influence action but we'll talk about how to lock a region but that's a very simple thing you just Place influence and so if I had you know three op points I could do that three times or I could mix and match these up points with a

different operations so another thing you might do and in addition to placing the influence is as I mentioned earlier you can spend one of those points to Move It from Reserve to available the other thing you could do is you could place a the US place a phone up and that's always going to cost you one if you're the US now again I showed you China their cost is going to go up based on the tension level now the differences here is that the U.S phone Ops here these are going to disappear every round these are going to go away the China ones once they're placed they stay there unless some other like event card or something remove them but for the most part they're going to stay there and that's going to be a piece they're going to have for the rest of the game now in either case whether it's us or China and they place a card or a cube out here in these islands the tension level is going to increase and here you have the tension track so we'll just boom move that up and there were other the other events and things that move that up and down now it is worth noting anytime somebody does any kind of action or anything that moves this to critical then they have to then take and move one of their available cubes to the reserve for being the culprit to move everything to critical now the last thing we can do here the last two things I should say is we can do a political Warfare thing so we can place one of our markers here in the political Warfare and then the other thing you can do is you can resolve political Warfare now resolving political Warfare costs you zero so one of the little trick plays

you can do you'll find this out pretty quickly is let's say you play a three card and let's say we had three here in our Reserve so I could go one two three and there's all my Ops and then I can do resolve political Warfare which cost me zero points and what you do at that point is you flip the top card over of this deck as long as is equal to or less than the number of political Warfare which is a one in this case it will take and put that card I should say at the bottom of the deck and then you will have a successful political Warfare these go back here you will then increase the tension and then you can choose to lock one of these spaces like that so you can choose to do that with only one or two political Warfare you're just taking a little bit of a gamble in terms of you know what card might be flipped over there and that's again it's worth knowing that you can also replace somebody else's Cube so if you wanted to do your own political Warfare if you're the China player you do that and then that will replace that Cube and the other players could go back to the available and I think I mentioned but let's just just for clarity when you do the resolve political Warfare you will also increase tension there so that's all your basic Ops stuff now let's talk about the scoring and the mode and the events and all that thing well of course as I mentioned in addition to playing the card for the Ops you can just play it for the event that is if the event matches your team so only a US player can play uh this event here the China player would never even want to play because it's always favorable to the team's color that it is and you can anybody can play the neutral events they just have the black border on the left

now the other thing that could happen let's say the China player did play this card and the US player goes oh that's neat I really like that and what I want to do is I want to play that event that the time player just discarded so if I play a card with the matching mode and the events is favorable to me or is for my team I should say then you can use the mode there to trigger that event for yourself and so that's the interesting thing is so in Twilight Struggle when you play the card automatically triggers the event for the other player but this you're sort of putting it down hoping it doesn't but it might so that's how you would trigger that with the mode icon now the other thing like I said is you can play cards for the scoring so you get economics the phone Ops let's see Philippines Brunei stuff like that so then you can just play this you know for the scoring and all you do is you in this case brene you take the card score it flip it over then that's your turn but let's say you had this card the other player played it down there and it's for your team if you're the us then you can play here we have this one so with the mode instead of just triggering the event you can actually trigger the scoring of the car that was just played so that's the other thing you're kind of playing around with here and that's really the gist of the two player game I'm not going to go into Super detail on the solar rules because it's just kind of a little bit of a procedural thing basically you flip the top card of the event deck you see if it'll score based on the scoring and then you score if it's going to score positive for your opponent and then if there's a mode match there's like a little bit of a different rule change there and if not

then you basically walk down these in order so it'll try to resolve a political Warfare put out some some CR and phone Ops like in this order and then resolve placing influence in this order and stuff like that it's it's all pretty simple so you just flip the card see if it scores see if it triggers this little mode transition and then you go through in place cubes as it will sometimes they can't because you know the attention track is too high to do something like that but that's pretty much just the game okay so that was Flashpoint South China Sea let's go through my three pillars of review uh first I'll talk about uh player count the game is obviously designed for either one player or two player I have played it both I really like the solo game it's it's fun it's it's really simple it can be kind of swingy uh the way it works because sometimes in the favor of the human player the AI will just not really flip uh the scoring cards as often as they probably could but that kind of simulates what happens in a two-player game if you don't get the scoring cards that are there but but with a human opponent you can kind of like say okay well I don't have anything that's really scoring right now but I can kind of work towards that or you know at least try to prevent the other player from scoring too many points and then kind of you know hope for a better hand next time uh because you all again you also score the the points at the end of the game so there is kind of a long game that you can play

in the two player game that the AI opponent doesn't really simulate all that great compared to the two-player game but it is fun because there is a tension there with the still with the event playing because because the event triggers aren't on the immediate play it's on the possible play of your opponent which we'll talk about more in a second uh there's still some interaction there between the player and this AI deck where it's like well I don't really want to give them that because if they mode you know a mode match that one then that's going to give them some points or give them uh some extra stuff that they can do it's just it's nice because it's almost like a slight rule break but some of these games um with their AIS they're like oh this is breaking the rules like you know like Unstoppable now I have not tried it against the like most difficult I just tried it on normal and it was pretty easy to beat but I could see with you know playing the harder difficulty that would be a little bit more fun so I would say definitely you could play it in my opinion uh normal mode just do that as a learning game and then switch into the harder mode but again I haven't had a chance to try that yet now two player I think is where the game really shines uh we'll talk more more that in the later part let's talk about play time I don't know what the box says on here um I'm gonna assume it says an hour because that's about how long it takes let me just take a look sorry I should have looked it up it says 30 to 60 minutes yeah I guess that's true I guess with the solo game it's probably closer to 30. I wasn't thinking about that when I was saying an hour but with two

players it's a good 45 minutes hour it's it's on the the longer end of that 30 to 60 which I think is great um you've had a lot of these games that are very Twilight struggle-esque where they're like hey you can play some 15 to 30 minutes which is neat you know like watergate's one that I liked uh 13 days is one that I liked about the Cuban Missile Crisis there's 13 minutes which I haven't played uh there's some other ones I have one that's it's kind of like it's not really it's called 300 I still have that one in my collection that's a fun one uh this is a little different because it's more like army battles but it's card driven and stuff so and there's some area majority things so it's in that kind of vein of a car driven war game but this is nice this is kind of like this medium ground that we haven't really seen yet because you've got kind of your heavier Twilight Struggle 1989 1960 a couple hours to play two three hours definitely with some of those games well this just sits right in that solid hour range which is really really cool so that's your play time now speaking of all these other games the 13 Days Watergate Twilight Struggle 1960 you know what is this game like that's my final pillars like what what's this game like so again it sits in that kind of nice sweet spot which we've not really seen too many games of now I really like this game let's cut to the chase it does some really neat things some nice Innovations on the Twilight Struggle sort of idea even going back to like Washington's War where you have the event cards and all that and the Ops and

the events and triggering your opponent's events and stuff this is a really smart way of doing it I think where you play the card it may it's not going to automatically trigger the event for your opponent but it might and so that presents a decision on your opponent's turn like hey I could match that event I've got a mode but I don't really want to do that because an event may not be you know all that great um they might just want to play a card they have in their hand they might want to maybe mode match it for scoring and so there's a little bit of a thought process that has to go on and there's a little bit of like pacing that you have to kind of like learn with the game which I thought was very interesting so I think there's there's some good replay value here because you have this kind of this two-pronged idea where you're making those scorings mid game and trying to you know be opportunistic and grab as many points as you can when you can because it's going to be there's not a lot of spaces on the board so it's going to be pretty obvious to your opponent like oh they're starting to get more of a foothold here in the Philippines so I got to make sure everybody take care of that um where you start to see how you can try to make those opportunities score for you during the three rounds but also set yourself up to do really well in the final round so that kind of give and take there works really well with the replayability and the strategy and all that stuff and it really kind of informs all the card play decisions because you're like well there's a lot of obvious ones but then there's like there's a little bit more subtle ones as well it's like well

whatever they can score two points for Indonesia because I'm gonna go this is gonna make me set up a bunch of stuff over here and I'm really going to lock this place down now the other um subtleties here which I mentioned one of them during the walk through is the phonops and the CRS basically like the naval stuff I call the naval stuff because it's in that South China Sea and um the US is able to do it very cheaply but there's disappear every round whereas China can be very expensive to do it but once they're out there they stay there which kind of makes sense because it's you know this is kind of China's local home Waters here the US has got to send fleets there theoretically and have the permission of some of the other Asian governments there so there's that whole dynamic there so that's an interesting part of it and um but it's also harder for China to do when the tension is high so it costs more expenses the U.S player in a way will try to ratchet up tension on purpose in some ways to do that and that's kind of an interesting thing and so there's some events and stuff that play with that tension which kind of adds against some of the flavor and the theme of it you know and a lot of all this is kind of sort of pulled out of the headlines and there's there's a Taiwan card and there's some other cards with economic kind of blockade stuff um and then you know some of the leadership cards like all of the like leaders in this area um you know the Japanese president who isn't they're not really even featured in this particular geography but they're kind of adjacent right so they have the North Korean leader uh some other

leaders like that so you can do that kind of you use it it feels like you're kind of thematically using them as a proxy to kind of have negotiations with so that's kind of a neat thing the other part is all the cubes we've got the economic and the Diplomatic cubes in the different countries the economic cubes come off every round so the diplomacy Investments that you make have a little bit more of a lasting payoff but the economic ones you can score immediately you can make those immediate scores um but again they go they go away because you've got to invest more money you know diplomacy is one thing interpersonal relationships are one thing money is a different story right so money is money money is only as good as you have it or don't right so I like that little interplay there with the economics the Investments that maybe either side is making in these countries um and then you know the diplomacy side so there's that other little things and they're very very easy like it's just like okay we're playing these cubes doing aerial control but economic ones disappear or phonops disappear there's not a lot of rules there right but there's a lot of subtlety uh to what's going on um so that's neat just a lot of those this real simple things and then kind of that Twist on the event stuff just makes this a really really solid game and I think a lot of folks will get a kick out of it uh mechanically wise uh now thematically wise I really like it as well because it's very I mean this is you know a lot of these are like Twilight Struggle you could say they came out what two thousand four or five and the history of that was 10 years old

15 years old depending how you look at it and so that was pretty modern right you know it's within a it's within a generation within a lifetime for sure um but this is like right now this is hap this is like ever present I mean this is almost forward-looking in a way uh because you know some of this stuff is yet to play out um with the relationships between the United States and China and that kind of uh I can't remember the exact name of it but that in the South China see there's like that Nine Mile uh Maritime kind of border that is disputed you know China thinks it should be bigger than it actually probably some other people say it is you know because it's kind of invading that International water border of some of the other countries like Philippines and Indonesia and stuff and so there's that choke point in the western southern southwestern part near like Singapore that little it's almost like a little Canal that China gets a lot of their trade through so that little aspect of it is neat um that they kind of pulled some of that geography and that those kind of trade blockades and stuff and there's like a card for Taiwan you know in there although um Taiwan probably could have like a half a deck you know or something I don't know but I don't think you want to spend too much time like on one issue with a game like this um so I like those Dynamics and I think this is really I mean we're gonna we're gonna step I'm just gonna kick politics like just kind of rub against it for a second so I mean it's like a cold war that we're kind of in right in terms of

our governments um with in the long ways I mean with the economics of this air this region um and the sort of growth of the region a lot of these countries are becoming much more modernized um there's just a lot of um uh you know issues with the food supply in Indonesia and some of the global warming stuff I think Indonesia I think it was Indonesia they're actually moving their Capital because of the increasing Water Supplies there um some of the some of the food production in Indonesia is very interesting because of the way that it basically can feed so many people and how the implications that kind of thing has I mean there's a lot of things that are not my expertise that just kind of adjacently know about um and then like I said there's that kind of canal blockade and there's the whole um uh the human rights issues in China and stuff like that which the game does not touch on um I think this game's probably been developing for a few years so the whole uyghur region um it's not the weaker region the weaker people in the region I can't remember the name of the region you know there's that whole the way that they're being treated and stuff like that so that's not been addressed here um but you know so it's a very interesting idea let's talk about it a little bit objectively here about something that is you know it's a Flashpoint game and I don't know if the rest of these are going to be like that like let's take a modern conflict area and then make a game about it I mean I don't I think this one's good I'd be a little nervous like if

they did one about Ukraine or something I'm like whoa you know let's let's let the uh the dust settle there um you know before we start publishing on the back of it in this case I think it's fine I think it works good and I think it's a it's a good exercise and it's also I think there's a certain level of Education that can come with this because you know I a lot of people probably just kind of go I mean I know people where I live like oh China you know like okay whatever you're just saying that because you watch TV you know um it's so the interesting Dynamics and interplay of how these other countries involved um or how they're involved and how important these other countries are not just Taiwan but these other countries and the Dynamics of that and the the sort of global interplay of that and that's very Twilight struggle-esque where you had the US and the USSR kind of proxy you know fighting each other in these different regions and this has that same kind of vibe there um and so it's good it's just kind of crystallizing the whole cold warness of how things are and I think that was pretty effective that a game could kind of do that and kind of there's some color you know in some of the uh the playbooks and stuff like that and the text and the cards um so it's nice it's like it's been a while since I played a game like this that got me excited in this kind of way um you know the coin games have gotten me um thinking about things like this um and so this this is nice it's a much more accessible way of doing something like this uh it's very solo friendly I like the solo that's a better two player

but you know it's it's even if somebody didn't really wasn't really that interested in the theme and they might be a little bit bored or put off by it but mechanics and stuff are really very solid and very interesting and so if you can kind of let yourself get into the theme a little bit the mechanics will kind of carry you home I think so I definitely recommend Flashpoint China Sea South China Sea and so take a look at it um just kind of come out of left field you know and I'm curious to see what other games they do in the flashpoint series because this is it's going to be interesting okay thanks foreign

Progress saved