Skip to main content
Loading video...

Tobago - First Play Review

Transcript 12:07

Hey there, I'm Jonathan with Getting Games and this is my first play review for Tobago. Now, what you're going to see here is a snippet from an exclusive live stream with the Patreon supporters of the channel where I talk about how the game plays and my thoughts about it after I played it that first time. If you'd like to join in on a future live stream, you can learn more about that by going to gettingames.com/support. Now, if you have thoughts about this game, maybe you've played it, it's a pretty old one, then please leave a comment down below. Also, if you enjoy the video, then please click the like and subscribe buttons down there as well. All right, let's talk about the game. This is a game that came out in 2009, which coincides with when I got into board games essentially. Uh 2008 is when I first uh was taught Katan. And 2009 is when I started going to open game nights and you know, the wide wide world of uh of modern board games was uh shown to me. And I remember seeing Tobago on the table a lot in 2009. Uh there were some people who just loved it. And I kind of always figured I'd get around to playing it. and it didn't happen. It just it's a really cool looking game with a hex board sort of.

It's sort of triangular. And you know, time went on and here we are 16 years later and I was at board game GeekCon and a friend of mine took Tobago out of the library and he's like, I've always wanted to play it. And I said, you know, I've also always wanted to play it. So, we sat down and got to play a three-player game and I quite enjoyed it. It's fascinating. Let's talk about it. So, you have a board in the middle of a table that's made up of multiple boards that kind of uh fit together. So, you have a a different island that's going to be constructed every time you play. And this game is about hunting for treasure on this island. And the way it works is fascinating. So, on your turn, you have essentially two things that you can do. You can either play a card onto a play or you can move your little ATV rover around the board. Now, most of the game, most of the thinking seems to be with the cards. And let's talk about that. So, you have these cards. You're always going to have four of them. And there are four different colors of treasure that can be found on the island. Black, brown, white, and gray.

Now, as you can see on these cards, we have various icons. And these have to do with the terrain and various elements on the board. And what we're trying to do here is bring down the number of spaces where a treasure could be to a single hex on the board. For example, this one right here shows the shore. So, the the sand on the side of the island. And then these icons mean the largest. And that means that for the white treasure, it is going to be somewhere on the sandy area that is largest on the outside of the map. So, we can look around and see that this is the biggest one. It has five different spots on it. And as you can see, there are white cubes. Now, you put these cubes down to show where the treasure could be once it's um restricted down to a certain number of spots. And as you can see over here, there are three of these white cubes.

And that's because there is another card here that says that the treasure is not going to be next to water. So, if we look over here, we can see that these two uh spaces are next to water, which means the treasure can't be there. So, as of this moment, the white treasure is going to be here or here or here. Now, you can't actually dig up the treasure until it's down to a single spot. And by taking the cards in your hand and playing them out to a play, you are reducing the options where things could be. Um, hypothetically, bringing it down to uh one, you cannot bring it down to zero. That treasure will be somewhere. So, we could look at our hand and see like I could put this one down to say it's not in uh mountains. But, of course, for the white, that would not help. We already know that the white is not going to be on mountains. Um, this one over here says it's going to be adjacent to the largest beach area.

Well, that doesn't work. We know that it is on the largest beach area. So, neither of these can be placed. This one as well that says on the rivers can be placed. And this one says it's um somewhere in the largest uh forest. So, that means I can't play any of my cards right now onto the white treasure because none of those will actually reduce the number of spots where that could be. But I could place it somewhere else. Like this one over here says that treasure, that brown treasure is within two spaces of the largest river. So, that's the general gist of what you're doing with these cards. And as you place the cards down, you put your own little token down. So, you can see this card was played by the red player, me, that card was played by the yellow player. Now, once the treasure gets down to a single spot on the board, it can be dug up by a person, the first person who moves their ATV onto that spot. When you do an ATV move turn, you get three movement, and you can move as far as you want for one move within a contiguous area. So this yellow one could go all the way over here for one move and then it could jump like here for a move and then all the way over there for a move.

And if you land on a single treasure spot, then you dig it up. You put another one of your tokens over here and that is when you dig for treasure. And this is maybe a polarizing part of the game. So you're you're digging for treasure. You don't know what you're going to find. And you're going to draw cards from the treasure deck. And you're going to give them to players equal to the number of tokens they have. So if I had two red tokens, I get two of these. and I can look at them and see what their values are. They range from 1 to six. And there are also two curse cards in that deck. Once everybody's looked at them, we put them into a pile. We add a random one. We shuffle it up and then we start dealing them face up. And the person who has the most recent token gets to choose if they want that card. So if we flip out a four, the most recent person can take that four. Or maybe they saw earlier that there's a six in there. So they want to wait and uh until that six comes up so they can take it. So they pass on the four. Then it moves to the next person and they could take the four or not and the next person they could take the four or not.

Once it's taken, you remove the token and then you reveal the next card from the stack. You're going to do this for every single one of these tokens or until a curse is revealed. If a curse is revealed, that's it. Nobody gets any more treasure. And everyone who still has at least one token over here loses their best treasure that they've taken previously unless they give up an amulet. Now, amulets are a really big deal in this game. Every time a treasure is found, uh, new amulets are going to be placed on the board based off of these Moai statues. They kind of point in different directions. You put them onto the beach and then the MOI move. So, these amulets keep getting placed out. You can pick these up with your ATV. And you can discard an amulet to not suffer that penalty. But on your turn, you could also discard your amulet to ditch your hand and draw new cards. Or you could discard an amulet to move your ATV up to three times. Or you could discard an amulet to play a new card onto the table. And you could play as many amulets as you want on your turn.

So, these are incredibly powerful and they let you do really big things. Um, we saw two turns in this game where somebody burned through like three or four or maybe even five of these amulets essentially taking like six turns in a row, like put this card down, move the ATV, move the ATV again, move, put this card down, move the ATV again. Okay, find the treasure. And of course, you're burning through these amulets to do that. and the amulets protect you from the curses, but it really lets you piece together some really powerful turns to then find that treasure and you're the first person who can take the token and hypothetically get a bunch of treasure cuz maybe you put a bunch of these cards down to have these tokens down to get the treasure. And that's pretty much the game overall. Probably too much detail, but it's a fascinating experience. I don't think I've played anything like this before. And it was easy to get a little frustrated like in this situation like you know I like white there's so few white left on the board. Sure my ATV isn't particularly close but if I want to add to white I can't. But I have five amulets right now. I could discard one to ditch my hand and draw new cards that will maybe be a little bit better for the situation. Or I could say hey there's no cards for gray right now. We could start working on gray. I could put one of these down and suddenly we're all collectively working towards finding the gray. As I said, there is some polarization with uh people and that treasure deck because they range from um you you lose a card to you can get up to six points, which seems pretty big. And the first two treasure that were picked up were both by my friend over here. And they got such good treasure. It was like six, five, five. Uh and then like another six and a four. And I was

picking up like three and a two. And like I was having fun. It's fine. But it was it was easy to be like, "Oh gosh, like this seems kind of random, right? It just, you know, depends on, you know, how these things are going to come up." And, you know, you have all this stuff to think about, like really smart um crunchy decisions and then you're flipping up random treasure cards to see who who gets what. And then, of course, curses could just wreck everything. Of course, you get to see some of the cards. So, if you can peek at cards and you see one of them as a curse, uh you might give that away if like it comes to you and a two flips up and you're like, "I take it." Everybody else might be like, "Uhoh, did they see a curse in there or are they like playing a long game on me? I don't really know." So, you keep playing until something happens. I can't exactly remember what. And interestingly enough, uh, I won this game, which I did not expect. I really thought the person over here was going to win. And I think they were winning until the very end of the game where two curses came out back to back. One of them was astonishing. We actually went through the entire treasure deck and we had to shuffle up a new deck. And literally the top card from that one ended up being a curse, which was funny. We laughed a lot obviously. Um cards were lost overall and I somehow squeaked a victory. Um even though one of my friends was doing really well in the early game, I apparently did really well um near the end of the game. And overall, I really enjoyed the experience and and I'm not really sure how I feel about two elements of the game. First of all, the randomness of the draw. You do draw a lot of cards. I think I'm kind of okay with it. Like it adds some spice to the game. I you know, sure it does mean that somebody could just get six after six

after six and it's like, okay, well, maybe they're going to win, but in this case, that that seemed to happen and that person didn't win. The thing that I had probably an actual problem with the game was the amulets and the fact that you could spend as many as you want on your turn. Um, you can get a whole bunch of these as I as you can see here, I have five of them. At one point, I think this person had like seven in front of them. And the analysis paralysis can definitely squeak in when you could take six turns in a row and you you feel motivated to do that. Um to like, you know, snatch things up, especially maybe as the game is getting uh near the end. And I kind of wish you could only spend one amulet per turn or maybe just one amulet to move your ATV and one amulet to or uh to play another card so you can play at most two cards or move twice or one card and one ATV and then maybe spend other amulets as much as you want. Oh, another thing you could do is spend an amulet to just remove a cube from the board. Um, which can of course really contract things down the the space for where the treasure could be quite a lot. Um, it's not a major gripe. Like I'm not saying, "Oh, this game is broken. Oh, it needs a house rule or anything like that." It just felt a little bit loose and AP uh inducing to have that element of the game. And um overall, I'm really glad I finally got to play this one. And I think I would jump at the chance to play it more. I don't think I'm gonna like buy a copy. Although, if I saw it for cheap, I might not be able to uh say no on that one. We played a three-player game. Uh with four, I'm not sure how I'd feel. Um you're going to have more things happening when it's not your turn, which means things will get restricted more probably between turns.

There's going to be more downtime, I suppose. Overall, it seemed like it played very well at three. Um I'm not sure how two would feel. Maybe a little bit wonky based off how things go. Um I could see four being quite a bit of fun as well. It's just a fascinating game. Uh, as you can see, there's a lot of really cool stuff that came out quite a long time ago now. Um, and I can see why this was played so much in my gaming group back when it first came out. There's also some shared incentive kind of things going on now that I think about it a little bit more based off of the tokens. You know, there was a part of the reason this player seemed to do so well early is because they got I think they burned through some uh amulets and they placed like three of their cards onto a spot and then got there. So they had like they got to take like four cards and in that one particular draw there was some really high value treasure. But of course if you have a lot of tokens down and it's not quite there, there's less incentive to help that person out to get those points. But of course if you do help them out, you put a token down after they do and that means you're going to pick cards before they do which means they're more likely I guess to get hit by a curse and that sort of thing. It was definitely an interesting push and pull with that element of the game.

Progress saved