Trench Raid Light Review & Impressions | World War 1 Solo Tactical Wargame | Compass Games
Transcript
Hi everybody, I'm Zilla Blitz and welcome. Today I'm going to offer up some impressions and do a light review of Trench Raid from Compass Games. If you're not familiar with this game, it's a solitire game where you lead 10-man patrols out into no man's land as the British in World War I. Uh, good things happen, bad things happen, and there's a five mission campaign game that you can play where you're trying to keep your soldiers alive and yet accomplish as many missions as you possibly can. Now, I've played the game a good bit over the past week. I wouldn't say this is a full review, but I've seen a lot of the game, certainly enough where I feel comfortable oper offering up some impressions and a light review, if you would, of the gameplay. First up, going to start out with uh is it fun? Did I like it? Uh absolutely, yes. And so, I'm a big fan of narrative games. Uh games that tell stories. This game oozes narrative. It does just a fantastic job with spinning the story of your patrol on pretty much every mission. You're going to have missions that are easy.
You're going to have missions that are absolutely horror shows, but and it's got such a nice range of events and uniqueness to it that I feel like every time I've gone on a patrol, I've come back and it's like a chapter in a novel. It just tells a marvelous story. It's got a very good It's done a very good job with the amount of events and then the detail in the events and the variety of events that can happen. Basically, you've got a moderately large set of about 20 events that can happen to you in no man's land and then another set of events that can happen to you out when you're in the enemy trenches. And within those events in and of themselves, there's some variety. For example, one of the events is you can run into gas. Well, it could be chlorine gas or mustard gas. And those have different consequences for patrol for your patrol.
You could run into an enemy patrol and it could you could be outnumbered, you could outnumber them, or it could be an even fight. And so that dictates how that event will unfold. And so in a lot of cases like this, you run into prisoners that you run into um wounded soldiers. Are they enemy soldiers? Are they your own soldiers? And so this narrative generation story capacity of this game is just really marvelous. I like these types of games. So, I've really enjoyed this one and I really really like the variety of events and the variety of narrative that this game spawns. Now, the the next question after that people always want to ask is in a game like this, how much control do you have over what happens to your patrol? And I I want to talk about this from both two levels because I think it's a dual there's a dual answer to this question. The first is you do have agency over your patrol um in three basic ways that you could say this counts. You've got first up, you're you're equipping your patrol with certain types of equipment and skills.
And that's going to matter quite a bit as to what you run into. For example, if you give all of your patrol members a gas mask and you run into the chlorine gas, you're going to be in good shape. But that means you've taken up one of those equipment spaces with gas masks that you can't use for something else that you might need for something else on a different type of event. So you're predicting to a certain degree what types of things you might need and you're calculating to what's the optimal load out for your patrol to carry out your mission with the greatest chance of success and the the smallest sense of danger. Now add on to that. There's an RPG element to this where if you play the campaign game, um you can designate the statistics for your soldiers. You have a 25 point total of points that you can allocate over a range of different characteristics in your soldiers. Things like speed, shooting, throwing, and various elements like that. Now, um, when you do this, you can customize that when you're playing the campaign game to try to optimize the roles for your soldiers and their likelihood to succeed over a number of patrols. So, you've got further nuance and control over your patrol and its chances of success by by doing that, by refining those statistics. And then the biggest way when you're in patrol that you can dictate and influence what happens to your patrol members is through the use of what are called luck points. So, when you start out a mission, you've got three luck points per soldier, and those are basically rerolls on the actions
that your patrol members will take. Now, on a longer patrol, you have to be very careful how you spend those luck points because you don't want to spend them all too early cuz then you're going to run out. You could run into a horrific event when you really want those luck rolls and you don't get them and catastrophe strikes. So balancing how you judiciously spend those luck points over the course of your patrol is another element as to the degree to which you both have control over your your events that happen to you and control over the success or failure of patrol but also to the degree that you're going to be able to mitigate the damage that happens to your different soldiers. Now, having said all that, oh, also too in the campaign game, uh, success patrol members that survive get an additional luck point. So, they can keep going by the fifth mission, sometimes two luck points. They can get more luck. And there's ways to get luck during a patrol. So, you can actually accumulate those points and have it be more likely that a patrol member is going to be able to survive missions as they get deeper into the campaign. So, yes, there's a number of ways in which you have agency and control over what happens in the game.
Having said that, there is a wide and swingy range in terms of the types of events that can happen to your patrol. Some of them are downright deadly, like if you get hit by an artillery barrage or you run into an enemy patrol and you are outnumbered. Um or if you get chlorine gas and you don't have gas masks or you've lost your gas mask or and there's just a countless number of ways that you can have some events that really go sideways and they can just rip through your patrol causing all sorts of casualties and you go from a healthy 10-man patrol down to three people that are just basically trying to scramble back to their own lines and survive the mission in any way that they can. So, while you do have a level of control over what happens, the biggest thing, the bigger picture is how the dice gods are going to either toss you down and crush you or lift you up and give you success. So, there's a a limited amount of control, but the biggest picture, I think, is just what's going to happen to you. So, what does that mean? That means a few things. one, if you uh if you're a player who likes to play games as a test of your skill, um or if you're a player who uh doesn't like losing, who takes losing personally, I think you'd probably get frustrated with this game because the game's just going to beat you up at times. Um if you're a player with that, if you're a player who likes narratives and is okay with losing, and if losing
is just as much fun sometimes as winning, if it generates a good story, I think you're really going to enjoy this game. So know what type of gamer you are before you jump in and and grab this one. And this, you know, within that bigger context, Trench Raid is very similar to games like The Hunters, um, Silent Victory, uh, Western Front Ace, right, where there is a modicum of skill that you can bring to the experience and mitigate the risks that are going to happen to your patrol and increase the chances of success. But to a certain degree, this is a game that generates narrative. and at times it's just going to beat you up and at times it's just going to lift you up. Couple other things that I was wondering about before I started to play that I thought I would address. Now, uh the game comes with these 10 sheets and there are two patrol members per sheet and each so you've got your a sheet here for your 10 patrol members. Now, before I started playing, I wondered there's a number of events like where you have to make a dice roll for each one of your patrol members. You know, uh when you run into an enemy squad, for example, you each one of your patrol members has to roll a fight action. If you've got 10 patrol members, you're doing this mini calculation for all of your patrol members. And then you're keeping the record tracking of, you know, injuries and statistics changes and all kinds of things and equipment on these cards. And I wondered before I started playing one, is the like the 10 die rolls for each soldier, is that going to get kind of old after a while because you're doing that all the time? Um, and how is the recordeping going to work? Is that going to get really kind of tedious as you're playing the game? I'm I'm very happy to say that I actually enjoyed this a lot. I felt
like this system, which I was really somewhat skeptical of before I played it, it worked really well. These are all very kind of laminated sheets. They're glossy sheets. And then the game comes with whiteboard erase marker and this little eraser on the tip of it here. And through that, you write on these and then you erase and cross off as you're going through the campaign to keep track of everything. And I thought, this going to be kind of is this going to work? Right. I'm happy to say that I felt like it really did work with one caveat. I found this whiteboard marker that comes with the game is too blunt. And so when I was writing on the little charts, I'm trying to write words like the names of characters or their skills that you have to write out. I couldn't read it. It was all blurry. So I went off and on Amazon, I got some ultra fine whiteboard markers and they have a much finer point and these work great. I'll put a link to these down below in the video description if you want to get I think like seven bucks on Amazon for like eight of them. Um and so it worked great. So with the fine markers in this system, I felt like this was a really good combination. I struggled when I was trying to write with the marker that came with the game. Although I do like the little fuzzy tipped eraser there.
Now I also use a regular whiteboard eraser just because I can, you know, when guy die, you can just wipe it all off in quite a quick second rather than very slowly with this thing. So that's something else you might want to consider if you got lying around. But I'm very happy to say that I found this fun and I found this in an RPG sense of the way. It was really fun to kind of see the stories of the characters as they unfolded and use this. And it wasn't uh anywhere it wasn't tedious or ownorous or any kind of a burden as I thought it might be. As well as when you're doing the 10 dice rolls and you're going through a whole patrol and each patrol member has to succeed or fail in an action. They're super fast. You know, again, this and that comes into the next point too. Uh, but it this game was really easy to execute. I could go through 10 dice rolls in maybe a minute or two minutes. So, it's not like this complicated process that you're doing for each soldier. It's literally you look at their card, you know how many dice you got, you roll, you decide whether you're going to use luck, you roll again. If they're wounded, you got to make a couple more rolls. But, it was easy and fun and it just it kind of added to the story book nature of what's going on. And that brings that connects to the next point. I thought this was going to be tedious and burdensome in terms of tracking that. It wasn't at all. And that goes to the bigger point to how difficult of a game is this to play. I felt like the rule book and the gameplay was really easy. I would put this in the beer and pretzels category.
I really didn't struggle at all to execute the rules. I barely read the rules before I started to play cuz most of the time it's going to spawn an event and then you look at the event, you read the flavor text, it tells you exactly what you do. You just go in and you execute that and then you go on to the next thing. And it's it it was just a joy to play. It's very very simple. They've done a good job clarifying the rule set, articulating what goes on, and it's not a complex game. I would say a two and a half and a three out of 10 now after having played the game a number of times at this point. So, uh you don't have to worry about the complexity of the game. It's it's I think it's a level easier than things like the Hunters or Silent Victory uh that I've played that are similar games of this. British Tank Ace for sure easier than that. Uh this game is just really clear, easy to execute. The way they've organized things just really, really works. I mean, there's a couple of fuzzy spots, but I'd be picking nits to mention them in this review. It's not worth it. Um, just really good job with the rules and how to execute the game. Not difficult at all.
There we have it. And overall picture, bottom line, thumbs up for me. I really like this one. I encourage you if you like games that spawn narratives, I think you will really, really enjoy this one. It just oozes flavor. The quality of the writing, the events, the variety of events. It is just really fun. But you have to be the type of person who enjoys losing. You have to be able to say, "Well, I just lost seven of my 10 patrol members on this patrol with an artillery barrage." It's okay. It's it we'll get seven new members and drive on. If you're that type of player and you you know you you're playing for narratives, this is the game for you. If you look at if you look at games and you like games that are solely as tests of skill, I feel like this is probably not the game for you. Um I think you'd want to be in the other category of gamers. So, there we have it. An impressions and light review of Trench Raid from Compass Games. I've greatly enjoyed my time with this and I'm looking forward so looking forward to doing a full campaign with this one as well. Thanks for watching.