Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 22:38

hello today we're going to be talking about a little game called tapes try where you try and record the entirety of human history on a 90 minute Maxwell tape I mean I suppose you can try and interpret this title as tapestry but I would just be silly I mean who's going to try and record the entirety of human history on what is effectively a glorified curtain it just wouldn't work

in tapestry you will be handed a civilization you might get something like the merrymakers an entire culture founded on the long-standing English tradition of getting pissed they're essentially the future people from that time machine movie because as the game goes on they just get free things to enjoy without having to do any real long-term planning who needs planning when you're mostly drunk or maybe you'll play as the Mystics your entire goal of the game predicting at the very start how well you will do if you predict correctly you will get a lot of points inevitably doing better than you originally predicted whatever you end up with you once again dip into board gaming's favorite thematic Fran asan's the rise of civilizations and whilst tapestry doesn't really ring true of that theme from a gameplay perspective it's nothing like its namesake video game experience it certainly nails that nonsense history angle the very first sieve game had a famous bug where in certain circumstances the very peaceful computer-controlled Gandhi player would do a 180 and suddenly go all-out launching nuclear weaponry or did it people make games made a very interesting video on that you should check it out if there's one element of the entire civil game experience that really encapsulates it it is that nonsense history imagine playing as the English for example and never colonizing anything or or having a vote realizing

you've made a horrible horrible mistake and then having another one tapestry achieves this with tapas which conveniently are the size of a magnetic tape I should probably let that Joker as the game progresses you'll have the chance to play this to your player board defining your civilizations direction for its next era thus you get combinations like starting out with inventing fire then going straight into capitalism because why not make all the mistakes at the beginning realizing that doesn't work and going into colonialism and then just jumping straight into piracy because nothing matters anymore cheeri and I hear what some of you are saying Africa I'm not about all this anachronistic mumbo-jumbo I don't want to invent the Age of Sanitation without first having developed the concept of a toilet and that's fine tapestry might not be a game for you but I think I think that it is a perfectly fine thing okay so tapestry is nothing like its progenitor in gameplay but then what is it like let's give you a rundown like in many games in tapestry you'll be wanting to have the most victory points each time your turn comes along one of the two things you can do is a hard reset because you've run out of resources and you need resources to do things and you trigger the income phase which will let you activate whatever abilities your civilization has planned in tapestry card upgrade an attack that you have trigger any scoring abilities based on how many houses you built and then get new resources based on how many houses you build got that okay because all of that barely ever happens in the real meat of the game is if you choose

to not do income and instead advance on one of the game's four tracks I did that I won't take no I didn't and that's where things get a little bit tricky to explain although the game doesn't share that sentiment because the entirety of the rules fits on brief four pages printed on this same magical paper as the wingspan rulebook after size manual which was designed by the same designer Jamie Stegman I was a little bit disappointed to see this truncate of approach because that was one of the best manuals I have ever read and this is not very adequate at teaching the game but it is indicative of how simple tapestry aims to be each term you will choose one of the four tracks exploration military technology or science and advance on them wistfully lamenting the absence of in this world each time you advance you'll pay the resource cost of your current bracket and execute the ability of whatever space you landed that part is easy to explain executing actions let's just say that every action has a different effect making this a game that has nearly as many actions as a feast for Odin thankfully there is a handy reference sheet that explains all of them but it will take you at least one game for your brain to absorb a decent portion of what is even possible bouncing from one space to another is intoxicating the phrase kid in a candy store doesn't even quite cut the mustard I'd like in it more to a kid who was told he was in a candy store but then every candy was secretly replaced with Ritalin that was dipped in coca-cola the

dizzying array of spaces actions and potential combinations might seem overwhelming but it is a genuine delight for someone who loves exploring the unknown likes to prod things to see what they do and genuinely gets excited when the plethora of light bulb starts blinking do not despair there is method to this madness each track has an Associated mechanism all common actions that are part of the action spaces that you land on exploration appropriately lets you expand into new territories at the center of the board each time you explore you place a new tile from a personal supply available to you as soon as you are allowed to do this you will experience an emotional tug of war an irresistible itch that is central to the tapestry experience do you want a resource that will let you go further before you have to reset or do you want more victory points they'll let you climb the ladder of success if you learn the borders of each tile to match the terrain with other existing ones you'll get one victory point per border and then you will get whatever is depicted at the center of that tile bead a resource and new technology called a new tapestry card or even one of these dinky little buildings naturally some terrain is more common than other so a tile where the strong bonus will be harder to match how many victory points you give up for that bonus is up to you this emotional seesaw is even starker if you get to conquer which

is an action found on the military track conquering lets you expand on to the expanded territory you just expanded onto by placing a little outpost as soon as you do you roll to combat dice one will display a random value of victory points the other a resource your choice now let's pop back to the income phase because much like a good rug it really ties this tapestry together progressing through any given track lets you build buildings associated with that track because building each building uncovers a bonus each income face you'll get more resources that will help you progress further on that track sacks of cash for technology bulky man for science communist stars for military and you need mushrooms to explore but crucially you'll also uncover scoring opportunities that are once again tied to said track wafting through military you land on spaces like archery cavalry or tanks but each time you'll just plop out an outpost next to your territory there's even the tiniest smidge of confrontation if you conquer the territory controlled by your opponent you will topple their outpost whilst simultaneously placing yours still very much standing this contracts their territory and at the same time expands yours and that's important because every income phase will get points equal to the number of territories you can clone twice if you have both of these

uncovered and that's a hefty dose of points cream that you can rub on your face every income phase exploration has a similar mechanism but because the game has no memory of how much you actually explored you just get a flat rate pulling bonus but it's only when we come to the bulky man of science that things get a little bit yes these are actual real pieces you'll get in the game but really it's the entire science track that is weird the others introduced their core mechanisms right from the get-go and very gently where science is made from very different giblets the idea behind it is that it will let you propel yourself further in your other endeavors sometimes rolling a die and telling you on which track you'll move or sometimes if you're very far along just letting you choose but to even start your trundle towards with the world of isotopes and Schwarzschild radius --is first you have to make a sacrifice the initial steps of the science track will let you advance on the other tracks but without receiving the bonus and no there's nothing clever you can engineer here skipping a step can have devastating effects towards whatever strategy you've picked and even if you do find yourself wanting to skip a particular step you don't get to choose you just have to roll the die and eat your vegetables

horrible horrible luck vegetables the gravy here is that once you do get past the vegetables your hunk of roast beef has some tender juicy bonuses later down the track rolling the die advancing and getting the bonus feels like a lavish treat because now you're inching closer towards the end of two tracks but also you might be winning the race each track is separated into four sections not only do the sections signify the cost of advancing but if you're the first person to cross into the new section you'll get a funky chunky anytime you get one of these bulbous beauties all the dinky ones from your player board you get to place them in Capital and just like that tapestry presents you with another puzzle and just like in the military and the exploration tracks it's a choice of getting points or resources except on the science track you want to fill up complete rows or columns with buildings in your capital board ignoring the pre-printed spaces on the board cover up an entire quadrant of your capital instead and you'll get a free resource oh maybe there's a way I can do both tapestry is like that waiter at a fancy party with a tray of entrees and even though you've already had your fill he's there with the plate going would you like some more no thank you I've already had enough and

actually I need to watch my I don't know those are really delicious maybe maybe I'll just have another dumpling and then five minutes later he's still there waiting watching would you like some more I could tell you about the technology track with yet another puzzle of grabbing technology cards I can't actually pick them up and choosing which one to edge upwards for yet another set of points or bonuses but by now I think you've got the idea instead I want to draw your attention to these clay rations again that's a portmanteau of clay and creation stay with me no they are not made of clay they are plastic either way you shouldn't really need them the original skulls hull were definitely clay creations from artist Ron Brown the impressive design is Jamie stag Myers so much but they served as the basis for this entire game Jamie wanted to design a game that could house these houses provide them with a loving home on your boardgames shelf and I really really really really wish that he hadn't the definitely a Marmite inclusion in terms of aesthetics but I will admit I do like them very much the quirky off-kilter almost funny and a little bit messy basically everything that I am and I was to give them a hug so much but my oh my me tell you right now that tapestry is

$100 game and I would guesstimate that all of this plastic makes up about 40% of that cost it's not just that they are form over function it's that the form turns out to be lacking tapestries buildings by the virtue of being more free dimensionally pronounced sacrifice the potential of being interesting puzzle pieces they are either perfect squares rectangles which are a kind of square and if you're really fortunate once in a blue moon they have one protruding edge but even then they somehow manage to be confusing because unlike cardboard tiles which can be cut to precisely fit the puzzle they're meant to fit these don't quite aligned to the spaces on this board far too frequently I was working towards getting one and then realizing that couldn't really place it where I wanted to place it and then you can't even fling them because they - gosh darn adorable and they don't make any sense thematically far from representing the various stages of history like Roman times medieval times or my favorite period the age of LCD soundsystem when James Murphy was the king of all humans these look like a misguided set of Playmobil figures where you get a bomb a police station and for some reason a space rocket this mishap is further intensified by the fact that in terms of artwork tapestry is gorgeous illustrator Andrew Bosley should absolutely Pat himself on the back because he's got the

best looking game of 2019 in his portfolio the continent you create at the center of the board with bright pastel colors is inviting the illustrations on each civilization sheet are inspiring many a times when I drew my random starting civilization I immediately wanted to take them on this journey based on artwork alone without having even read what they do the player board hits you with glowing hues of magic our sunrise and ever present parallel to the dawn of your people which is all a very roundabout way of saying that I agree with Jaime Stegner that they should definitely be a game that uses these but this as an idea simply outgrew them as their and pragmatically looking at tapestry is a delight and simultaneously a disappointment because imagining what mr. Bosley could have done with just some cardboard tiles is a constant reminder how much cheaper and better this game could have been let's forget about the price for now what if it didn't matter should you still get this game well there's no easy answer for that like suspect the tapestry will delight as many people as it will frustrate and potentially do both of those the internet was quickly compared to Gong Shan clever a simple roll android game we advanced on tracks but they littered with bonuses bouncing between them like an inebriated pinball advancing on all the tracks all the way to the top is a mathematical impossibility so you have to pick a couple of them and do your best tapestry takes this drunken giant metal

marble grows it tenfold and unleashes it onto a circus floor full of trapeze artists livestock and murderous clowns where's gonzo clever never allowed you to go on whatever party you liked your choices were hamstrung by those rules introducing much-needed variants to what otherwise would have been a math Abul puzzle tapestry instead injects variants into each step you take and then it ejects it again and again and again and again and again and again and let's set aside the argument that having more than a dozen civilizations with wildly differing powers leads to imbalance frankly there's no way of ever knowing with so many factors so many d'Arles knobs and levers to manipulate the mechanisms of this game it would take thousands of samples to get an array of statistical data and even then there's no way to account for the fact that some people might simply have a skill set that's better suited to doing well in this playground the argument is nonsensical and unnecessary the problem isn't whether they feel balanced or imbalanced the problem is that some of them on a gut reaction level just feel a little bit flabby being handed something that feels like it doesn't have the potential to marinate into a good brooo means that you stop there for a couple of hours trying to make lemonade out of vinegar and I don't know if you noticed but vinegar smells that musk continues to pervade the tracks as you

go along them whatever faction you have been given will propel you in a certain direction that's good but everything else could either immensely reward you for your chosen path or continue to crush you against the weight of every decision you have made everything from tapestry cards to die rolls to tile drawers to play account to seating order could potentially elicit responses from oh my god I can't believe how lucky i got to i wish i was doing anything else right now but playing this game in one of my games I got to play as the isolationists one of the factions I found more engaging the power lets you place a second outpost each time you conquer a territory that makes them protected against any incursions in the game but the icing on the cake is that each time you do this you will get a resource of your choice the natural inclination is to do it early so you get the resources you need to grease and all your engine but that means that you've likely done it close to your capital rather than the area's you actually need to protect from those incursions why is that important well because isolation is score points at the end of the game based on the size of the territory they manage to create all comprising and adjoined identical terrain not only am i given a clear path in terms of which tracks Christ should pick to advance on

exploration would give me the necessary tiles to place and surround myself with space and military would let me place those outposts that I need to place but you know what there is enough flexibility in there to deviate the isolationists are compelling because there's no one clear path and there's an inherent choice built into the faction I'm playing but guess what happened next my very first tapestry card was the each of sale I could not believe it after our game finished I looked for the entire deck of tapestry cards and I sincerely doubt there is a better one I could have drawn not only does it effectively give me free points each time I explore in this area but it also gives me a cornucopia of exploration tiles full of hills sand lakes forests mountains and whatever it is that my heart desires and naturally 40 points for my faction ability at the end of the game that of course feels amazing but you know what doesn't watching your opponents struggle to draw anything that resembles a cohesive plan trundling along through tracks with not an ounce of whim or vigor for every person on my table who had a great time with tapestry I could point to another person whose entire game melted into a flubber which you know I can forget Jaime stedmeyer is a designer is more and more in tune with his strengths tapestry is a strategy game but it's

Saini fast-paced and wonky er than a daikon grown in English soil which I can definitely see some people embracing what I cannot forgive is some baffling design decisions that add my most generous I can call glaring oversights why is it that the end of the technology track gives you the option to discard free technology cards for 10 points whereas the other tracks give you opportunities to discard redundant resources to score some points the technology track lets you discard the resource that scores you points creating situations where sometimes you'll discard 9 points to get 10 points which is okay but at other times 18 points to get 10 points when I is the 2 of the 4 ultimate spaces of each track are such utter disappointments why would I want to roll a die 4 times for either no effect or if I'm lucky maybe scoring 5 points why would I want to draw a new civilization at the end of the game when its effect could be completely meaningless why are the factions in this game that are utterly rubbish in a two-player game why wouldn't you put in your rulebook we don't recommend playing with these factions in the two-player game was the rulebook being four pages long really that important this is just a smattering of effects and abilities that I don't understand the inclusion of and maybe I'm missing something fundamental but that's just my generous size talking and if I were to turn it off

for just a second I would say something like this game needed more rigorous testing and development before being rushed out to buyers ultimately I would equate tapestry to an irresponsible parent that leaves a toddler in a giant room filled to the brim with amazing toys and lit candles whether it has the time of its life or says the house on fire is not something it's concerned with because insurance is probably going to sort it out I have to sheepishly admit that I did enjoy tapestry and had fun with it but I had to turn off my empathy because some of my friends including Elaine really didn't weather that along with a hundred bucks is a price you're willing to pay is for you to figure out

Progress saved