Scythe Boardgame - Quick Review
Transcript
Hello. Yeah, what do you want? You what? Scythe? You want a Scythe review? A bit late to the party, ain't you? It's ancient. You still here? You really want a Scythe review this late in? Oh, go on then. Board Games 4K Hello, ladies and gentlemen. Welcome back. Popular demand. Not really. This is a Scythe a little bit of an overview of Scythe. We recently played this one. So, if you want to check out our play through, you can uh we'll put a link down in below, upstairs, or somewhere even another room somewhere. But anyway, this this is this was massively popular on Kickstarter a few years ago, wasn't it?
I think it blew everyone away, I think. But um what do we think about it? We've played it quite a few times, you know what I mean? We've got a couple of expansions. We've got the Rise of Fenris or all the new encounter cards, but we've got the the uh God, what's it called? The the airship thing. The Yeah, we Well, that's another day and another story, but and we've got the we've got the uh extra two factions in here as well, but What What is this game? I mean, we can't figure out whether it's I mean, it's got a bit of everything. It's almost like Jamey Stegmaier like sort of looked at every all the games that are around, like, and took bits and pieces and stuck them in a big cauldron, mixed them all up, and then this spewed out. I'm not saying that it's bad or nothing, but But um yeah, this has got like area control. You control the factory in the center. You've got worker placement.
Uh action selection. You've got a random element, haven't you, where you pick up the encounter cards. You've got like resource management. You've got that even got that Seven Wonders thing where you you you're sort of playing off the two people to the left and right of you. So, yeah, this is a bit a bit of a mishmash, a bit of a hotchpotch. You can't it can't figure out whether it's a Euro game or whether it wants to be aspires to be an Ameritrash game with the miniatures and everything, you know. So, yeah, we still haven't really figured out what niche what genre this game fills. So, maybe that's why we keep playing it. I don't know. So, what do we like about this game, then? Uh First of all, I mean, it's got to be said, isn't it? The production value and the the artwork, I mean, it's just it's just off the charts, isn't it? Just the the style of the artwork is is is so original. Not really seen anything like like it in board games before, really.
You know, it's not none of this sort of this kind of stuff with a a mad king staring at you. This is this is like creating a a full-blown sort of ecosystem, sort of like a there's a proper world out there, you know? This this living and breathing and yeah, it's it's just amazing quality production. There's plastic, there's wood. Board looks fantastic. It's just it's just absolutely phenomenal. So, yeah, that's one of the first things that we obviously got to draw attention to is the production quality and the artwork. Absolutely stellar. Yeah, obviously I don't know if you see like our recent top 100 board games, obviously we put Twilight Imperium at number one. And um this sort of borrows One of the One of the things we like about this is it borrows from that in the sense that you've got this sort of slow burning build-up and then bang, it's it something happens and it all kicks off. And then you you've got to If you If If you're fortunate enough to lose that and you've got to rebuild, but you're not completely and utterly blown out of the game by what you're doing. So, yeah.
One of the things we really like is the difficult choices that occur at the beginning of the game because your options are so limited you're just you're stuck in the corner of board with literally nothing to play for. And you've got to get over that that wall. So, your options are limited but it gives you the opportunity to expand it in multiple different ways and there's multiple strategies coming out from that that one little area on the board. So, we really really like that that part of the game. Yeah, one of the other things that is a sort of that's kept this keeps kept this coming back to the table is the the fact you've got like faction specific abilities like everybody starts with the same type of action, but the way that they the actions are loaded on your specific board are completely different to somebody else. So, you know, when you first start playing this is like oh, if you look at this action this is what you do, but they're looking at it going, "Well, that's not what I've got on my board."
So, the fact there's now seven factions in this and you mix and match your your player board with the faction board it's just a multitude of different different options, different strategies. You can't play this game the same way more than once because you you you we always do like a random thing apart from my wife who likes purple, but anyway, we always do a random selection of this. So, you never really know what you're going to get and you might be sitting in a different place on the board next to somebody who over time if you play games regularly with the same people, you sort of get to sort of think well, you get to know what the way that they play the game whether they're going to be combative or whether they're going to be defensive or whatever. So, this forces you into into different different strategies based on your starting actions and the things that you pick cards. So, yeah, that's well, all awesome. Yeah, another thing that keeps this coming back to the table is that it keeps developing James Stegmaier keeps developing this this game. So, you start off with the the vanilla game and then he expanded the amount of players and the amount of options that you've got there and then he added the airship modules and that and then different ways that you can finish the game in that in that module.
And now you've got the the campaign in the Rise of Fenris. So, even though this game keeps on being expanded and keeps growing, none of the none of the expansions are are essential, which which is sort of refreshing. It It doesn't really matter whether you play with the expansions or not. You've still got the same quality of game there. It's not like you can sort of say, "Well, you know, we used to like this game, but now the expansion's out, we won't ever play without it." You can play You can play Saga without the expansion. You can play You can mix and match loads of stuff in, and you will still get a solid quality game no matter what. And that that's that's that's really really refreshing in the board game industry at the moment. You know, you don't have to get the expansions. You're still going to get a solid game for your money.
So, what then we like about Saga? There's plenty to talk about here, but I'm not saying we don't like like the game, but the fact that there is a limited player interaction apart from the the 7 Wonders thing where you where you got the two things. It's not You're sort of You're stuck in the corner, and yeah, you you die on a sort of branch out. You want to do as much as you can and get out. You You can't You can't do everything you want to do. And you're building up building up your stuff, and then you suddenly make a move, and no one wants to have a scrap. Do you know what I mean? It's not like Cyclades where you sort of you get stuck in. You might lose a couple of men, and then you you retreat, you build up, you come back in. Well, that's how we play anyway, but with this one, there's not that many fights. I mean, some people might say that's a good thing, but it just seems a bit bizarre that you You've got all these mechs, and they they they're they're basically their primary use really for a lot of our games that we play.
They're used as a transport system. That's That's it. You know, you you want to see You want to You want to tool these mechs out with all these big weapons, and you want to get stuck in and and have a royal punch-up with a factory there, but nine times out of 10, that don't happen. So, yeah, that's one of the negatives is that the the the upgrades and the the the expand when you expand your engine, you're not really sort of utilizing it in a way that the game tempts you into doing. So, Yeah, another negative finish probably been widely talked about this one is the fact that the game ends directly after someone gets their six-star on on the achievement track. So, that means that not everybody gets the same amount of turns. So, why? I don't really understand that. So, we house rule this and we always make sure that someone's got like a first player marker or something to to get that to to beat to beat that score. So, I mean, okay, the the wind this airship thing, I can't remember the name of it now, but that fixes it because you got different um different endings that you can have. You had I think it's a 20 20-round limit.
But, uh yeah, when we first played it, we're like, "Well, hang on a minute. You've had one more turn than me. How's that fair?" But, it is what it is, but we just house rule it and we just say we play it till to the end of that round, but Yeah, I mean, this isn't one of my criticisms. I quite like this cuz of you see Cyclades was my number one, but a few people I played this with, they they get frustrated where they don't feel like their engine is building as quickly as they would like it to build, you know? They like going for those encounter cards cuz it gives them a really nice quick and free bonus, but they struggle to It's like you're sort of wading through water. Try desperately and in a sense, that's sort of like poetic justice in a way cuz you obviously you've got to get the uh the water walking ability to get out of that little that little bit of land you've got, that peninsula, but a lot of people I played this with, they they get frustrated at at the pace of the game at the beginning and they're tentative in having a fight because I don't want to Whereas taking so long to build up, they don't want to lose any of that that that engine that built up. So, uh yeah, it's sort of Yeah, once again, like we said, it tempts you into thinking it's going to be it's going to be a punch up and it's going to be sort of exciting things, but really it's like a plodding it's very slow-burning game and there's no real there's no real climax to it. It's just, you know, somebody you see them getting up the the one of the tracks or they take control of a factory, load it with mechs, and you're like, it's not worth the risk. I might as well turn my
attention to something else. Anyway, Yeah, so uh that's that's another semi-negative, not personally, but things I've heard bandied around. So, uh overall, what do we think of Scythe? Well, it's a in my personal opinion, it's a it's an absolute classic game. I mean, I think it changed the way uh not not the way people play games or it wasn't a game-changer in essence, but it changed the way people it changed people's expectations of what they what board game could and should be. Like, it just raised the bar on production levels and it raised the bar on what's possible. And I don't think if I don't think any other company could have could have produced anything of this quality. But, um yeah, I mean, I don't think you'd have to play it hundreds and hundreds of times to to close the game down and say, "That's it. We've we're done with this."
Because there's so much content now for this this this universe. But, um it would just I've been uh talking about a modular board now. I mean, I thought like The Rise of Fenris was meant to be the last expansion for this one, but he's talking about chucking out a modular board like a Clans of Caledonia down it. And I mean, that that just like changed the game up even more. I can't wait for that. That's going to be That's going to be awesome. You know what I mean? It's going to be absolutely fantastic. So, yeah, Scythe, I mean, the fact that this game is still growing and it's still it's it's still it it sort of changes its personality over time, you know? It's a of people like David Bowie. They can read the market and they adapt their persona and it sort of morphs itself dependent on what's what's the zeitgeist at the time I suppose. I don't know.
Anyway, without getting too deep here, recommended game. Late to the party with this one but who cares? I mean, it's it should be in everyone's collection. No doubt about it. Absolute brilliant.