Skip to main content
Loading video...

Is 12 Rivers more than just a gimmick? -TCbH Review

Transcript 7:13

Today, I'm reviewing 12 Rivers from Good Games Publishing, and if you know anything about this game, it's going to be about this central gimmick, the marble-rolling centerpiece that dominates the table when you take it out of the box. And you are probably going to be expecting copious amounts of footage of the marble-rolling gimmick. So, I'm going to go ahead and get a montage of that out of the way at the start of the video. Look at them. Look at them go. Ooh. Marbles rolling, rolling, rolling, rolling, rolling. All right. Now that that's over, let's talk about this game and see if it is good without the gimmick.

12 Rivers is a game of collecting pearls that fall down the mountain to the village below. Your tribe is trying to grab the most valuable pearls while also appeasing the local villagers. Each round you'll have two phases. The phase where you place tribe tokens in turn order, and the phase where you resolve those tribe tokens. Tribe tokens can go on the mountain or in the village.

Placing your tribe token higher up the mountain to guarantee what kind of pearl you're going to get is going to cost you more cards, while going to the least valuable spot will actually gain you a card. Similarly, you can place your tribe token in the village, choosing which villager you want to add to your tribe. If you choose to go first, you'll have first choice at those villagers. But again, it's going to cost you cards to go before everyone else. Well, maybe you don't want to go first. You can just take these spots which don't cost any cards. The villagers aren't going to have game-breaking abilities, but they will have varying capacity to hold different colored pearls and unique scoring opportunities either from having the most of a certain kind of pearl or by filling up their carrying capacity.

Importantly, adding a villager to your tribe is one of only two ways that you can add new cards from the deck to your hand, and these cards give a lot of depth to 12 Rivers. On top of being the main resource you use to position yourself to gain pearls or villagers, the cards have special boosts that you can use to enhance your turn, such as drawing an extra pearl,

moving a tribe token up the mountain for free, along with others. Some of these cards combo incredibly well into one another, so you can have these big explosive turns, but it's at the cost of shedding cards from your hand. To get these boosts, you do have to play your cards in pairs, which leads to difference in value turn to turn. Yes, you may want to draw two pearls instead of one, but if you only have one fishing net, you can't play it, so it's liable to be discarded to go higher up the mountain to secure pearl you really need. This is really smart, but it's not the smartest thing in this game. That goes to the turn order track. You see, when you place your tribe token higher up the mountain, you are going to resolve your actions first this round, which means you're going to choose what pearl you want, you're going to remove your tribe token and let the other pearls fall down the mountain, and then you're going to place your tribe token at the last available spot in the next round turn order.

This adds so much more risk into going up the mountain and enables some strategy that I wouldn't have really considered otherwise. This is brilliant and it's one of the reasons that I think 12 Rivers is great in spite of its gimmick and because of it. There are a few games with similar enough core mechanics that you could argue 12 Rivers is only standing out because it has this huge table hogging centerpiece. And it it is a huge table hogging centerpiece, but this game does a lot of work to make itself so much more than that. The pearl capturing system gives a great risk reward mechanic of trying to figure out how high up the mountain you actually have to go to get the pearls you want without them being stolen away by your opponents.

The pearls trickling down the main ramp to the awaiting lake below makes the game feel so much more thematic and let you visualize where the marbles are going to join together. There are going people who say that you don't need this huge centerpiece to reach the same level of gameplay, that you could easily easily have a flat board and have just players finagle pearl tokens down a set stream of rivers and get to the same spot in terms of gameplay and mechanics. But I think that skips over the fact that this is really fun. The marbles rolling down the mountain is a spectacle and does encourage people to get this game to the table. And the point of board games is that they're meant to be fun. So, for me, I don't really think that's a fair criticism.

I do have a few critiques of my own that I I think are good and fair. This game isn't super deep. There's no multi-round long plans that you're formulating. It tends towards reactionary play styles, just taking into account what's available right now. Where are pearls available and if there are any villagers that will help you get the most points. I found that to be the sweet spot in terms of weight for many of my board gaming groups, but it may feel a bit thin for yours and for the price point. This centerpiece probably costs a lot of money to make, leading this to be about 20 to $30 more expensive than other games I'd put in a similar weight class. If you want the most bang for your buck, this is something you're going to want to take into account. Speaking of, there's something that this game desperately needs that is lacking here, a round tracker.

There are some tokens in this game that get placed in different spots depending on which round you are in and the game ends after you played five rounds, but there's no way to actually keep track of what round you're in. This could easily fixed with a tiny piece of plastic that goes on the spot of the board already numbered one through five. And there's even a few 3D prints of the exact piece you would need going around, but it's a bit disappointing that it's not included when the game already costs so much more than other similar games. 12 Rivers is a bit of a gimmicky game, and it is also a heck of a lot of fun. I played this game a lot to see if the gimmick would ever wear off for me, and let me tell you the 15th and 20th time playing this game were just as much fun for me as the first.

There are going to be games with equal levels of strategic depth, if not more, that are going to be cheaper than this game. But I found this game a lot easier to get to the table because everyone gets excited about it from the moment you open up the box to set up. For me and my gaming groups, this game works really well. And if you're looking for a light to midweight game, this is something that I'd recommend taking a look at. That was my review of 12 Rivers. Let me know your thoughts down in the comments below if you have played it, or let me know in the comments what your favorite game with a big gimmicky centerpiece is. Thank you for tuning in. Thanks for being an awesome community. I've been Eric with The Cardboard Hero.

Progress saved