Skip to main content
Loading video...

3 Ring Circus Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 22:08

hey everybody today we're taking a look at three ring circus which is a wonderful player Euro strategy board game published by D and designed by Fabio Lano and Remo kadori this game takes probably around 60 to 90 minutes to play on average now before I share my thoughts on three ring circus I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor kendra. co.uk who are my go-to online retailer and if you use the link in my show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order okay so I've just finished a 2player game of three ring circus here and you can see that if you play with fewer than four players some of the board is covered up um to make it nice and tight no matter what player count you are playing with and of course the board would not be this populated because again I've already finished the game here and normally all these tents would be in the player's own starting area um rather than already on the board so you can see the main board here is essentially made up of these different um towns you have small towns which are the tiny little ones like this you have the mediumsized ones like this and you have the large ones that look like this and you're going to have uh these variable cards which are basically these requirements that you're trying to put on in these particular cities so for example Indianapolis wants to see an elephant and they want see something

smaller than an elephant as the First Act and something more powerful than the elephant in the Final Act of these particular types which will make sense um very shortly now towards the top of the board you have the different card types so you have endgame scoring cards you have money cards and you also have ticket cards which are your kind of Acts that you are going to put on on your personal playboards that look like this and again these would not be populated at all at the start of the game so you have three different rows of your performers here and they all come with a bunch of different information on those cards so you have um sometimes with the cash cards you have the money in the top left hand corner which is kind of like a multi-use card system so you can actually use cars to pay for other cars like for example I could you know if I wanted to um buy this um you know this 13 card here I could give up cash cards up to an amount of 13 and and then place it on my player board but again we'll talk about that later you have a certain type in the top right hand corner here which can be relevant to some mediumsized cities on the main board which again will make sense very soon and we have the victory points in the top right hand corner here and the different types as well so you got these kind of um the yellowy types or the goldie types like this which are the animals you got these special performers which are these kind of like um little Chevron ones and you also have the I think they're gymnasts which are the square ones you also have this

Podium track on your board here um which is can constantly change as the game goes on but generally you just want to boost it as much as possible to get more tickets and you also have three slots for endgame scoring cards which will be populated again as the game goes on because as you can see that as you play more cards when you're placing them you getting certain bonuses such as more victory points U being able to move cards around um and so on and something that's very relevant in this game is the symbology in terms of what is on display so you can see here that on my player board at the moment I have one two three of the train symbols visible and which means I have three movement of my particular Carriage on the main board and that starts off pretty strong but as you're playing more cards down um it actually gets weaker because again you're covering up those visible symbols so the gameplay of this game is actually pretty straightforward you have two two main options you can do uh the first of which is to play a card on your player board as I explained earlier and you're going to give up amount of cash cards equal to or to pay for the requirements of those cards and the cards come in a bunch of different types so generally the lower ones come with these podiums on them which is going going to boost you up those Podium tracks now they always come with a base level of one but you can see that this particular one here says I'll get an extra Podium for every animal card to the right of it and I have none of those at the moment so that's not being played very efficiently but this one here is going to start with

one Podium plus an extra Podium for every specialist card I have to the right so that's going to be an extra three podiums because there's again three podiums there to the right this one here simply has a Podium um as a passive ability there some of these cards will score points based on the requirements like you can see this um weight lifter here says I'll get three points for every specialist to the right that's going to be six points there essentially know two points for every specialist on the board um three points for every level six specialist on the board which are the jugglers I believe so you can see my strategy has lined up there um and so on now when you play these cards they always go in numerical order from low to high so you can see here that you know goes 3 4 6 6 12 and something that's important is that you only pay the difference between the last card played in that row and the new one that you're playing so you know if I played this 13 here I'd only need to pay a difference of two in order to play this level 15 card and if I was to play a lower card like um say for example I already played the 15 and then played the 13 I would not have to play anything sorry pay anything and it would automatically slip into position and push the other ones along you can also see that a number of these cards come with instant abilities which relates to the second action you can do which is to do a performance and when you do that performance you'll cash them in for the instant bonus like for example this will give me a temporary two podiums give me two victory points um give me a Podium for every animal I have on my board Etc

so let's talk about the second action you can do which is to do a performance so as I mentioned earlier there are three different types of cities or towns on the board these tiny ones here which will simply give you money if you move your wagon there so you know if I moved my cart ended up here not only will I get a a money card for the empty City I'll also get a money card for every exposed money symbol that you see on your board and you'll also get a um a money card for every adjacent um city or small small town to where you've just gone so you know if I went here later if that wasn't there Not only would I get the bonuses for this one along with the ones on my board but I'd also get an extra money card because the next town along has not been um has not been performed in yet and once you do a performance you are going to take one of your tents place it in that town to make sure no body else can go there the mediumsized cities are where you are going to basically acquire either ticket cards or victory points and they are you know corresponding to the different places on the map so if I stopped in Cincinnati I would be performing in Cincinnati here um and you are going to count the the amount of podiums that you have sometimes getting a bonus if you have at least one performer of that type on your player board and then you're going to um basically gauge that against these different categories here so if I had eight podiums I would place my tent on the eight and I can either choose either five victory points or I can choose three tickets and when you take

the tickets you can either draw them from the face down deck there or you can take them from the face up kind of display and they will get replenished after you have taken your cards and the large cities work more in Synergy with your personal um player boards where you are trying to get very particular acts in the right order you can see here this one wants the level 30 13 weightlifter and if I have that I'm going to gain six points but I'm going to get some bonus points if I have other cards either lower than or higher than that in the order on my player board so you can see here if I have a specialist act that's stronger than the 13 I'll get a bonus Five Points and if I have an animal act that's weaker than the 13 I'll get a bonus four in this example me as the yellow player got two of those three categories done for example you know I've got the 13 with a stronger um specialist sorry stronger gymnast higher than it on my player board therefore that would have got me 11 points and if I'm the first person to get these AXS done I'm going to get some bonus points as well you got bonus three here and the second player will get a bonus one and much like those medium cities and the smaller ones once you've gone to a major city you cannot go there again now something that's important to say is that after any performance is done you are going to move this kind of passive um PT baram wagon around the board in a clockwise sorry anticlockwise order or was it clockwise order I forget um and as that goes you're going to Simply go from town to town and when they reach

the major cities there is going to be a scoring um opportunity based on area majority so you know if it ended up in Washington DC and you're going to count all the tents you have if you have the majority you are going to get 10 points second player is going to get six points and the third player is going to get three extra points and the tie breaks are based on the strength of the Cities you know if I have a tie break with another player but I have the strongest place on the major city that I'm going to win that tie and of course the game is going to end as soon as the wagon goes all the way around the board and ends back where it started there are a couple of other little mechanisms here like for example when you complete a column on your player board you are going to get to play one of these endgame scoring cards which of course will give you some bonus points like for example if I have quite a few T put down in the New York area you know if I have four down I'll get 10 points or every different specialist act every different numbered gymnast act and so on and of course when I said the game ends once the um wagon has gone all the way around the board you're going to add up all the points you've got during the game with your endgame scoring cards and you're also going to calculate all the points you've got from the very specific acts that you've put on your player board and the player with the most points will be the winner okay so let's share some thoughts on three ring circus so if you watch my content regularly you're probably aware that I'm a big fan of games that streamline rules and I think this game has done a good job of that

this is essentially a two action um game yes there are different kind of um variants on the towns but generally speaking they're very simple to understand and there's a lot of similarities again you either playing cards to your player board using that multi-use card system which is another thing I do like you know do you want the act itself do you want to use the card as the currency or do you even want to use it as the instant ability which because all these are beneficial and I didn't mention that you do have a 10 um card hand limit which can definitely become um a factor but yeah again you're either performing or you are playing those cards now I do like the fact that this game is kind of built on on building blocks you have to get a foundation of money the money will let you get the podiums the podiums will let you per form in the mediumsized cities which will give you more or fewer tickets and of course you're trying to tailor those tickets towards the big cities which is where the bulk of your points are going to come from there's a bit of a rush aspect there because um you know if you're the first to do it you're going to get a few more points which can be important of course but I do like the fact that sometimes these actual um scoring categories of the major cities can conflict with the actual endgame scoring from the cards themselves um you know because you can actually get quite a few points from your personal Tableau of cards you know for example if I did have this three points for every juggler I have that might be something that kind of um Takes

Me Away from the main board strategy and it's all about trying to maximize those points of course you're keeping other things in the back of your mind such as the endgame scoring as well which can again be significant if you Max all three of them out that's 30 points uh you can have there so you are spinning quite a few plates here I also do enjoy the fact that the area control part of this game is is timed and you can plan for it because again that's um wagon the um the PT baram wagon does go around in a fixed order you know the order which these cities are going to score in which is going to maybe give you a few more tactical decisions to overcome if you know that New York is going to trigger soon um nobody else has put much work in there you can try sneak in there just before the scoring and get a huge output of points or of course you could do some ground work later and maybe slip behind for the first few scorings and know that you'll catch up later because you've really boosted up those particular regions so again you are spinning more plates here now the area control itself is fine there's not really anything particularly interesting about it just have the most tense in the region but I do like the fact that when there is a scoring um the other players get a bit of a chance to catch up because um depending on the player order there can be a few more rounds or turns before the actual scoring is resolved another nice little touch with this game is the fact that these icons you have on display um are quite relevant because you do start with quite a lot of movement in this game which is kind of like this natural

balancing thing because as you start the game there of course most of the border is completely naked and bare so you're going to need more movement points to stop off at all the locations on the way and but as the game goes on the tents are going to start clogging up the board which means that you can actually skip over those locations which will naturally go hand in hand with you covering up more of these train symbols on your personal player board so it's quite nice that that goes hand in hand and it's something you do have to be quite careful with because I have been caught off guard with this game before where I start covering up so many of my train symbols thinking that I've got enough movement there I'll I'll do fine and then I found myself running out of time and not being able to travel across the board fast enough to get the to the locations that I needed even though I invested so much groundw work into getting the exact right performances so despite having some nice things to say about this game I do have some issues with it which I'm going to um cover now um the first of which is that it can feel quite swingy at times um because of how significant these big performances are as they should be and maybe this is a nitpick I'm not quite sure um if somebody pulls off their movement just right you leave yourself you know with not quite enough time in order to put up a big performance and they do um they' pretty much won the game so you need to be making sure that you need to stay kind of neck and neck with your opponents in terms of putting these big performances on um again because you are getting you know 15 18 points each time that you do a fully completed big performance which is going to be a big chunk of your final score I also think

that this game could have benefited with a few more tactical decisions to overcome along the way because I do think that you can again at the start of the game you can look at a glance about what you want to do and not much is going to get in the way way of that so sometimes it feels like your brain is moving faster than the game is and you know exactly what you want to do and it's just about going through the motions to make sure that you're getting that completed and that feels a bit odd because the cars that are available um in terms of the tickets are of course Very luck dependent and there are duplicates and several duplicates of the same um card which is of course very important because there's only three big performances at least in a two play game available here and if there's no lion cards coming out then you're absolutely screwed you know you can't do that performance because nobody well you need to have the lion at least to go to that location and sometimes that can be a complete um you can be completely at the mercy of the card draw here you could be drawing all the cards that you need and your opponent could not therefore you are naturally at a very strong Advantage there so you can plan all you like but you are still going to be subject of the luck of the card draw and despite me liking how this card system works in terms of the podiums boosting and feeding off each other I felt like it's way too easy to get this maxed out um it seems like within a few rounds you can completely just Spam this and you're flying right up the track which makes feel makes it feel like you haven't

really achieved much when you start going to these locations and you can start getting you know a turn of point or just completely start mopping up the cards so um it doesn't really feel like you're earning much in this game and I think a big part of that might be psychological um because you're not physically handling or managing resources or even like money a lot of the time when you're playing these cards you're not paying anything or you're paying very little because again you're only paying the differences or if you're playing lower than the existing ones you're playing nothing at all and when you're going to these locations and you're taking the points rather than the tickets sometimes it feels like you're guessing like seven points or so without doing any work at all so I think this game can feel a little bit underwhelming and it doesn't feel like you're getting like dopamine in terms of earning the points here it just feels like you're just getting points without putting much working now I did feel like the scaling of this game is a little bit off as well I actually think it's best at three players because it still moves at a faster Pace um and it's a bit more difficult to get everything done you know I've played I've only played this at three and two players and at two players I felt it was way too easy to get a ton of things done again I felt like I was getting get my podiums done way too quickly I was just spamming any card I wanted out any time because you always seem to have a flush hand of cards and yeah just felt like I was just completely going through the emotions and just achieving everything I could and getting a ton of points without putting much effort or even like having a slightest bit of brain burn so I feel

like the decisions kind of play themselves and it's a little bit too Loosey Goosey and particularly when it's two players the replayability of this game is a little bit lackluster for me um there are only a certain amount of these major city cards that come out and to be honest even if there are different numbers on them they are in theory the exactly uh the same there are quite a lot of cards in the deck and there are different strategies you can take with these um but still it's it's fairly minor and it doesn't feel like you are playing a different game each time I feel like after you've played this a few times you've pretty much seen everything that is to see as usual with d games the production is abs absolutely fantastic here I love the way this game looks very bright and vibrant the artwork on the cards is fantastic that circus Vibe really does shine through nicely the symbology is excellent um very clear in terms of the rules in the rule book was very good um and yeah I like the way everything looks on the board um it is a smaller package you know if you know um d games they put their even their bigger Euro games in a pretty small box which is nice if you want to minimize your shelf space and all components themselves are nice you know the uh the wooden pieces and the little tents look good on the board um the tile quality is generally decent and again no issues at all with the production okay so let's share some final thoughts on three ring circus now I was in two minds with this one when I first played it um there was

a lot I appreciated about it but it just left me feeling a little bit numb I wanted to give it some more plays to kind of solidify my thoughts to see if I was missing um anything and sadly with more plays I actually liked it less um and less and a lot of the reasons why are things I've said already um I don't find it terribly satisfying it feels everything's a bit too easy and just falls into place um sometimes it could be very frustrating by not being able to draw the cards that you you are pivotal Parts um of the game um and again it just feels like especially at two players you can get way too much done way too easily and it doesn't really feel like you earn much um here I do like that timing exercise of the wagon going around triggering the scoring but I think it's been done better in other games such as calamara by the same designer actually I really like the idea of you know the order in which these locations are going to be triggered in in terms of the scoring um so you can plan for that you know do you ignore one and start working for the next ones knowing that it's going to come up soon um it's just been done better in that aforementioned calala um they get me wrong I think this is a better than average game but I don't think it's going to hold up to repeated plays to keep players interest despite how clean the rule set is that is something I definitely appreciate about this one is that it's definitely not overwrought it's actually pretty straightforward and I do like the way that these cards link with each other and merge with each other um me mechanically I like the way that works and I like the way the

scoring Works um but again I felt like it was too easy to get everything maxed out and um you within a few turns you've pretty much shot right up that Podium track and you can just go around and just Spam the mediumsized cities get all the tickets you want or even go for the um go for the points if those cards aren't going in your favor so this was a little bit of a disappointment for me um I wanted to give it the benefit of the doubt because I love the the look of it um I generally like things that de put out I generally even like games that Fabio Lano puts out there um but this one just missed the mark for me and um again each additional play solidified my thoughts even further so um sadly this one's a bit of a a bit of a missed opportunity um and I can't really recommend three ring circus

Progress saved