Skip to main content
Loading video...

Through the Ages Review

Transcript 28:46

welcome to john gets games today i'm going to talk about through the ages this is an epic abstract engine building civilization game first i'll do a rules overview and then i'll jump into my review alright so how do we play through the ages well to begin with we have one central player board which tracks the status of our civilizations and has a bunch of cards in the card row and then every player is also going to have a personal uh player board here with a bunch of cubes on them actually most people playing this game are going to have a bunch of discs i happen to have cubes because i bought a little upgrade pack from the board game geek store but that's why these are cubes but the colors are all the same and uh so we have blue cubes and we have yellow cubes and then white and red over here and uh this is essentially your civilization right here it's very abstracted there is no map anywhere um this just shows how good your civilization is at doing things and the cubes are multi-purpose they they mean different things based on where they are so to start we have these yellow cubes here and down here they are essentially potential population that you could um create once they're here they are unused workers and then once they're actually up here on top of cards then they are workers that are currently in use they're more like buildings but i'm just gonna say they're workers up here so uh what that means is that this is one philosophy lab these are two agricultural farms and this is one uh one infantry warrior and the cube gets

you a benefit equal to the level of the card so this one warrior cube is giving us one military strength which is why myself and potentially a green player are both at one big military strength at the beginning of the game and this one philosophy lab is getting us one light bulb which is uh science on this science track so let's talk about these tracks these three tracks right here show the current level of your science culture and military in the game and what that means is uh you're going to make this much science and culture at the end of each turn and the military just shows you where you're at so right now you make two sides a term and you track the science on this track up here it goes all the way up here and so this shows you how much stockpiled science you have and then you track culture on the culture track that goes around the board and these is also known as victory points so getting these every turn is good uh so going back over here uh if we look to our farms then this just means each of these cubes is going to produce um one cube that's just part of production whenever you do production every yellow cube will create one blue cube but you'll put that cube on the level that it's at and those cubes equal the value so these both these blue cubes equal one food because they're on this same goes with mines for making ore and those are the only two resources in the game food and ore so let's talk about uh how you play your turn the first thing you do is you can take a political action you have this kind of side hand of cards

that are called military cards they have a dark background they're hidden they're drawn randomly the only real part of randomness in the game and uh and you could do a political action which involves seeding an event or attacking somebody i'm not really going to go into too much detail on these in this overview i'm going to try and go high level and not go into the nitty gritty so this doesn't take half an hour when you seed events you you place them down here you get a victory point equal to the age you played and then you get a reveal event and reveal an event and it happens to everyone this one gives everybody two science so they go up on here yay cool so you get your political action and then you jump into the main part of the game uh which is on your turn you look at your civil actions which are these white ones here and your military actions which are these red ones here these uh start out being equal to your government level so we have four white and two red because we all start out with despotism and uh then you just do your turn you progress all these at the same time and then once you've done all of your actions your turn is over you'll produce and then it's the next person's turn there's a there's a big blocky turns and uh most of the things you want to do will cost on action so let's talk about the main thing that you do which is drafting cards from this card row here and this is actually the thing that um that breaks what i just said this is what could cost multiple actions so you see this disc down the bottom is the number of actions that takes to draft those cards so these all cost one these right here cost two civil actions and these right here these cost three civil actions to draft bring them into your hand and your hand

limit is dictated by the number of civil actions you have so you have a hand limit of four at the beginning of the game um so you know i could just uh draft a card you know this would cost me one civil action bring in my hand and usually i just track it by pushing off to the side now it's in my hand uh the next thing that you really potentially want to do is play cards from your hand uh so every car that has a blue number on it with the light bulb is called a technology so you can see that governments are technology these are special technologies and uh this theater is a technology there any card that has this is that and it costs a civil action boink down there to play these and you put them out in the column of the associated top right text so this is a mine this is a mine that's now an upgrade but that costs five science to do so let's just pretend if i had been at five science i would go down to that so it's gonna take a few turns to generate that much science in order to build iron so that's one thing you can do for a civil action uh another thing you could do for a civil action is to place these yellow guys down into a new building so uh when i do that it costs whatever the building says it costs so i could build a new bronze mine for two ore or a new iron mine for five ore i could build a philosophy lab over here for three more let's pretend i do that now we'd go over here actually um i can't i let's pretend i had one more or there we go now i have three or these are each value one i place this here cost three or and these all go back to the uh the ore bank over here so that's one way you can build uh you

can get these unused workers out they just cost or and the moment you do that you get the benefits so this increases our science by one now we're going to make two sides a turn which is very good uh next thing i want to talk about is upgrading uh you know we put this upgrade uh technology down but if we want these yellow bronze mines to become iron mines which are way more efficient we're gonna have to spend a civil action and then the difference in ore to upgrade so in this case five minus two is three so again it would have cost three or they would have had to be over here already you can spend three or back to the the ore bank and now you could move one of these guys up and at the end of your turn since every yellow cube nets you a blue cube the blue cube that this guy nets is going to be worth two ore so you're getting much more efficient so uh those are some of the main things that you can do with the civil actions you use military actions to increase your oh actually jumping over real quick uh one also very significant civil action is to create new people so we take them from our population bank down here we bring them up here for that one civil action and we pay food equal to little food bank costs so that would cost us two food those would come down here and now i have another person that i can use to deploy and now jumping into military military actions are more focused on the military cards themselves so um if you want to build another warrior then you would put that over here you would spend the two ore and that would cost you a military action in order to do but now you go up one military strength because each one of these cubes is one military

value and you know there are other uh texts out there like this is knights it's calvary instead of infantry so you put this to the side and you know if you'd make that instead and that one cube would be worth two military cool so those are kind that's kind of like a brief overview of many of the options that you can do with your civil actions on your turn and you can just mix and match and uh and oftentimes do really cool things to chain up and just build up your engine at the end of your turn you're going to discard cards equal to the number of players or based off this rubric if it was a two-player game then all three of these cards would go away and then these cards would all slide down and then we would get new cards from this stack right here very briefly i just want to mention that there are a couple different types of cards we have in here we have leaders you can only have one of them uh at a time and they do various special bonuses we have wonders which you take and immediately put into play but unbuilt and then it costs or in different stages to build this so three different stages the first one two ore then four more than two ore and then the wonder gets you benefits and then also governments is there a technology you can spend a small number to go into a revolution and essentially skip the rest of your turn or you can spend a larger number of technology to place the government down and this is one of the ways that you can get more uh civil action cubes and more military action cubes so getting new governments is very important

uh so we keep playing around oh and then once you do all these things then we do production and just uh one more time when you do production you take one cube per yellow um one blue cube per yellow cube and to put them up here so i have two yellow cubes that gets me two blue cubes each of these are worth two foods so i just made two food uh you looked down at your consumption if for instance i had made this guy then we see we now have one consumption which means your population just is so big that they eat one uh every single turn and then you go over here you do your production of ore i have one bronze and one iron that means i just made three ore because this one is value two and this one's value one and if you're being really inefficient with your uh with your turn you could see if all these blue cubes were out in various different places this says two corruption you would actually pay a penalty back to your bank if you're just not being efficient enough if you have these blues are gone then you would actually have to pay this right back and you would have only netted one or on that turn so you really want to make sure to keep using your blue cubes you don't want them just to get stuck in different places making goods making resources is really important but being efficient and not making too much is also very important in this game uh and uh we keep doing our turns um round and round and round and uh you keep drawing from the stack once you've drawn this entire age one stack and they've all come out on the row every single card is going to come out then you go to the box and you get out h2 you put this here and then the h2 cards come out and they are more

powerful we have you know a theater here now which is just the upgraded version of drama here and you see the technology gets more the ore gets very very expensive but the benefits get better and uh in this game you go through the three different ages um oops that shouldn't be there but lastly you have h3 and then once you go through all of h3 uh then you have played the complete game and you see who has the the most fixture points at the end i do want to spend just a minute to go over aggressions a little bit more so you have some idea because i'm going to be discussing this quite a bit in the the review part of the game and just to show you how these work so this is part of that political action i talked about in the very first round before you do the bulk of your turn and these essentially let you attack other players they cost military actions to do so you see this one has a little red disk there so that would cost a red action uh to do it and then you you just uh say to an opponent so i could say to my green opponent if we look over here right now my green opponent is at military value one i am a military value three i could just say green i am attacking you with a value of three at this point green now has the opportunity to try to defend themselves and there are a couple different ways they can do that the first thing is some of these cards um that come from this military stack are can be defense cards so military could just say i defend it three reveal defense cards that's two plus one equals three and ties go to the

defender and then the aggression would be nullified but if green did not have one of these then uh the only other options green could have would be to sacrifice units that they might already have in order to to make the score bigger so if um green if we pretend you know greenland has one military value so green would just have the one warrior i know this is the red uh board but forgive me uh then you he's getting that one military value but you can also destroy sacrifice one of your um your units to get its uh its value again so he could sacrifice his one warrior to get um one more uh military value so one plus one is two but that wouldn't be strong enough in this instance to defend um uh three level aggression so in that case orange myself would win and then you in this case uh destroy a rival's urban building and you get ore equal to half the buildings cost so urban buildings are these gray ones right here so you can really get in there and break apart opponents pieces of their engine uh through these various aggressions there's lots of different types of aggressions there are also war cards which are much bigger uh aggressions that take an entire round to go through and they can they can actually backfire on the person who uh sends the who starts the war but the war uh can do as much as you know destroy many different buildings or kill many different um yellow cubes from an opponent's player board so these aggressions and wars are have a very real impact on how the game

is played because the uh because they can destroy engine they don't necessarily just target victory points in fact for the most part very few of them do target victory points most of them destroy buildings or destroy units so they can be very destructive all right so with that i'm going to jump over and start discussing my review of this game for my review through the ages like normal i'm going to start off with the things i really enjoy about the game then i'm going to cover some potential issues i have and lastly go through some things i dislike about the game now i've played this game 17 times about half of those have been online and half of them have been in person in the cardboard and one of the things that i love about this game that just comes out every single time i play is how incredibly satisfying each individual turn can be in this game some of the most satisfying turns i've ever taken in any board game ever have been in through the ages so that's a pretty big thumbs up when it comes to that i really really enjoy the options that you have on your turns now sometimes you have a stinker of a turn or a turn that's kind of just it's obvious i mean especially early game when you only have four actions the turns can be a little bit quicker and a little bit less interesting but you know once you start getting five six seven actions or even when you have four actions you can have some very interesting decisions to make you know when you have when you're drafting these cards you know these cost one civil action these cost two these cost three you know if there's a tech that comes out that you that you think is just close to mandatory for yourself like iron oftentimes people will will

consider spending three civil actions to grab you you get to think about the the cost analysis the cost benefit analysis for taking that you know what's the relative benefit that it's gonna get you you're gonna potentially sacrifice a whole turn if you're spending three out of your four actions to take that card and you might even corrupt you know you might with your last action you might not be able to spend enough of these cubes to get them down here to dodge that but that still might be worth it to you to get that card because you think it's so necessary uh i found that in a four player game at least online the games usually go about 19 turns and so you know losing one turn or not losing but you know having sort of a a null engine building turn to get a building block that you desperately need is not the end of the world however these things do add up uh you know the way that the culture and the science work out if you get this one little culture on the third turn of the game that ends up going 19 turns long well that one point is that one culture point is actually going to be worth about 16 points to you and i've many times seen the game won or lost by less than that it's often times you win by more than 16 points but that's a very real number of culture that that has a very big impact on whether you win or lose the game so it's very very interesting options that you have you know do you do you spend your actions to increase your population to spend these cubes so that you don't corrupt and then if you do that well then that you know that might say well you can't get this action you can't get that action you really you really get to well there's so many things to think about

and it's really satisfying to think about i find usually uh the next thing that i really like about this game is the balance between greed and military and by that i mean greed being if you go heavy engine and light military then you are gonna be weak you're gonna be uh susceptible to attacks but you're gonna be making more science and more culture uh science being way more important early and mid-game uh versus if uh you go heavy military well your engine's gonna be pretty weak you're not gonna be making that much resources or science or culture but you might be scary you might have lots of military and people are going to be worried about what you could do to them and oftentimes you don't even have to attack them in order to penalize somebody for going greedy if some that person goes greedy and i go military they might slow down their or stop their greed entirely and just get some military on the board because they're really scared of being dismantled by a precise aggression or two that you might be able to get in there and really slow their stuff down so it's really cool how you if you go military you don't necessarily have to attack people just the threat of your military is going to affect how other people play potentially some people don't and oftentimes those people get steamrolled at some point in the game if you know there's it's really important to make sure you are not way behind on military because it really can destroy your engine so i really like the balance between you know usually you're going to be somewhere between heavy greed and heavy uh military and it's just really cool to see

how the the game balances out you know if that person over there maybe they're not going crazy greedy but they're just a little bit better engine than you and you're looking at the cards out in front of you and you say i can't catch up to them in the engine department in the short to medium run right now i am going to shift a little bit a little bit more military and that little shift towards military will make them sweat a little bit more and then shift a little bit away potentially and make it so it just there's all these subtle little shifts in the game as you're building your civilizations that everyone is actively paying attention to because you have to pay attention to it otherwise things can just get out of control relatively quickly so now i'm going to shift into some potential issues that uh can come up with this game the first thing is that uh long-term strategy is awesome in this game and it's also potentially a big deterrent to playing with newer players or newer players playing with you you know i really like that you're going to go through this whole deck and this whole deck and this whole deck you're going to see every single one of these cards you just don't know what order they're going to come out in so if once you've played this game several times you are you know that the operas are going to come out and you know that shakespeare is really great with operas or you know various combos that you could work towards and if it's your first time playing you're not going to know any of that i've played many games where i lap in points i double the score of the other people i'm teaching because i've played it you know 10 12 times at that point it's their first time and they think they're doing great and then the pieces to my engine fall into

place and suddenly i'm making three times as much culture as them and i immediately go way past them so that can definitely be a potential issue for newer players in this game playing with old play people who've played many times already there's definitely a huge skill gap if you've played or not played which is potentially a good thing and potentially a bad thing uh the next potential issue with this game is the play time uh i found realistically this game plays about an hour to an hour and a half per person and that's that's a long game you know a four-player play game of this if you just sit down and play it will likely take you six hours uh at least in my experience i mean some people you look on board game geek i'm sure people say no i've played a game in three hours but from my experience that's going to be a very long game that's going to be a major commitment for your day even a two-player game can take take a couple hours like i think two hours would be the quickest i could see myself playing a two-player game in this even with someone who really knows what they're doing because even though you really know how to play the game you the more you know the more you know so sometimes someone who's new to the game takes a quicker turn than someone really knows the game because they don't know all the ramifications of the actions that they're about to take so that's definitely something to keep in mind is that you're you're sitting down to a big game and part of the reason that's potentially not an issue is if you play online uh then you know sure you might have downtime of an entire day between turns but you go about your life and you you have a game take a whole

month but that's fine because you're not sitting down committed to it in fact that's potentially really fun because you can take an entire day just reveling in that delicious turn that i was telling you about earlier and not really worrying about people around the table you know giving you really angry looks because you're just taking too damn long with your turn so the last part of my uh the potential issues i have with this game are just how downtime and analysis paralysis definitely feed into that long play time and that is that you know certain players will just just take too long on their turns you know i i like to revel in my turns but once the the turn clock is going on seven eight minutes you you just really want that person to take their turn because you know even if everyone takes a four-minute turn if you're in a four-person game well you know it's 12 minutes between turns and there's lots to think about and strategize and talk about with the opponents who are not actively in the turn but analysis paralysis and downtime could definitely be potential issues with this game all right and for the third part of my review the things i dislike about the game realistically i'm just gonna cover one thing uh but it's a pretty big thing in my opinion and that is that i've found in every game i play this now especially with experience players not so much with new players is that late game high over militarization is a dominant strategy and i don't necessarily mean that that person wins but i do mean that the person or persons who go to high dominant on military are going to obliterate other people

who literally can't catch up and and i played this many i play this 17 times and i so i could say well this people were not good enough but in the late game military jumps of 20 to 25 points are common i found at least when i'm playing with really good players and usually when that happens other players cannot catch up to that humongous single term burst and then the the person who has the crazy high military well they wouldn't have done that if they didn't have you know wars and or really bad aggressions in their hand already and then they start to rain these down on the people who literally have no way of getting up to that military level you know there just simply aren't enough techs or they're just not getting lucky enough to pull the correct tactics cards i didn't describe tactics cards in the the uh the rules overview but they're just they're military bonuses for having certain sets of um military and if you just don't have the correct ones and there is no military out here you could just find this awesome engine that you spent four hours building just get eviscerated by a war you know these wars you know some of them like this one is just culture so it's just gonna take you know 40 victory points from you or something like that but other ones like holy war and war over territory like these destroy your buildings these take your yellow cubes and they go away they just get destroyed you lose your resources it's not that you just you lose some resources or some buildings you get crushed into the stone age

and and there's nothing you can do about it oftentimes sometimes you can but the problem is if you're the weakest and even if you're only weakest by a couple you're you essentially always if you're not going heavy military you want to be the second to most weakest because the most weakest person is going to get attacked and if they defend if they sacrifice to put your units to try and defend then that makes them even weaker on subsequent turns so then there's this this effect of you are you're too weak you have no way of getting anywhere near prepared after a humongous burst turn you get hit hard your engine gets destroyed and now you're even less able to defend yourself and you'll find you're doing great you're doing great you know all of you guys are at you know within five military of each other and it might be near the beginning or middle of the third age and then somebody has this 20-point turn and on the next turn they wore you or do a crazy aggression now suddenly instead of being five away you're 25 away for various reasons you know you lose your engine and whatnot now you drop down by five more and now the person to your right is now ten points above you instead of five and then they attack you and then you go down and you go down and by the time it gets back to your next turn you are out of the game you know this game you might been playing for four hours at this point or if you're playing online you've been playing this game for three weeks and you're really invested and you've been trying you you know that it's a possibility you've i've played this game and i see it

coming and i always want to make sure i'm not the person who gets stomped on in fact you want to be the person who over militarizes but it seems like usually only one or two people get that option of really going huge on that now you might say that the person who's crazy on military should not attack the weakest person they should attack the the person they think is most likely to win but to that i say with these wars they absolutely should attack the weakest person because the way wars work is you get benefits equal to the difference in military strength so oftentimes it benefits the aggressor to attack the weakest person not their biggest threat to winning the game not the person who they think is going to has the better engine necessarily but the person who is least able to defend themselves and just reap humongous benefits from that and that person is essentially out of the game i mean the rules accept this there's actually a part of the rules that talk about surrendering and bowing out of the game entirely so obviously this is not something the designer did not know about but i dislike it i love the engine building in this game i love the epic scope and the long play times and i hate the way it seems like every single game ends these days and again it didn't used to happen but it seems like now that i play with my experienced players almost every game ends with this crazy militarization maybe one person is able to match one or two people aren't and they just they lose they get obliterated and then they have no chance to win and so and again like that person who went crazy military does not necessarily always win

but they oftentimes decide who doesn't win and that is that's a very real problem that i have with this game and honestly it's part of the reason i've slowed down playing this game almost to a standstill i still i still love this game i have a very nostalgic love for this game and i will still play this game i'll still own this game but man i really wish it didn't have that and i don't i also don't want to play without aggressions because like i said in the parts i love about this game i love that tension between building your engine and going military and this the subtle like the shifts and the way you want to do that the problem is how incredibly volatile military is late game it's the spiking that happens it's the way you can go from you know 10 to 10 to like 25 or whatever in just one turn and just how you know this long-term planning just at a certain point you're not able to deal with it and so so yeah uh in conclusion i love this game in conclusion i recommend this game but really big asterisk because wow is military just it just it could suck a lot of fun out of the end of the game and when it's a long game like that you want the end to be satisfying even if you lose and it is not satisfying to get bombed back into the stone age all right well i hope you've enjoyed my review of through the ages it's been one of the more challenging ones i've had to do and uh let me know if you have any comments and i'll see you guys next time

Progress saved