Skip to main content
Loading video...

Arkham Horror RPG: The Hungering Abyss - Starter Set review

Transcript 27:11

hey everybody welcome back to the dungeon dive Daniel here I hope you're doing well and if you're not I hope you are soon okay in the beginning we had the call of cthulu RPG from chaosium and Sandy Peterson the call of cthulu RPG made the successful transition to a board game with the first edition of Arkham Horror a board game for monster hunters from Richard lonus Lynn Willis and Charlie crank then chaosium passed the torch onto Fantasy Flight games and we have Arkham Horror second edition board game from Richard lonus and Kevin Wilson and then after many great games the torch is being passed to Edge Studios and now we are back to an RPG with the new Arkham Horror roleplaying Game and this is the new starter set the hungering abyss and this was provided to the dungeon dive as a review copy so almost all of the games that we cover here on the dungeon dive are from the solo perspective or at least the co-op perspective that's just the way that I play almost all of my games and so I know people will be coming to this review looking to see if the Arkham Horror roleplaying Game is good for The Soloist and I can't beat around the bush I do not recommend this game for solo play If you're looking for a solo horror

RPG there are simply better options out there and we will actually be looking at a ton of those very very soon probably in the next couple of weeks with my guide to solo analog horror and that will be coming out and we'll be looking at about 10 or 12 different games for solo horror games so Arkham Horror the role playing game from Edge Studios is really a boxed mystery game with player focused puzzles focusing on an investigation with definitive answers I've spent the last five or so days with the game contemplating the ability to play solo wondering if there was a way and wondering if it was worth the effort not in terms of it being a bad game and wanting to and not wanting to put in in the effort but just you know if I want something solo there are better games to turn to now I'm sure that somebody will come up with something to play this game solo people always do and of course it's doable because all games can be played solo as long as you just play them by yourself but for me there are simply better Alternatives and hey you know what that's totally okay not all games need to be Solo or Co-op so let's approach this for what it is I was supposed to play a session last weekend but the couple that we were going to play with uh they ended up with a family emergency and so we couldn't play so this look is based on my preliminary thoughts of the system and the boxed

Starter Set we'll take a look at everything you get I'll talk about the system and then kind of talk about my thoughts on the system and my final thoughts of reading through the scenario reading through the hungering abyss the module that comes with the starter set let's take take a look at the back of the box here so Arkham hor are the role playing game hungering Abyss A Chorus of howls a ravenous hunger and the endless Abyss death has come to the cobbled streets of Arkham Massachusetts each day more missing posters are added to the growing pile and another cluster of graves are left defiled and robbed the police seem baffled or perhaps complacent and the fate of the city rests in the hands of those who would risk themselves to uncover the truth of the hungering Abyss in this beginner friendly learn as you play Starter Set players take on the roles of talented and bold investigators caught up in the mystery behind the lurking dread that has fallen over the city of Arkham in the height of the 1920s the investigators must do what they can to stop whatever Force is is feasting on the fear of the city and they must do it before the true horror can be summoned from the world beyond their own so as far as starter sets go I think this is a little bit of a mixed bag however it does have me excited for the full version when that is released but I am a little apprehensive but let's start with

the positives and one of the positives is all of the cool stuff you get in this game for the price I think it's retailing for 35 so even if you got a group of people together to play one GM and four three to four friends and you all chipped in Eights or something you could have a few sessions of really fun time playing this game and you would never need to buy anything else again you could think of it as a closed box game but in this uh slim box you will get a few characters starter characters we will get William yorck Daisy Walker Rita young Carolyn Fern and Joe diamond and as I'm sure you saw with Rita young here some of the characters do come with some tangible evidence that you will need to look at and read and investigate so there are some some things in here for the players to interact with some codes and things that need to be solved by looking at this Cipher and then determining what this says we will have some other piece pieces of evidence like this medical report or perhaps uh these cards here that are little uh pieces of paper from the Arkham Police Department from a tickets that a certain officer has written so there are things for the players to interact with there are pieces of evidence there are pamphlets and and um props for the GM to pass out to the players we also get our rule book SL scenario book and this is a learn as

you play I'm not huge into that idea especially with an RPG and I think this leads me to one of my negatives is the rules are scattered about through the scenarios through the different acts throughout the different scenes and so it makes it very difficult to find where a rule is if you need to go back and remind yourself I am not a fan of this type of thing in an RPG at all there's no index there's not even really a table of contents and so it does uh mean that if you're looking for one certain rule you will have to stop and really uh turn through every single page until you find the thing that you're looking for so it's kind of a while it's a hard while they tried to make it easier to learn I think it kind of backfired and it actually made it a little more difficult to learn you also get a GM screen that has a couple handy tables uh basically a table for your trauma and a table for your injury I do think there is one error here though on the trauma table on how you're supposed to add this says that you're supposed to roll a D6 and add one for each existing injury but that's not right that's for the injury table this should be that you're supposed to add one for each one you roll on the horror Dice and we'll talk a little bit more in detail about that but I did want to point that out there is just that little error there but you'll get a list of all of your actions your simple actions and your complex actions so this is just a nice

way just a nice little cheat sheet you will also get some large cards for your NPCs and your enemies so our allly here we have Lita chantler we have Agnes Baker and then we have some of our enemies here we have the um umor tentacles so we have a few of those that you can encounter we have uh naroth the charal Lord we have the ghoul priest we have Bob the ghoul Billy Cooper the cultist we have the ghoulish cultist we have a few of those the ravenous ghoul couple of those and we also have another co uh cultist and Peter Warren you will also get some recognizable tokens to keep track of your physical injuries and your mental injuries there we'll get two stacks of dice and so we have these gray Dice and those are used for the player dice for your pools for your pool of dice we'll talk about the system in just a moment we get some green Dice and these are for horor dice and when you take horor damage you will substitute you will add horror dice to your dice pull when you roll and if you roll ones on those and that's when you start taking mental trauma we will also get a small deck of cards of items and spells and these are things that the that the players can find such as ward of protection blinding light an antique lamp an improvised blunt weapon a Peter Warren's dagger a flamethrower a Bowie

knife a stick of dynamite a Molotov cocktail cultist robes a kerosene lamp and a pulsing amulet so we'll get some physical uh components there to keep track of some items we have a few other little tokens that you can keep track of ammunition and just things that you might need to keep track of on your character and also uh damage for the enemies there and uh this game also does have player focused puzzles and those are in the shape here of these sliding puzzles now uh longtime viewers of the dungeon dive will know that I am not a fan of player focused puzzles when it comes to um RPG and I have a long video about why I can post a link to that maybe above here but uh that's because I like my characters to be the ones solving puzzles not my players and I don't think that my my intelligence as a human sitting at the table should not be tested because I'm not the one on the adventure uh Rita young is the one on the adventure so it is her intelligence that should be tested and so yeah just not a huge fan of player focused puzzles but this game does come with two and they are both sliding puzzles very similar to the kind of sliding puzzles that you might see in in mansions of Madness second edition and as a matter of fact in a very kind of weird way this game reminds me of playing a scenario of mansions of Madness second edition but substitute

the app for a human GM it's kind of funny how that circle is complete now uh Mom 2 mom 2E we had the app was a substitute for the game master and now we're back to the other side there and then you will also get some tokens for your your your characters there so here we have all of our tokens for our different Heroes we will have some tokens for some of our monsters and some tokens for some of our cultists and maybe some tokens for some various NPCs we have these generic tokens here and those are recognizable from Mansions of Madness second edition same type of tokens there and ALS o some more tokens for our monsters and so these are all used on the map boards because when you go into combat and we go into more structured turns the game does kind of feel like a board game and so you will have three double-sided Maps so here we have the map of the graveyard for the scenario when you are in the grave graveyard we have a sa Mary's Hospital there we have I believe this one here is Joe Diamond's house let's see see here uh yeah Joe Diamond's house so hey we finally get to see where Joe Diamond lives how cool is that uh so his house looks pretty nice I didn't imagine him having such a nice house uh here we have uh Peter Warren's house there and then uh this map is really cool I I like this map quite a bit we have this um this Arkham woods so when you're outdoors and

then we have this really cool kind of ritual chamber here the ritual site and man that that's a really cool that's a really cool battle map I could see actually just using this to play some games of forbidden Psalm or something on there but yeah so that's kind of all of the physical component so you get quite a bit you get a lot of stuff in this slim box for $35 another positive I think is the core mechanism the D6 dice pool system they call it the DPS system and that is the dynamic pool system where your pool of dice are spent to do actions and your dice also represent your health it's a cool system so if we take a look at one of our character sheets here on the back we'll have our story so far very similar to what is going on with the Arkham files games and then it'll have a little preview of some of the evidence that that investigator is bringing to the party and on the inside of our character sheets here we will have all of our skills agility Athletics wits presence intuition knowledge resolve melee ranged and lore and there are two different types of actions you can take simple actions and complex actions and those are all all outlined on this quick reference side so simple actions are actions that are hard to fail they usually cost only one die to perform and so when a character is in tiptop shape they will have six dice in their dice pool 6 D6 and you can put them on your character sheet like that as they take wounds they will have to uh cover up one of your dice pool spots with a with a

wound token and that limits how many dice get added back to their dice pool on a new turn you also might have to put in some of these mental injuries these mental uh um afflictions here you'll Place one of those on on your character sheet when you do that and you want to spend a couple dice to do something you will also have to add a horror die to your dice pool and if that horror die rolls a one then you have to roll up on one of your trauma tables and so that's how you take trauma that's how you take mental trauma now at the beginning of your turn you have the opportunity to completely heal yourself you can take off all of your injuries and if you completely heal yourself you start with your full pull of dice but you take an injury and as you take more injuries you will have to add more to your result on this 1d6 table here and if you ever roll an 11 or higher that's when your character dies and injuries can be healed by taking prolonged rests in unstructured turns so we have two different types of turns we have unstructured Ed and structured unstructured turns are usually social interactions or investigating you're looking around a house for a hidden object you're conversing with NPCs trying to figure things out and when you do that you are it's more of a relaxed style of play when you go to the structure turns that's usually when you are on one of these battle maps and

that's when the game becomes more like a a uh a board game where you are taking turns doing actions and reactions and so if you were in an unstructured turn and maybe you wanted to read one of these books in order to figure out something about the cthulu methos something about the cthulu cycle deities uh Rita Young's not very good at that she has a lore of six so I might want to spend three dice to try to get a six or higher and no okay so no six or higher so those three dice would be spent and then I could try that again on my next turn to try to get a six or higher no we also have a thing called uh insight and insight is a currency that investigators that players can spend to add Dice and to mitigate some of the bad luck in an unstructured turn when you have used up all of your dice the other players can use up their Dice and then you will start a new round and you will get all of your dice back and that's kind of how a structured turn works as well but there are more complex actions to take in in a structured turn such as aiding another investigator disengaging from melee combat healing your horror damage healing wounds uh reloading under pressure and doing melee attacks or ranged attacks and attacks work the exact same way for a melee attack here Rita young is pretty good at melee so she has a four or higher so if I wanted to attack uh Peter Warren here I could

say okay I'm going to span two dice and make an melee attack of a four or higher I hit I would do damage based on the equipment that I had and then Peter Warren his uh dice pull would also get filled up with uh with injuries dice pools the dice remaining in your pools is always public knowledge even on the MPCs even on the enemies so the players always know where all of the combatants stand from one moment to the next you know longtime viewers of the dungeon dive will know that I am a huge huge fan of D6 dice pool system it's just so easy to conceptualize if I need to roll a fiber higher that was that is harder to do on one D6 than it is on three you just have more chances and it's easy to see and because the players can constantly see how many dice other players have how many dice the monsters have how many dice the NPCs have is really easy to keep in mind to keep track of all of the action on the table so each of the characters will also have some knacks and such Rita young is a try a track star so the first time that she spends a die to move each turn she can move an additional 10 feet so she's better at movement because she's fast she's also a skilled fighter when you perform a complex action to attack an Engaged Target and you score three or more successes that Target cannot use a reaction to block the attack so characters not only can you spin actions to do things on your turn but you can also spend dice to react to

things when it is another player's turn or when it is a monster's turn or a cultist turn or an NPC's turn and so your your dice in your dice pool really can be spent at just about any time to do actions or reactions overall I think the system is pretty cool the equipment is uh pretty simple here such as Rita's baseball bat engaged so she has to be engaged to use it meaning uh in melee combat and it's two damage and it does two hands but if you roll a one on an attack your D your baseball bat might be damaged and that's when you might take one of these damage tokens and put that on your character sheet there and if both are ever filled up then your bat breaks and you might have to find another improvised weapon but each of the characters will have different knacks and different things uh some characters will have spells and spells you have to do lore tests in order to cast your spells so here we have William yoro is an encore performance and a preparation and Poise he comes with his Gravedigger shovel a heavy leather jacket he can punch and kick he has a kous SE a lantern and some other equipment so one thing you don't get in this Starter Set is any kind of rules for character creation this Starter Set is completely 100% focused on these pre-generated characters and for me that's a huge bummer I frame almost all of my RPG thoughts around character creation for me it's the best way for the players to learn the game it's the best way for me to learn a game and it's the best way for me to teach a game as you step through each of the character

sheet all of the different sections and you can teach each section as you get to it that makes a lot of sense to me I know there are a few starter sets that completely forego character creation in lie of presenting preens and I do think this is a bad way to present the game because it forces a lot of knowledge on the player all at once uh more recently we also had The Walking Dead uh starter set that came that that that approached the game like that I think that also limits how useful the starter set is with um after your initial plays because you can't really do anything else with it I think if we take a look at a better examples in the latest call of cthulu RPG the latest starter set and the DND essential set is great because it does both of those do focus on character creation and they allow you to play really a full game just kind of a a a reducted version a reductive version a stripped down version of that game this starter set feels more like it's focused only on the things that come in this game and I don't or in this box and I don't think you'll be able to use a lot of this stuff later on down the road but I am not exactly sure but when it comes to character creation I'm curious about how that's going to happen I have a a feeling that you will just be able to assign a certain spread of numbers to your skills and then there will probably be a

list of knacks that you can choose and then maybe you'll get to spend some points or something on equipment uh we do have dollars here but it doesn't really talk about spending money so I'm not sure what the dollars do we have things like a fedora but I don't know what that does I don't know if these knacks are just created for these characters I'm not really sure uh having all of the characters have six D6 in their dice pool means all characters have the same amount of Health so I'm not sure how that's going to go another thing that you might notice is lacking is any kind of experience and so I'm not sure how the full game is going to handle character progression this Starter Set handles character progression by having the characters level up at certain key moments during the scenario and when they do level up they can choose one of these options so leveling up happens twice during the adventure the game master will indicate when you gain a level it doesn't matter what you do it's completely really completely out of the player's hands uh the first time you get to choose one skill and improve it and improving a skill means you drop down a die so if you improved your knowledge it would be a five plus if you in if you improved uh Joe Diamond's agility it would become a four plus uh the second time you may improve two skills but they can't go down uh to three or or higher is is the best they can get or you can gain a new ability listed below and I have a feeling that I guess abilities are

knacks I'm not sure there's nothing here on the character sheet about an ability so I'm not sure if those two uh terms are interchangeable or not so I am really curious about how the full game will handle not just character creation but also character progression and I think both of those two things are really key for me personally to get into a game from the GM side of things you really won't get any kind of tools or tables or anything for any kind of random elements this really is kind of a linear Adventure from the beginning to the middle and the end towards the middle the players will have the option to explore a few different areas and you do have this one table here so they can explore St Mary's Hospital the police station the graveyard uh Professor Peter Warren's house Joe Diamond's house velma's Diner Ye Old magic shop or the river River dos but there are no random charts for any kind of encounters or anything like that so you are just kind of reading through this and you are doing the thing that the scenario book tells you to do when the players encounter it I am hoping that the full game does introduce some more random elements for the GM to roll up random Mysteries random scenarios Random Encounters and that kind of thing I always like a lot of random elements when I am playing a a GM roll in a traditional RPG or if I'm

going to be playing solo and if this game is going to be soloable at all once the full game comes out it will need those kind of random elements because coming up with a a a mystery on the Fly is something that will be very important yeah so overall my thoughts on this Starter Set are a little mix it's a mixed bag I can see this working really well for some especially if you just want to buy the game go in together with a few friends each of you put in about 10 bucks and you can have a lot of fun with just this close box game and even though there are some things I don't like about it I am still very curious and somewhat excited about checking out the full game when it is available um from a solo perspective I think there's a real opportunity here for Edge Studios to do something interesting and different in this kind of investiga of RPG space I was hoping that they were going to more fully embraced the board game Lineage of Arkham Harbor and what separates Arkham Harbor the the Arkham files games from its great great grandparent with the Call of cthulu RPG is that they were Co-op and they were soloable and when I first heard that they were making an Arkham Horror role-playing game I I thought wow maybe they will make this a co-op RPG how awesome would that be but they didn't they chose to go in a different direction person I would have chosen to embrace that Co-op nature of the Arkham

Horror name and make this a co-op RPG but I'm super interested to see how the full character creation and progression is handled I'm interested in the tools that they will present the GM with for coming up with Mysteries and things for the players to do I hope they don't rely too much on these really tightly scripted scenarios and instead come up with a set of interesting tools for the GM to use to fac facilitate a kind of more open sandbox RPG set in the strange and wonderful city of Arkham Massachusetts so all right guys well I hope you enjoyed this brief look at this Brief Review my my preliminary thoughts on the Arkham Horror roleplaying Game uh let me know what you think and we will talk to you later bye-bye

Progress saved