Skip to main content
Loading video...

This War of Mine Board Game Review

Transcript 16:00

publisher awaken realms is known for their story rich games is this war of mine one of those games this is their view for the board game this war of mine the good and bad about it by the end of this video you will know if this game is for you we have six burning questions that we will answer but before we do that janice what is this game all about misery it's about misery you start out bad and then everything starts getting worse and worse and worse until you lose yeah pretty much so so that's uh this war mine but what happens before you lose oh yeah right you are just citizens ordinary people caught in the middle of a civil war and you're trying to survive to do that you go outside of your comfort zone of your home to scavenge and get stuff and risk everything you have to get a bit more to try to improve your living conditions and stay alive until the war ends so at the beginning game you get some survivors and each of those survivors are very unique some might need cigarettes some need books some feel very bad when somebody else is hungry if we would be there then we would need board games or else we're dead so by scavenging and going out you're trying to get all these things to survive the biggest problem is that while you are scavenging bad things will happen you will find people that aren't too friendly maybe somebody will go and try to rob your place this game is all about this experience of living on the edge and trying to survive and since the place you're staying is also already like a huge pile of rubble and things

you can try to search for something they can use there as well build different items like bed or radio that will help you survive feel better improve your morale and do other stuff and this is a cooperative game which means all of you play together but all of you also control all of the characters you will never know what will happen outside it's just always different because you have this huge storybook the book of scripts with a lot of texts that will give you options stories and everything that will improve your gaming experience now let's get to the review part and the first question is who would you buy this for

here we go scavengers and story lovers i think when you talk about this game you just automatically have to mention two things one is the scavenging system because i think that's the most fun you have can have in this game very unique as i said you risk with everything you have your morale your health your items to get stuff to just barely survive i think the best scavenging system i have played on board games as well as the story the story is very very very good but also dark and i think you're gonna talk a lot more about it but just be prepared that you will have some tough decisions to be uh making in this game well mine's very specific and niche mine's solo gamers who are not squeamish well first of all i think this is pretty much so in a solo game you just decide what you do and you execute there are no extra rules if you're playing two four six or 1 it doesn't matter why squeamish this is a very dark game and when i say dark i mean dark in a real life sense of things there are people struggling with depression misery hunger and the decisions sometimes you have to make are really tough if you play games to escape the reality of the world this might not be for you but if you're okay with exploring these themes then this might be a perfect game for you for example eating a dog would you eat a dog no but in this game maybe exactly top three best things about this game two one i'll start with the third one go ahead which is building stuff after you

scavenge a lot of materials wood components electrical parts you can start building and improving your house or living space like building a bed building a workshop first of all there's so many stuff to build which is awesome and you can even have a new ideas and find new stuff to build when you finally build something you lose weight from your shoulders finally i can sleep it gives you this light at the end of the tunnel which feels amazing and i love that building and scavenging system my third is the teach this game has done something that i haven't seen somewhere else where you kind of unlock new rules as you play you start off with this small little rulebook called journal just glances over most of the rules but as you go and do those things things will come up and it says congratulations you've unlocked three more advanced rules and it's a very unique way of introducing this uh because that all the extra rules are in this uh book of scripts just hidden between the actual like narrative the game so you don't know where it's gonna come up and how it's gonna come up and when you're gonna learn that you can eat dogs which is actually pretty early on probably you don't have to do that but you know that you can next one is dilemmas and dilemmas here are very very tough and they feel real you have to choose between saving somebody's life and sacrificing their life to save your own they feel like they matter and you're always left feeling like that was so tough but you know we survived somebody's knocking at your door

and yelling please help what are you going to do that could be a trap you don't know yeah but they might need help if we have guns we might open the door yeah we might as well as the consequences of your actions really felt real it wasn't there just because the game needed it to be there it really felt like oh yeah that makes so much sense that would happen in real life they actually enjoyed it they're actually saying the rules that you should approach this game played as an like a rpg like the role-playing game and just you know role play through it that is a good suggestion and this is the only way you should play you shouldn't concentrate on what your goal is like survive or anything just you can be this nasty survivor who just cares about himself and tries to survive no matter what and who he has to sacrifice or you can be this empathetic person who tries to help everybody which spoiler alert is really tough to do my second one is the replayability there are a ton of cards there are so many cards and each of those piles might seem small but they have done a fantastic job depending who you leave guarding the door uh narrative is gonna go that way or one another way and so much is just putting these cards just drawing them in certain order will change up the game from the previous one so i feel the replayability is definitely there and a lot of it and the last one is it's so thematic mechanisms here complement the story so much definitely yeah everything you do feels like it's spot on it's great the problem of course is that theme is very dark and

we're gonna probably talk about the bad things uh right after this so stay tuned if you're okay with that the story is amazing yeah really yeah that's what i have is number one as well like narrative is everywhere like i said the previous point depending on who you leave to guard your shelter story might go that way depending who you rescue departing where you go depending what items you have when you go somewhere depending what do you talk to people or trade with them this book like drives the game just wow i mean you have to experience it it's it's uh it's amazing how everything you do matters and might drive the story forward even though it not necessarily is a story game right it can feel very mechanical and very like strategic i think both story lovers and very mechanical bureau gamers could enjoy this definitely definitely worst things about this game so let's talk about the bad things yes there are also some bad things in this good game and spoilers you said good game is that a review and surprise we already got to the review part it's a good game thank you for watching and see you next time yes please subscribe yeah please we're gonna name different problems here things that we feel like could be problems for you guys and we're also gonna rate them from one to five how bad it is one being you just dropped the dice that you rolled really highly like a six and then you drop it down so you have to reroll it five being you leave the dog at home so it doesn't get eaten and then you go scavenging and you come back and somebody ate your dog you're going first what's the problem you see in this game

length of the game is gonna be a problem for example for me this is a game you can't probably play in a quick sit down it's well i'm gonna say at least three hours at least i mean you might lose real quick right for example for me i needed to leave it set up there is a save system we still have to gather all the stuff up and then put it back down but yeah the length of one game takes like three plus hours yeah i would rate this problem as a four it's the same for me the way i enjoyed this game the most you already mentioned it i just left it open and if you have a tablespace where to do that it's great just from time to time go and play it a bit but playing it in one sitting is really tough also maybe with the theme and just the planning it just feels a bit slow and that means those three and four hours goes even slower than you are actually playing it when it rains it pours meaning once bad things will start to happen to you they will come in bunches one person can die from your team and that means you can get food the scavenging phase and that means that will happen so it goes goes on and on and on you will feel like i mean i could start a new game i guess a lot of characters react to situations of other characters for example this guy feels really bad if somebody's hungry and then he is miserable which is bad so if you're already doing bad this guy reacts to that and he's bad and then everyone's feeling bad i describe this game as it starts out bad and then it

gets worse i'm gonna give this actually a two because it depends on the player you are a lot of people are gonna enjoy the constant challenge and punishment that is thrown at you trying to overcome it so depending on your person it might be higher than two but generally i'm gonna give it a two also another thing is it just complements the game it shouldn't be easy and it's not my thing and i've put this as a good thing but it's also a bad thing is the teach but hey you get to unlock a couple of rules as you go but sometimes you'll have a situation where you're like what does this mean but you can't find it because there's no normal rule book they do state like if you come up on a rule that you can't figure out just make the best assumption what it should be okay i'm gonna pretend it's that but did i miss something really important i'll give it two as well this problem was the biggest at the beginning when you just started to learn because it also this journal shows you that you need to start out step by step meaning you just set it up and then start playing but it's sometimes annoying because you at first you need to make decisions that will you know matter later on and you never know how it will matter yeah so it can get frustrating and also i agree that sometimes you just have to wing it but after playing few times you just get used to it and it's not a problem it will be problem for the first uh few times for sure just be prepared for it this thing you already mentioned but it's the multiplayer yep that was gonna be my number three as well you wrote it down that it's a solo game uh i agree with that but i mostly enjoyed it with two players but of course it just feels

like a solo game yeah i'm gonna give it like three it's in the middle for me it's not a minor thing because i think a lot of people will be disappointed and again it's not a hugely big thing if you know this and now you know might not be a tree for you anymore if you're a solo player how long is the honeymoon three two one until you win i have until you beat the game i have an asterisk where i decided last moment or until it beats you you're not going to win in your first try right you're not going to win your second try as well right it's going to take a while right it's going to take a while if you really want you know that that last ending to get to the end it's it's gonna take a couple of games figure everything out and just get lucky i mean there's luck in mould obviously until i won the for the first time i had this honeymoon for sure that i love this game absolutely i just want to go back back and then when i won i thought great i'm gonna put this in my shelf for a while all right and then i'll come back after a while yes you want to read all the events and see how it ends and you want to beat it but there is as you said a lot of replayability here so even if you lose the first few times there's no problems getting back in and trying again and there's also an expansion which i think introduces kids into the game think deciding about the dog was tough try deciding about the kids my wife would say that for the dog it's 10 times harder the best alternative watching documentary on animals being going extinct and dying out on this planet two one oh wow this one which is it oh wow

nice okay mine's seventh continent seventh continent is a big card game and this theme is nowhere near this dark it's darkish but it's all fantasy it's all made up and it's also about survival you have a deck of cards that are your actions and skills and they run out and then you have to eat to replenish them and if they run out you die and there's always this constant sense of dread plus the narrative i mean it's mostly narrative in that game and it's just so full of story just like this so i felt that those give me the same sense of story so much story and oh my god we're gonna die soon what do we do yeah mine is robinson cruzo and it's about scavenging it is building stuff it's a cooperative game it is it's very tough to win depending on scenario but yeah there's also dying and some dangers and animals that could kill you all that stuff but not close to this one other than that i felt like it they are very very similar this war of mine is more story driven because there's a huge book with a lot more texts and story uh but robinson crusoe tells the story in a different way making the seven deck which is super fun also worker placement and each time you play through like a day your workers there then the night happens storms happen weather happens all that so i think this is really really good alternative this one uh what are you doing there uh nothing just erasing mine yes that's that's a good alternative and now the final rating mine's going to be the longest rating

i've ever given on this channel world record of the longest ever rating on this channel is i have fantastic realistic solo game uh i have fantastic plus as well i think it's almost a must-have for me i really really enjoyed it it's awesome but also when i just like finished it wanted i'm not looking to go back into it again but that said all the bad things we talked about it doesn't matter for me mostly yeah so that's why if they don't matter to you as well and you enjoy you think you would enjoy this mechanism and this story then i mean it should be a must-have for you it's brilliant design for me it's a fantastic game as well but it's a fantastic solo game with a realistic and dark theme for example my wife would never play it like ever i didn't even try to offer like hey do you want to play a game where you're constantly starving and are in misery and might have to eat the dog or cat to survive do you want a divorce yeah exactly yeah but if you're fine with that i think this is a fantastic game that you should try uh at least once alright i hope you no know if this game is for you be sure to like subscribe and do all the good things yes please do and see you next time on our next video yeah bye bye you know what i'd like them to do is take this basic mechanism and just put it in another theme imagine like nemesis survival kind of game where you crash on somewhere and then you have to go out of your bunker and scavenge among like aliens maybe

you

Progress saved