Skip to main content
Loading video...

Undaunted: Stalingrad Review - Emotional Gauntlet

Transcript 23:46

once in a blue moon a board game comes along that changes everything is undaunted Stalingrad that board game let me answer that question with another question is pandemic Legacy season 1 that board game is Memoir 44 that board game is Dominion that board game is Crash octopus that board game yes yes yes no although crash octopus should be that board game I mentioned the other three for a reason because mechanic te Ally and conceptually you could describe undaunted Stalingrad as a genetic offspring of pandemic Legacy dominion and Memoir a product of audical minaga but that's not the point of comparison that matters you know that feeling when you first play a board game and you think wow this is transcendent this is special this is an experience that will sweep some people off their feet and make them touch think and engage with board games differently well that feeling is undaunted Stalingrad so then what is this game well let's turn to EA for a brief overview I said let's turn to EA for a brief overview they're not real Soviets they're not going to take you back it's just a board game could give me a paper cut though how about I give you a paper cut now and then you won't be scared of it hello this is undaunted Stalingrad this is fine my thighs are fine they're not trembling

Stalingrad is the fourth installment in the undaunted series which began with undaunted Normandy followed with undaunted North Africa both expanded by undaunted reinforcements that also serves as storage for all three titles combined you'll notice that Stalingrad is significantly chunkier than its predecessors and it definitely UPS the component count but comparatively its ambition has also balloon to burst the seams of this unashamedly enormous box in this exclusively play a game you and hopefully not your significant other preferably just some random person that you don't want to remain friends with will each take on an opposing side of a bitter conflict in World War II the available sides in this installment are well let's just say that in 2022 you won't be ordering a t-shirt with your team's logo on it okay you picked your team what next next you do some deck building and not in a fun on a porch kind of way if you know what I mean nobody knows what you mean but I do recognize deck building when I see it every time you plug into undaunted you will consult your very own private scenario book and this will tell you what your starting deck will be often it will consist of cards that represent your soldiers on the field such as Riflemen or Scouts belonging to one of two squadrons you might even end up with two different Soldiers with the same designation such as two Riflemen

from Squadron B but on the map they function as the same token there's also cards like your platoon Sergeant or one of your squad leaders they don't have tokens but they do boost your troops by letting you purchase new cars which could be alog together new units on the map would I like a machine gunner thank you very ratatatat finally there's fogs of War dead cards that gum up the works but how could that be you say has a number one on it and we all know that number one is the best not when it comes to initiative each turn you will draw four cards from your deck for potential soldiers to send into battle except this is a brilliant lie and is the real Ingenuity of the undaunted system you have to have to pitch one of these cards for initiative each player simultaneously choosing one card in secret and revealing it you won't get to play with that card you won't be able to send it into battle to try and eliminate a Rifleman about to shoot up your troops you won't be able to use it to take control of a building that Commander said is the most important thing and of course the better the card the more you want to keep it to play it the higher the initiative but if you do play it for initiative you might get lucky and get to go first to up the anti even more each of the three cards you do get to play can only do do one thing for example this machine gunner

can either move or shoot if you want to do both you better have drawn two in the same hand and not also played one for initiative that's not very likely thing is you want both undaunted is a game of compromises and risks that compound every turn and it's very good at showing you your mistakes because so much of it is based on gambles imagine that you wanted that machine gunner to get in closer and storm the Enemy Lines you spend your lone machine gunner card to move it in imagining all the while what it must be like to be them alone cold with nothing to eat but your ushanka and nothing to wear but your loaf of bread you sit there in a field and wait exposed to Eastern winds and Western bullets you contemplate how life brought you here what it is you truly want you realize quickly that what you want is to shoot your gun and not die but there's been no order to shoot your gun and not die you ask your commander sir please can I shoot my gun and not die and your commander replies sorry one sec just seeing if Commander proves it Rifleman a Rifleman B platoon Sergeant machine gunner oh but I really need those Riflemen to advance and I really want to buy some new troops with the platoon sergeant just hang in there buddy any moment now

I don't get it it sounds exactly like undaunted Normandy but undaunted Normandy is £25 and this is £90 why would anyone buy this I'm glad you asked that question that you yourself didn't know the answer to even though you wrote the script well I certainly didn't do it because we had to overview undaunted for those unfamiliar with the system no doubt what are you not going to do next I'll tell you what I definitely won't won critically analyze undaunted shortcomings to emphasize how Stalingrad triumphs over them right let's critically analyze undaunted shortcomings to emphasize how Stalingrad triumphs over them here's a brief overview of the very first scenario you will face at first glance it's a very symmetrical battle both the Germans and the Russians have the same starting deck access to the same units and the same objective control tiles with a total of four command points but take another look and you can tell that the proposition for each side is very different the Germans start with two machine Gunners camped in these tiles each tile being worth two points if they can take control of both of them that's the Four Points needed to win the scenario the Russians have no option but to send their Riflemen the only units that can take control of tiles through a Bullet Storm to even have a chance of winning in mechanical terms that means drawing a Rifleman card playing it to move move now it's on a tile with a lower defense value meaning the German machine Gunners have an even better

chance to shoot and kill that Rifleman okay so what if I want to move my Rifleman B again or what if I want to shoot with it well it's in my discard now so I have to go through my entire deck before I even get a chance to draw it again because again this is a deck builder when your deck Runs Out you take your discard pile you Shuffle it and you make a new deck aha but what if I purchase more Rifleman B well that's great but remember this is the start of the game so we just have our starting deck and any cards we purchase just go into our discard pile meaning it'll only be until I shuffle my deck that these new Cards start to circulate meanwhile whilst they waiting for that to happen Nothing Stops the Germans from just shooting The Rifleman B and if they successfully do that I have to remove that card from my deck from the game and if that was the last Rifleman bat card in my deck then to add insult to injury I have to move it back one space literally waving a white flag however the distance the Germans need to cross to secure Victory first with Scouts then with Rifleman is much greater and if in that time the Russians can dismantle this enemy encampment they'll turn a hurdle into an advantage undaunted is

fantastic and painting a strategic landscape through play it's also very good at showing you where you succeeded and where you went wrong if you fumble getting your Rifleman P the trenches and the Germans raced ahead and took control of the key points well the answer is clear you were too careful you did not recruit enough Riflemen and it took you too long to get them there you spent your Scouts on removing fogs of wall from your deck rather than scouting the tiles you actually needed to move into because scouting again is a double-edged sword you do need to scout the tile first to be able to even move any units that aren't Scouts into it but then when you do that you have to add another fog of War into your deck except that is a well-crafted illusion in reality undaunted is a very robust system but it's driven by two elements of high chance you could draw an outrageous combination of cards at a time when they are entirely pointless or everything could be going swimmingly but in a key point of battle you draw a hand that is as Barren as the winds whistle that's then further compounded by Dice and not just any dice 10-sided dice which aren't exactly known to be reliable you can of course affect all of that for example a scout could remove a fog of war from your deck permanently that's good but

you will notice that a scout has a whopping four actions what are they what could you do instead you could for example add a fog of w into your opponent's deck is that good yes is it better than removing a fog of w from your deck who knows you can also do other things you can affect your chances in combat for example if I move this unit into this tile it's now closer it has to shoot at a closer unit that's good that increases your chances in combat at the cost of you being in a defenseless position every turn every move you're offered tactical choices that are tough to gauge so you take chances and undaunted makes you believe that those choices mattered that sounds like a criticism and within the extent of a single game it is there's only so much of well that's all for you that I can take when I invest myself into these decisions and then dies or cards with original anded I found myself liking these systems liking the narrative that they wo but never really wanting much to return and return is what I got from Stalingrad because it's a campaign game what do we want more Campaign games when do we want them I think if we try we could maybe get everyone together

just one second Campaign games might seem a touch less exciting in 2022 but if there was an award I would give to undaunted Stalingrad it would be most finishable campaign game ever not only do you need to convince just one person to take on The Gauntlet a task much easier if you have a potential victim loitering inside your house already but the maximum 15 scenarios that you'll play are much less daunting when most games are between 30 and 45 minutes with longer ones stretching to an hour sadly Osprey games decided to class anything that isn't the most basic undaunted mechanisms as spoilers a decision that precludes us from talking about some of the aspects of the game without most people switching off which is a little bit baffling because one you learn a large bulk of it after the first scenario anyway and two rules isn't exactly what make this campaign interesting but if you want the juice a spoiler tastic unscripted chat will be on our patreon y when will it be on our patreon now literally now along with all of my top 97 games apart from 10 to1 that's for later the very first thing you notice when you rip the lid off this box is the Colossal number of tiles inside these serve as the totality of Starling

grad with each scenario zeroing in on a specific area then there's a slightly smaller drawer of tiles that serve as Replacements here I have to be a little vague because again spoilers but the gist is that these replacement tiles will sometimes replace the existing syst tiles meaning the decisions you make in battle will come back to affect future scenarios maybe past elae shouldn't have that building 3 days ago because today Elaine has to sit in that building and somehow defend it bonus if you wanted to you could actually lay out all of the tiles if you have a table big enough to see the whole of the city which is really neat pointless but still neat I say this to emphasize the sense of consistency that pervades the campaign and the thing that cements that is these two individual scenario books my heart skipped a beat when the rule book said that my opponent could never see my secret scenario book and nor could I ever read theirs and then when I found out there were scenarios with actual rules that had to be kept hidden from my opponent I was telling the NHS to get the EKG machine ready to top it off there's even a table that is easily the most exciting wrting table since the invention of Microsoft Excel or Libra office scal for the real Rebels amongst our viewers the idea here is that the game is always in a shifting State depending on who won the last scenario

and that state is tracked with a code say something like 2A but this code remembers the outcomes of all previous game States and leads you towards the next scenario that's most appropriate based on everything that has already happened not really a SP but if you Peak towards the end you can see that the last scenario has a whopping 14 game States leading into it looks complicated but it isn't you simply find your current campaign State on the campaign tracker and that tells you which bit of narrative to read then that follows inter scenario instructions and when you finish that you just find the new game State foiler and there's a persistent narrative that also responds to these game States once again it differs depending on which team's booklet you're holding and it's well it's board game narrative so pedestrian at best however it does a lot with how little there is of it it establishes the important characters which range the whole gamut from reticent about war to excited about war recounts the effects of the previous scenario and establishes some strategic underpinnings of the upcoming one but the point of narrative here isn't to tell a great story because that's never been how undaunted told its Stories the real retelling of events comes through scenarios the choices you make and the consequences of those choices I've often thought that scenario design is the

unsung hero of Bard games and nowhere is it better seen than in undaunted to tell you anymore would be the real spoiler so you're just going to have to take my word for it it's not the types of new soldiers that you unlock that matter because they will become evident as soon as you see the punch board it's the effects of your journey as a commander any scenario can end in one of three ways either team achieves their objective you route all your opponent's Riflemen or and here is the Banger your opponent concedes which might seem anticlimactic but this system manages to make concession feel like an appropriate conclusion if I was playing any other board game and my opponent conceded I'd feel weird I think calling it bad sportsmanship is a bit misguided but I certainly feel like maybe they were having a bad time and the game failed at facilitating a chance for everyone to have fun but undaunted makes concessions feel like good strategic decisions especially for someone who's playing the long game a good Commander wouldn't risk everything on a full hearty objective especially if luck hadn't been on their side in fact in one of our games play ConEd with the first 5 minutes of us playing and all I could think was yeah that makes sense considering that start that is what a good Commander would do who cares about their soldiers all right yeah it's me yeah talking of soldiers

undaunted always had this layer of emotional investment like giving soldiers actual names which I always thought was a cheap attempt at sentimentality like ooh did you consider that these are real people no they're not their cards the only damage they'll receive is scuffed edges from constant shuffling and when they're done fighting they'll sleep very soundly in their calx or at least that's what I thought when the scope extended to just a single scenario but Starling gr says no we're going to simulate something here and you have to buy in for the Long Haul and suddenly I started developing relationships with these cards they became became familiar not just because of their faces and names but because they weathered battles lost and succeeded admirably in battles one some Might Have Been instrumental in a pivotal moment in battle others might have just always reliably been there I would draw my four cards for the turn and instead of immediately going right what can you do for me I thought hey I know you you did that thing two scenarios ago when oprey games sent us this copy I thought 15 scenarios of undaunted this is going to be the quickest review ever and then we found ourselves managing to average just two scenarios a day because there's a real emotional weight to this game the high

luck theatrics the veil of tactics and strategy it all found a natural home and despite all of that Swingin after 14 games we found ourselves even seven victories each readying for the final confrontation and that's where Stalingrad decides to write it in and abandon its tight and Brilliant elegant scenario design and do a victory dance just before crossing the Finish Line it pulls on its worst instincts giving a crowd-pleasing finale instead of Leaning into the Freds and tones it's been so carefully cultivating throughout this entire Campaign which obviously ends up pleasing no one and Falls flat just very quickly so that people know exactly where we stand before you lean into the criticisms what's the verdict well game of the year so far emphasis on the so far what about you game of the year so far emphasis on the so far for me too now you can do your thing right that last scenario I understand the platonic ideal of a satisfying finale you know the Avengers style Showdown but you might as well tip out the entire box onto the table and then rub your hands in it you'll achieve the same level of mechanical Fidelity also not to pile on but the emotional Arc I undertook during this journey has been completely undermined by that to the point where I began to doubt the intentionality of everything that I've

experienced that's of course just one scenario out of 15 but also as much as I think the game itself is worth the entry cost the physical part of it doesn't exactly feel like 90 the bulk of the box is rammed with these tiles which I would argue is the least impactful campaign element most of your mileage will come out of these locked upgrade and Reserve decks the contents of which I again can't show you but I think there's some clues in the names but then if the cards are the star of the show and because you have to shuffle them a lot why make them so cheap Starling rat has clearly been designed with replayability in mind because you can reset the entire campaign but if I'm going to hold these in my hand all of the time for that price I'd want them to at least feel better than the stuff you get in top trumps none of that stops me loving the game but I also wonder how much mileage would I get out of regular undaunted if I just bodged a home rugen pain system for it if you love undaunted I think you owe yourself a copy of this it'll be a memorable experience you'll talk about it for years to come but if you if you've never played undaunted and you're not sure whether you're going to love it I think the first game in the series is going to be a better purchase to test the waters on the very final note on this level of simulation in a game that's Meant For Less historical War Gamers and more for General audiences and serves as entertainment I'm just not

sure how comfortable some of you will be with what you're doing here especially with these teams that's of course a personal choice but I developed an emotional connection with undaunted Stalingrad and whilst that's certainly a selling point is it necessarily a good thing just what are we in acting here this isn't All Quiet on the Western Front this isn't literature it's play you're not feeling what some author wrote for you to feel you are feeling your own feelings of War simulated cardboard war and those are not real but I imagine they are more real than you give them credit for so I haven't got any easy answers for you but the more I look at it the more it Disqus me

Progress saved