Skip to main content
Loading video...

Castles of Burgundy - Does it Hold Up After 14 Years? Back to the Board

Transcript 28:06

hello and welcome to board stupid my name is Wayne and I'm Matt and we're going back in time Matt we're going back back to the board back to the board with this series where we explore and dig into detail a classic game from the past and look at the one that we've picked for you and be like yeah finally managed to get way to play castle of burgundy for for a long time year and a half now he his favorite game that's not true maybe they not watching keep watching and you'll find out absolutely and if you want to hear what I think about cast of burgy after playing it after the first time in 15 years then y hit the Subscribe button yes nice that's really nice for everyone yeah exactly and after You' done that uh if you wait a few seconds we're going to start talking about this is it still worth playing it still worth buying it which version you should buy and all that L all that good stuff yeah cool let's go nice C for dreams and GES click subscribe it's a Vibe for two all we need for you and me what you should play see so Matt castles of burgundy released in 2011 by Ravensburger and designed by

Stefan Feld which is the brain behind such games as civil ustion for those latest more recent to the Hobby uh as well as numerous other games uh but this is a game set in sort of medieval 15th century France of the L Valley yeah where you are Aristocrats right you very much yeah you own you own a castle you own ready you start with one Castle so you are a castle or super and then uh that's you and you're creating or developing your estate yes and that's the conceit of the game I think and it's heavily abstracted but that's the the point and that's the what all of the mechanisms are built around you've got various um you got shipping you've got farming you've got buildings and of course you've got castles yeah let's talk about this design a little bit so this uses dice allocation or this dice action right um as its driving force yeah and what's really smart about this and what Stephen Feld has done is he created what is essentially a dice game that doesn't feel random yeah it's not there not Randomness or very highly mitigable yeah mitigable yeah yeah and the randomness is always before your decision- making right yes so you get a bunch of Randomness but it'll be okay the dice will happen and then you can make a decision but then you have various tools at your disposal to either mitigate those uh random results or by using the dice to do something else

right there there always seems to be an option you can always do something even with a worst um dice roll you can always do something and again you during the turn you will always roll two dice and you always have at least two action that you can use those dice too and one action could be buying some uh dice mitigation tokens that will let you uh change the results of the of the other di so if you really need to do something in a turn you always feel like you can as as least achieve something and that is reflecting it very well into the game where you always got an option you can always do something beside having to roll the dice and it's not it's quite clever how how this was uh was done at the time yeah definitely I think it's this is a game that gives you not just an option I think most turns you you have quite difficult decisions to make so during that I think as we had the discussion earlier M around round two round three maybe round four on it feels like you roll the dice and each dice that you use you've got two or three choices and they all seem equally good at the time and that's quite challenging because this game is trying to make the most of your limited set of actions and if you spend the dice badly then that can set you back um if you spend the dice well uh then you're being more efficient than your opponent and this is basically a game of pure efficiency in that way yeah it is you're trying to build this like mini combos on your on your board to trying to uh score as many points as you can with this kind of like

all right I'm taking this that will let me do this that will let me do this that will let me to one you start the game starts slow as many as many Euro game at the end of the day because it's like that is kind of like how the Euros works you start with a very limited things kind of like I can only do this I can only that going toward the end of the game of the game yeah it it transforms toward the end where your turn is going to be slightly longer the star just go of all the combos that you started building and um again it it works really really well um the fact that you there are multiple ways of you can win the games one will be I don't know collecting all the animals just building all these like um animal parks that will multiply every time you add the same type of animals to to a cluster or going for the end of game scoring with the uh with the yellow tiles where you can actually um my seems to to be not very good at the stop but I'm actually collecting all the stuff that is going to give me like a multiplier of points toward the end of the game um or simply just like getting richer and getting getting as much coins and and as much um boats that you can so you can take all the shipments and then you can resell at the end of the game and and get like a lot a lot of points so you got multiple ways of winning the game multiple Parts the victory which I think think is always always good right cuz it you never want to feel like there is one

dominant strategy one of those things I love about those those beautifully deep Euro games is that they obfuscate the obvious way to win you really have to read the board and read your opponents and make the best decision at the time uh and it could be through going purely through the shipping routes or it could be like as you say through doing this endgame scoring this game that we've literally just finished before filming this ended in a time yeah it was that close quite unusual and it swung back and forth like 20 points either way throughout the game through the various things that we're doing Matt was dominating the shipping lanes constantly selling Goods which was driving me mad I was like please just leave me those uh but then I I think I started early with the animals and got in pretty pretty heavily with these yellow buildings so I was opportunistic about those as well but nothing felt like even when you were driving ahead I didn't feel like uh that was unfair I thought there was another route yeah that's that's really good cuz um again I think the first few turns you were on top of me like 30 points something like that but is that kind of game where like all right I'm I'm slowing I'm building my engine to to get to get points later so um and this game it does it really well again what we said so far it works for a lot of other the Euro games out there isn't it so absolutely but we're talking about a um something that is from 15 years ago so that's why I think that a lot of mod games takes inspiration from

um from this in terms of like the the design overall not just the not purely just the mechanics but actually how the game flows how the um the different path to Victory and all that at the time were not such a thing or there were there were few games but this one is the one that brought all that stuff on the bigger Market yeah oh yeah and in something from Ravensburger and for you know for a cheap rice that year you can go and buy and enjoy it yeah absolutely because other games from the year that might have done you know the more complex deeper gameplay is things like the first version of eclipse or Mage Knight but these are heavy heavy games and expensive games so this is like this is way way more accessible it's still a complex deep game but it's more accessible than those games yeah it is and in the game itself you got different level of difficulties represented on which B you're going to play with you got the uh the starting player boards that where both the players play with a a very simple um with not many um additional rules uh but then once you play with the with the initial one there are um other um boards that you can use and uh you can play with the second type of the the board with a third type or a certain point when all the players are very good at the game you can start basically drafting the the tiles that will have that will let you play the

game in a different way because some of them will be full of cities that you you need to fill out some of them will have a lot of of rivers that you need so the games will be very different um depending on which board you you're playing with and again that's something that probably at the at today it will be sell as a um as an expansion true but it's including nice is absolutely nice um it is a point sality game so what's really quite satisfying about this game and other games that do Point salad type design is if you don't know what that means everything that you do gives you points and it is quite satis one I do a thing and suddenly I move my marker like 10 points at a time 20 points at a time it's huge you're going to be scoring well over 100 points each time you play this game that's what and that's a satisfying thing we had what 191 yeah I think I think the the big scoring smallest he's going to score is probably in a in a two- player game is around yeah the 180 to 100 points three player slightly less but still on on that things the four player is the is the one where probably you got to score less and and each point is going to be really um really important yeah absolutely we both love t uh T yeah and this is a uh tile placement game it is uh deeper but and and it it doesn't have a huge amount of interaction so this is the type of tile placement where you're taking from a central board and then placing where you as opposed to

something like hang or yellow yanki uh or rebirth where you're taking from your supply and placing it in a central board more competitively but that doesn't mean there's no interaction here there is some interaction through denial yes it's it's very much uh uh a mean game if you really want to when two two three expert player of the games will check what's the other needs on their single and will trying to deny removing that stuff from the from the market uh or trying to achieve this or that winning condition before that player so that player will not get the the bonus points um all of that so yes that is the the interaction is very much deny deny being mean the other play Old Fashion hate dting ha droing um so Matt in terms of the play count cuz I've played this at two and four or I have never played it at three um but I get the feel play at three did we play at three we play we might play at three but in any case um I think two and three feels better four for me felt too long I'll be honest with you between terms because I think this game because there are so many options potentially just with each dice it can bog down a bit in the four player when you've got all of the different tiles out and there's lots of different things that you can do with each dice they can I I felt it slowed down yes so the two players is back and forward yeah much uh P pom pom pom you can finish a game probably in 40 minutes you you you're done um with a three player probably is

my preferred player account for this for this addition amount of yeah because you have more of course the the the Central Market on the board will scale depending on the number of players so the more players you got the more tows you will have in the market so the the ma more option you got um but um it it makes it it makes it more uh prone if if someone doesn't really got already that kind of stff because um yeah every all the players they roll their di at the start of the of the round so you even if you're the last player you kind of can start making a plan but that plan will change every time because if you really want that tiles and when he's taking it hey might be gone by that point so you really have to try and swivel right and uh and try and CH change your um your strategy but uh yeah the the four player might take a little bit longer especially if you don't have um experienced player that played it like many times before before it can it can slow down a little bit so I would say three player is the favorite count two player works very well as well let's talk about the complexity CU I think we did this uh a little while ago and one of the first things that we did on the channel we talked about uh yeah how to build a board game collection the series somewhere up there finally we're probably going to redo that that was an old one yeah yeah we'll do that we're going to do that this year we two years old um but I think we put this I think in next step or intermediate games and after playing it for the first time after a long time that I'd say this is

more of an advanced game for me this feels like an advanced game this is like a gateway to heavy Euros to me I I don't agree uh just because I think the things that he lacks in this version of the of the game is a is a is a good UI um and a good play ref player ref sh that is just on the on the represented by icon on the board and on the on the player boards but it's not that intuitive um it's really I think um but for um for some ones that play ball games normally this is an intermediate game if you never played it before this could be a top of the intermediate okay the start of the advanced I think we'll have to agree to disagree I think this is an advanced game cuz I think it it does fall into that realm where if you like this I think you're more inclined to like heavier Euro games for me I feel like yeah because like if you really like this then you and you like feld's designs then he might lead you down the the the dark path of things the dark the dark the heavy stuff but yeah I might be wrong on that but that's okay because because weight and complexity is subjective right so it's to some extent absolutely AB there is a level of opportunity but there's there's an individual ual Point as well um right M should we talk a little bit about the critic the criticisms I think I think it's probably worth talking about because this is a game as we say 2011 a

little bit older and I think the obvious one that we talked about a few times just just together is the production of this original version is pretty bad yeah so we just touch it on the on the UI of the of the game so two things the production itself is bad is bad this version original version it's bad um all the all the tiles have the very thin that that you can you can feel that they going to get um ruined by just looking at them um all the tiles are not colors and everything is is a little bit lacking it's all this pastel um doesn't doesn't stand out yeah however the the newer you got two other option if you don't want to get this this is the very bad one so this 2019 Edition the 2019 is very much the same game um very much the same UI but with better colors and better and better quality of the actual cardboard pieces and and everything else so definitely go if you really interested and for a for basically the same amount of money that is the version to buy um I had this in the collection for forever so um I don't think I will change it for that because I already have the game but if I was going to buy it to someone as a present definitely

that version is way better there is also a really really really fancy version yeah developed by and published by awaken Realms yes who are famous for games like Nemesis uh and that series of games of this insane production values uh and they've done the castles of burgundry like extreme ultimate mega Edition and that is uh something that I've been um you've been eying to about for a while to to buy it because I really like the game and that is the superior version each one of the tile each one of the tile is kind of like one of those um a poker chips material or Baker light or yeah but whatever you want to call it that the very good tile materials um all the UI has been um um reshuffled to make it better and clearer uh all the the the components yet the top of the range of the of the production um you got minis for the for the castles if you want to throw money out of the window you can buy minis for each one of the tiles I don't think this game is needed even if I'm a big fan of the but hey if you really love it go you can buy you can buy minis for everything I don't think you need any of those minis but for the components only of everything else is amazing it adds an expansion that it was present in the past as well but it it kind of like merge into the into the game that is the vineyard so you got all of that as well um so I that is a

version that I'm very much thr buying for around £40 for a quite a very big box yeah it's quite it's quite that's expensive isn't it feels expensive um it's again is a mega deluxe version so it's not needed it's very much uh if you got money to throw out of the window and you really like this game it's uh income that's that it's called but if yeah if you have a very good job then I ain't going to tell you what to do with your money go do that exactly but this is production so production has been sorted with years and you got different option um now the the other things is about the yeah the UI itself I think is pretty bad I mean it's fine I think once you've played it a few times but I think it's definitely a little bit of a barer to any at the start yes at the start it is because there are what I think 10 different types of buildings I mean there's a lot of yeah there's a bunch of different types of buildings at least eight and they all do different things and they all have their own individual icon and then there is these other mystery things then you all the science sty ones each one will have a different um end of game or scoring with that you constantly will you will not remember by remember I play million times I car some of them are pretty clear is you it's four coins for each one of this type of building but most of them you will go every time and check it back

what they do and there is no in this version there's no player a that tells you what what those stuff is yes there is on the board itself the the icons that will tell you what some of the build what most of the building do but sometimes is always like uh what was that exactly is it take one of these or takes one of those put on there anyway so the UI is is is not great but has I think been reshuffled in the new ver yeah in the in the awaken Realms one is uh looks looks better looks a better exp player experience um I think we did touch on that it slows down a little bit at the four player count we've already mentioned that but um I think that's pretty much it m i mean for me going into this you know 15 years later you you are the one they always been very against again it's brown it's brown S A just like it's don't get me wrong this it's one of those games that it's really Brown you love Brown I do like brown games I like this game no you did not really enjoy this game in the past no now that I forced you to play a bunch times what do you think um I think my opinion has changed on it a little bit has warmed slightly so um I was very much I feel like the the production in the UI actively detracts from how good the game is yeah I think it genuinely does um but the game itself it I have to say it is satisfying especially that last game where we played where it was so tight it was neck and neck the whole way it was back and forth it felt pretty

quick the decisions made were fast it was enjoyable seeing all of the all the points uh scatter up I just wish I felt a better connection from the theme to what I'm doing that's all really wish about yeah because it's it is yes we talk about you know medieval 15th century L Valley France but it's just an abstract I at the end of the day you're building a landscape it's an abstract it could have it could have been anything else um so the theme is there just to give it give it something yeah I mean there is that but I I definitely might would say that I I definitely enjoyed it more for sure okay yeah I I if it hits my top 100 I don't know I don't know maybe maybe I mean well but I'll have to I'll have to sleep on yeah at the time of recording this game is 16th on the b top 100 of all time and it's been there for ages and been there so I mean since 2011 so it's it's been there for 14 my opinion is an outlier no no no no but he's an outlier I'm the unusual one but um I don't know there was something I just can't I couldn't connect with it for a long time but but you see how the I think yeah P the um the theme past the the the UI problems that you got I think the mechanics of the game is U is what makes this game one of the most famous games yes that ever came out yeah and I think yeah if I take the positives of the critique certainly the fact that each dice gives you so many

options it giv is really it is quite thoughtful in that way what about you m let's we've taken it back to the table after a long time thought yeah you know I'm not the um it's not not a fan of Euro games I love a lot of Euro games um they will not be my first pick to to play however I always felt kind of like a a connection to to this um probably yeah probably was one of the most um at the time most complex games that I started replaying when I started into the into the hobby um and every time I I got a feeling that yeah this is a good game I never I don't feel the age of it no that's true it doesn't feel old in terms of the game playay yeah it looks old but it doesn't feel old while while you're playing that's why I really I really want to get that aw RS if you're listening to me can you send us we'll do a nice radi comparison and everything whatever you want to do it's got It's got the um that Eternal effect like games like raah El Grande and um and pandemic and all those big boss for me at least those games that don't feel their age they just feel like great games cuz as we keep saying a good game is a good game it's always it's a good game forever yes and um again going back to um I feel I feel that a lot of game have learned from uh from Castle of burgundy and um and use the learns to to

develop different games sometimes even better games but um I mean you got more heavy Euro games which may have been influenced by this by think like things like um Great Western Trail oh yeah Terror mystica that sort of thing or otherwise guy project they kind of take these these principles to the next degree fully deterministic that way um but the the whole idea of using those dice uh for them for for their actions and having them being able to be mitigated so having a little bit of Randomness but actually not really you can you can always planned to mitigate that that stuff yeah I think it's it's it's fascinating it always felt to that this is one of those like you know the favorite game or your favorite game designer like that your favorite game design is favorite game yeah exactly it's it's probably H as a burger that's a good point it's yeah it could be why not I mean because he he made the history and it was so well uh put out on the market as well because again that's the power of someone like Ravensburger that can manage to do this games in um and and sell it heavily in um Germany us UK and really pushing it for for a very for a very low price um so yeah I think this games might be in a lot of like people's Library they they don't even know that they got it it's just around yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah absolutely Matt should we take a break and then go to the outro yeah let's go so Matt we've gone back to the board

with C burgundy does it still deserve to be played yes yes it does I think that's quite clear I I 100% agree with you even as someone that doesn't really like it but I've warmed to it over the last um month that we've been giving it a go um and playing it again and I've enjoyed it much more and even though I I don't feel a massive connection to it like you do I 100% respect what it does and actually even still now it feels quite unique in some ways in how it expresses its design uh and I think that's something to be applauded absolutely I will say do not get this version of the game do not buy this version get the the the the second version the Imes here um that is a is a better better production you probably can't even find this anymore probably like secondhand Market but if it's really Brown don't get that one yeah get the other anyone that isn't Brown um so don't not I'm not saying spend the money for the awaken Realms one if you are a fan of the game and you got some cash to throw throw out probably VI it cuz I'm probably going to do myself and if you do have that cash to throw out why don't you consider being a patron oh yeah buy you buy the fancy copy and then for a c we can throw a couple of quids to the to the patre hit the link below and you can find out all about that where we can give you all this amazing extra content including exclusive video podcasts and uh Early Access to all of our exactly well that was a great segue

that was thank you very much appr perfect uh apart from that what would should say subbe is free yeah hit the Subscribe button that always free check out the rest of our videos and let us know in the comments below how do you feel about coner burgundy do you still play it is it one of your favorite games uh and does it still hold up for you after all this time and what is similar to this game yeah let us know all right we'll catch you again real soono what you see

Progress saved