Asian Tigers - Board Game Review - I Was Hoping For A Zoo Game!
Transcript
hi there I'm L this is the broken me the show where I Raven rant about board games but usually more the ranting part let's be honest so today we've got a game that is definitely I will say outside of a comfort zone this is Asian tigers a story of prosperity supposedly an economic game about the a the growth of the Asian markets um yeah not exactly the first thing I would sort of gun towards do you think but I wanted to give it a try it's a publisher new publisher Pythagoras I've not really seen a lot of their stuff uh the designer has done games like nepon and madira and panamax which granted are not games that I gelled with either but I do like to jump into these games now and again to say like you know some hidden gems do come out of the woodwork when you go out of your comfort zone there are some that are even on my shelf you know pul 2849 is a classic example I tend to use but this one definitely was a bit of a weird one at first because when I looked up before Essen I didn't see the cover all I saw was the name and it was just say Asian tigers and I thought oh this would be cool you know we can have an Asian Zoo themed game that'd be nice you know something a little bit different from the general Norm of giraffes and zebras and all that and then I looked at the cover and realized ah right it's um yeah it's uh crap it's an economic game imagine the disappointment where I thought I was going to get a zoo game about Asian tigers and then realized oh that's what Asian tigers means okay Google is your friend but by all means I wanted to jump in and see what it's like it's not had a lot of people talking about it apart from a couple of you know the usual the usual folk who
get out early and say everything's great but I wanted to find out for myself whether this could be a Hidden Gem before we get started does anyone want to get out Asian tigers takes place over two rounds of which you have 10 turns each your turns are essentially dictated by these meeples well these tiny little figures white gray and black you will take 10 of them out of a bag at random out of essentially having four of each color and place them on your board so that you know for the 10 turns of the round which worker you're going to have available this is important because every time you go to a spot on the board the worker the color of the worker dictates what workers can go to that spot for the rest of the round and in each quadrant you have to have all three types of workers so there is a little restriction there players essentially have a board full of different infrastructures represented by these little cylinder tokens as well as some factories represented by little Miniatures the what happens is that on your turn you will take the next worker off your board and place it into an action space in one of the quadrants they're all pretty much the same Nyon 95% identical to each other but the idea is is that these free spaces allow you to spend investment funds which are on a track and these investment funds are used to build the infrastructures in here so you take one of your things off and when you un when you clear them all off a particular space you can get cool bonuses as the game goes on but the main thing is is that you can build universities factories power plants or Laboratories depending on what it is you need do I need energy in order to build factories build a power plant do I want
to get a factory and get some of these resource tiles well then I'm going to need the specific Factory do I want to get more science tokens do I want to you know whatever it is you need you're going to build that type of infrastructure the other thing to bear in mind though is that the whole premise of this game is essentially getting influence in the four quadrants so as you build these infrastructures you'll be able to get influence and level on the track but when each era or each round ends Whoever has built the most investment in each quadrant is going to get more influence than other players and then by the end of the game you're scoring Prosperity points which are randomly dictated before the game starts by way of random setup tiles and scoring a lot of victory points based on oh I've influenced this particular Market this particular Market or this particular Market as well as building this different type of infrastructure you also have these flag tokens that will be set up in the middle of the board and you can also place a worker on these segments following the same placement restrictions as before to trade in the resource tokens acquired by your factories and collect flag tokens these flag tokens are placed to the side of your board and essentially these represent endgame scoring uh modifiers for things like building a lot in one particular quadrant building lots of different types of infrastructure having a lot of factories power plants that kind of thing but these stars represent the multiplier that will um apply to them at the end of the game but they also level you up on this Central track here which enables you to again score points at the end of the game but also dictates the turn order for a round both rounds proceed kind of in that similar manner you have 10 turns each you know
what worker somebody is going to use next you know the restrictions where you can place them and you know what workers you've got coming up so you can kind of plan ahead is to right I need to do this white one first this black one next and so forth but once the two rounds at end you dropped up all the victory points which predominantly comes from your position on the influence track your position on the global Supply track and also any endgame scoring bonuses you have off your board and of course the one with the most of course now beauty is in the eye of the beholder but I am going to question the eyesight capability of anybody who looks at this game and claims that this is a beautiful game in any way shape form color reality Planet I don't know um I thought raafa or whatever it was by delicious games this year was going to be one of the worst looking games I've seen this takes the biscuit this one is a bland ugly looking board as you can see it's all muted colors it's all just segments and squares and little circles and numbers and tracks everywhere there's no bright color anywhere nothing nothing's bright your yellow player pieces are the brightest thing that you will see in this game now it's trying to be like more efficient in terms of graphic design and to its credit some of the graphic design looks a bit messy at first you think what on Earth does this mean what does this mean du but as you read the rules and absorb it the graphic design starts to make sense and you can tell that there is a certain logic to how these things work with the one exception that I don't like how the you know different segments have got writing that is so unbelievably small that even
me with near 2020 Vision without my glasses I wear them mostly for fashion and looking at computer screens but me with my near 2020 Vision at this distance can barely read the writing anybody with worse eyesight or sitting further away cannot read the writing that says what these segments are they really needed to be a bigger writing or some better way of separating them out you know segregating them but yeah I mean the tokens themselves are not you know they're not great quality they're just typical cardboard these meeples are so thin that they wouldn't stand up to a light Breeze let alone an earthquake test the components I've had I mean I got a spare Factory in addition to the factories I need I've got like I've got seven rather than six but then these little cylinders not only are these a pain because as soon as they fall over they of course roll why did they need to be cylinders but also I've got ones that are cut weird I've got a pink one or something that doesn't have the top on it at all I've got um plenty of these yellow ones here where there is such a bad cut on the bottom of the wood there's like tiny little bits sticking out which means the thing will not stand up this won't stand up straight and you know a lot of this game just feels cheap it's got the look of spreadsheet the game and in 2025 almost we really should be done with the whole spreadsheet thing it's already a theme that's not that interesting the growth of Asian markets the theme means nothing in this game I kid you not right the only reason you even remember if you didn't have the Box near you the only way you can remember that this game is about Asia is the fact
that the four quadrants are named after Asian cities so Taiwan South Korea Hong Kong and Singapore if you did not have those four names this game does nothing thing to remind you you are talking about the Asian growth markets this is as Bare Bones a theme as you can get it might as well be a pure abstract game okay fing components not off to a good start what about its length you know is it a quick game at least no not really the box says two hours and that's actually pretty accurate even for a solo game at times the problem is that you've got 10 turns each so if you especially if you've got four of you it's 40 turns per round which is quite a lot but there's a decent amount of AP that can be generated from this game and even though you have some restricted choices about where you can put your guys the game does drag on and on and on and all you are doing is rinse and repeating the same thing all the time you're just basically deciding right okay I'm going to put a worker in this space I'll build one of four infrastructures maybe I'll sell a resource that's an optional thing but that's most of what your turns are worker goes down build an infrastructure worker goes down build an infrastructure worker goes down build an infrastructure one maybe twice in a round you might just side I'm going to go to the middle and sell some resources and get some Flags but most of the time it is literally person there get build an infrastructure person there build an infrastructure person there build an infrastructure the only time it actually sort of generates a interesting s bit of fun is when you trigger the bonuses on your board so when you take these infrastructures off you can do them in
any order you like as soon as you take the last one you get bonuses it could be a bonus tile that just gives you some other ability or bonus influence it could be getting a HQ down which literally just breaks tie Breakers it could just be getting bonus influence and triggering a quadrant bonus which again is just literally a random tile sit at the beginning of the game or you can put the satellites out which are basically more investment points for the purposes of seeing who's got the most influence in the area but that's even those those bonuses don't change every game they're not particularly interesting I mean yeah you go hey I get a little reward but it doesn't feel that fulfilling it's just like yeah I've just level up this track a little bit more okay great you know whatever really the only part that sort of feels like oh yeah okay this is a little bit different is when you put the flags on here because some of these bonuses are more interesting but then you're restricted as to which um you know flag types can go into each part as so many times so it does make you sort of be a little bit more considerate as to what you're going to do with them although again it also means you have to diversify in this game you can't really focus because you just can't have that many flag tiles on the same spot so I don't feel like I'm differentiated again but these bonuses are just a a minor part of the game when all you're doing is just basically going well I'll go here I'll get some power I'll go here I'll get some science tokens I'll build a uni here that that's me uh you know level up this track and then at the end of the round here I'll level up this track and then and I'm falling asleep you know the interaction with other players is barely there I mean yes you're competing for these but that's the Crux of every game you're
competing on a VP track in a normal Euro the fact that you're competing on these influence tracks is the nature of the game but I don't influence your B I don't directly like do anything to you it's just I put a worker down and I block her space you might have liked to go but you need to think about your own board you can't go somewhere purely to stitch someone up so if you are stitching another player up you're doing it pretty much by accident and not deliberately so you know little interaction 2 hours not the most like compelling of gameplay either where are the good parts of this game and I mean there are some the rules are not that complicated you have got you know you've got two books with the game one of them is about the concepts of Asian tigers which I mean and like the sort of design diary basically which I don't think there any kind of warrants it frankly but then you do have a rule book which is not particularly huge there's a decent amount of pictorial representation to go with the text and there's not a huge amount of rules and the rules themselves are relatively straightforward I wouldn't put this in front of a light gamer this is definitely not heavy this is probably a mediumweight game overall but you know aside from a few bits that could have been written a little bit better the rule book is not bad until you get into the solo mode then the solo mode is an absolute pain because first of all you have to flip constantly between the solo rules and a specific part of the appendix that explains what the automa player AIDS like player tiles and you know things like that do which is
already bloody annoying but also the wording on some of the rules with the solo mode particularly in the cases of when you've got a situation where it could go to one of two or three different places which one does it go to are worded terribly the iconography not intuitive at all in fact some of it actually looks like it contradicts itself and you know there's a particular rule with regards to how it gets Global points from Flags that's worded so badly in the book that the first time I played the game solo I got that completely wrong and it maxed itself out on that track once I realized oh wait that's how you're supposed to interpret it it made more sense and the solo mode balanced it yourself a bit better you got four levels of difficulty and essentially all the AI does is it flips a tile and it tells you where it builds infrastructure and where it puts workers so it functions essentially like a multiplayer character which then stems to the fact of why would you play this with multiplayer frankly I mean if you play this with three or four players it's just the fact that there's a bit more contention with the spaces whereas with two player you have slightly less spaces anyway and you know they kind of do stuff just like any other normal multiplayer person would so there's so mode is fine once you've got the rules down but it's not a short game you're still going to be playing this for a good 90 minutes or 2 hours doing it and again when all said and done what am I doing that's particularly fun it's just a pretty bland game overall I mean it looks Bland and it plays Bland but I'm seeing a few people who like uh the pred the designer previous games and
spreadsheets you know giving this like 8.5s why are we on decimals you know nines and like that and why I don't get what you're seeing here honestly the game is not bad per se I mean it's it's hard to call it bad because it functions It's relatively smooth um it certainly will at least get your brain ticking but it's just so Bland it's flavorless the whole thing looks flavorless like there is not a shred of you know trying to sell this to people in terms of a game night was one of the hardest tasks I've had to do this year and believe me with what I've had to do at work lately that's saying something you know trying to sell people by going look this is what it looks like this is the cover you know this AI generated cover which I don't you know don't get me started on that but the you know you've got this theme you've got this cover you've got this board and these components try selling that to your game night group trust me it's A Hard Sell trying to get people to play this they almost have to do it out of you know I'm practically falling in debts like a John Wick where I cash in the coin saying look I played your game last week you owe me you will play this and then they played it and for the most part people have just been very met on it you know I've probably disliked it more than others but nobody's really come out of it going oh yeah that was amazing I really love that they just kind of go yeah it's all right it's fine does the job but does the job
isn't good enough and for me it doesn't even really do the job you know I don't want to sit and play this for 2 hours if I'm going to play something dry there's a lot of other dry Euro games I would rather play and like countless amounts but you know this one doesn't even have the theme it's based on you know it it could be themed around literally anything because it is basically just a spreadsheet with a bunch of tracks if you're into that sort of game fine you're going to have a blast you you'll probably enjoy this and I know some creators have already enjoyed it because most of the time they do just play spreadsheet games and somehow get a kick out of them but for me I want something more ftic I want something more interesting I want something different this game doesn't feel different this game feels like it probably came out 10 15 years ago and you know maybe it would have actually done really good if it was 10 15 years ago but I don't see people grabbing this off the shelf I don't see this getting a ton of Buzz I don't think this is going to be talked about in a few months let alone next this time next year it just feels like a complete dud um I can't call it terrible because it doesn't make me angry playing it you know there are games that do that far better but you know comparing this to something else that I rated quite low which was septe at least septe gave me something nice to look at and had you know some other cool little bits within it but it was still not particularly great I'm giving this one overall a three out of 10 you know this one for me is just a game I'm not interested in it it doesn't have the aesthetic appeal it
doesn't have the game play that would keep me engaged I'm Bor barded by the time I'm halfway through this just rinsing repeating and if I play the game again straight after I'll pretty much just be doing the same stuff again like the replay value just isn't there and some I I definitely heard like one cre say like oh yeah the replay value is in how you you know tactically do stuff from turn to term um do I need to quote The Princess Bride here you keep using that word I don't think it is what do you think it Miss or perhaps I should quote Star Wars that's not how the force works it is isn't present you know if you like the gameplay of this you'll have a good time but I think you're just going to find it syy as you play it over again I don't think people are going to play this every week CU you'll just run out of variety that quickly once you've played this once you've seen everything the game can offer with no chance to it being that much more varied for the next game it's the same thing every time it's the same spreadsheet just looped basically and for me that's not good enough for 2025 you know maybe it will have its fans I'm certainly not one of them I don't think it's a bad game even though I am rating it a 3 out of 10 but it is just very very boring I hope they remember you so that's it for me on this episode of the broken meele if you like what you see then please thumb it up on YouTube and thumb it up on B Game Geek when it goes live on the page check out the rest of my essn content there's a lot of games I've been reviewing and more to come besides even when I go off on my holiday there will be some more content releasing this one didn't work for me
but maybe it did for you by all means let me know in the comments keep it civil if you're a fan of this game yes Different Strokes for different folks but if you really like the game then explain clearly the reasons why because I'd be interested to know and I think a lot of other people would as well but you know is this the type of game for you have you had any interest in it have you had a better experience than me or have you had the same experience as I have you know by all means let's discuss Civ so is that a word no probably not so take care and remember regardless if you would have preferred this be themed around an Asian Zoo it's still only a game so bye for now