Shadows Over Camelot: Discussion
Transcript
Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised. Hey everyone, welcome to the discussion for Shadows over Camelot, which is a game that is insanely old at this point. Like bread. We just played that game. That was from '86. That is true. No, so this I mean this game is one of the few that came out that was I think it was might have been one of the first hidden hidden traitor games and it was one of the first that I did on my channel so many years ago and my feelings on it is exactly the same as it was back then. I don't even remember my original feelings. I remember not caring for it and I still don't really care for this game. So I'm going to let I'm going to let you guys go first cuz I have a feeling that you guys probably like it.
guys want to go first? Yeah. Well on actual thoughts. Second first, Brad. I'll let you guys expand on that more. Yeah, second first. So what do you guys think of Shadows over Camelot? So this was actually one of the ones early on in our collection and when we played it before, you know, it was it was new, it was different and I think we got at least some good play time out of it earlier in our collection and it was one that we could take and you know, and take somewhere and play easily and so it wasn't a big deal. What I really liked is when Steve actually went ahead and painted everything cuz then it just made it more fun to look at and play. look phenomenal. This is yeah, these are amazing. Because looking at the original figures is just a little rough. It it was awful. looking at the pictures on that earlier and I'm like those aren't the worst.
Yeah, but but painted is is Especially from Days of Wonder. They look really good. Yeah, so once it just made it more fun thematically to play it. So we've had it to the table a couple times I think in the last year. Mhm. But this is just a it's a one that you can always go back to. It it's there. It's not hard to pick up again. And uh I I will always this is one I'll always go ahead and play again if that is what we're going to be playing. I I like the game. I don't you know, I don't always like the traitor element but sometimes if you have a fun traitor Mhm. it it it really Or one that doesn't know what they're doing. That's fair. Oh yeah, tell me about it. One that refuses to play. So I I mean as Amy said, this is maybe one of our earlier pick-ups but um like her I'll always play it because it plays a lot of players.
Yeah. I mean how often can you get you know, seven to the table? Yeah. Uh and you can play you know, there might not be a traitor. You know, for a second I was like we don't have a traitor in this game. Or or or I was looking at you guys and I'm like they've they've I know they've played this game quite a bit. They're probably really good at being a traitor. Like cuz if you get a traitor that's not the traitor all the time then they could have no idea what what to do and they or they might show their hand too early. So So so I do like it. I mean especially since it's painted. I mean you know, this is like one of the first games I painted. So it's not exactly great but I mean it's just better than looking at plain plastic but it's one that I think that the difficulty level isn't so high that you can introduce anybody. You know, I could I could get Igor to sit down at the table and play this because it's not that difficult and it's you know, yeah it I won't even say it's a table hog but you know, there's a lot of different components and stuff but I mean my one gripe about the game is that you know, once you get like six or seven white swords you're like, okay this game it it could take forever to finish it because it's like we you know, you've got to manage mitigate the damn siege engines. You're like, okay somebody get me some health.
Yeah. And then it kind of snowballs at the end like that. Yeah, there's kind of a that was one of my biggest negatives was this game has a pacing issue because once once you go after the big three, you know, the big items, the then it's like, oh, I guess we'll try to do this one for one sword. Oh, anyone have a two? No, no one's getting a two. Okay, I guess we'll go here and draw and draw and draw. So, you go around the table doing one action a turn, and it's like, oh, I finally got a two. Boom. Okay, Brett, do you I hope you have a three. Oh, what? You do? Great. All right, your turn is to move there. All right, let's make it around the table again. And I think there's a character that's better at fighting the siege engines, too, if I remember correctly. Yeah, I don't I don't remember what the other two were. oh, it's the siege engines.
Percival and Yeah, and and so I And I found though that it gets a little one-sided when you have that character out because they seem to just have to stay in Camelot and just smash things. Now, the two left are Sir Palamedes. For each victorious quest you are on, when the quest ends, you gain an additional life point. Um, and then you have Sir Percival. During the progression of evil, you may peek at the top black card before deciding whether to draw or another evil action. Maybe that's good. Maybe it's I don't know, there was I just don't know which one was better. Regardless Oh, it was Kay. He never used her ability. Uh-uh. Sir Kay. Uh, if you are on a quest Oh, in combat ends, he may play an additional life. So, you can basically help Roll the die. Oh, I missed it. I can play another card. Yeah. Yeah. So, but like I said, there's there's you usually end up with like one person just smashing things because you're mitigating Yeah, cuz you have to.
And they they can come out really really fast. Yeah. Brett? Um, largely agree. Um, there is, in my mind, a fundamental concern I have with uh um especially games that only have a single traitor. Um, maybe. Yeah. I mean, it's a fun mystery. It's fun to look around everything like that. But, it really takes somebody who's experienced at the game to know how to be a good traitor. And that would not have been me had I been chosen. I was like, Right. Dodged that one. Right. I almost prefer games that like Battlestar Galactica I think is one of the perfect traitor mechanisms because there's two halves of that. The first half there may not be one, but there's a point halfway through the game where you know for a fact someone is now. And I prefer that because once you realize unless someone like you said is really good at being the traitor it becomes too easy. Like once you realize oh okay we're all working together on a game that was designed to be against you because the traitor's in.
It's like Dead of Winter. If that if you know for a fact no one's a traitor in Dead of Winter it's it's one of the easiest games to win. So it's I don't know. I don't know. I didn't have that experience. We just died With this one? No, it just didn't turn died. Oh with Dead of Winter? Yeah, the run through I did for Dead of Winter once once we realized everyone wasn't a traitor it was a piece of cake cuz everyone's going all in. Like no one's hoarding cards, no one's doing anything. I mean suspecting anyone else. one Yeah, you don't have that weird mystery where Battlestar has that where it's like okay everyone's kind of working together and then you hand out the new Cylon cards and it's like oh [ __ ] now who is it? Like and then the game totally turns on its head. I mean there's only 12 copies so they have to look like something. Yeah, that's I mean it's it just I've I have yet to find a traitor mechanism game that does it as well as Battlestar.
You know it it's a lot of luck driven. We didn't really get a lot of these special black cards like all knights must return to Camelot. Yeah. That's a killer. You know We also didn't draw as many. Like we we kept like our opening hand almost kind of sealed it against Cab once I got I got all grail cards at the very beginning of the game. Well I had two and then you everyone gave like and then you funneled more to me. So I'm just like oh great. All right we're we're getting the grail. Yeah. As long as you're not the traitor that worked out well. Yeah, exactly. I was like am I the only one who doesn't have a grail card? LIKE I NEVER GOT ONE THE entire time. Yeah, and then that's all I kept drawing. So, it became I mean, but that's the thing is like this game it what what bugs me is that it's it's so slow. Like, this game is so slow.
like there's a lot of luck versus strategy cuz it is. Yeah. There's a lot of strategy, but the actual play depends on a lot of luck. Yeah, for sure. And yeah, you have to change your strategy based off of your draw, for sure. Mhm. I mean, but it's like there's no one I mean, yeah, you but I mean, I wouldn't mind it so much if you could take a wound to do the same action so you can speed up, you know, a quest, but the fact that it's like I have my Tristan special ability is virtually useless. I get to move from here for free. I think that's a great special action because you get to take essentially a move and an action at the same time. Once. But that's what I'm saying. I I went I went called back. Until I get called back. And if I mean, maybe I shouldn't have gone to the the Grail at the beginning, but since I had all the cards, I go there and then I have nothing to do until I pop out. So, I set normally people go together to the Grail to get it done quickly.
Right. So, that's We just gave all of our cards to you in the beginning. Yeah, and I didn't have any help until later. And that's the thing is like since it worked out because it was just me, so it wasn't four of us tied looking for the Grail and then and we could mitigate damage elsewhere. Um I mean, I will say that this game doesn't have any I mean, it's it's not like it doesn't have any strategy. There definitely is co-cohesion and cooperation, especially using okay, trade for me. Okay, let's you know, we're going to win this quest, so let's move all there so we can heal, so we can use that to mitigate, you know, so we don't have to draw these cards, so we can take the damage. Oh, okay, we want cards, let's give the special cards to Galahad cuz he can play them for free. Like, everyone utilized their abilities perfectly so that we we can win.
Um and I will say actually, my initial impressions of this game was that the game was actively I mean, it is actively working against you, but I it almost felt like it was unfair. I don't think that's the case anymore, which is good. So that's an improvement cuz I was like Okay, everyone has to do a freaking negative card. Like and these are all bad and so it just progressively gets harder and you know there's a traitor. So you're just helping the traitor. So the traitor doesn't really have to try. Those were my initial thoughts. But if you have people who obviously know how to work together, then the traitor does have to try to actually win. Or potentially not. The game could be super random in that Oh, we never got any cards to fight the siege engines. Okay, well we all died. Oh, we didn't get the we didn't get the grail, you know.
Cat, what do you think? I think this is definitely a game that like if it was offered, I'd play it. If it wasn't, I'd probably just forget about it. Um just cuz I mean there we just know that there's so much more out there, especially traitor mechanic-wise. Um I would play Dead of Winter over this cuz that's more my I just like that one more. Uh but it's this is good in some aspects and not good in others and I do think a lot of it has to do with like with the pacing. Yeah. The pacing of the game cuz yeah, it went really really fast at first cuz we were all very gold driven and then it slowed away way way way way way down. Yeah, it's like Okay, well Not not for lack of us trying. I mean we just didn't get the cards that we needed. Right. Yeah. And there's no way to counteract that. Like you just have to hope Okay, well, let's keep trying to find Oh, no, okay, it's this one. Oh, it's that one. Oh, it's this like and then there's it's like God, I just wanted We knew we knew pretty much that we were going to win.
Like but Yeah, I wish there was something in this game obviously shows its age, I think, because there are no ways to get around that. I mean well that's not entirely true. There is like one card in this entire deck that you played. Uh might be in there. Reinforcements? No, clairvoyance? No, it was here heroism. That gives you an additional sword. That's the like the only way to kind of quicken the game. Uh if I want additional swords. out early enough, you could get it twice cuz we did burn through the white cards pretty quickly. Yeah. But uh that's probably my biggest complaint, honestly. Uh I used to not I used to hate not the theme cuz I I like this theme. Uh gameplay-wise, it's not thematic really in any way. It's like, "Hey, let's go to battle." And you beat them by playing a straight.
Like, let's go let's go to joust the black knight. Two pair. It's very odd to me. Uh Well, how would you change that? Uh I mean, I'm not a game designer. Shadows over Camelot the euro? I mean, you know, like I mean, give it to I must trade in my resources to raise this knight and level this knight up. I mean, you can absolutely have that to where you could go on go on quests that actually require you to have an army to fight these. Uh I'm not saying it's bad. I'm just saying it's not thematic. Like, you're playing you're playing poker in every quest. I mean, except for obviously the the big ones. Well, even just two of them, Excalibur and and the Grail. Um even the siege engine isn't bad. Like, cuz at least you play fight cards. So, it's just it's odd. It's always been odd to me.
But I don't know. I don't know. I don't think I I don't think I would play this game again. I don't think it offers enough for me personally to cuz it's like it's fun at the beginning and then yeah, that that screech to like a halt to just hope that you draw the right cards just to end it one way or another. have to go full ham. That's the thing though. Like, we just chose to go after the big ones. No, you do. Otherwise, you lose. Of course, would your would your thoughts be different had we not reached the screech point where if we would have gotten all the cards and we would have been done 30 minutes sooner, would you have been like, "Oh, yeah, I didn't mind that at all." Yeah. Yeah, no, that that if if the game was 30 minutes shorter, then it'd be it'd be fine, but that's the thing is there's no way have been. If she wouldn't have kept us from doing what we needed to do.
I really truly didn't. No, actually I think that that's I mean, if there is no traitor, um and then you have luck on your side, then yeah, I mean, but you can't guarantee that. Sure. Uh in fact, I would say the it's the opposite is true that it might go longer if you have a traitor who is actively Mhm. you know, drawing these and holding grail cards. Oh, no, but okay, I'm just going to get rid of these three face down to heal. I really need to heal. rid of it the Excalibur quest. Normal cards. Yeah. Like but that's a double traitor. I was trying to be as um nonchalant nonchalant Yeah. I mean, she did a PRETTY GOOD JOB. GREAT. LIKE ALL THESE were out before I even was like I can't believe mean, so so yeah, I mean, she didn't do bad because we all thought there was no traitor. Um and because of the way the game kind of just naturally progresses, we could have just lost on our own without her even having to try.
I was hoping. But that's my doing really great. Two swords at the end? Yeah, yeah, it does it does come to a screeching halt once you get seven black because there's no way you could possibly win. Yes. Right. Well, actually no, you lose if there's seven black swords. That's what I mean. Oh, but that's that ends it. It doesn't keep grinding you through the rest of the game to finish Right. And that's that's kind of what I'm saying about the opposite is true. I mean eight or nine white swords? Maybe but there's still a chance that you could lose and you really do need to play Well, I'd say even if you got the only way that you would lose uh if you got like a majority of white swords, even nine, like nine nine or 10 white swords, the only way you're going to lose is by siege engines because even if the traitor's not revealed, they can't flip enough black swords to actually break the tie or have majority. Um and at that point you just come back to Camelot and and fend it off and do exactly what we did uh to stop the traitor. So, that's what I'm saying is the opposite of what you're saying is true. The chances of this game being shorter uh is less than it being longer, especially if you have an active trader who knows how to be like, "Oh, they're trying to get the grail. Okay."
Uh well, they're getting quite a few, but I'm going to keep drawing. I don't want to hurt myself. I'm going to keep wasting grail cards. Um or I'm a I'm going to sit here and just hold the hold these spots and keep drawing black. Granted, they can always accuse you, and that kicks you out of the game, but you're still active. In fact, you're even worse off cuz then you're holding you're pulling white cards from people and then adding siege engines or drawing black cards, too. So, if this game could consistently be an hour, then I'd I'd play it. Which I think is what it's rated as. It's supposed to be about an hour. It's supposed to player count dependent for sure on this one. Yeah, absolutely. It says 60 to 90. I mean, it says 60 to 90. Like, it was 90. there was 20 minutes of table talk before we took our first turn. Absolutely. Yeah. Yeah. Uh I mean, at for the time that this game came out, which is actually, I think, when I played it cuz it was huge cuz I had the expansion, like the Merlin company company, which basically just brings in gang.
Yeah, he just goes out and kills. I don't remember what it does. Um I do remember brings in Monty Python quotes. Oh, yeah. I thought I remembered Monty Python. I thought they were in the base game, but no, it's in the expansion. Uh yeah, I think in in that expansion, you could actually like detain people. Have you played with the expansion? Yeah, I think you could actually like detain people from from doing stuff, but it I it's been so long. But I mean, at the time it came out, it was definitely innovative. It I I see why a lot of people do like it. Um but for me, it's just it's it's not my favorite. Okay. You guys got anything else? Mhm. I don't think so. Cool. All right. Scale of 1 to 10, Amy. Uh I'd say six. Six? I like that number.
Okay. All right. See you. I'll give it a six as well. Oh, wow. Okay. I expected higher, but I mean, six is a slightly above average game, at least in my in my ranking. might even be like six and a half because you know, if people want to play it, I'll play it just because it it never really hits the table. And six isn't bad for me. You have to realize though because we have so many games that we play, Mhm. you know, it it's in the genre of like Three Dragon Ante is the worst followed closely by Lords of Waterdeep. Dragon Ante is one, Lords of Waterdeep is two. Okay, I'm getting I'm getting it. Uh no, I I completely agree. Yeah, I mean, five is a is average for me, six is slightly above average. Um I mean, we're not the Dice Tower. It's like, "God, this game is just [ __ ] dog [ __ ] Seven." IT'S LIKE, "WHAT?
WHAT?" YES, this is what it would equate for me. I'll never play it again. But but like but like I said, just being realistic. I just don't like it. Brett. No, the the the Dice Tower's rankings crack me up cuz they'll be like, "Look, it's not excellent. Like, I'm not I'm not going to give it a seal of approval. Eight out of 10." I'm like, "What What do you mean? That's a great score." Anyway, uh Brett. not excellent either. They are right. Yeah, they didn't put their seal on it. Despite this play through, which was a lot of fun, uh five. Yeah. Yeah, that's that's exactly where I'm at as well. Um like I I would give it a five. Where I will say previously, I don't I don't even remember what I ranked it all those years ago. I would have probably ranked it lower uh cuz I did not like this game, but it I I think it's I I think it's fine. It's a it's an average game for me.
10 out of 10. I want to be the traitor again. I can't wait. Cool. Uh I will give it a five. Cool. Average. Again, would play again. All right. We'll forget about it tomorrow. That's just how I am though. So, that's our thoughts on Shadows over Camelot. Let us know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day this is for you. Nice. Hey everyone, thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video. If you would like to see more of my content, go go and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content. If you feel like supporting the channel, you can go ahead and click that Patreon link to be taken to my Patreon and any help is truly appreciated. Other than that, stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top 10s or whatever I feel like putting on. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.