Blackout Hong Kong: Discussion
Transcript
viewer discretion is advised hey everyone this video is brought to you by audible audible is offering you a free audiobook with a 30-day free trial membership all you need to do is go to audible.com for word /bg unlock the link is in the description below and now enjoy the video hey everyone welcome to the discussion for black out Hong Kong the I think technically third game by Alexander Pfister I have actually played I love sky and we Great Western trail and then this one oh oh you mean Andre of astora I mean yeah I like it been there many named Pfister um so what do you guys think of black out Hong Kong surprisingly I like it quite a bit yeah yeah like whenever you compare like especially because today we just played Great Western trail and then you come to this one you think it's gonna be like oh my god this is gonna be this is far far simpler yeah yes absolutely um which also has a still a bit of depth like a bit of pre-planning with color coordination of your cards and the different different columns which are gonna let you unlock you know like a lot of points and I mean basically it's a rondelle resource management game yeah just to complete objectives like there's not really a whole lot going in the game but I think what makes this game really
really great it's the fact that for that for what you're doing the game matches the or the game length matches the material so like if this game was any longer his name would be boring yeah it'd be like wow doing this but since it's so short and it always ends ends quicker than you want it to yeah if we had like at least one more turn I got 10 more points why would you complete one of these yeah I needed to pull one more card to get this done oh yeah yeah I mean I was in there and I was like man I can't really those and then my to my purples were starting to get hurt so I was like man those are really hard but like having bought the one you needed oh well I needed that one to be able to place my purple here mmm like that was that was why wouldn't she bought that was like dang it but then I was able to buy an objective that let me play one anywhere um so I know when Kat and I played it we both really liked in a two-player game it's longer like you have like 30 something cards in the draw deck versus the 21 for a three-player game in a four-player game it's a even shorter there's five cards there no there are 15 cards significantly your drawing yeah this is probably meant to be played with less people yeah shuffle the 72 objective cards deal a number of cards to form a facedown the reserved deck and you set that aside and it will become it will come into play when ended game is triggered so yeah like it's a it's
pretty impressive like how well this game is balanced like even because normally when you think of a tracker you think of you're gonna can't consistently gain points and then it's like wow there goes the runaway victor yeah that's what I suspected would happen and like I said at 0 for the longest Tommy sounds here for literally up until the end of the game till you because you did not heal anyone did you nope no like I kept I played my doctor one time and I fumbled on it and I was like it's fine right like yeah literally you got 5 points at the very end of the game for owning a district so by end of the game you got 30 points and I mean 48 to 33 that's a lot closer this is a very tight game I think something Kat was talking about whenever her in that play she's like wow I expected us to cover districts a lot more yeah I thought that that was gonna be like a bigger thing and an easier thing to do yeah it is not it's not I mean especially because you have to manage your objectives like which ones here you're gonna be buying it which ones you're gonna be completing and you're like okay so but what's really really cool about this game probably my favorite thing is the fact that you have so much man over the resources you're actually getting like if you really needed fuel and it's like crap they didn't get rolled oh well I can just I'll just spend a couple points and grab some more of these and then just spend those when I'm placing all place a double blue and then I'll just spend I had a one
solitary moment I'm like man it's worth spending two points to get two of them and I didn't and had I not mean that would be hi you guys would be tied right it's just it's really neat because you also have management over the resources with batteries like it's like oh I will need to do that I'll just use a battery took to cover my my tool cost for this objective like I mean the game is very very simple but still has not so much thought as Great Western trail I know that this is checkers the chess in my opinion yeah I mean it's it's pretty crazy that the games that he's made I mean I think I haven't played Maracaibo but great awesome trail is definitely a stinkiest game Isle of Skye is kind of a I mean it's a tile placement game and you definitely have to think but it's a lot of bidding like auctioning between muumuus but it's really good too he's just an amazing designer cat what do you like about this game um I like I like everything like I'm trying to think of something I dislike and I can't really think of anything at all I like the length of it I I agree with you what you said like the length fits the content material yeah I like the Rondo I like how you can manipulate it I like the fact that you can go out look for resources and I just I like I like it it's a good game mm-hmm yeah works really well once again at any number of players yes so far yeah yeah like the I
mean if I had pretty much one negative and it's not really like the negative of the game it's just the whenever you're playing the game just having to stack your your this is kind of it's just kind of like fiddly a little bit it's not it's not like the worst thing it's just like because just because of the table I mean I really any table that's just kind of gonna bog you down but I recording purposes this is kind of just a math short and at the same time like refreshing your hand like that's just super like everything is just so streamlined in this game everything's kind of really free-flowing you're not constricted the really only thought you have to manage it's like okay like I love being like like you can get a good and then spend that same good I seen you get it like I'll play my yellow oh I gave me a book okay well then all completely forgot about spending five coins get wild yeah to get batteries I mean or a point to get those I mean the also just the the free-flowing nature of like objective is like yeah I got them all ok objective boom done like you don't really block each other either on no I'm spending around like it's just it's just super smooth the victory points what's another cool thing is that like if like this one there's I think there's only one district there's only one 7 district in the game and it's this in the middle right here 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 which is 14 points but what's cool is
like if you complete one and I have cubes there I'll get some points like I was there like I helped out a little bit so that's pretty neat the can get points for being on beat no no that was for your oh yeah sorry she got two points we did tie this whole [ __ ] time I was like where the hell is B at right yeah he was right there whenever he got a need to be yeah and you were you needed a place here yeah oh you're right but yeah whenever he completed that district you got two points they guys did tie but when we did tie I was like man I feel I can't did so much more than me and I mean she went all out on scouting like that's kind of a thing that that's like like his other games there's multiple like avenues to victor like victory you went very heavy strategy I tried to go a little bit more this time too and I intentionally went for the doubles because I'm like that's gonna get me even more scouting power that the the hard ones like this one is like if you get a 12 like hat god that's six points it's huge there's no one there's an 18 point over there for 12 points yeah I was tryin otherone real hard to get I can't remember what stack is in there was another one that was five and I'm like I won short right and it would have given me some more points yeah I like how you only get the reward once when you scalp like for example that funny enough this entire stack which is all random
there's victory points and victory points in victory points so it's like if you're looking at it if you went for this lower one you got one point you can't capitalize on the on these others they would just go facedown and become more scouting power so you might want to wait and because you get to look at all of them you can be like oh okay there's an 18 there I'll plan for that in the future I'll try and aim to get more scouting power like I mean if I had any one night do we have any negatives about the game I can't think of any because every mistake I made was my own doing right if I had one complaint about this game is that it looks like [ __ ] yeah like aesthetically this game would not catch any eyes well I'm gonna die you'd be like I mean the the title son that's what actually always kept me away from this game honestly was like I'm like baka Hong Kong that sounds really cool that looks awful like that oh like III honestly don't have a problem with the design really it seems very you know covert like I I was when you said blackout Hong Kong I had two thoughts in my mind one is Hong Kong suffered a blackout yeah or we were spies yep that's that's all that I was gonna say that espionage like we're like trying to assassinate or do something and that's
what I thought it was and then like the longer I looked at it I'm like oh there's doctors and medicine and whatnot it's like okay so it's we are helping Hong Kong during a crisis yet of power outage all the people that you Scout you're looking for in the darkness and you're hiring them yeah like you're meeting them and I mean the the objectives are at the mad cool like mine was another Scout drone which is look how its source of the sky do you see that light on the screen so like you help access the library help help the fire station which which is another really cool thing another avenue of I went I went very heavy missions I was like real disappointed where I'm like damn I can't complete more than one this turn I was trying to do as many and a bird as possible yeah like you yeah you will you went objectives for people high scoring people yes and cat went high scoring Scout I kind of did a combination of all three like I tried to go high scoring too actually I went districts yeah that was my my big thing but I tried to go because you could easily just go for these are really easy to to go for and then once you get a you know phase eight it's like okay I'll do all of them boom three points cat finished her emergency plans so a fuel for three points but I like how it has the 1x like you can't sit there and be like oh I got five fuel 15 points it's like no you can only do any of these ones there's there's just I mean there's like this many cards to that didn't get thrown in like you shuffle you shovel
these and you'd like this one right here the Scout pay a book and pay a fuel to get to three gps's there's enough randomness from the dice and mitigation then the dice ability don't matter a whole lot no in fact but what's cool is that you're thinking okay please roll a tool tool yes okay I don't have to spend anyone to anything exactly and it's like I I have to kind of rely on what my opponents do mmm-hmm and then it can help me or hinder me depending on things yep so no I really dig this game I like and can't jump in at any time if you have anything that we're not saying there I'm not talking well it is 11:49 right I mean it like I got cuz I have nothing non night-shift people and it is but I live in a black know um the other thing that is really cool is the free-flowing nature of buying objectives it's like if there's one you really want and you are first you can be like okay I'll spend the floor or you can chance it be like okay I'll pass and then hope you don't buy it and it may be even buy one then the same row it's like oh yes now it's cheaper so but if you buy one and the cat passes well I still get to come back in and go thank God now I'll buy it but if I'm sitting there I'm like I'll pass and then you both pass it's like you miss out on your it's it's the risk/reward of either they both pass or one passes one buys and then I get the opportunity to
buy protein so yep or it's like yeah and it's just really quick that you don't have to wait as soon as one runs out it just immediately refills it's just I mean the scoring is just so simple - like for the most part I don't care for scoring like this mm-hmm just because it's like everybody saw that was right you can see there I was there in the 20s something you had zero I was like here you were at 26 that's it like 15 and I was at 5 and then all of a sudden Kat and I are both it 33 33 yeah and I had [ __ ] I had just enough of a lead throughout the game to maintain it but for the most part like my people weren't that expensive the highest one I had was the second mechanic and you can get some really cool combos there was one where it's like I had some objectives I needed to meet and some debye but I was able to place one one there with a yellow and then two mechanics pop off to get me six 14 coins I mean this is like boom alright they're working I'm getting I'm getting money now here's objective and then I just buy the objectives that I need say I had four four people that were worth four points apiece so nice yeah and I was really bummed because my leader got hurt I like how you can risk who's going on the stout it's like the leaders gonna get you two things but there's a chance he can get hurt and he did and I had my doctor who was in my shortest column so
I'm like well can't willingly do that it's just really cool there's not a whole lot going for it but it's very streamlined and verse Tottle with a lot of variety and if the dice were a set in stone thing this game would suck yeah but the fact that you have so many opportunities of being able to mitigate where they're going even whenever you're placing it's like I need to place on the yellow okay well I'm not near one okay I'll just spend one in place one over there it's very much luck but you get to change your luck yep yeah I don't know if you'll do an expansion for this die don't know I don't see a reason for it sir I can't really think of a way that he could add something to this game without hindering it without just making a weird light oh there's a fourth Dyer so it'd be like this it would just be stupid or like oh there's a Northern Railways to the north um but what's also cool is the game comes with a campaign like a four-game campaign and you just you campaign score and then okay so you have it just it's just different setup you modify set up it can play like you can play it solo or you can play it you know with other people I'm pretty sure it's a five chapter sorry I don't know I think it's competitive oh yeah I think it's makes sense like the whole thought
process I'm having is like we're different medical corporations or whatever or like different like Peace Corps type things and we're all trying to get credit and donations and whatnot oh yeah that's probably it um yeah I mean there's like you're obviously the the better one cuz you're powering powering to districts to districts I've got one yeah cat has none but I mean she's got a supply line of like supplies yeah like okay it looks like it's broken up in two hours so the first chapter is our 48 chapter 2 is 72 chapter 3 is our 80 chapter 4 is our 96 and chapter 5 is at the end of the first week and you just have different setups and kind of how so two days in three days in halfway through day three day four and at the end of oh so I mean so that could be pretty cool that gives it some versatility like I wouldn't expect a game like this to have a campaign but I just I could see like that would be neat because you can 'mentally I can see like society yeah collapsing very shortly without certain modern necessities especially in like a place that's so tightly packed yeah that's true yeah there's I don't know how many millions or people are in Hong Kong at billions Oh in Hong Kong itself yeah I know there's over a billion in China but
like Hong Kong itself I have no idea it's probably an immense number like you have to think about like how health quickly things degrade when very basic things are taken from us like nobody's gonna be picking up the trash toilets anymore you will run out of water you have to find those things a lot of food can't be made without 7.4 million people in Hong Kong so that I'm calling the white power yeah I'd be insane yeah I don't know how many people are in New York City like as a comparison yeah but like I'm imagining like New York City just the lights out yeah I mean I'll do population of New York Island old in New York City yeah eight point six million so yeah a similar size to New York City and like I'm sorry that's New York but yes oh all of the state yeah so like an entire state and one city doesn't power goes out that would be utter chaos yeah yeah I mean it's it's terrifying and I mean that's that's kind of like my only negative it's like I wish the game kind of represented that a little wetter like Great Western trail you compare at least inside Great Western her it doesn't have a whole lot theme but they even that's more thematic than than this one you kind of have to stretch I mean the people that you're hiring like I wish they had at least titles every one of them could have had not only do some don't like the special ones like dr. Lederman a thug yeah yeah
ready boy yeah HR like you get some theme from the objectives and and stuff like that which i think is cool but just I wish the theme was a little bit more there yeah but overall this is this is a designer that I'm just gonna like like be little star that I'm gonna sit there and be like boom like what's he making now because these games just sing for me like I would equate this one if I was to compare a viola start again this is probably on on par with like escape plan x-ray skate clients still probably a little bit more meteor but compared to Iron Sky Great Western trail this is definitely the lightest but so let me ask you is this which one do you like better great western trailer blackout Hong Kong you like this one better fold this one is really good um I would say from this flow is more my pace as far as games are shortened sure that makes sense I would say that it sounded negative like like what but I like I would wish the game was a little bit longer uh three people another round yeah - maybe yeah uh that's that's nitpicking for me sure yeah I mean like I said the game is still very good and you do get enough done for the most part whenever you're whenever you're you're strategizing and there were times where I wasn't even like 10 points that's a lot but so for me both times I tried to
play this almost similar I tried to focus more on cards than I did anything else and cards got me a lot of points 13 13 the tummy yummy 27 27 points 27 points yeah because I was like oh man it's drops gonna pull another first game of great western - like I thought because you had five by the end of it and I'm like where you get 0 for the whole game and I was like he's not gonna like this one and then it's like Oh 30 32 are you three points it was 32 okay because I went from five they got 27 oh that's right and they cat was at 30 and then we overlooked her 132 we're tied um but yeah I uh I I dig this game if I were to pick between the two I may want to play this a few more times because like I have more Great Western trail under my belt than I do this that's true um after the first impressions first impressions I would probably play Great Western trail okay just because it worked a little better for me yeah the last time but also this is shorter and it's more constraint to time bug if we'd rather play something short that's of this gray area ters games I would pick this one right yeah that's a good point I mean I would also agree I would pick Great Western trail over this one but at the same time like that's kind of splitting hairs yeah like they're both fantastic and you're right like this game is significantly shorter and gives
you enough thought into it to provoke a break exactly it's not it's not like fully like brain Bernie but there's enough like really cool combos good decisions so many you're not constrained there's no punishment so I want to know Oh punish you you know it's like if you take objectives and don't finish them you don't get negative points you don't get negatives if people are hurt say the only negatives were the the buying transports and oh yeah that's something you willingly have to do but you can sit there and get like okay I'll complete this one and get ten points and then it's like okay I'll spend two and get two more of these and like that's that's willing there's no like oh [ __ ] my leader is injured that's negative ten points there's there's none of that this game is very forgiving my leaders dead you lose the game yeah like like the objectives the unfinished objectives weren't worth any negative points which like typically you could see that in the main game for sure yeah it's like oh man you guys I wanted I wanted that six one so bad I wanted just for the purple I mean looking at a point you know just for the points oh really yeah but that's a good one too where it's like you can get eleven coins for that that's just a better mechanic but you need three of each yeah and it gives you a purple but yeah like Great Western trail I think is the better game overall but this is a really really good game by yeah it's what it's what toilet type so uh yeah you guys have anything else to add
I do not think I do okay scale of one to ten Josh uh I'm gonna give it eight point five eight point five awesome awesome good deal uh it's not quite uh nine yeah but a great great Western trail is a nine in it with uh with the expansion not going fine for me so this is just a little under that okay eight point five eight point five I am going to agree with you I'm a given an eight point five as well well I'm gonna give it a nine actually because it's becoming difficult to find great games like this that work well with multiple players reap eople best of all and multiple players to players like you get the same feeling you get this I guess just a very clever cabbage yes yeah cuz like you get the exact same feeling same strategy it's not like in a two-player game you have to like put in this weird AI or like you're missing something where it's like oh I couldn't really do this captain when Kat and I played at two players we were both able to like complete objectives like jump on two districts Scout do everything that we needed to do and the game still was like oh this is quick like it was so we get flew by I think the point spread was actually pretty close she got up to like mid-30s and I got maybe like in between the 50s and 55 so it was still pretty close like a pretty even point spread so it's it's impressive
because like a lot of Euro games it's just like guys it's just weird that like smaller player counts and even at odd because you how many times that we play the game where it's like man this sucks at three but about that four would be really good no we're like it's like this would be boy better if there was just even Mountain players yeah because it's like the one odd person it's gonna get just [ __ ] on yep and doesn't happen in either of his games eyeless guy is just just as good so cat I'm gonna give it a 9 9 awesome I really thoroughly enjoy it I like the pace I like the fact that like you're very at least I was this time I was very aware like this game does go by quick so every turn does count that's actually a good point yeah like all of his games are very tight-knit like I mean but in this one you don't get you don't get docked you don't get hurt for not being so accurate on it I do like that like this is definitely a light a lighter version of one of his games I just yeah yeah I would say like the only thing like that is you have to be I mean the comparison between the two is you have to be pre-planning yeah every time concise yeah the biggest points that you're probably gain is districts and you have to sit there and be like Kat was like I really need a blue and but she never could get and so then like the alternative is like fine I'll go for this one and and I'll just let me place
it anywhere like if you're not messing with objectives you're you're probably not gonna lose but it definitely helps I gained 12 12 points from these two and 12 point difference would have been 36 yes so that's I mean 46 huh oh no if I didn't get the twelve points I if I didn't districts I'd be down to 36 points which is a 4-point difference instead of like instead of X and that unlocks even checkmark actions which like this one is for coins for two points and Kat had that one for so you can actually get a lot of endgame Vic like like checkmark victory points there yeah yeah but but yeah so that's probably just like Great Western trail you have to plan for Kansas City and keep doing better here you got a plan for those colored objectives to start powering up districts which is once again the whole theme he has a one central thing that's like this is what you at least have to do everything else around that is just bone icing on the on the cake yeah so you had something else I think yeah no I no I don't think so um I like I enjoyed sake games frill good very solid yeah um we've had some real doozies on the channel but uh this is this is not one of them sure yeah I agree and it seems like he liked the companies who publish them are always different Great Western trails stronghold this one is a grits peel I
can't remember who did in Maracaibo but like it's crazy so looking at the scene maybe he maybe he's like freelance and he just like he might hit he might be freelance game designer and he's like hey I have this idea if you guys are going to bond yeah um so he's just that good the weight which is the complexity for this is a 3.5 out of 5 I wouldn't go that high I don't think it's it's over a half I'd probably give it a it's a three maybe two points we might be like the highest I'd give it I probably three or two point five I didn't I would say maybe like the complexity lies in some of like the finer rules like the things that like we have to naturally clarify like oh yeah like in Great Western trail has a three point six nine out of five like that I'd probably give it a three point seven out of five but this I don't think is anywhere near and so this is nowhere near the complexity of Great Western and to put it into perspectives we played Great Western trail and black out today like at the time of this recording we're literally right after one another so it's not like we're pretend like play grey was control a year ago and then we played this one we're like oh no we're like we are very fresh and which one is more complex a lot people say this is bet this has an eight point three it's then number eleven overall and then black out Hong Kong dang it black out Hong Kong has is
a seven point six also best with three so I mean and its overall 566 so I think this one might have flew under the radar and violently like based off the title cuz even I thought it was about spies whenever I first surveyed and it's why you if this doesn't compare to like some other spy games like you said Twilight war whatever Twilight Struggle toilet struggles yeah it's the cold war but it's about espionage or uh and stuff like that yeah so I mean and then Maracaibo which is his new one from from 2019 Maracaibo came out yeah like I said this year and has an eight point three and it's a three point eight seven out of five but everyone's saying this best with three so we have no there's no reference for that we haven't played it but people are saying it's it's heaviest House websites so it's even more calm a lot of people from what I've heard say it's similar to Great Western trail in terms of gameplay so this is kind of this probably flew under the radar as well especially if with that publisher I don't know them off the top of my head right now but I know I know stronghold very well so say I he might just be freelance yeah and he's like he pitches an idea he's like I have this idea for a game who's gonna pick it up who will fund me and then yep so awesome awesome well fantastic eight point five nine and nine very much enjoy definitely check it
out if you haven't it's fantastic especially this designer like he's he's he's really making a name for himself and I very much enjoy his games so that's what thoughts so what you've said so far this is you haven't played a game that you don't like fragged correct I play the Isle of Skye grain with some trailing blackout Hong Kong and they have all been devolved to spin bangers so I mean it's like a fatal sorry the game I'm gonna like jump on it if I can and now it's nice you can pretty much and then all of eagles games I'm going back to buy and play because I'm like well I've loved everything one of them let's just keep going so that's our thoughts on blackout Hong Kong everyone I hope you enjoyed let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like home subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day that's for you hey everyone thanks so much for watching this and if you like this video then click the subscribe button below to enjoy any video that I put out and right next to that subscribe button it's a little Bell click that so you get notified of whenever I actually upload these videos if you want to support the channel you can definitely visit my patreon page the link is in the description below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day of this for you