Skip to main content
Loading video...

Nidavellir Review: Can You Ever Have Enough Dwarves? - By Board Of It

Transcript 11:52

hi everyone tallyanne farrell here from board of it and welcome to our review of needle believe a game full of pubs taverns dwarves bidding set collection and tremendous amounts of fun for two to five players and great for all ages this has become a first favorite with our group so an ancient dragon has awakened in a mythical land filled with dwarfs and apparently that dragon is causing quite a problem so the king dwarf fella has sent you out together the best dwarf army you can find or whoever's left over after your friends offer to pay more than you do which frankly serves you right for being such a cheapskate i hear you're the toughest warrior in all the land we've come to get your help with the dragon we're ready to pay you this all right we'll have to double it i think we've got a team together nida valley is so quick to teach and grasp it's really a joy to get to the table there are three taverns on the table each with randomly drawn dwarves represented by cards at the beginning of each round players will take three out of their five coins and place them face down on their player board one for each tavern then in tavern order

players will reveal their coins simultaneously and a player with the highest bid gets to pick their dwarf first and the person with the second highest go second and so on when you bid a zero coin you then get to swap out the coins you didn't use so you flip them in this case five and a three you add them together eight and then you get rid of the higher value coin and swap it out for a coin of the sun so the goal is to have the most bravery points by having the best army and each type of dwarf scores in a different way the blue explorers score just from their printed value the red warriors work in the same way except the player with the most warrior ranks at the end of the game as the value of their highest coin to the red warriors score the green hunters score the amount of ranks that you have squared the purple blacksmiths score by way of mathematical sequence so plus three plus four plus five and so on and finally the orange miners score by adding up their total value and multiplying that number by the amount of ranks that you have now having heard that you might think that you only want to pursue one type of dwarf and get as many points as possible out of that type but it's actually quite important to diversify because if you get one rank of every type of dwarf you get to pick a hero and these hero cards are an extremely delightful twist on the set collection gameplay now these will allow you to either boost the strategy you're currently undertaking or they might allow you to go down

unseen roots the last things to know about the game are that it's played over two eras comprised of a variable number of rounds based on player count these two errors are virtually identical except the fact they have two separate decks at the end of the first era there are five bonuses available one for the player that has the most of each type of dwarf the thing is gameplay-wise ninja velir is terrific it's fun it's vibrant and it's engaging at the beginning of every round you get this great little burst of strategy as you decide oh what coin should i bid at what's happened for what card what's important to me and then you get all the thrill and excitement of a bidding game as you go to have into tavern and reveal your coins and see if you've won best of all though nobody goes home empty-handed because you'll always get a card and this means that even if you don't get what you want you're not that annoyed and the game moves at such a quick pace that it just doesn't really allow bad feelings to creep in the fact that you can take anira tavern to bid zero and upgrade your coins adds a really interesting twist it allows players to pursue a lot more strategies than you'd otherwise think you could opt for the strategy where you upgrade your coins early on in the game but you sacrifice your ability to be able to choose what you want early on in the game but with the view of being able to select the dwarfs that you want later on in the game or you can start out strong and bid your highest coins from the beginning of the game choose what you want and shape your strategy from the start but that's not to say that you'll always

get to shape your strategy it's rather interesting in this game how you can start out and you say i'm going specifically for this and then the game just pushes you into something totally different because the live the cards and what other players do will always throw a spanner in your best laid plans it's almost as important to see what other players are doing and try and interfere with them as to enact your own plans because this is what will allow you to win the game you'll need to be crafty you'll need to be flexible it's probably worth noting that here the theme isn't really important and we mean that and you could be doing anything it could be that you're picking up breeds of rescue dogs and the coin is related to how late you show up if you're looking for theme to drive the mechanisms then you won't find it here this isn't something we've ever really addressed before as we're usually pretty happy to take the theme of a game at face value but for whatever reason with nina valeer the disconnect seems to really stand out well said though nidalee kind of makes up for it by being generally quite humorous and charming you see you're going to pubs and taverns you're bidding you're flashing coins you're getting dwarfs creating a dwarf team of avengers it all has this comedic edge skillfully helped along by the excellent illustrations and the heroes add further depth to this world as they all have fleshed out backstories written in the back of the game manual and perhaps it's this world building that illustrates disconnect more than other games between

the mechanisms and the theme because usually if there's a pasted on theme there's no effort to make any world building unlike the care that's gone into this the heroes though are a highlight of the game design on show here there are many unique heroes to choose from and always multiple great options to suit any situation that you found yourself in even better you can chain heroes as you get one every time you have a set of ranks in all five suits and some of the heroes come with ranks so you can slot them into your tableau and instantly trigger another hero the best feeling in this game is when you masterfully link together a massive chain of heroes and bump up your score by about 100 from a single bid also just want to give a shout out to my favorite heroes the twerk brothers these are five brothers that work better together and the more you have the more points you score and if you can get all five it's basically game over for anyone else and they're just a really hilarious set of heroes because if somebody starts pursuing them as a strategy everyone else around the table starts sweating because even having just three of them is a huge swing of points and somebody might have to take the gamble and just start buying dwarfs themselves to stop you the length is just perfect too you'll often end feeling like you needed just one or two more turns which gives you that i want to play again feeling it plays in under 45 minutes with minimal differences between player counts which is just perfect as you'll almost certainly want to play more than once it's just that type of game where when

you introduce it to someone they instantly want to play again because it's just that engaging one small gripe is that we wish the suits were more diverse in how they scored you've only got five and two of them score in the exact same way another two are also quite similar because whilst they score differently the end result is the same and you're going to pursue the same strategy with both of them it's just a shame that there's not more diversity considering the low number of suits this carries on to a further issue in that the difficulty of the strategy for each suit isn't equal you see purple and green the only strategy there is to get as many as possible because they score exponentially the more you have but then you take orange which can be quite profitable but you need to have a lot of ranks and you need to have a lot of value and some of the cards only have a value of zero so it's quite tricky strategy especially because it's a strategy where if one or two players take one or two crucial cards for you it can be a waste of your entire game whereas if you lose two purple cars going after the purple strategy really won't matter in the long run this means weirdly that you might have to play offensively in this game and actively take cards other players want we've seen in our games when a player actively pursues the green or purple strategy without any interference they'll almost always win it's become a bit of an issue in our later games where one of the players has wholeheartedly pursued one of those strategies and they outright win with purple

seeming a bit overpowered and it becomes more of an issue at higher play accounts because you play less rounds and you really feel the difference and that means it's even more crucial to get every card you can so it's a really tough ask to get players to give up a crucial piece of their strategy to mindly inconvenience another player who might be on the road to victory but all is said and done the most important thing to know is that this isn't a game where you're going to care so much who wins and loses all you care about is getting to play again because it's so much fun we have one last negative and it's something that we believe other reviewers have also commented on that there might be an issue with longevity with nidavelir whilst you do get variety and how the cards are dealt and how the players bid for what and where the core of the game remains unchanged round to round and game to game the strategies aren't that tough to work out and much of the experience comes from the fun of bidding it's probably one best enjoyed occasionally in small doses although that is pretty tough because it's so damn fun surprisingly natively is great at every play account you'd think that it would work two players being a bidding game but because at its core it's really a set collection game you don't lose too much of the experience of course it is more fun more competitive and more interactive with more players but this is honestly a game that we would keep in our collection even if we knew that we would never play it with more than two players again the main comment to make is as few

around at four and five players it does feel much shorter and tighter still fun but everyone agreed that they prefer it to be the same length as at two or three but that's impossible to do because there aren't enough cards even players that had never played a game at two or three were upset by how quickly the end of the game came around final thoughts knit overlay is a terrific lighter game to add to your collection what we wouldn't say is a must-have and it might have longevity issues you could potentially solve them by grabbing the expansion which might shake things up and to be honest it's got a terrific price point and provides more fun per minute than most other board games the simple set collection combined with constant player competition through bidding culminates in a thoroughly engaging and enjoyable game for everyone if you enjoyed this video we'd really appreciate it if you could give it a thumbs up please subscribe to our channel if you're not already and let us know in the comments what your favorite bidding and slash or set collection games are and we'd be happy to answer any questions about nina valeer as well just let us know in the comments thanks for watching

Progress saved