Skip to main content
Loading video...

Minecart Town Review: The Children Yearn for the Mines

Transcript 10:56

Hello. Welcome out to the Dice Tower. I'm Wendy Ye.

And I'm Chris Ye.

And today we're going to be reviewing Minecart Town. This is by Jelly Jelly Games. Um, and the designers are Shun and Ya from Studio Gigi. And the art is by Saepu.

Sa Beepoo is very, very uh prolific Japanese artist. beautiful cute look to this game about

running a town that has minecarts in it. Oo, and my phone always auto corrects this to Minecraft Town, by the way, and I hate it.

Oh, Minecraft town.

The the auto correct, not the game. Anyway, we're just going to show you how this one plays and then we'll give you our thoughts.

Mhm. In Minecart Town, players are going to be building up each of their own little towns. And in these towns, they're going to be producing goods. They're going to be transporting them along rails and potentially through other building locations and then they're going to be processing them into other goods or they're going to be processing them into points. The game takes place across four different rounds and each round has four phases to it. The first phase is production. So any building that you have that has this little green symbol here is going to receive the production that's next to it. And this is the way that you're going to fill up your buildings. But if you notice, each building has a certain amount of space it can hold. So, it can only produce up to however much it can hold. The next phase is done in turn order. And so, players have the choice of either building something or upgrading track. Um, so when you build, you can choose to build one of these uh either straights or curves from the stack pile and they cost either a wood or a stone or you can choose to build one of these buildings here. We have the basic A or B level buildings depending on which uh set of rounds you're in. And then you have the C buildings over here.

The price is in the upper left hand corner and the benefit is in the bottom right. Some of them are going to have immediate bonuses, some are going to have production bonuses. Um, and then some will have benefits or bonuses during the other phases. The other thing you can do on your turn is to upgrade track. Um, you can go ahead and pay an additional stone or wood and you can flip it over and it now becomes a three-way intersection instead of just a two. Now, the other option is that when you're building track, you can actually immediately build it on the higher cost side paying that full amount. If not, if you're upgrading, you're paying the difference. Resources for building can come anywhere out of your city. You don't have to have stuff connected by track. Um, however, the next two phases will matter where your track is laid. So, phase three is the transportation track, and that is going to be moving cubes around your board to other spots.

Now, any building that is directly adjacent to each other are not considered connecting. Connections can only happen through track. However, you can move through other cities. So, for example, right now, mine and forest are connected, but they're connected because we take this track all the way around through the ore mine and back up to this regular mine here. Now, the point of the transportation phase is that you need to move around cubes so that they can land on spaces that have a processing symbol to them. And that is going to be the fourth phase. So, if I'm going to transfer stuff here, I'm going to go ahead and transfer both of these cubes across this line here. And then maybe I'll transfer this one down here in hopes of processing in the future. Now that transportation is done, I can take my processing action. And what this will do is it will spend the cubes from the place that it's at. Um, and I'm going to be able to trade them in for points. So, I can spend one stone and one coal for six points. As a quick recap, go ahead and produce stuff each round. Then you're going to build all the buildings in the tracks that you want to. You're going to transport all your cubes. And then finally, you're going to process them. You're going to do that four times and then count up all the score at the end of the game. And there you go.

That's a brief overview of how you play Minecart Town. All right. So, starting off with this game. Uh, this is a very slight game for what I expected.

Yeah. I mean, it I wasn't expecting rounds.

Yeah. Yeah, I wasn't expecting like a brass birming or anything like but I love games about building railways and connecting different little things and then oh resource production engine and conversions and stuff like that all sounds very promising. It's very short and you need to know that going into it.

I think so. Um so because you have some tiles that produce, some tiles that convert, some tiles that give you instant uh resources. It's interesting because the ones that produce over time, there's really there's four rounds total and if you don't build it, you know, the very first round, really, you only have three. Well, no, even if you build it the first round, you only have three productions.

Yeah. And

there's just so little.

Yeah. And and I like games that have a quick punchiness to them. I think that this one feels a little short. Uh the actions are quick and back and forth and the decisions of what you're building, they're not tremendously difficult. I like the little building railways and stuff to connect little things. Do I do I spend two to build like a wider rail connection all at once? Maybe, right? But that's kind of like the the realm of decision-m you're having in this game. It's not tremendously wide nor tremendously deep. I actually do think that it's very clever that you can either build a like two path rail or a three path rail because uh you can either do it all in one turn or you can upgrade later so you have a little bit of freedom to change if you want to expand out and you want to do some of the tiles that have endame scoring for stuff around them. Um, but also it's a little bit of feeling out the market because this is one of those games where if the stuff out there you can't afford it and it's not really what you want and you're not ready to pass yet because you have resources you want to spend, you can kind of kind of push your luck a little bit and be like, I'm going to build a small rail and that small rail is going to give me another round and if I have to, I can upgrade it to a big rail next round to give me another round that hopefully someone will have drawn something out of the so that I can get something new.

I think that's maybe one of the biggest downsides of this game is that the market, you're very much at the mercy of it. You might invest in some like long-term scoring thing and you know, you need sheep in order to convert into lots of points and you're just kind of waiting for sheep tiles to show up and you know, if there's not many sheep tiles, there's not a lot of ways to kind of do anything else. Well, I mean, you have to now lean into something else, but you that scoring dial that you might have invested on early to say like, "Ooh, I bet I can make this work. It's It's not working.

The sheep are not coming out." Yeah. It's interesting because I think that they mitigate that a little bit by having you stack the same buildings on top. So, you don't have a market full of all the same stuff. But, I don't know if it mitigates it enough. Um because you have what six letter buildings out in a two-player game, seven or eight in a three and a four player game. Like it's just really not that much.

Mhm.

I do like that the C buildings stay out the whole time so you can look a little bit ahead. Um but yeah, I I almost wish that that you just had all abs and C's so you can kind of progress as you want to progress instead of that hard middle cut where it's like now we are doing very little production and we are moving on to just processing. It's one of those games where it kind of feels like it would benefit from having one of those every player can once a game wipe the market and kind of put out new tiles, right? Cascadia kind of figured that out. Uh certain games like have have figured out little ways. Uh Dune Imperium has one of the expansions and I feel like this one needs it. Uh and it's fine. Everything about this game I think works and I don't have any like major complaints about it, but that is one of the the big things is that oh you're I'm kind of you know I have the luck of the draw and see what happens. Oh, but it's fun to mitigate in those cases. In some games it is more than I think it is in this one. Uh because I also think that the main action driving system of this, you know, is is fine, but it's not it's not really like exciting turns either to kind of spice up those four very short rounds.

I agree. I agree. So, I'm going to come at this with a 6.5. I feel like it's close, but it just needs a little bit more play testing, a little bit more development, um, for it to really get to be there for an approved for me. But, like you said, like there's nothing wrong with it. Everything in it works. Um, I just want it to have a little bit more fun and a little more excitement and a little bit more ability to plan ahead or at least change up that market a little bit. Now,

I'm coming in at a six on this one. Uh, and I know that sometimes numbers don't do a good job summarizing all the feelings on. That's why we kind of explain here, right? Like there is nothing wrong with this game except for perhaps lack of excitement. And so that for me means it's not a game that I'm going to be coming back to nor recommending to people. But if someone had it set up and said, "Do you want to play Mine Cart?" Like, yeah, because it's a quick like 30 minute romp and it it's going to go quickly. It's going to go smooth, but it won't necessarily have like peaks of excitement. Oh yeah, I finally did this exciting thing. Oo, I have these, you know, tough choices to make with a simple rule set. No, you have pretty easy choices to make in an easy rule set. And so for me, that just slides right at a six, right? It's it's fine. It's all right.

Yeah. Well, there you go. That's our thoughts on Minecart Town. Go ahead and share in the comments if you've had a chance to play this and what your thoughts are on it as well.

We'd also like to give a quick shout out to a few of our uh our backers from last year's Game Found. So, first off, we have got uh Mel and Mel and Shi. We have T West Moore. And we have my lovely family.

T West Moore. Hey, what's up, T West?

Well, there's more. My lovely family, Doran, Ellia, and Micah. Thanks for all the games we play and all the love you give me. I'm not sure who this lovely family of mine is, but y'all are fantastic.

Thanks for joining us today. I'm Wendy Ye.

And I'm Chris Ye.

Have fun playing games and riding on mine carts. Hey everybody, thanks for watching another video from the Dice Tower. Hey, you want to learn more about us, communicate with us, we have a Facebook group, we have a Discord channel, lots of different ways to get involved with the Dice Tower. You can find that in our link tree link below. So, just click that and we'll take you and you can communicate with us on Facebook. Join our Facebook groups. There's lots of cool things that you can find and become part of the Dice Tower. Thanks so much for watching. I'm Tom Bassel. I actually really wish that I could ride on a minecart.

Do you play Super Mario RPG?

Yes.

Yeah. That whole mine cart section of it with the mold people. The best.

Yeah. Mario Kart you're playing, but there's like a little mine tunnel thing map. That's one of my favorite ones. It's got really big swooshes.

I like big swooshes. And I cannot lie. Your roller coaster can't deny

when a

mole walks in with a itty bitty

Progress saved