Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beyond Solitaire Podcast 125: Stuart Ellis-Gorman on the Lost Cause Narrative in Games

Transcript 1:02:04

it's adbreak time I'm pleased to announce that the Beyond soliter podcast remains proudly sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through games and simulations as usual they are up to amazing things today I want to especially focus on Damon Stone's upcoming class which starts on August 28th it's called core Loop finding amplifying and refining the fund and it's part of cgs's certificate and applied game design which is made up of courses offered in collaboration with Gen Con demon students absolutely love him and he definitely knows what he's talking about so if you can register for this class you should and soon cgs's latest game 500-year-old vampire has just finished a very successful campaign but if you forgot to back it you will soon be able to pre-order it through backer kit so keep an eye on that page I also want to plug my own patreon your support means a lot to me both emotionally and financially patreon money is what makes it possible to keep improving my channel by upgrading equipment and I'm also hoping to increase the amount of videos I can publish over the course of the next year if you want to help out please head over to patreon.com beon soliter for now though let's get on with the show hey gers this is Liz Davidson from beond soliter and this week on to PO I a very special guest U this is Dr Stuart Ellis Gorman he is a world expert on crossbows and a freelance writer and editor is that about right Stuart I think that's about right yeah I found my Niche and I've carved it at it's crossbows can you carve with crossbows I'm kidding steel ones you know it's not good for it but you could you could have a go uh so we are not actually on the

podcast to talk about crossbows although I promise we will make time for you to talk about crossbows uh but we are here to talk about your current research project so you were an academic like me but you like to Branch out and do different topics also like me uh so what is your current um your current research project and how are you going about it so I'm working on studying the Lost Cause and kind of neoc Confederate ideas in historical wargaming and this is primarily at the moment being done through a podcast series that I'm doing in conjunction with homo luden the YouTube channel the Fred ser uh the podcast is called we intend to move on your works and I'm playing along with my friend Pierre who is uh English and does knows nothing about the American Civil War uh we're playing through the American Civil War roughly chronologically sampling a variety of game systems and designers and scales and so we're doing X encounter we're doing operational block games we're doing strategic games and kind of discussing each game after we play it and releasing that as a podcast and then that's kind of Research Foundation to then write more about it in a more holistic fashion at the same time I'm also reading more books in the American Civil War because as you might have guessed I'm an expert on crossbows there's not a lot of crossbows in the American Civil War uh so my back wor for that I know it's really it's shocking stuff they should have tried it and so my my background my kind of relation to the American Civil War is really deep more in the fact that I'm from Virginia originally and I grew up

surrounded by the American Civil War and in a very uh a society that's really obsessed with it so kind of branching back to my my youth and like interests from when I was young and applying a more academic view to them and then as well then applying them to my hobby which is writing about games talking about games I don't think you can ever escape your past so was your family like a big big like into the Civil War family yeah my dad was a big and still is a big American Civil War buff now I had escaped some of the kind of worst of this and that my so I'm from Virginia but my family is not my dad's from DC so he didn't have that kind of like long Confederate history to bring to bring to bear uh so he kind of still I mean grew up reading a lot of these popular histories from the 50s and 60s that have a very strong strain of Lost Cause in them but not like you know I wasn't grown taught like the South was right you know I never was told to say that the war of Northern aggression or any of that kind of stuff so but I went to American Civil War battlefields all the time as a kid he would drive us to transville or the Wilderness or out into the valley and we went to Gettysburg almost every summer because when we went to family holidays we would go to this up to Upstate New York and we would drive past Gettysburg most of the time so we'd stop in Gettysburg I've been to Gettysburg like I don't know 30 times or something so yeah that that was definitely a very formative experience for me uh kind of and then just in Virginia I don't know what it's like where you are but people talk about it

all the time it's like an obsessive point of conversation so that was also just like in the culture yeah I actually have sort of like a mixed upbringing on that so I I was born in Texas and I grew up in Texas where Texas history is like a big thing they teach it in school but my mom's whole family um is from Newberry South Carolina and so you know my grandfather's a history buff and it yeah so I got a whole lot of like Civil War history talk as a kid but for us it really started to ratchet up when my grandfather did a genealogy project and figured out like he traced our family tree back pretty far it's actually pretty impressive and so you know among the ancestors there's like cool ones like NE of the nine hostages or like you know a Madam he found a Madam in our family tree which I find hilarious um but also he found several Confederate soldiers and he was like way more excited about that than I would have felt comfortable with yeah and uh you know my grandmother was like oh well you could join the daugh da of the Confederacy and I'm sitting there thinking never no no uh and I remember like you know early Beach trips as a kid and stuff like my cousin thought he was really edgy because he had a Confederate flag beach towel uh and I remember my parents feeling uncomfortable about it and like I could tell there was something off I was so little at the time but it's like it's always kind of been branded as like a divisive thing for me because I remember like from an early family interaction that not everybody had the

same response to that flag symbolically and so you know and my grandma definitely said things like the South arising it in college I don't know that she realized what the full running implications of that were does that make sense like if you talk to my grandparents I think it's definitely a common theme yeah a lot of people haven't thought about it or or never or just bought into the fact that it's it's funny or it's entertaining or it's it not really thinking through the full implications of of what this means yes and so how do you um how do you approach that as you as you work on your project because I feel like I feel like you and I have a shared like like kind of personal childhood level tension about this but how do you maintain an academic approach and then how do you talk about this in a way that is as I don't want to say objective because I don't really believe in objectivity but is is as intellectually Fair as possible it's a tricky one so one thing that I think really helps in this kind of through the podcast process is is is working with people who know basically nothing about it so they don't have the same kind of point of reference for me so it makes me feel like kind of nudges me more towards justifying my position a bit more and trying to like explain to them because I think because this is baked up in my childhood and a huge amount of this is personal and that relationship with the kind of the Lost Cause narratives I I don't really want to shed that at all like that's very much part of it and trying to talk about it from the perspective of someone that like didn't necessarily Buy in totally

to the self arise again but definitely I was taught Robert E Lee was a good man as a child you know that was like a lesson that was there I went when I was in the Boy Scouts as teenager I was in The Stonewall Jackson area Council and we had a Stonewall Jackson patch we wore on our arm you know so like this stuff was just kind of around there and you were taught to sing Dixie and all that kind of stuff so y I think that personal is part of it and I I don't want to shed that but then as well like I'm working people who don't have that relationship at all and don't even really understand that perspective so trying to kind of explain it to them helps me better make my thoughts more coherent and I try and also as part of the podcast not assume that you know anything about the Lost Cause and talk about sort of my perspective and why these things matter like in the most recent episode I'd realized that i' talked a bit about like flag symbolism and the various flags and games but I hadn't actually explained why I cared so sometimes it's like it's a work in progress so they'll be like okay look we're going to take a moment and talk about flags and why I care that the Confederate flag is a symbol and and why I think it's a symbol of white supremacy and why we should be thinking seriously about whether we should be including this in our games or not and then if we are including it why it's important that we include the right one and one book I think was really helpful for for this and I would recommend to most people uh was Tai Saul's Roberty E Lee and me which is a really interesting book and I'd say the reason I'd recommended to most people but not everyone is that I don't think it's radical in terms of the historiography that he introduced and it's not really meant to be the big

perspective is that the author himself he was a history lecture I think head of the history department at West Point career army officer but he grew up in Virginia he's from Alexandria where Robert Lee is from and he's like like he went to a seg Academy which I'm sure means something to you but people who don't know it's it's an academy that white kids went to after segregation ended private school just for white people when you know they had to integrate the schools so he was like deep into lost cause Neo Confederacy and came out of it and is now has like he talks about having like you know the passion of the converted when he talks about it so it's a really interesting book for conveying that kind of experience and also for kind of showing so much of why he cares about this stuff like why it matters and that was a really in like you know kind of outside of traditional geography a really useful book for me because like I'm also from Virginia I didn't have it as near as is to the extent that he did but I still did so it was kind of an interesting shared experience and reading about his way of dealing with it was really helpful to kind of articulating my own thoughts also he wants to described Virginians as snobs and it's the truest thing I've ever heard and i' never thought of it before but we are absolutely the snobbiest southern state like oh it's so true we're just like that that makes so much sense it never it never occurred to me but we're such snobs that's funny yeah you know from Texas and people debate whether

Texas counts as the south I mean mixed but I would say culturally generally yes because you could take me through the I mean although you know what the south is one of the most interestingly diverse regions of the United States like I find this topic difficult partially because I really appreciate where I'm from and where my family's from and there's so many lovely things about the the South East chunk of the United States and then we get the Lost CA here yeah it's one of the things that I I try and shove back on it in a few ways that I find very frustrating so there's the kind of description of just like assuming the south is just white people in the south is always a huge problem and even just calling there's a common par to just call the Confederacy the South which isn't really fair because some of the South isn't in the Confederacy I mean that Virginia is but like Kentucky is the South and I would say and wasn't in the Confederacy you know and we can argue about whether or not Missouri is the South but certainly it was a slave state that wasn't didn't secede so there's there's divisions and there were regions within those regions that were opposed to seceding I mean West Virginia is the most famous because it splits and forms its own state but East Tennessee tried to secede from the secession but just didn't have like was too Central in the Confederacy to ever successfully be separated so versus West Virginia could be control by the union and was able to split so there's divisions within that

uh and then as well like one of the things that comes up a lot because we talk about Robert E Lee a lot we talk about the Lost Cause because he's such an important figure in it and the classic Robert E Lee thing is that Lee I mean he quit being in the US Army to join the Confederacy and this is presented as like well when Virginia seceded it was only logical that he would leave the union and he would join his State and fight for them and that he was personally opposed to secession and personally opposed to slavery but he follow his State and that's complete horseshit like he absolutely like several he was one of the few members of his own family that suceeded like his wife was descendant of um Martha Washington so he has this like really prestigious line and then so most of his family stayed loyal there are quite a few prominent like I obviously focus more on the Virginia but quite a few prominent Virginia who do not sucede Winfield Scott the first US commander of overall military in the war is from Virginia George Thomas the rock of chaga who saves the Union Army in chaga and then destroys the union the Confederate Army of Chattanooga is from Virginia like these are the famous Virginians of the Civil War period we should be putting up statues to like these guys are great and they're the South just as much as Roberty [ __ ] Lee and Stonewall Jackson and these other [ __ ] like and like that's to me that's like a really important part of the story and it's we kind of we kind of talk a bit about maybe with somewhere like Kentucky that's famously was neutral in the war or mostly neutral so that has that brother against Brother people go to both sides but like there is divisions

within the South there are Southerners who stay loyal to the US Military and who fight for the cause and there are a small number of Union of Northerners who defect uh although it's less common so it is a little more complicated than that and I think there is a proud Southern Heritage to be had in this context but it it's the people who chose to fight against slavery not the slave owning [ __ ] you make compelling argument sir um but I I I do think that Nuance is something that a lot of our historical conversations are missing um and it kind of actually wants me it kind of leads me around to what I wanted to ask which is so what are some of the games that you've played so far and are there trends that you've noticed and how they tend to present the conflict yeah so we played a a few now we're only about six games in at this point some of them are really long so we started with uh Rick Britain's Manasses which is a classic game from 1980 and it's amazing just like side note if you like hex encounter if you don't like hex encounter absolutely don't play it but that was that was like a surprise pick because my father owned a cop but Rick Britain is from my hometown and it sent it to me when he found out I was playing American Civil War games and I was like well we'll try this first it's the first it's first Massa SPO run uh the game is fully titled Manasses being a game of the battle of first Bull Run so it's got both names in there which I like and it was aming aming like we were absolutely flabbergasted that it was so good so that was great then we played so that's hex encounter we played Shan andoa which

is a block operational war game about Jackson shenoa Valley campaign from Columbia we played uh the late unpleasantness which is kind of an operational game of the seven days battles uh from Compass we played Seven Pines or Fair Oaks which is an amabel Holland game about the Battle of seven pines or Fair Oaks which is a a battle right before the seven days and then we most recently played into the woods and I also played some dead of winter which are both great battles the American Civil War games uh into the woods is Shiloh dead of winter is the Battle of Stones River and then we're currently playing at time of recording Long Street attacks we've skipped forward to Gettysburg because we wanted to play Gettysburg game for the 160th anniversary so we're playing Long Street attacks which is a Herman lman H and then we're going to go back to playing more Shilo games but one theme I've kind of noticed the two the two themes that have really stuck me so far that I'm I'm pondering is first of all like there's a ton of hex encounter which I kind of knew and games don't really talk about slavery you know there's a real deliberate avoiding both slavery as a whole and kind of the political end of the war there are a few cdgs that we haven't played yet like for the people Mark Herman's Big strategic American Civil War game but there very little like engaging with the politics of the war and really kind of trying to zoom in on just these like very specific details that let's you kind of ignore the presence of slavery and like the presence of slavery is I think there's a conception that it's far away from the war in the sense that like you know if

they're fighting in Central Virginia it's the plantations in Mississippi that Slayer the slavery is but like the Confederate Army ran on slavery like slave labor is how they functioned that was how they ran like all their teamers basically are slaves all the cooks are slaves the entire infrastructure of their army is is slave powered and then all the officers and gentlemen who served had personal man servant man servant who were slaves so there's tons of slavery just like just at the edge of your map when you're playing a hex encounter game like where's the base camp that's where all the slaves are you know and that that isn't There's real lack of Desire I think to engage with what the war is actually about which I think is is interesting and a little troubling and then the other one is that there's just way more games in 1862 than I expected we we thought we were going to be well through 1862 pretty quickly and we're just oh there's so many there's so many more games on 62 than there are on 64 which I think is is interesting that is really interesting so actually okay I I I was gonna show you this I had a treat for you a treat H uh in this podcast so I'm gonna read it aloud for everybody who's listening I'm gonna try to share my screen for everybody who is here so I've been I just read Aaron trell's privilege of play and interviewed him about it uh but I linked through his book and his bibliography to a bunch of old editions of the general like the Avalon Hill

General and so can you see this steart yeah so this is volume one number one and I'm just going to draw your attention to this is the first page of Avalon hill hill General volume one number one there is no Mr Avalon nor is there a Mr Hill the very first games were published in a Baltimore suburb Avalon High up on a hill literally overlooking the genal plantation land a picturesque South Baltimore it was there that Gettysburg was conceived labor of love in which the famous Civil War battle was rehashed Time and Time Again by admitted Confederate sympathizers in the border state of Maryland Southern loyalty ran high one of the very first correspondents was an elderly Alabama gentleman who was having the time of his life slaughtering those damn Yankees great I just thought that I would uh offer that um because um you know we talk about kind of avoiding the political aspect of the war and I kind of feel like that isn't no that's just right in there baby and that's that's an interesting because I don't know when the the first issue of the general is but assuming if we're talking about the first edition of Gettysburg that's what 5961 around then

yeah this is May 1st 1964 yeah yeah because it was published um the game itself was published kind of leading up to the anniversary the the Centenary and that's I mean the Centenary is a really interesting point in discussing the history of the American Civil War because it's both a big moment of commemoration and also obviously like the high point of the Civil Rights Movement you know and a real reminder of what the like the kind of current state of things in the aftermath of the war and the failure of reconstruction and it's a real point when I talked about the Confederate flag I mean it's it's a real moment of resurgence for the flag is in opposition to desegregation and civil rights and so a lot of that symbolism of the Confederacy comes what it's kind of not been gone but like for a lot of the postwar period is more more the kind of purview of people like Daughters of the Confederacy and um Sons of Confederate Veterans and them and then it kind of really breaks more mainstream in the 50s and then becomes this huge symbol of opposition in the 60s and I think it's something to remember about when we talk about these kind of symbols in this conflict there's a tendency to think about well you know it was 150 years ago you know but it's like I mean is it like this was it's not the same battle but that's the symbolism and the meaning of that battle were definitely being refought in the 60s and 70s and people were killed like civil rights wasn't just people being rude to each other you know it was white people murdering people like quite quite a lot and

something that I liked about exp mentioning again Robert ele and me He discusses a lot of that Legacy and the kind of places he lived that the lynching history and places he lived because a lot of it reflects on his person he lives he went to Sega cademy in I think in Georgia anyway I think in kind of Central Georgia and he talks about like lynchings in Georgia during this time and stuff and it's like yeah this is like and these people are like they're not that old now like if you were a kid growing up and dealing with these especially because it's school children of a lot of times who are having to struggle through this you know when you look at like people like Ruby Bridges they're not that old now so it's not that long ago and that's just talking about that flash point like there's more more recently that aren't as violent but his history is not done and dusted and it's it's still very relevant so I think when you think about printing these symbols and talking about this history it you shouldn't be thinking about it like what is what did this mean 100 just you should think about what it meant 150 years ago you should also be thinking about what it means now yeah well I mean you know when you're doing history I think including when you're doing a game that is about history you're telling two stories you're trying you're telling what you think happened but then you're also telling something about yourself because of what you think happened in the way you decided to tell it there's always two parallel things happening when history is being done um and so I guess that kind of leads to one of the re I really wanted to have you on to talk about this is so I actually also released a game review on the University of Gettysburg it was of in in magnificent style uh

which I have by the way sent to your your box in the United States so have fun um it's a great game actually except that it's about it's about pick it charge uh and you know there's like lots of like heroic action kind of cards and so I just couldn't get out of the Lost causing of it enough to f enjoy it I released a review that I actually thought was pretty polite I literally just said like I don't feel totally comfortable with the subject matter like I'm not saying the game shouldn't exist or that you can't make a game like this it's just I just can't pass this um and people got like pretty upset like I got a couple emails that were just like oh you know this is just a game and you need to quit bringing politics into games and you know people can play games about whatever they want uh is this a respons that you're getting to your podcast like I never told anybody they couldn't play this game we definitely got accused of being w wargaming at one point I think I think we haven't been too mean yet but it's that might change with some recent episodes where we're gonna we're going to be a bit we're coming after some some more popular games because we really liked the first couple games we played so I think that's uh like Manasses and shann andoa we both really really liked those games so I think that kind of thre people off and then um we got yeah we got a bit of negative response to the late unpleasantness particularly when I I spent some time talking about the kind of troubling nature of that name the naming of the American Civil War and the tendency in certain parts of Neo Confederate and Los cause areas to call it the late un pleasantness the war of Northern aggression or the war between the states or that kind of thing uh so

we've gotten a bit of backlash I think we don't quite have the audience yet to get to get a really big backlash but I do expect that we will we will hear some of it and we we kind of expect that people will not like what we have to say uh particularly I think we've got I've got a small little pile of consolo G games where you play the Confederacy now to work my way through and I think that will be uh unpleasant for me and will not yield positive response from some people uh and I actually wanted to kind of ask get your thoughts on some of the comments that I I got because I think you're doing a version of this and you're gonna have to answer these questions too so I got several comments in I think some of them started out not well meaning but they turned into good conversations some of them were really honest questions too like you know there's people who want to be mean on the internet there's people who really just have a question and you know there's nothing wrong with engaging um but I got a couple versions of you knew the subject matter you knew you might not like it why did you choose to play and review it then and for me I think it's important to intellectually engage with things that make me uncomfortable and figure out why that is and like kind of you know just because I don't like it necessarily doesn't mean I should give it the time of day but you're doing an entire project on something that causes some profound discomfort and so like why and what are you getting out of it that's yeah it's an interesting one I I mean I do I think it's really interesting to intellectually engage with this and that's part of when I talked about this being like I'm not

trying to be really objective about it in a sense like I'm trying to apply good historical methodology and and be clear but like part of this is is self-interrogation and so I do think that's interesting to like pick apart these designs and be like but why do I find this uncomfortable or why does this bother me or what is it about this that I find so troubling or is there something in this like I see it as troubling and someone else doesn't and I really want to explain to them why I see it's troubling but also I don't feel like I can do that unless I actually engage with it like it's harder for me to I could tell you why I think Solitaire pickets charge is a bad idea but it's I think if I've really Enga if I've shown you that I've really engaged with it and that I've really thought about it then my argument holds more water and I can be more specific I can talk about like why specifically I can talk both in the general and in the specific about like why is this bothering me but I also like I pick my battles like I have an invested interest in the American Civil War and this I've you know to some degree I'm doing the self-interrogation anyway about like how do I relate to this conflict and what do I think about it and what is my history with it and so the games are kind of another Avenue for that like I have no intention of like finishing this podcast series and then doing one about playing Nazis in World War II absolutely not I'm just not doing it and I don't want to engage with that so like there are there are areas where I'm like really happy to engage and I think it's interesting and they're like this just makes me extremely uncomfortable and I don't want to play Nazis and like a lot of world I don't

play a lot of World War II games in a large part because a lot of that like when I particular when I'm playing something like strategic level I'm just like where's the Holocaust I don't want the Holocaust to be in this game because that would be also awful but at the same time I can't stop thinking about why it's not in this game and that just means I've spent like three hours thinking about the Holocaust and I I don't study genocides for a reason uh I find it too like I have nothing but respect people who do genocide studies but not for me that is too Hardo um but yeah like that's that's kind of broadly it and I think part of to kind of one thing that I was reminded of when you're reading this excert from the general that kind of kickstarts a lot of these thoughts in my head is I moved to Ireland when I was 18 and in Ireland and the UK as well Yankee is just a shorthand for American and as a fellow Southerner even if you're Texan I think you can appreciate that being called a Yankee if you're from the south is an insult like and it's particularly like I don't in Virginia we like we're snobby as I said and we would have chip on our shoulder about other parts of the South not thinking we're really the South like North Carolinians call us Yankees to insult us it's the whole thing so like I'm now living in Ireland and they don't don't mean it that way they don't know but I'm like so I'm being called a Yankee and I it's like triggers it's like this is an insult part of my brain but then I'm also like but I don't want to be called a Reb like I don't want that that's that's a whole I don't want people to be like no you're not a Yankee you are a Reb which is like kind of the default alternative and I'm like that kind of gets a whole series of like

self-reflection spiraling where I'm like oh I don't want to be a Yankee but I also really don't want to be a Confederate what does this say about me and where am I like I I think can tell you how contrarian I am and actually how much my father was so I'm from Texas my dad is from Odessa Texas and he grew up like watching baseball in an era where there's only so many Channel like so many teams that you can see on TV and you just kind of pick a team and that's what you have so uh you know I cheer for the Braves because live in Atlanta but just freak out everybody this is gonna be the most controversial moment of the podcast I'm actually a Yankees fan and I have been since I was like a child I love the Yankees I always will um I will always cheer for them whenever they are doing you know whatever it's the game with them and I wonder now if there's a rebellious young man reason why my dad liked the Yankees so much and then passed it on to me because you're right like it's definitely not always nice if a southern person calls somebody a Yankee um it's kind of interesting and actually you know you brought up another thing I wanted to touch on so I'm going to circle right back around so such a good guest um so you mentioned you know you don't even want to play Nazis and I totally get that um I play a lot of World War II games um I do not enjoy playing the Germans in World War II but like I will like I covered an Eastern Front game last year um I you know I looked at campaign fall blow from catastrophe it was a good game you know

it's a little I do feel like mild discomfort when I'm playing German generals but I thought it was a good quality game um you know I I mean I'm doing night witches right now of course like to drop bombs on Nazis in that game so that's that's different um but you know I had people also in the comments of my G review asking like well why is this topic going to be the one that bothers you so much like I guess you better not play any World War II games then I guess you better not do this like how is this any different in fact how is it any worse and that kind of attempt to put it all on the same scale I thought was really interesting but the reason I thought it was interesting is you know I don't think that there's anybody who's going to look at you dead in the eye and tell you that they think that the Germans were on the side of right in that war they might try to give you like a clean ve mocked myth or they might try to say well not all Germans meant it which but um you know there's I feel like with Civil War games there's a bit more of a well are they really bad at all though were they really wrong at all though like nobody's going to generally I've never seen anybody try it tell me that the Nazis weren't the bad guys guys and I I feel like there's an amb sort of actual neo-nazis yeah and you kind of hope you can spot them indeed and I think yeah a lot part of that as well is just I mean everyone's perspective is GNA be different and where you grow up is going to influence that and like if you grow up in America then that history of the

Americans of war is so fresh and particularly in the South but not like universally in the South and I think everyone has to be aware of it I mean you see the arguments about Confederate statues going on right now and they're not calm or passive debates you know these statues aren't that old and they commemorate like you know it's like if we were having arguments in Germany about Hitler statues and you know statues to goals and these kind of people and like there's the very little of that stuff remains any of it that is still in Germany or Austria was put up during the war like I remember I was in uh Austria one point I saw there's a stained glass like Cathedral window that was put up by the that had like Nazi imagery in it that was put up by the Nazis in the I think the early 40s and they had left it but they had a bunch of notes around it being like this was literally made by the Nazis and we didn't want to tear out the stain glass um but like that's not kind of the same level of context you get for these kind of statues of like equestrian hero statues of Confederate generals and that memorializing of them and that nobility of their cause and this kind of like symbolism of the Confederacy being like kind of an ultimate Underdog that is struggling against the oppress Ness of the US government which then channels into a lot of like current political sentiments where like you know the idea of opposing big government being inherently Confederate and then it's and like it's it's something you encounter outside of the South you know like there there are a surprising number of Confederate general statues in the midwest so it's it's a broader American issue and that I think makes that

relation much more intense in some ways than like something like yeah like neo-nazism or Holocaust denial which is fringed crazy person like you know if you meet someone like that you just walk away versus like your dad might believe that the Confederacy had some good points you know like in a way that if you meet someone who's like well I actually think Hitler may have had some good ideas you're just like nope done with this conversation absolutely not we're all gonna make you a pariah and we're gonna walk away um Neo conf federa ISM doesn't have that I mean there are extreme versions of that like there are definitely levels of Neo ISM that can be like okay that's a bit much but even like dressing up like a confederate soldier and marching around the streets of Richmond is like eccentric not like vile in in popular kind of culture like if you met some like I would not be surprised if I met some elderly friend of somebody's who's like yeah on Saturdays I dress up like a confederate soldier and I hang out in front of the Confederate museum in Richmond Virginia be like okay okay that's weird but we're all talking to you like you're a normal person great all right so you know I think you're right that we would not necessarily have the same kind of value judgment of um of someone who's doing like Civil War reenactments it's actually pretty common in the United States especially in the South um actually Confederates in the Attic was kind of an interesting book about that if you have not read it it's about have not I should though yeah it was

actually pretty entertaining read and kind of interesting look at the whole thing but um does that I think that does also translate does that seem to translate over to games or we just try to like I feel like there's a school where you're supposed to just be game to play anything in a board game and not see it as that big a deal like is that a vibe that you get from our community as well I think so yeah at the very least like I think there's an acceptance if you're like if you say I don't want to play War Games people would be like okay but once you're like game for war games there's an expectation that you are up for literally anything that's in the wargaming space and that at even if you don't want to play something it's entirely up to you to self self- police it like you just you can't criticize something unless you play it so like it would be much more valid for me to criticize like the Russian campaigns you know representation of the East Front Logistics because I don't think it Maps strategically as well as this other game that I like versus like if I'm just like I think it's gross that these front games don't include war crimes but also I don't like playing war crimes people would be like well you're not really one of us so your criticisms are invalid yeah yeah I mean I'm personally the belief that it's not so much that a topic should be off limits because I and you know I'm very anti- censorship of any kind my parents are media retired media like I'm very much for like you're free to create the

art that you want but we're also free to comment on it uh and so I guess this leads me to you know what would make a civil war game responsible in a good game like what are you looking for like I I mean I'm assuming that you're not of the school that no Civil War gam should exist no I think the American Civil War is too important to not to not include in this and I I don't think it's undeserved particularly given the publishing so the Civil War is like the second most popular subject in all war gaming um and and the kind of the originator right we talked about gettysb earlier the original Avalon Hill Gettysburg is the first historical war game of the modern ER anyway so I think particularly given publishing industry is American pent it's logical that the Americans Civ war is a big part of that and I think it is a useful way to kind of work through a lot of these issues and it's not even like a lot of my problems with the game and it's a little bit of a flaw in the podcast I found uh because we we're doing it on a game by game basis is that like like I love the game Manasses I think it's a really great game I think it really does a lot to cover like the experience of green soldiers being put into battle for the first time the chaos of these wars you know like I think it does a really good job of that it doesn't tackle the political and my problem is more not that like a game like Manasses exists but that like the overwhelming majority of American Civil War Games feel like they're this kind of purely Battlefield tactical not dealing with the political

side of it and I think that to me is it's a lot of like what's your coverage and what's your your what have you choos chosen to represent now there are games that I think are probably genuinely not great ideas and I I'm not happy that they exist although at the same time like I'm not a publisher I'm not stopping you from publishing these games I am going to tell you I think they're a bad idea but that's you published a game I'm I'm well within my rights to do that I think what we need is more games that really engage with like what is the what's the war about what's the political side of effect of these wars and one thing I think is really weird about these games is that they take a really kind of purely military simulation like the idea is that the key to winning the B this war is is winning battles is kind of the idea they give you like it's all the military and they leave out the notion that like really the way the Confederacy was going to win was the death of political will in the north and that was always a concern for the North like the idea that people would just decide they didn't want the South anymore and it wasn't worth all this death and money and like we have to remember like the north is really quite racist as well at this time they don't really care about slaves they don't like slavery and Institution for the most part but they don't like they're not like deeply invested in liberating their black brothers and like elevating them to an equal status in society that's not what this war is about to them to most of them anyway I mean there are radical abolitionists who who had that view but they're very much a minority and so like the political will is such a major factor of this war if Lincoln loses the election in 1864 it's very possible that

they form a peace treaty and the South remains a separate State you know the Confederacy becomes a legitimate government and that is not an element I really see represented in games it's not an element of like what does that mean like what is what is the actual political bu and some of that would involve kind of you know discussing the fact that like you know the north isn't perfect you know they do hold a lot of these quite deeply racist SYM these are not as bad they don't have you know slavery but they're not we're not dealing with slavery we're not dealing with the political side of this War I don't feel like we're actually a lot of games deal with like what is the war about what are the stakes what does it mean what is the overall result what does the end of slavery look like what does it look like the passage of the the post Civil War amendments the 13 14 15 amendments like all of this stuff that's really kind of essential to the American sort understanding of it is kind of left and instead we get tons and tons and tons of really detailed like battle games and I like those games I enjoy a lot of them uh some of them I enjoy significantly less uh but I think there's this tendency towards extreme simulis and the idea that like to understand the American Civil War is really to understand like how far could you move in a turn what is the command structure of the Union versus the Confederate Army how does the what's the deciding factors of these battles who are all these generals you know like that kind of rivet County nitty-gritty detail and not the bigger questions of slavery and politics and the elections like my don't know if I'll ever actually

do it my idea of like a game that I would love to see in this kind of space would be a game that's just a political game of Elections between the Democrats and the Republicans in the north between 1861 and 1864 and you just have like the Confederacy and the war is kind of abstracted out so no one plays the Confederacy no one you don't have to and it's instead it's just like it's basically your your Democratic copperheads who are trying to fight to end who want to win election and sue for peace to end the war and Lincoln and the Republicans who are trying to hold on to power because things like I mean the 1862 election is as important as the Battle of antium to understanding the outcome of the battle and the Battle of anum's Victory feeds into that election and helps the Republicans win you know their midterm election like the war is radically different if the if Lincoln does the second half of the war with the Democratic Congress and we kind of forget that like the US political institutions that at least As Americans we all know so well you know midterm elections presidential elections governor elections senate elections all of that still functioned in the war and all of that was high stakes and I think that kind of thing I would love to see a game that's just about that and it's all about like if you have to get Lincoln reelected in 64 or else you lose the war like because in a lot of ways that's what it's about and the war is there to impact fortunes and to you know kind of winning battles is good for you losing battles is bad for you you also have to contend with the fact that generals had different political parties is a huge Factor about like the entire Legacy of General mlen kind of only makes total

sense if you also know that he's a Democrat and that Lincoln firing him would be seen as an extremely political action and you know that kind of tension is as important to understanding his military career as his inability to win battles and I I feel like that's missing and it's not that like I need every game to have that but when there's so many games I need some of them to have it you know and right now it's like basically not there at all and that very frustrating to me I'm happy to play a LX and counter war game about the American Civil War but I also want this this political stuff that really feels like it engages with the material and the history I think he rais a really good point there that it's not so much that any one individual game is quote a problem I mean I'm sure individual games can be in fact a problem but um it's more like looking at the discourse of the games they're creating together that internal conversation and playing a lot of them and looking at them as a whole that kind of reveals where the lack in our communal conversation about this is yeah I think so and I think we see that a lot like I mean this political element I also think I mentioned I think there's so many more 1862 games which I think is partly just reflection of like how many battles there are and that kind of being a high point of the kind of kinetic Warfare and we don't really talk about 64 there's very few games on 1864 and like there are games you know there's so many American Civil War games is going to be G on almost everything but the scale of it is radically

different when you look at stuff when you're trying to find I been finding stuff for the podcast like trying to find games on 64 on the Overland campaign and that I think also partly reflects this notion of like Gettysburg is the turning point of the war and that like 64 it's kind of all done by then which is not true I mean like the Overland campaign was the highest casualties of the war and those cases feed into Lincoln trying to run for election in' 64 and needing military victories to kind of secure that and important to remember like you know in 64 I think the last US president to win reelection was Jackson so like it was far from guaranteed that Lincoln would win you know like two-term presidents were like a thing of a previous generation so that element of like the war is still going and the Confederacy could still win because all they need to do is get peace is missing from that kind of narrative and instead we kind of battle like it it's all that military H buildup of battles and then Gettysburg and then the kind of slow tail end and that's not really what the war was like and I think that that imbalance in the types of games that are being made kind of reinforces this narrative and I don't I don't love that yeah yeah I also think this actually is deeply connected to some of our larger Collective conversation about what is a war game and what counts because what's you know having come off the Charles S Roberts nominating committee and like been through people's discussions of like what is a war game during the golden geek Awards this year and everything you

know the game that you're describing about trying to win elections during the Civil War era and like abstracting the conflict I think is a that sounds like a really interesting game to me I would play that in two seconds and then I would turn around and have to argue with people about whether it counts as a war game even though it's still very much about a war I mean Wars are not only one on the battlefield they're one in the ballot box and in the logistics train and like you know there's there's just so much else going on in a war other than like the kinetic part um and yet we don't necessarily like that and I think that get politics out of my war games and it's not about kinetic conflict it's not a war game are weirdly connected is that a is that something that you see as well yeah I think so I mean that that that overemphasizing of like just the the detailed kinetic tactical or operational Warfare and not or even like on a strategic level like you don't want to factor in anything but like the pure military considerations without really a regard for like what does what does actually fueling a military engine look like Rec saw someone called this argue that polus wasn't a war game and I was like but it's a game about the pelian wars how is it not a war how you fight each other you send armies like it doesn't have a lot of the mechanisms of a traditional war game but like it's a game about a war like much more so than like we can argue about I I mean I think votes for women totally counts but we

can argue about like well that's like a political conflict like this is literally game about pelian wars it's it's got Wars in it what what's on what are you on but because it doesn't have like it's about like getting grain and supplies and the kind of economy of a war people don't consider it like a war game or some people don't and it's yeah it's insane to me this kind of Nar definition I subcribe to a very like genre as meaningless and should only be used to help you guide your own personal tastes and like the purpose of genre is like you know votes for women is a war game because if you like cdgs you'll like votes for women and that's the purpose of genre is to help you identify like things that are like things you like and that we shouldn't dig too deep but I appreciate that's that's a little more out there than some people are but like I definitely think yeah like if you made a game about if I made a game about elections in in the 18 or 1860s people would be like oh that's just like a politics game the same as like tamy Hall I be like but it's about the American Civil War this is what besides the war is the elections that's like the key factor to the path to Confederate Victory isn't actually that he's that they're going to defeat the Union Army it's that they're going to the the elections will turn against Lincoln and I think part of that is to get back to the Lost Cause a lost cause perspective of like it's the Lost Cause the the defeat is inevitable yeah because if you view it in purely military logistical conceptions I mean that notion that the union has has more men the union has more industry and that eventually the crushing weight of that will destroy the South or the Confederacy really uh is

kind of baked into that notion but like that's not really true because I mean yes the union has more industry and it has more people but it's only if it can bring all those to bear and it has the political will to do so and invading the south is extremely costly in both and the real path to Confederate Victory is in eventually degrading the political will part of this as well is the problem that that's not exactly how Robert E Lee fought the War so there's kind of a buying into you can't have Lee did no wrong and also we should have just fought a like Guerilla War of Attrition because like Gettysburg doesn't really make sense if you're I mean it kind of does but also kind of doesn't if you're those Northern invasions are much more contentious if you're really just trying to defend against Invasion interesting so I have a question for you if somebody is listening to this podcast there'll be people who listen to this and turned it off like five minutes in uh and then maybe somebody is listening and feeling uncomfortable but curious um about about what we're saying what is the next thing to kind of read or look at if you want to if you've maybe like grown up with a lot of loss cause narratives and you don't necessarily see anything wrong with them at this time but you want to hear what what our side of the of the line is is thinking I think like really useful book particularly for your average War gamer demographic uh is the one I mentioned Robert elely and me I say the average War gamer demographic because I think the thing that's really useful about Cid's perspective is that you know

he's a white Southerner who grew up deeply entrenched in this stuff and he's really walking you through his childhood how he got into it he talks about like childhood books that Rober Lee he read how he got kind of I think like it removes some of the guilt of that I think it can be a tendency to feel like if you grew up in a lost cause kind of environment and like I mean I did to a degree um when you're kind of confronted with how bad that is you can kind of you don't that criticism can kind of feel like you're being criticizes the person or that you you're a failure of person or like you know someone's calling you racist can kind of make people kind of clench up and it's I think a lot of it is to recognize that like the culture around you is what instilled you with this like it's not if you grew up in a lost cause kind of Southern environment um it's not necessarily your fault that you believe these things uh because that was what you were taught by the people who you were told to trust and the people who you know like I mean I was taught in school the Lost Cause like by teachers I was then thankfully untaught it by another teacher later uh but like in Middle School I was taught that the American Civil War wasn't about slavery right like that's and that's like that's my teachers though I've been told to trust telling me these things are true and it's very easy to just have kept believing that like if I hadn't done apus history and had that teacher maybe I wouldn't have been untaught that fact and I would just believe it and I think the thing I like about Robert Lee and me is that he's you know way deeper than most people are going to be like particularly in this podcast I like most people who listen to this did not go to her segregation Academy did not like

choose their University because it's the university that Robert E Lee was president of you know like like he's he's in deep and he talks about that experience and he talks about coming out of it and the problems with it and I think that relatable element of that narrative is really useful the reason I don't recommend it to like everyone is I think it the strength the points he's making are very standard for like what's in the historiography so I think if you are coming at this as like particularly a white man from America I think that his perspective being relatable is the key point of what makes it good but like if you are you know a black Southerner you might not need that you probably don't need that same perspective like you have been taught a very different version of History you've experienced a very differ history and so maybe somebody like WB Deo is a much better read for you for getting like that kind of Reconstruction Era history because he has a much more relatable perspective and he's going to be raw in a way that's much more relatable to you and you don't need that white guy talking you I mean it might still be interesting because you're gonna you get that perspective of how these people live but I think there are other books that would probably work better um but for certainly for me as someone who's white Southerner uh like Rober is great if you're looking for just kind of General histories I mean the battle battle C Freedom by James mcferson is still a great book it's super super super long and is a little bit old but I think has it's kind of the current standard General history I have a book on my shelf called armies of Deliverance which is meant to be a really good update and

kind of a a shorter uh I think only like 450 Pages history I haven't read it yet but I'm really looking forward to that another one I'd recommend that's a bit more narrow focused but I think is really interesting is um searching for black Confederates like Kevin Levan which doesn't really he addresses this popular myth that's really emerged kind of in the 80s and really through the 90s on the internet age of the idea that there were black soldiers who fought for the Confederacy and it's very popular you'll see it on internet discussions it's a really uh common myth in Neo Confederate spaces and he does a really interesting job of like unpicking why why it doesn't make sense like first of all going through like the history of slavery in the Confederacy during the war the use of slaves personal slaves in the war where these ideas come from and then like how this myth was formed the kind of period of the kind of memory of being a slave during the war and Camp slaves and like there were people who were former Camp slaves who went to Confederate veteran reunions and stuff and like this really complicated history of of remembering the war both like you know as one of these former slaves and as the white veterans and how this was commemorated and then eventually into this no this modern search for this idea of black people who fought for the Confederacy which you see in stuff like Gone With the Wind this notion of like I mean like I think there's a line where one of the slaves says we're going to go out don't worry we'll get we'll whip those Yankees kind of thing like so that that idea and the ways in which it subtly changes so I think that's a really interesting

examination of the changing narrative over time and is a really interesting read and is also much shorter than something like battlecry Freedom so that's one those those are as as any academic I've been asked for recommendation and I've given at least four EX because why would you ever recommend one book and then I think maybe the most important sum up question before we go into some softy stuff is just so you and I both have troubled relationships with this history but uh would you say that your project has made you appreciate the Civil War more historically as an event I mean I guess like does does does having that troubled relationship prevent you from being really into the history thinking it's okay for other people to be really into it you know that I think that we always have to kind of draw that line between like yes I have emotions about this but also I think it's really worth my engagement and I'm glad I'm doing it yeah I'm very happy I'm doing it I think it's been really interesting kind of because my engagement with the American Civil War was stuff I learned in school going to battlefields just kind of like the general Vibe I'd read very little actual books in the American Civil War which is unusual for someone like me who reads loads of books and everything um so like really digging into the history and stuff has been great and it's gotten a lot of those like those really interesting personal stories and and narrative moments and stuff like the American SE war is really exciting you know like there there's load and like that's something I think I've done a good job of conveying to my various co-hosts is like this is this stuff is interesting it's exciting there's really

interesting turning points and like narrative beats and stuff and it's also about something that's quite difficult to engage with and those can both be true and like you can have the excitement of D-Day and the Holocaust and you can have having to engage with difficulty of slavery and the horrors of you know and things like the horrors of Andersonville prison and also exciting battles and heroic charges and you know all this stuff and that that is part of what makes history interesting and I think having a personal investment is a really normal thing to have in history and it's about being aware of it and you know like I like I don't know a lot of the historians I worked with like during my PhD and afterwards like if you ask like who's your favorite medieval King they would tell you and they would have a strong opinion about who their favorite medieval King was or who their favorite Med like such and such was they don't study Kings or politics but like like there's a very like strong personal investment in this material and I think that's fine and that's why you're doing it because that's kind of what carries you through from Beyond just this is kind of interesting too I'm going to spend years of my life doing this but you also need be aware of it and kind of it's balancing that kind of awareness of your own personal excitement and also like treating the material with objectivity but I think if you really care about it then you care about being honest with it you don't want to buy into a lie or a falsehood or a uh a

negative problematic belief like if you really really care about it then the truth of it matters I think that is a perfect place to stop this at least chapter this conversation I actually would like to check in with you when you're further along with your podcast and I'm going to go listen to much of these now uh but now it's time for softy questions which uh so what are you playing for fun right now is it all Civil War stuff or uh it's mostly Civil War stuff right now uh I'm playing I have antium 1862 from Worthington which is a fairly light hex encounter I have the main battle for that set up upstairs but I'm almost finished playing that solo um I most I play a lot of hex encounter stuff solo and I quite I like it and then I'm currently playing with my podcast opponent Pierre we're playing Long Street attack still and then thing I'm most excited about is that I I finally think I have an RPG group so I'm gonna play some role playing games gonna have like a regular role playing session so that's not GNA be American Civil War themed uh so I'm really looking forward to to playing uh some RPGs again and I got to play a one shot at the weekend so that's kind of the most exciting thing for me um and then I'm trying to organize a game of successors the from failinks the fourth edition of the old Richard Berg game so I like big multiplayer cdgs big fan of here I stand so I recently came into a copy of successors and I'm going to try and see if I can organize four people together to spend a day playing playing some uh Alexander tomb carrying that sounds fantastic honestly and then if people want to follow your

work or you know reach out and ask questions where can you be found online yeah so I have a website Stuart Lis gor.com that's where my blog is where I publish articles I do a lot of written reviews I write I review the books I read so you can read a lot of written reviews of the kind of civil war books I read and then lots and lots of books on 100 Years War which is my kind of current actual research project besid out of gaming and game reviews and I repost the podcasts and stuff on that and then I'm also on Twitter at Dr crossbows it's Dr crossbow and I'm on other media but not as active and I'm also on various uh Discord servers mostly the homo Len's Discord server which you have give Fred Ser all your hard-earned money to join but if you want to hear me rant and Rave you can come and come and join that community and I Pierre and I actually stream our games on that Discord server so if you're really really interested you can come and watch us uh fumble through the rules some of these games until we till we learn them uh we usually play like once a week on the server fantastic yes I also have been suckered into giving money to Fred Sur um so if you're not giving to my patreon but you want to give to somebody do give to Fred he is fantastic um and uh yeah I'll put all this in the show notes I can be found anywhere online as Beyond soliter obviously and steuart thank you so much for coming on I really enjoyed being able to have this conversation with you I'm excited by your project and I just really wish you the best and that it's very fulfilling and interesting um all throughout thank you I think it's G to

be it's G to be good I think I'm going to go a little bit insane when I get to the solitire games but I'm sure you'll hear all about that as I complain to you about them Perfection all right and so for those of you who are out there uh please like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy gaming

Progress saved