Skip to main content
Loading video...

Compile vs Radlands - Which is Best? Cardboard Kombat!

Transcript 34:19

Hello and welcome to B stupid. My name is Matt. Time for another episode of the cardboard combat. Insert coin. Press start.

Get over here.

Round one, fight.

So, on this episode, we are going to be seeing the differences and comparisons, pros and cons for Compile versus Rad.

Yes, cuz you guys asked for it and uh we deliver. That's what we're doing. So, you hit the subscribe button if you haven't done it yet. Uh, let us know in the comments which one you want in the next episode as well, but we'll talk about these two after the jump.

So, Matt, why have we chosen these two games to enter the arena of Cardinal Combat? Well, let's say that um these two games like compile especially is been very hot last year and he entered both of our like top 40 games, top 40 whatever it is. Um and he's a is a spectacular lane Butler.

It really is. Yes. Uh but my heart is with Rottland cuz Rottland was the original like not the original L butler but it's um it's the ones that like I always loved

and it also blew up the industry when it came out as well. Radlands came in again these two games are two lane battler games. They have some really interesting overlaps. Um the idea of course where you're fighting across three areas same in Rad Lantern Compile. They also have a fantastic table presence, the two of them, which is really cool as well.

They also have some interesting and similar uh design ideas at the start. You are doing a draft for sure in both of these. You're drafting camps in Radlands and protocols in your pile. And also you have this kind of strategic protection of your cards. In Radlands, you're protecting your camps, but in compile you're protecting your cards by going underneath the protocols. So, really cool stuff going there. They they go they are similar but very different and we going to basically decide which one wins this fight.

Absolutely. Should we start with one? What one we starting with?

Let's start with Ratland. So let's start talking about the first fighter in this uh in this battle that we said is is Ratman. So Ratlance 2021 by Rolexi Roxle. Why I keep saying

Rolex Rolex mate. by Roxley. Um, this version that you see here and you see the picture is the deluxe edition. Uh, the normal version comes like less than 20. Uh, the difference between uh this version and the other retail version. This one has u the the chunkier uh chips in terms of like the the the resources chip, the water chips, and uh it has indestructible card. At least that's what they say. But they are basically waterproof cards and uh I can tell you they are because I I took this around with me a lot of times and they're a lot of pubs and

Yeah, absolutely. So yeah, production wise in this particular version amazing. This is Roxley's, you know, top tier production stuff.

So let's start with the pros of Radlands. Uh and I think obviously I think a very obvious one is the table presence of the cards in this game. The artwork is absolutely top tier regardless of what version you get. I mean the deluxe version you get these wonderful synth cards which are amazing but the artwork is some of my favorite in board games. I think it's absolutely fantastic.

It's it's the things that um at the start when the game came out I was just like what is that with all these neon colors and everything. Um then um yes top top there is not I can tell you now that that part of the fight There is not. Yeah. But this lens for me wins with with so many other games. It just like it's one of the most beautiful

looking game. It's a stunning.

Um that's that's be if you're lucky enough to manage to get the um the playmats as well, go for them. You're not you not be disappointed. Um so the game itself um let's talk about the like older lane battlers than than Radland Spurs. Um I'm thinking something like Aland and C. Um with Aland and C where you need to put like like in compile more similar to compiling that where you need to put uh numbers against certain territories. Um, what Rundlands did is kind of like took away that part of the of the game. And basically, you still got three lanes that you need to fight for, but you need to do damage to the to the people um uh bases. And how how you do it is you need to play cards in front of your bases in three different lanes to protect your own base. And each one of the character you're putting down on in front of them will have certain power that will let you do damage to the other other players um character or to their camp or launch raids. The raids is like the this event section that you can do in the in the game as well where there are some events cards going into an an event pile and each round you you advance the the event until it triggers and the events can be the raid where you can do damage to the camps without without um possibility for the other player to to do anything about it. Uh or

atomic bomb that destroys everything on the on the theater. There are a a multitude of of that. The game itself is pretty easy to understand and to and to play. You got uh three water that is the is the resource at the start of every turn and each cards will have a cost of in water and each character has abilities and the camp's abilities that you need to spend water with. Simple as that.

So, let's talk about the water because this game has an extremely tight resource management system. So you have three water each turn.

You've only got a limited number of cards. You'll start with a bunch, but they'll quickly go away.

So every single decision in Madlands is very tense. It's a very like ah gosh, which what do I do with this card? Do I spend it for its effect? Do I play it in front of my camp? Do I um discard it? Do I spend the two water here? Do I spend the water using my camp's effect? Everything is a very tight decision that leads to a constant sense of tension, which I love in this game. very of the most powerful card or abilities will cost you the entire three waters that you got. That means that on that turn that's the only thing you're doing.

You can mitigate that by spending the cards, discarding the cards for the B. So the cards are multi-use. You can discard them. There is a little symbol on the top left and you can get that resource or that do that specific action. For example, you can discard a card to get in a free water on there for that turn or discard a card to do a damage to another another character or to launch um a raid depending on what cards you got. But the card as well are a very limited resource cuz uh you will start your game the camps that you select during the draft at the start of the game will tell you how many cards you're starting with. Uh so initially immediately you got the two players my star one with four cards and the other one with zero cards. Yeah, that is a possibility. Uh it's really hard to do and then each turn you can get you will get one card and the and and the three waters back. You can spend water to get more cards, but cards and water that go alongside to being tied in terms of like

super tight. Yeah, super super tight. Um, let's talk about the interaction then because this is also another big pro for Radlands is the fact that this is a proper slugfest. I mean, it's the same with any of these two-player type jeweling games, but this is a really high interaction kind of a mean game where that very mean.

Yeah. Where you are smashing stuff, you're, you know, destroying your your opponent's best laid plans. You're setting off crazy events. It's a very highly interactive interactive game. But I think that yeah, in a positive way, this is a really true back and forth battle.

Yes. The the things that makes it this um uh is more interesting for me as well is the fact that both the players shares the same deck. So all the all the cards that you picking up during the game are in a shared deck. So it's kind of like lack of the lack of the draw, but you will see the same character. You will have the chance to have the same things that the other player has. The only asymmetric things will be the starting camp that will have special action that you can do. But for the rest, it's just like how lucky I'm gonna be. But as well um you will know what the what the other people what the other people

the potential they have because it's the same potential that you've got. So it's a real like fairly fair back and forth. But there is a lot of uh take take that in the same like all right I'm discarding this these two card that creature that costed you all three water last

but then it's just like I'm discarding two very precious card to do that thing and kind of like maybe that was your plan for me to to stall another turn. There is there is strategies uh especially on pushing the other player to use resources and and cards to do to do actions.

And the final pro that I want to cover before we move on to some of the cons for Adlands is that variable setup that you mentioned Matt. We've got the shared deck which we'll cover in a minute. But also the more important thing I think for the pro is the fact that you have so many camp cards that the variety in how you set up is absolutely vast. You've got I think 34 in the base game or at least. Um and so your starting hand size as you mentioned your starting abilities is going to be different every single game.

So uh the game uh in the rule books there is a uh preferred like uh camp selection and the games tells you like use this six cam three and three to start the game. So it's that makes the games a little bit more um balanced. uh when you go into the drafting version of the game, that is the like how the game is is supposed to do. Uh you're taking like a certain number of camps from this stack of and uh it's very much like I'm taking this. Oh, you took the then I need to take this away from you. It it takes a little bit more like knowing the game. Um, but I think you can always play like as well with just picking up blindly the just and seeing what happens.

Exactly.

If you want to learn the game, if you wanted to get into the game, then when you're really good at it, the drafting is really cool again because there's so much variety that god knows what's going to come out even on the on the draft. So, um, yeah, that's I really enjoyed it.

Absolutely. Should we go on to some of the cons for

Yeah. What what what you were thinking?

So, I think you mentioned one already that this is a shared deck. So, I think one of the cons for me would be that this is a little bit luck of the draw where of course for both players it's luck of the draw. But when we're comparing both fighters in this instance, Radlands versus Compile,

you are relying on getting something good from the deck and it may not interact well with the things that you've already drafted. Yes.

So, that's definitely something to consider. So naturally, if you've got a string of bad or duff draws in a row or very expensive cards, then that's going to be pretty hard to deal with.

Yes, if you get in if you just need a certain card at that point to win the game, so to not lose the game and you don't find it, that's that's it. But I will I will spin it around um saying that that makes the game faster.

It does. Uh because you can you can get rattlins down in like doing a game in 20 minutes. Sometimes even less, sometimes a little bit more, but usually 20 minutes is the is the what takes you to play a game and to start again with different camps and hoping for uh for for different cards. It's um it's a con

when you say when you say like like that. I do agree. Uh but it's a pro as well for something for the speed of the game. game definitely has an inbuilt timer to it because of the way the rating works etc.

Well, we'll see later, but um um compile might drug a little bit sometime.

Let's also talk a little bit about the fact that because of this shared deck, there's slightly less in the feeling of true asymmetry. You do have some asymmetry, but it's really not the same as some other games in this space where you can really get a feeling of what I'm doing is very different to what you're doing. It is very, it can feel a little bit well, we're playing the same powers against each other, right?

Yes. Yes, it is. Beside the camps that again, you got those like three powers that you can do is it's very much the same.

Again, spinning is less less asymmetry or true symmetry. Uh, but on the other end,

you don't need to know everything about the other player. like

in um in compile again if the if you never played with um those those other three protocols that you're going to use you have no idea what those decks are going to do. So this adds uh a little bit more balance in terms of like the knowledge of the game.

Yeah. And I think with that as well, Radlands um has got a tighter rule set which is I think you know in general it does there slightly less in the way of FAQs or like weird abstruse rules which is good in terms of getting it to be played quickly and understanding it but it also gives slightly less scope for like crazy interactions or like very unexpected plays.

Yeah. So, uh this is something that um the the guys at Roxley sorted out as well with the latest um um expansion that is cult of chrome. Uh that basically what they did they uh swapped some camps for the for for new one not new ones revised ones. They added some new some new camps and they did a a fantastic things with these like stickers that you put on your rule book where they basically tweaked some of the rules or or simply explain them better to avoid some crazy combos that you could do in the original game. Again, we're talking about you can do those crazy combos if you are an expert game that knows exactly what to do and you draft exactly those camps. is for the majority of the people it's not going to happen and if it does happen by by chance

you're getting smashed in 10 minutes then you can play another game with another with another camp but yeah the rules are pretty tight very well explained the rule book is couple of few pages fantastic and um is is super tight and with cult is even better I think

even tighter okay Matt should we move on to compile let's go

okay the second fighter entering the arena in Cardboard Combat is the new cube

to the throne. Yeah. Combile this beautiful uh cube of of beautifulness.

Uh this is main one, but there is a new version as well, but it's it's a standalone expansion which Matt's going to bring here as well. We have main two, too. So, there's loads of different stuff here.

Yeah.

But the two version, the two games are Yes. You say standalone expansion that you can mix and match. mixing and match because the particularity of this game is exactly mixing and matching.

In each game, the players will select three protocols. The protocols are the territories that you will need to um to defend and at the same times each protocol will come with a set of cards. That sets of cards once you select all the three protocols that you want you those are going to form your deck. So you're taking those three mini decks, put them together, and that's going to be your deck for the rest of the game.

First first big difference is the decks are completely as imagined because the other player cannot select the same protocol. So will be completely different. Each one of the protocol has a certain way of playing the game. Some of them are more destructive. Uh some of them are more um fast, so will let you play faster card. Some of them will do like crazy debuff to the other player or crazy buff to your own player. That is is is all for you to discover because there are at this point with the with the two version uh I think there are 24 in total including the mini expansions um that you can all mix and match. Uh they're very cool in this kind of like AI. So it's basically compiled this um the team is like competing AIS.

Fair enough. I I do like it that it's more cyber punky. They could have make it with another fantasy team. Yeah, I I think that is is pretty cool that they did this um this cyber punky cyber funky feels.

So yeah, this is a what I term to be a Smash builder. I love that idea. It's super nice. And because of that, one of the big pros of comb is that you have this massive deep combo potential. the ability to take two protocols which will focus on different areas of the game. They could be drawing cards, they could be burning cards, they could be doing damage, they could be moving cards around, whatever it is. Um, they are all quite different and part of the love and the combo potential and the strategic potential is about smashing them together and trying to work out how can I make these two concepts work well. Yeah, I think that's super cool because a lot of the game is about triggering and re-triggering effects based on covering and uncovering cards. And there's so much with that map.

Yeah. So, in terms of like the the game play, this is very much now we're going we're going back to a classic lane battler like a land and sea. So, in each lane at this point, you fighting lane by lane. Uh you will need to put the majority in that specific lane to be able to compile. That means like conquering that territory, win the lane.

Um uh and how you doing? you you're placing cards of different value on on each one of the region. Whenever you reaching 10 points in your lane and you got more than the than the other, you win that territory. H So, we're going back to a more classic view like London Sea when it's purely like putting numbers down. But this one with a a few twist, not just not just one because each one of the cards will usually have two to three different um activation.

Yeah. Different effects. Some that stays for the rest of the game until that card is not destroyed. Some that will happen as soon as you play the card. Some will happen as soon as you put another card on top of it. So, um the the the rules there getting a lot of bend because the interaction between them are quite a lot. A card might tell you, all right, you can move this card from this lane to another lane. And when you do it, you move into another lane and the lane that you say is like, oh, if you put a card here, destroy a card from the from the from the other side of the

when a card is destroyed. This will happen and then move it to here and then when this moves, it's trigger something else.

So that's why it is it is a more complex game in terms of like rules. The rules are pretty simple in terms of like the uh the structure, the concept of the game is quite simple, but the interaction and

it's it's a little bit more complex. That's why there is like

13 pages.

Yeah. It's that you can also get from this game. So, one of the big pros I think is that depth, that endless depth I feel like between the interactions and with that depth and with the different um protocols from

comes of course with massive amounts of replayability. I mean, I know that you obviously Radlands has lots of replayability, but I feel like that's taken to the nth degree with the different combinations in compile.

Yes, Compile feels more like a competitive game. feels more like a games that probably there are already like there are tournaments like almost it feels more like almost playing Magic the Gathering while Rattlands has kept that ball game feeling of all right it's a one versus one game you play 20 minutes fair enough that's I got blown up let's play again this one this game is more deep you can you can really go into which protocol works which um in the in the proper version of the game on the pro version of the game there is a snake um draft snake draft. So if I see Wayne has got the uh the metal and the and the whatever

and I know that there are cards that combo together. I either need to get the the third piece of this puzzle away in the draft or I need to take this or that protocol that I know works better against that. So that is that is pretty cool and that makes it like a um a competitive game. When it came out like first things that I told you when we started playing it's just like I feel like I'm I'm playing Magic.

Yeah. It feels like you're playing competitive Magic. But what is a great positive about that is you have the feeling of that sort of competitive collectible card game but with a very low overhead which is you buy a box.

Yes.

And you get that feeling in this. There's no spending tons and tons of money. Yes. Massive.

Yeah. Exactly. It's another one uh original netr runner style where you get in a box with all the cards in it. You build a deck that you want and then you play with your deck and you can use the same box to play with two players. You don't need each player having a box. Yeah, absolutely that.

All right, Matt, should we talk about a couple of the cons for compile, shall we?

Yes. What What are you thinking? I got I got go got a few.

Okay. Well, I think what do you want to start? Let's start.

I think let's lead off of one of the things that we we've mentioned a few times, which is because of the massive depth, the complexity, the rules, interactions, the FAQ. Um there is a lot that you could get wrong or there's a lot to try and understand. Now, I think you could quite happily play this at a casual level and not really worry about it. Yes. But if you want to play again like with a more like an intense game, then you need to understand the timing effects and the way that things interact and don't interact and reveal and cover is complicated. And like I said, it necessitates a 13page FAQ to really get the grips with everything. Um, that's a lot, man. I mean, I feel like it's a it's a woolly rule set.

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. you if you play the game a lot, you will start recognizing the rules and and know exactly how they interact with each other, the timing of each one of them. Uh but it's the same things of playing Magic when it in in the good and the bad way there are so many rules interaction that if you miss one of them or you don't understand it, you kind of like not ruin the game because again, we're not we're not playing the compile world cup for money. Uh but um but kind of like you miss part of part of the game. Um it's at the same time. Yeah,

this is a good and a bad things at the same time. Um if you Yeah, if you want to play pretzel and beer, fair enough. They're just like there's nothing there's nothing wrong with that. Just crack on with it. You can just be like what this rule does. Well, let's say that it does this. Fair enough.

Yeah, the the rule sheet such that it is isn't super detailed. So you will miss a few things. But for a game that comes out and 6 months later they need to issue a 13 pages um FAQ is it's quite a lot. But that means as well that the the people really received this game in a very

positive way

very positive way and they just just want clarification to play the games a higher level

as you like at the at the under%.

Yeah. Yeah. 100%. Uh let's talk also I suppose one of the cons when compared to Radlands is the theme is much drier. So, yes, this has beautiful production. They are great looking cards, but it is like an abstract mosaic compared to Radland's incredible artwork. It's not, like you said before, it's not really close in that fight.

No, it's it's it's a beautiful product,

but it doesn't come close. It doesn't have the same table presence.

Exactly. It's just like you don't really have any artwork. this

uh you do have a UI of the cards that are really really well made, but then you got a background for the card that someone could say is AI.

Exactly.

I mean, it's not it's not really you don't have any characters in the um in the cards. Um, that is that is a little bit of a negative, but again, there is so much text on the cards then that you need you need to

it needs to be clear because every card has a ton of text,

but a little bit of fl extra flavor would have been would have been would have been great. Yeah.

Uh, the final one I've got on my list is that I think you mentioned it already um in our prehow conversation is that compared to Radlands, there is no kind of internal timer in compile. So, if you do have a back and forth game, it might drag, especially when you're playing with the control piece. The control piece is an additional rule that is played as like the advanced game. Uh, which, you know, I recommend you play with it. It's really cool. Um, but if you are going back and forth with that, the game will go to 45 minutes.

Yes, it's a way it's a way longer game. Um, it makes sense because there are more complex rules, more more rules interaction. It drugs a little bit. If we got if we are at the pub and we just having a point and going never happen but but if we were just to have one point I would not tell you to start a game of compiler. I would say let's play let's play rap's more likely. Um

also table wise compile can take quite quite larger a larger presence but um it can drag it can drag especially to um uh

similar ability players maybe or

yes it it

yes it can drag cuz it just like I know what you're going to do and

you know what I'm going to do.

Yeah. You know you know my protocol. I know your protocol.

Let let's see who's got it. at the end you might need that you need that last point to finish and it's a back and forth. I remove a car that had the car remove a car that had the car. So it's uh it can drag a little bit more. Um

it's a bad thing.

Yes. If you don't have enough time it's not a bad thing if uh if you do have the time.

Yeah. The end game when you're fighting over the last lane might grind for a few turns while you're like grinding. It becomes very chessy in the terms of like I know what pieces you are, you know what pieces are. Yeah. Let's see who's make the first arrow basically. Um but yeah, let's start. Let's let's go now and do the to the clash. Let's see. Let's do it. Let's do it.

Let's do it. So Wayne, which one between Compile and Ratlands wins this episode of the cardboard combat as a car one versus one card game ish lame butler ish.

Oh my goodness, it's such a tough decision, Matt. This one is even harder than our first first episode. Um, on three. Should we point to the one that we won?

Ian. Okay. One, two, three.

Okay.

All right. Interesting.

Yeah. Give me your reason why compile over rat lens.

And and before we say it, I I just want to add they're both the same price point. So you are around the 20 mark. So as well they are very similar for that as well.

Yes. I mean this is a really really hard decision. Um Radlands I think is absolutely amazing. I mean this is just by a hair's breath. I there's something about the sort of the smash building nature of this game and the fact that there is this kind of endless depth between the the protocol concepts.

I love that idea so much. It sort of gets my brain going in a really cool way where I'm like, I'm going to pick this and this and it's going to be completely different to what you have here.

Right. So, it's going to be completely different to what you're playing. We're going to be playing almost asymmetric games. I love that sense of like almost true asymmetry in that way. And there is so much depth that you get in like a deck of what do you make like 12 cards? Something about 18 cards I think it is. Yeah, it's there is very little that you actually have in your deck. It's a very thin deck, but the amount of scope and depth in that I think is absolutely tremendous. I think it is quite a phenomenal achievement that Michael Yang has achieved with this game. That's why it still remains one of my favorite two-player games. I think

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

But that's not to say this isn't top of tier.

No. Yeah. Exactly. So I I do agree with all with all you said. Um I feel to me rap lens it gives me more uh of a ball game feeling.

Yes.

So um I will say that compile is is to me is more like a is a competitive game.

Uh while Rutland's got more like the ball game feeling. Uh while compile I will put it in almost in the bracket with yeah with magic and rat runner. Rutlands goes into into the ball game feeling like

okay other

even like a land and sea at that point because it's it's slightly more um uh simple uh but with with storytelling attached

with storytelling attached. So that's that's why Rattlands and on top of that artwise there is no like there's no magic about Ratland is one of my favorite like art design like in board games like general not just the the two players or car or car games.

I feel like Radlands is kind almost feels like as Simon friend of the show uh this is like an arcade game. It feels like it feels arcadey is more of like a simulation game. So, it feels like it has this arcadey punk rock like like kind of vibe.

Yeah. Toss some coins in the machine and have some fun.

Yeah.

I'm gonna fight you. This one is a little bit more sit down and think about it.

You know what I mean? Like really like crunch it out. So, I would say if if you if you don't know which one to pick or which one to pick first or you got one that you you want to ask about the other, I would say if you're looking for something competitive, yes, like you are um you are a magic player and uh you want to introduce your partner or your friend to something that is a slightly less than that but gives you that kind of feeling, compile is your game. or if you're a recovering magic player comp. Yeah. Um instead, Ratland is more of a of a 20 minutes madness with the other with the other person. So where you do have a a little bit of depth and strategy that you can add, but there is that elements of u of the lucky

Yeah. tactical chaos.

Yeah. Exactly. But as well in 20 minutes you're done in dust and you start you you will for sure wanted to start another game. I'm not sure if you're getting your back kicked in compile you want to play immediately after

maybe have a drink in between.

Yes. But rat lens I will I will uh trust me if even if you lose very badly in the first five rounds the first things you're going to say is like let's play it again.

Yeah absolutely man. I think you've summed it up greatly actually for the the type of player the type of gamer. Uh this will kind of hopefully give you an idea of which one would be for you. So that was this month's edition of Cardboard Combat. What two amazing fighters, some featherweights in size, uh but heavyweights in content.

Yeah. Yeah. Fantastic games, both of them. Uh we do love both of them and we will keep playing both of them in the in the right occasion. Compile for the more competitive even think about it for a while. Heartlands. Let's have a laugh and let's play something that is fun cuz that's that's but they're absolutely great. But we want to hear from you guys which one you think is the true the true

champion of the lane battling featherweight

between these two again late battling with kind of like Rattland's moving away from that specific lane. But yeah um yeah it's that they're really good. I want to hear you guys what

let us know in the comments below which one you think and also go on

and also let us know which one you want to see in the next in the next

Let's know what's what's the next match up.

Yeah, we we are rolling this with your suggestion of what you guys want to see. We already got um a couple of other ideas but vote it down below which one you want to see. We are ting up all the boats and uh we'll see next month which one comes. Uh but as well once you've done that you can check out the patre page.

When you check out the Patreon, no combat required. It's a friendly community over there because when you click the Patreon page, you'll get access to a bunch of stuff including monthly updates, a special exclusive monthly video podcast with me and Matt. As well as that, access to our super secret and super lovely WhatsApp community who are absolutely amazing from which we do uh personal meetups as well with everybody where we do some stuff just for patrons and as well Matt the monthly giveaway.

Yeah, exactly. So don't miss out the chance of winning a game for the cost of a coffee.

Yeah, £3.

Uh make sure you also if you can't do that, please subscribe.

Hit the subscribe button. Thank you very much. Yeah, absolutely

appreciate that. Check out the rest of the videos. We'll see you in the next one. Yeah. Next one.

Sh. What you should see

Progress saved