Skip to main content
Loading video...

Goa - First Play Review

Transcript 15:56

Hey there, I'm Jonathan with Getting Games, and this is my first play review for Goa. Now, what you're going to see here was a segment that was recorded for the Patreon subscribers of this channel, and you can learn more about joining in on that by going to gettinggames.com/support. Now, what you're going to see here is me talking about what this game is like to play, while I also discuss how it was played. Now, if you enjoy this video, then please click the like and the subscribe buttons down there, and if you played this game in the past or just have thoughts about this while you're watching, then please leave a comment down below. Okay, let's jump into it. The very first thing that I want to say is, just to clear the air, I did make a sponsored quick play video for uh Goa, for the new version that's coming out from Quined Games, and Quined Games is a long-time client of mine. So, obviously, I'm very biased, so keep all of that in mind as I continue to talk about this game. So, it's currently on alpha on Board Game Arena, and I was able to get this one played with two of my friends, uh Anastasia and Taylor, and both of them had played Goa before, but they both played with the original version rules. So, in 2012, there was a reprint, and they changed the rule for one very important element, which I'll be talking about soon, and it was interesting to see them kind of grappling with playing this game with the small but very impactful rule change. So, let's talk about how this game works. Now, it might not look like it, but the heart of this game is tracks. You've got these five tracks on your board, and it seems like, I've only played this once, but it seems like the vast majority of your points, probably every time you play this game, is through moving your tokens down these tracks. Now, you're going to be playing the game over eight rounds.

You can see a little tracker right over here. And within each round, there are essentially two main phases. The first phase is an auction, and it's an interesting spatial auction. Each player is going to be putting out these tokens. One person's going to put the first and last token down, uh and the first token has to go adjacent to a tile. You could see this was placed here. The next person clockwise puts their token down with the next higher number. So, a one was placed, then a two, and this had to be placed adjacent orthogonally or diagonally to the first one. Then, the next player had to put a three token down orthogonally or diagonally adjacent to two, and finally, the one goes down, once again, next to the three. So, these numbers are the order in which we are then going to be auctioning. We move into the auction, and we do this one first, then second, third, and fourth. So, as you are choosing where these go down, obviously, one at a time around the table, you are really dictating what the options will be for the people after you in turn order. There were many times throughout this game where I put a token down onto a tile that was okay, but it forced the next person to go into a tile that they really didn't want, and I didn't super care, so I decided to choose it in such a way to kind of make life harder for the next person, which, you know, I like doing in these kind of games. So, then we get to the auction, and it is a once around auction, and I love once around auctions. Like, as soon as I hear that, the first thing I think of is Santiago, which is a brilliant game that I love, and this game is similar but very different. So, if I put this down, let's say, right here. I'm the blue player. There we go. So, I put this down right here. What that means is I don't do anything at first. The person to my left is going to make a bid with their money, then it moves on to the

next player, who can either bid or pass, and then finally, in a three-player game, it came back to me, and I can either accept their money, so they pay me, and then they take the tile that I put my token onto, or I could pay the bank one less than the highest bid. And this is the key rule change from the original version of the game. In the original, you paid one more. So, that's a pretty gigantic shift right there. Uh it doesn't seem like much, like just, I guess, uh two money different, but it it really had a ripple effect on the game for the people that I was playing with, because um you know, obviously, in a three-player game, there's only two people bidding, essentially, and then one person deciding. So, you have situations where you, as the not auction person, want to bid higher, so that it's even more expensive for the auction person to just buy it at that discount, but if you're playing with the original version rules, I can imagine it's a lot easier to push that person into a situation where, like, okay, fine, I'll just take your money. So, it seems like when the new edition came out in 2012, and again, this new new version uses that same rule, um for some reason, the designer felt like they wanted to push people buying their own tiles more, and again, I've not played the original version, so I don't have any insight here, but I can imagine some things, and one of those is money leaving the system, because after we move from the auction, we're going to do this auction for every single player, then we're going to move into an action phase, where players are going to take three actions, one at a time going around the table, and you're going to activate these tracks on the board that's in front of you. Let's go ahead and zoom in a bit. And when you do an

action, you have six options. The first is the boat auction. You look to this track, and you're going to gain boats equal to wherever your token is. In this case, I would get three boats for that one action. If the token is up here, I'd get one boat for one action, so way less efficient. The second option lets you gain resources. In this case, I would get two resources of my choice, and those resources are placed up here. Now, these are depots that you actually win in the main auction out here on the board. You could see there's a whole bunch of these depots out here. They get really big near the end stages of the game, and when you buy them, they come with a resource on them, but once you spend that resource, it's empty until you activate this action to get those. Next up, we have money, and this is what I was getting to just a minute ago. For an action, I can make 10 money. At the beginning of the game, it's four, so obviously, it's gotten way more efficient for me as this game went on, but if I take this 10 money, and then I bid on something, and then you accept my bid, and I give you that money, the money isn't leaving the system. So, I do wonder if perhaps the designer felt like they wanted to motivate money to leave the system more, as opposed to people just having more and more and more gigantic stacks of cash in front of them, because it only leaves when somebody buys the tile for themselves and sends that money back to the bank.

I'm just guesstimating here, though. So, the next action is here. This lets you draw exploration cards, and these are really good. Uh we have a hand of them down here, and you draw them randomly, and they could do very strong effects. Also, they give you end-game scoring based off of set collection. You want lots of the same icon. It's a little palm tree right down here. Finally, wait, no, I lied. There's two more, but the next one is this one that lets you get an outpost, and this is a contentious element. For this one, you're actually going to draw random cards from this deck right here, and you're going to look to the uh contract value in the bottom left. You don't keep them. So, in this case, it has a three, but it could also have, like, a one, as you could see down there, and you're going to add to that uh a base value based off of how much you've upgraded this column, and you can also discard the contracts in order to buy these outposts, and you put them here. So, these are storage places for resources that you can get without an auction.

Also, these score, like, the first one's one point, the second one's two points, the third one three points, and the winning score is 39 in this game, so these could be decent points as well. The final final action is uh probably the most important, and it's where the rubber meets the road in this game, and that is moving down the tracks. It doesn't have its own track, obviously, and in order to do this, you have to pay the resources and ships for the next slot. So, for example, right here, uh right now, if I did a boat, actually, I get three boats, but if I move this here, I get five boats for one action. That sounds great, but in order to move this down, I need a white, a yellow, and a brown resource. I don't remember what they are, sorry. And each one of these has a boat icon in the back of them. You have to send each one on a boat back. So, that means this is going to take an action, three boats, and these specific three resources from your depots and your outposts that you have already acquired. This does give you points. You jump from three points down to six, so that's great, and you get more efficient. And this is why you're trying to do everything in this game, essentially. Uh this is the reason they have resources. So, when we go back to the auction, there are some uh tiles that are like one-shot effects, like, you just get some stuff immediately, or you could use them once per uh round. I got one that gave me one of these for free every round near the end of the game, and uh it ended up being pretty darn clutch. But, realistically, this game is about getting resources and getting boats to move these down, so that when you do actions, you get more resources, boats, money, cards, and outposts to hold your resources, so that you can move these tracks down, so that you can

get more. So, this is the cycle, and uh when you look at the game on the table, it seems like there's a moderate amount going on, but realistically, I wasn't expecting the set collection to be baked into the sense of progression in this game, at least going into it, cuz I've heard about this game for years and years and years. It came out in 2004, and I've been kind of curious about it. And when I finally read the rules to make the sponsored video, I was like, "Oh, that's really fascinating." And then playing it, it was pretty darn interesting. So, as you could see, I went really hard on the boats, and later on in the game, I was able to get my boats and my resources and my money all here. I think I got the boats down to the very bottom, actually. So, I was really invested in taking action to get boats, taking action to get resources, uh taking action to get some money to win some auctions, and then spend those boats and resources to move down, and then rinse and repeat. Get some more boats, get some more uh resources, but do it even better this time. And uh the person who came in second place was Anastasia. She ignored these first two columns entirely, for the whole game.

And instead, she focused on the uh exploration cards and the uh outposts, moving down these two tokens here, and she also increased her money quite a lot. And when the game ended, I did win, but I had a moderate asterisk. There was a rules uh misunderstanding when it came to the set collection. I think there's a very real chance that Anastasia would have won this game if um that had been cleared up. It would have been incredibly close if that had happened. And it was really cool, even just when the game wasn't done yet, and we didn't know who was going to win, we could tell that we were just neck and neck, and it was interesting to see, like, I was going for what seemed like a more obvious strategy, like, you need boats and resources to move your tokens down, so I'm going to go up the tracks that give me boats and resources more effectively, so that I can move down the tracks with boats and resources. It just that seemed straightforward to me, so I went for it. She ignored those, and instead was drawing so many of these uh these cards every single round, essentially. She was drawing tons of them, and they are really strong. They give you massive discounts. They let you get rid of things you don't necessarily need to get things that you really need and at the end of the game they could be worth a pile of victory points for you as well.

So it was cool to see her piecing together a totally viable game plan using these cards and then obviously I getting these outposts. I think she got three out of the four. She could have gotten the fourth but there was something else that gave her more points that she went for right there at the very end of the game and it was interesting to see that. Also she ended the game with five cards in her hand because that's actually the hand limit. When you take this action the number of cards you can hold it goes up. However, I never took this action the entire game but I ended the game with seven cards in my hand because you only check the hand limit when you do this action and so I was getting these cards through tiles on the board and like I said I picked up a tile later in the game that I could just use. In fact, I think it's Yeah, it's right here. I won this auction that let me once per round use it to get one of these exploration cards and this is in the third to last round. So I used it in one, two, three rounds. So I pieced together more exploration cards than she did for end game scoring which is funny cuz that was the thing that she was focusing on. It was just It was kind of a a funny thing that that worked out as we were playing and it was really fun.

Like I very much enjoyed this play. It took probably about two and a half hours but we were taking our time for sure and it was my first time playing and they were both knocking off a bunch of rust and really reeling from the the difference with the the way that you actually pay things. Like again, it just seems like two money it shouldn't be that big of a difference and in the later stages of the game it was not that big of a difference. We were like winning things for like 15, 19. We're having like 60 money at one point and then spending it all but in the very beginning stages of the game even one money can be huge and we were you know buying our tiles quite a lot so that meant there was I guess less money in the system as we were going on. So yeah, I'm I was really intrigued by this game. Obviously I've not played a physical version of this on the table just yet but I'm hoping to get a copy of this one from Quined Games. Again, super biased. I made a sponsored video for this one but I really found it fascinating. It it has some vague hints of Santiago at least when it comes to the once around auction and how painful those could be but Goa doesn't have the shared incentives.

Instead Goa has more of that progression euro arc thing and this spatial element is fascinating too. I could see one game playing very differently from the next. Like I said, Ines went really hard on these tracks over here and it wasn't because she was like, oh this is what I want to do all game. Maybe she wanted to but a main reason for it was in the early stages of the game she got the pink and blue resources. So those were the tracks that she could go down and then she kind of decided to cycle in on those. In the very beginning of the game I picked up a spot that gave me the brown resource and I did that specifically cuz I figured getting money is probably good in a game that's full of auctions and so I went really hard on this early and I did get a random exploration card that gave me a huge discount to get this down to the eighth money spot very early like long before my opponents. So I was able to get a lot more money than them which felt really strong until I realized, oh right. I get that money and then I pay them and then they have that money. So it's like I get this benefit early for having a better money engine but then it goes out into the ecosystem, you know, if I bid, you know, 10 or 11 in the early to mid stages of the game which feels like a lot and they say, sure and they take it. Well, okay.

I guess I uh don't have that money anymore and now they do. So that money that I spent that effort bumping up the track went over there. It's just kind of a funny thing. So I don't know if I can really dig too much deeper into this one after playing it just once. I'm quite curious to see what this would play like with four. There would be one more auction happening. There's also like I said the first player gets to do two auctions as opposed to one for everybody else and you're actually auctioning off the first player token to get an extra action. There's There's a few other little things I didn't really want to go into the details of but I think there's a reason this game has been reprinted a couple of times or it's getting this new version that looks great in BGA and I had like it looked great with the the prototype that I had here on the table when I filmed it but of course at that point I hadn't actually played through it. I was just kind of mock playing with the with the video. So yeah, that's Goa. I hope to have more opportunities to play this one in the future.

It's definitely crunchier than I expected. I remember when I first learned the rules I was like, oh okay. That you put a token down to set the auctions once around auction, cool. Take these actions. They seem very straightforward. This probably won't be more than 90 minutes. Well, I'm sure you could play this game in 90 minutes once you're experienced with it but the ramifications of your decisions are pretty significant. In fact, now that I kind of wander around in my brain a little bit it reminds me just a little bit of the crunchiness of Concordia and probably lots of other games that have set collection but you know, Concordia is a very straightforward game like in a lot of ways like very easy to teach. The game could just flow, flow, flow and then somebody does the Mercator action where they are buying specific resources because they have very specific goals that need exactly this and this and hold on I need to make sure I have enough money and I have enough resources to do that. This game feels kind of similar not for a specific action but more for the general actions you're doing like getting the depots and then I guess doing the resource action to make sure that you do have all of the specific resources and that you have the capacity to hold the specific resources for the plans that you have. So I guess this is kind of standard crunchy euro set collection kind of thing which I do enjoy. It's not my favorite thing ever but I think this game does it in a really good way and also I just like doing things more efficiently. So I really like that seemingly again the main thing that's going to give you points. You get points for cards and for these outposts but the main thing it seems like you get points for are these tracks is the thing that makes you do things better. So many euros like you do stuff, you build stuff, you get stuff,

you spend it for points and then you do it again and you get points and my my credo is that points are boring and so this game was able to wrap all of the points up into interesting things that I would want to do anyway and I just think that's cool.

Progress saved