Skip to main content
Loading video...

Mansions of Madness Second Edition Review - Oozingly Good

Transcript 16:40

it started one dreary afternoon when I received a mysterious phone call the sky was gray like the blankets they give out at homeless shelters I searched for a phone box to return the call but I couldn't find one anywhere I searched everywhere without luck it was like trying to find a seagirl in a flock of albatrosses albat is it alberry or albatrosses I don't know anyway but maybe the ill-fated Albatross was an omen of things to come I threw my hands deep into my pockets subconsciously may be looking for a clue or answers but all I found was pocket lint and an old cigarette butt hey Fantasy Flight games we've known each other for a long time now and we love your stuff yes you bring us a BFF like every 6 months now not that kind of BFF Aline even I know the friends aren't made out of cardboard what I mean is a big Fantasy Flight game but besides BFFs you really like to make us go locco for Lovecraft which is kind of cool here at NPI we really like pop fiction no not that Tarantino film that was highly overrated and much worse than Jackie Brown no what I mean is a publishing model in the 1920s to 40s which focused on such genres as horror Adventure fantasy and sci-fi and you not the only one's responsible for this

seapod craze you see pretty much every board game publisher has a slimy tentacle in their product catalog I'm talking about cthulu wars to tides of Madness to miskatonic school for girls what were they thinking with that one actually we all know what they were thinking but you see it's your particular brand of Love crafty and horror that really strikes true because it's pulp but scary but fantasy but dark and that's really really neat you kind of really capture the essence of Lovecraft through history and how we see him now minus the racism there's no racism out of all the love crafting games Mansions of Madness was our favorite in it all but one of you will be playing investigators who go on adventures in this on the F and one of you will be playing The Keeper who will be seeding the board with things like axes and spells and nothing of interest and we felt like delivered everything a board game should but it did come at a price it was fiddly and a bit clunky and to be honest maybe a bit broken but that has changed in the midsts of time and space with the second edition and just look how big it is look how big we we need to it we we need to it the new iteration of mansions of Madness replaces the very Cluny keepo with an app and boy what an appropriately insane

app it is it just clicks and hums and buzzes at just the right times and provides tension and suspense with its inbuilt Ambiance but that tension doesn't just come from music when you begin a game of mansions of Madness the app will take you through a narrated introduction into the story and right after that it will reveal but a single tile of The Not So humble a Bood that you are exploring and it is full of things to poke and prod and many exits to take what's Bey on them I don't know it could be anything it could be a slithering monster or it could be Boris Johnson you will only find out when you take the explore action which will then instruct you through the app to place the next tile and you could find a trophy room with a hunting rifle strapped to the wall except it's not strapped to the wall anymore because the thing that you do is you immediately run into it and yank it right off that's what's so great about Mansions of Madness second edition the aitous feeling of uncertainty you never know what is behind anything and that is incredibly incredibly exciting the app doesn't just handle the suspense and the Mystery of the game it also tackles the rules if you look at the learn to play guide you can see that it's not the thinnest of rule B but once you open it you can see that it's quite sparely laid

out and it refers to the app a lot and that is because the app does most of the heavy lifting of the Min of the rules and it makes it really quick to learn to play In fact when e was teaching it to us he said that you basically have two actions one is that you can move up to two spaces and the second one which you can do before during or after that move is to interact with something in the room in which case you click on it on the app and you do the thing that it tells you to do and for a big box game it makes it really accessible because you can just open the box sit down and play it and that is unparalleled the app is a winner it's incredibly seamless and once you've tried it or especially if you have played the first edition you will immediately fall in love with it and that's because it does so much of the heavy lifting you see it generates random maps for subsequent playthroughs it remembers everything that it needs to remember without the need for you to having input everything aside from the monster damage you actually have to input the monster damage and it even orders Chinese food for your play group when senses that your group's hunger levels have risen that last one's actually not true but most importantly it replaces the cumbersome combat mechanic with roll some dice see how many Elder signs you've got and if you've met the target number Mark the damage on the monster and the thing is if you don't manage to kill the monster don't worry about it just chill out put some narly Bob Marley the app will

remember all your contributions every time your investigator bashes the head against the ceiling beam or traps the thinger in the fridge door they'll have to take one of these cards and if they're lucky they'll be taking it face down however however if they're not lucky they have to take a face up one which imposes extra negative effects but but you want investigators obviously don't want to take these cards so every time they're supposed to they get to roll some dice and depending on how many successes they get which are Elder signs then you will be able to negate one damage for each of those successes but here's the thing on top of these damage cards you have these cards which represent watching free seasons of Keeping Up with the Kardashians in a 48-hour Marathon something no mortal mind can withstand and remain intact they are sanity cards and every time you take one of them you fill up this track and that's it's the same with the damage cards as well if you fill up the track full of damage cards then you pretty much just get wounded and you carry onwards until you fill it up again and then your investigator dies however if you fill up this track then you have to take a card that says you are insane and you really really really don't want to take this card honestly these cards are a little bit of a crapshoot they can make the game so much more interesting or sometimes just really rather dull even though the latter very rarely happens you see on the back of each of

these you are given an insanity condition what makes your particular mind go bunkers and sometimes you'll see your friends as giant carnivorous plants and you'll feel like you just need to douse them with a heavy friendly dose of kerosene and sometimes they'll say you're fine you're completely fine nothing is wrong with you continue as you were but no matter how much you trying to convince the other players that you are indeed fine they will never believe you see that's the beauty of these cards it's not how you actually feel about your Insanity it's how they feel about it and especially if you are one of those players that likes to roleplay their conditions boy you'll just bring a lot of tension to the table and that's what they're meant to do they're meant to bring tension and uncertainty and most of the time they deliver on that in Spades and now imagine that two of the investigators you're playing with have gone insane that is a lot to cope with especially because it takes a single person to derail everything you worked so hard on achieving to just break it and that's why this particular Insanity mechanism won't be to everyone's taste you see if you get a card that says you lose the game unless the other investigators lose the game then you might feel like you've already lost anyway it's like s invaded this board game what's the point anyway but here's the thing whilst that sort of

card might not necessarily be enjoyable to you not every card is like that and some players will simply Revel in being a joyous traitor and working against other players and if you are that sort of person that's fine just maybe don't come to our gaming nights one of the things that is great about this game is the puzzles because sometimes when you come across one of these Tok it will reveal a puzzle to you that you'll have to solve before you can progress and it might be to unlock a box it might be to put some wiring back together or it might be a subscription to the Daily Mail you don't know it's whatever the app and the game decides at the time and that's the brilliant thing all the puzzles are handled really well in the app so if you're a bit like me and you don't have manual dexos and have sausage fingers then it doesn't matter because you're not fiddling with tiles and putting them in the right order and things it does it all and it works really really well the only problem is that there's only three types of puzzle in the game so once you've done one of them if you come across another one you're like oh haven't I done this one before I actually agree sorry you have that now um I don't think the puzzles in mansions of manness work well don't get me wrong I'm a fan of puzzles and board games actually quite enjoy solving them but I just can't help but feel that the difficulty within the puzzles varies very much there are three types of puzzles that I mentioned but one of them we encountered was a mastermind style puzzle if you ever played Mastermind and

it just it was so much more difficult than the other two that we spent about I mean we might be stupid but we spent half an hour solving that one puzzle and it really took us out of the game and it was kind of a win or lose situation if you saw that puzzle you win the game but I just wish that it wasn't so long and that's the other thing the puzzles are on an app and to me that makes them feel cheaper than they were before like in the first edition they had this really nice tactile element of actual cardboard bits and you put them together to get a thing and here it just feels like you're playing a mini game on your hand computer is not fun and this is where we come to criticism number two of mansions of Madness is that sometimes it relies too heavily on this app not often you see apps in board games are a fine balancing line and it's either there to open up a new design space something that simply wasn't available before or it is there to assist the players in just removing a lot of the fiddlin and leg work and Manchester venz does both of that and it does it really really well and I love the app but I just wish that sometimes it wouldn't make you feel like you are actually playing the game on this app rather with all these lovely bits of cardboard and cards and Miniatures so that fine balancing line I just mentioned it's just ever so slightly wonky despite the previous two scenes being critical of the game I feel like I should say we really really love it we

love it very very much and it is one of the best game experiences we've had this year I know we just said that on our networks review but time goes on and we play more games and mansions of Madness does a lot of things very very well and even though we're not necessarily the sort of channel that focuses on a lot of American style games thematic games this one really struck aord with us particularly even though one of the main game mechanics is to Simply roll some dice look at your skill that's how many dice you're rolling and then you roll them and you get a thing or you don't get a thing and that was our exact criticism about Star Wars rebellion yet here packaged in this wonderful lovecraftian story it works it works really really well but there is a problem with the game and that's not really a criticism of the game itself it's just a problem and that problem is the price you see and I don't want to really get into this discussion about asod games acquiring all the new comp if you haven't heard as games is the game company that owns Fantasy Flight games and many other game companies and has been buying every game company in the world and a lot of people are up in the arms about that especially because new games seem to be becoming more and more expensive but I don't think this is man or man's fault it's actually got nothing to do with it it's just simp poor timing that this game was released now so in regards to this game yes it is expensive and some players have mentioned that hey

you don't get as many things as you got in the first Mansions of mad I don't mind that I don't care about that I value the Box not in terms of physical Contents I value it based on the experience that I get from it and that to me is really important I think the experience you get in mansions of manness is terrific you just don't get enough of it see the app only comes with four scenarios and whereas in the previous version of mansions of Madness you had three different endings for the five scenarios you got in that one whereas every time you play a scenario in mansions of Mana second edition you get the same ending in fact whilst you do get a map that is slightly different and you know there's a room that wasn't there before or there's a event that kind of happens in a slightly different way or a different monster appears than the one did that that did before it largely feels the same and so after four plays you've exhausted the game and the next time you're playing the same scenario you won't get that same narrative experience that you got before because you'll largely recognize all the elements and you'll know sort of where you'll need to go and that to me is slightly disappointing yes there are more scenarios coming and that is really important and key because I think the thing that really needs to round out this package which has been developed really just it surprised me how great everything worked and the reason I'm so

happy about this game is because I know just how much effort went into making each and every single Adventure all the bits of dialogue that you find all the characters all the monsters and everything just feels cohesive and tied together and that's great just wish there was more of it and that's it we arrived at the end of this adventure we've exhausted the Mansion of Madness and we've got pretty much nothing else to say but for maybe that this game will be beloved by hosts and what I mean by that is that if you like to have people over and deliver a fun experience to them this is the best game that you can get and you want to go out and buy it immediately and if you're not a very big fan of American style thematic games I don't think it does a lot to change that but if you mind that sort of experience this will be a game you will treasure and the thing is we really really loved it and we wish we could recommend it wholeheartedly but we know the price and the fact that it doesn't come with many scenarios at launch is going to put some people off but what if we just ignored the price a what if the like it didn't you know cost as much would then we would definitely recommend it yeah my mama CS in Italy mama swis in Mama's got a Chung my mama's watch in Venezuela mama like Cinderella Mama's got a Chung

Progress saved