Skip to main content
Loading video...

Stamp Swap Review: I Cut, You STAMP?!

Transcript 22:07

stamp swap I'm going to stumble on that word I'm wanting to read it as like stop swamp stop I was thinking stomp swap swamp stomp swamp yeah stomp swamp that's what I stomp swamp St stamp Swamp Stomp Swamp Stomp swap that sounds fun Hello everybody welcome back to board game Buzz today my name is Carly and I'm Kim and today we're going to be reviewing the brand new title stamp swap from ston Meer games

stamp swap is a one to five player game designed by Paul Solomon and the art is done by Connor gallette I I said wrong Gillette restart I'm sorry sorry k Sorry stamp swap is a one to five player game which is designed by Paul Solomon and the art is done by Connor chillet Thank you jillette I've said it like five times and I keep messing it up it's time for the animal you are stum oh my goodness my gosh okay I cannot do this all right it's time for the annual stamp Swap and show did I say that right it's time for the annual stamp Swap and show there you go it is the perfect time for collectors oh my goodness Beckham now is the perfect time for stamp collectors to come together to show off all their stamps swap with other people basically trying to get the most points this is the newest title from Stone Meer games which we are so excited to kind of share about but before we share our thoughts on this game we're going to jump into a really General overview of how this game plays and then we'll come back here and share our thoughts on stamp swap my earring oh did it oh no stamp swap is an ick you choose tile placement game at the beginning of each round of stamp swap you will select items from a central pool of stamps and attendee cards at the end of each round you will add your stamps to your album arranging them carefully to maximize your score this game is played over three rounds and each round is divided into three phases

the collect phase swap phase and then the show phase at the beginning of every round you will Shuffle the event cards then draw and reveal a number of cards equal to the number of players around the table you will then create a pool of items from the displayed event cards there will also be an event shown on the event cards this event changes from round to round and mixes up every round of the game after getting the General Pool set up then you move on to the collect phase in the collect phase players will take turns gaining one item from the pool until each player has six items if you select a face down stamp you may view it but it remains face down for now specialist cards are active immediately when selected and for as long as they are in your play area one of the tokens that you can choose to collect is the first player token but at the end of the collect phase if the first player token is still in the pool the last player to select the item gains the token token and places it beneath their daily collection once everybody has collected their stamps then we move on to the swap phase in the swap phase players simultaneously split up their daily collections during this time players can choose to reserve one item by placing it in the reserve area on your player mat you will then split the remaining items into two piles above your player mount with each pile having at least one item once all players have finished creating their piles the player with the first player token takes the first turn the active player will then choose one of the piles from an opponent's player mat and places it below their own that opponent now places all items in their remaining pile below their player mat and then can proceed to choose a new pile after choosing they can reveal all of their face down stamps

once every pile has been moved below player mats then the swap phase ends and we move on to the show phase in the show phase players will simultaneously move their chosen reserved and remaining items onto their albums and score points stamps must be placed upright with their value or cancellation Mark showing in the top right and each stamp must be placed if possible if not discard it and immediately gain points equal to its value you will score your items and albums as follows you will score points as shown on your exhibitors if you currently have the first player token you will also score two points and you will choose one of the contest cards at the bottom of the board that does not have one of your Show tickets you will score points for that card's scoring condition then Place one of your Show tickets there to indicate that you have entered that contest once that is done then that triggers the end of the round you will discard the top event card and any remaining items in the pool then Advance the phase token to the next round if the phase token moves to a new day repeat the round setup and begin the next round otherwise move on to the final show during the final show all players simultaneously score their album one last time as follows you will count the number of forever stamps in your album and compare that with the other players you will score 10 points if you have the most six points for second place three points for third place and no points are awarded for any lower rank you will score the points shown on all of your stamps if you have any specialist cards you will score two points for each of those and you will score points according to the final contest card in the finale section of the board once all players have scored

the points the player with the most points wins all right so I really hope that overview gives you a general idea of how this game plays but we're going to go ahead and jump into our thoughts on this game starting with everything that we enjoyed about stamp swap one of the things that I really enjoy about the game and I guess I like this mechanic um and a few games like Isle of the sky is one of my favorite games um where you get to like you pick your stamps and then you get to like kind of like puzzle it out and to put them into two separate groupings I really like I split you choose mechanisms in games that's something that I kind of that's something that I've kind of the more I kind of get into gaming like I kind I really like that cuz it's I like the tension that it adds but what makes this one really interesting is how there are some tiles that are face down so when you are splitting and when you're choosing sometimes you don't know like what you're actually getting from from opponents like it made the I split you choose mechanism that much more interesting I agree it added like a nice little element of suspense because sometimes I would do get a pairing and then it's like oh there is that bonus in there or you could like this one in this case in this example it's flipped face but there are a couple of negative ones in there so if it's face down and someone screw over your opponents a little bit like a little negative Point like it's not a huge you know negative thing but it's just just just like a little fun element of surprise and suspense that can happen yeah I also really liked how many different cards

that the game came with to swap out um I forget what these are called they're not they're not like endgame goals they're like midgame goals maybe yeah whatever these goals are down at the bottom um the game comes with so many different ones so every time you contest yeah yeah the different contests um so every time you play you really can swap them in and out super easily kind of gives you different things to be going for different things to kind of focus in on so I like that variability that those added and the other thing that I liked about it is that it's not like you had to like go in this order like on Friday we're scoring this one on Saturday we're scoring this one I could kind of pick and choose which one I want to do on each day and then the fact that there are four to choose from but there's only three days that you're showing or um or submitting your tickets to the contest I liked that show you can't do everything yeah you can't do everything so you have to yeah focus in on a couple things like a two points per stamp or um two points for two whatever or large squares okay so maybe like maybe I have two squares on two large squares on my in my book for on Friday but so maybe I could go for that and get eight points but maybe if I'm wait till do it for the last show maybe I'll even have even more and I could get like 20 points so it just kind of that trying to figure out and balance like which one should I go for each each

time the setup and the the Which shapes and Which shapes of stamps are available are pretty much the same like round to around but there are these like round the goals goals or things that change the round just like a rule change for the round and I really liked that too because it added like sometimes it limited how many you could take each time sometimes you got to take an extra one sometimes it was like you had to like switch SCS with the other like player you had to pick one to switch little rule change that happened every round y it was also interesting how the tiles that are available there are bound to be tiles that people are not going to pick up you can't get everything so it kind of kind of added to that tension right of what do I really want to get so it's like if I really want that particular thing I know I just won't get it somebody else will get it and then I can pick it up later well there's the likelihood that maybe nobody picks up the one that you actually want and so that again it adds to that attention of okay I really want that maybe I should get it and just hope that I can split my stuff in such a way that nobody selects that particular one um I liked how there was just so so many tiles that you had to choose from and building off of that I didn't use this like you could actually reserve a stamp which I didn't use that much the first play through I used it every s around but the next times I played cuz there would be times where I'd be like okay I really want

this one that I picked up and I'm going to have to split it and hope that maybe that they don't pick this one but I'm like wait I can actually reserve it so I really appreciated being able to just have that one chance to like just reserve the one that you really want usually in like tile placement games there's roles and structures and like you have to place it next to something that you've already put down um when Carly was explaining the rules and she was like no you can just kind of like now we just put them on our book can you put them however you want I was like what there's no it feels weird at first the very first time you place it you're like okay this feels kind of weird it just feels so like I guess I'm just going to put these down but I was surprised that I actually like really liked that part of the game like I was just like oh yeah I'm just going to like put it down and make it look pretty and try to try to meet these different show goals they were the contest and I just like had fun placing it how I wanted it to without any limits or restrictions Sometimes some of the cards will put restrictions and stuff like I know one of them was like having cancelled stamps on your Ed on the edges or sometime right but even then it's not like that's just something if you want to try to go for so it gives you like a goal to go for but it's not like a rule that makes it you have to put these on the on the edge and whatnot something else that I wanted to mention is I loved how when you were splitting and making your

groups it's not just the stamps that you collect but it's also the cards and the abilities that you that you collect and also like the first player token um I think my favorite part was how were these like specialist cards that you could collect and then you had split them and like do I want like can I get that ability um because these abilities they can some of them can be very very very beneficial um and then you also have your individual this kind of like siding but you also have your personal kind of goals that you're also going for which are all are all different all the boards are different so there's lots of kind of like layering to the scoring which I really appreciated and liked especially because this is so like free form and like yes I appreciate having like these different goals and objectives to try to like in my free forming it make it so I was also maximizing everything yep I think the other one of the other things that like I appreciated probably maybe the most about this game is how easy it is to table um cuz it it plays in you play it Friday Saturday Sunday so you have three rounds so go as quick it's just and it was easy to just kind of like present like okay this is what we do this and then like go it wasn't it's not a hard teach it's not like a hard one to grasp and whatnot even like some there are games that I love but they are a chore to like set up or to teach even so I really appreciated this like nice um

Family weight I guess aspect of being able it's okay like yeah we can play a quick game of stamp swap it actually kind of gives me cozy Vibes this game has cozy Vibes to it like I can see just like I mean we're learning it and playing it in the summer and it's hot but like I can see like in the winter like pulling this out like being like all like bundled up and having your tea and me like okay now we're going to like collect our stamps collect St I don't know there's just something about it that seems kind of like cozy okay so we're going to kind of swap my goodness we're going to swap we're going to swap we're going to swap tactics here and we are going to to kind of start talking about stuff that we didn't like about this game or could potentially see others not liking um I think the biggest thing for me that's kind of pulling it back is I don't think the theme is super drawing me in super much I'm sure I know stamp collecting is like a huge hobby I know tons of people are in it and I'm sure tons of people will love this theme yeah um it just it it I mean I think it's fine I'm fine with it it's not it's not one that I'm like I need to play that because of the theme you know yeah yep it's not like drawing me in necessarily yeah to me this is a game that's like don't judge a book by its often I think maybe you can with board games a little bit but like I do don't yeah we judge them by what they look like and their theme but like for me it's like okay don't judge a game by its cover and its theme because the game play was fun and Charming like I said

cozy um and like just like an overall enjoyable experience but the theme like when Carly like told me what this what the game was and we were looking at it I was like stamp swap like what really you ended up liking it I did end up liking it but I was and I was just like laughing so hard I'm like wait we're collecting stamps and we're going to a I'm like maybe I should make fun because collecting board games and maybe going to a board game convention is super ner like that's where like my mind went and I'm so much said that I was like what I actually want is I want this to be like board Game Swap where we're collecting games for your cxes yeah collecting our board games and putting them on our Shelf and then we're going to like the board game convention like why did they do that I don't I agree I think that the theme might be a little bit of like a barrier to entry to this a little bit um I'm sure if you love stamps and obviously I think you're going to love this one um but if you like don't know anything about stamps I don't think people are going to be gravitated to pull this off the shelf right from the beginning yeah cuz and Jordan had the same like thought he was like oh I liked this a lot more than I thought I would based off of the theme cuz he was like the theme did not appeal to him at all but like it it works for the game and for the idea and I'm like oh it's actually like really like charming and fun being like to pretend like I'm collecting my stamps I actually had to go to the post office cuz I had

some games I had to mail back to Publishers and as I was there I was actually like looking cuz you know well at least maybe all post offices do this but they had like a little display of like the stamps that you could buy and we're looking at it being like I've never really noticed stamps before like I think this game has like made me like notice stamps a little bit more for whatever reason what kind of kept messing with my brain was the stamps themselves like the artwork on the stamps because some stamps like for example the flower stamps I think I think like the flowers and the animals like it just shows the flower and then the rest of the stamp is like that actual color but some of them like the space ones there's actual like color on the whole inside and then the actual color of what the stamp is is just along the outside of the stamp and for whatever reason just all the different colors kept throwing me off like when I was trying to look at my board being like okay I know this goal is to have you know one of every color it was hard for me sometimes to like okay I have a red I have an orange and like the red and the oranges when they're side by side you can clearly tell but when they're all the way across the It's Kind hard to like I just felt like some of the colors were a little bit like diluted it kind of the space ones kep throwing me off because they have that background yeah well and I agree and especially in terms of like you have The Monuments and the vehicles are just they're just colored the the the stamp border color what the

color is meant to be but but then the animals aren't but the animals aren't and and then the space one has background the space has a background so I kind of wish they would have just like done it all in color and then made like this really nice big bold like border feel like in lots of poly polyomino games you want to like line up completely right you want to like fully touch all the sides you want to fully yeah you want to fully like build it out the stamps in this game are actually cut a hair smaller than the Grid on the board so if you do line up your stamps where they're completely touching everything is going to get get thrown off so when you're placing your stamps and maybe that like is thematic in regards to when you are actually placing stamps in your stamp book you want to give a little bit of space but you do want to be mindful of the space in this game you can't have everything touching when we were playing and I was like meddling with it and Carley was like I'm dying because like you're doing it too like I thought it was a me thing when cuz I first played this game without himim and then I played it with Kim to teach her and I look over literally I think we were still in like our first dat and noticed you just maybe it was our second date but I noticed you kind of messing with the board and you were like kind of messing and I was just dying cuz I was like I it's not just a me thing there's like a clarification clarification section for some of the uh contest cards and specialist cards but it doesn't have it for all of them felt like that was a little weird and there was actually like one like and some of

some of the scoring goals weren't clear to me like I'm like how do I what is how do I score this I could make a guess but I wasn't exactly sure I needed a little bit of clarification and like one of them I couldn't find it in the rules so I had like sat and pictur of Carly I was like do you know how this scores and she was like no is it in the rules I was like no it's not um so like just having I guess a complete appendix I guess would have been appreciated all right so we've talked a lot about this game stuff we liked stuff we didn't we're going to go ahead and jump into our final thoughts and ratings for stamp SP po um I'll go ahead and start I I'm surprised at how much I enjoyed this game I I really when I first played it I remember I got it and I was like okay that looks interesting again kind of like we talked about like the theme wasn't really pulling me in but after playing it like the first couple times I was like okay there is a charm here like I do I do like this I do think it feels different for my for me personally from the other games that I have in my collection so I'm going to be giving stamp swap a 7.5 I think the only thing that's kind of pulling it down for me honestly is is the theme it's not one that I would have gravitated towards if it wouldn't like if we wouldn't have been able to receive it for for for review purposes but after playing it I was like no I do like this so I I did enjoy this game like said I enjoyed it a lot more than I actually thought I was going to yeah yeah I think it's like a great like after quick after dinner game yeah for dinner where stamp swap yeah um I'm coming in at a 7 um for

me this game is a good game like it's good I liked it it was enjoyable it was fun I like would play it I would play it with anybody yeah um this is one that you really could play with anybody play with any anybody and it was just it was sweet it was Charming I had a fun time with it it didn't like leave me feeling like super excited like which like for me that that's when I rate board games higher but it was like an enjoyable experience it was fun and I definitely would recommend giving it a try yeah so if you do enjoy stamps absolutely check this one out and I think even if you don't enjoy stamps still give it a try still give it a try yeah cuz like you we're both we both had fun and we were both like not like I said at the beginning like don't judge don't judge it by its cover don't judge it by its theme the mechanics are fun and even like though the theme wasn't something that like I gravitated to I enjoyed how it played out in the game because it is a thematic game all right so those were our thoughts on stamp swap huge shout out to Stone meire games for sending us this copy to review for you today if you enjoyed this review and you haven't yet subscribed to the channel it means so much if you can do that really helps support us in everything that we're doing over here that's mean pushing the like button for you pushing the like button but until next time we hope you have a great rest of your day and we'll see you

later I have three songs tck in my head at once oh do you yeah like us and then it goes to people's windows blasted after this

Progress saved