Animal Rescue Team: Discussion
Transcript
Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.
Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked. Today I'm doing a discussion over Animal Rescue Team. This is uh one of the newer games by Matt Leacock. Uh apparently it's a game that came out a couple or I guess last year. It's not 2027 yet. So, that's good, but uh this is one I had actually never heard of. It's a copy that my friend had that he was telling me about that was designed by, like I said, Matt Leacock and uh you know, of Pandemic fame and of the latest Fate of the Fellowship. But, this one had an extremely interesting premise of that you are part of an animal rescue team and you are going around this map to uh try and rescue as many animals as possible.
And I got to say I hated this game. This game uh unfortunately I think has so many design flaws. Not that these um choices were uninteresting. There's you know, there's a little bit here to be said that it's trying to do something different. But I just think it does a lot of things that inherently make a bad cooperative game. So I mean, so the overall stick of it is you are going to be drawing cards from this deck that are going to be telling you a certain type of animal is in distress and you have to uh you know, it's in one of these locations and you have to take one of these uh, take one of these vehicles and go to that location, roll some dice to try and get a target number to load them onto your vehicle and then take them to a animal shelter, which I mean are basically these white squares.
And I mean, you can definitely tell that the bones of Pandemic are here. Uh, you know, that's kind of par for the course with everything of his design. Which I'm a huge fan of Pandemic. I love almost every single one of them. And Fall of the Fellowship is one of the best games to have come out. Uh, especially probably his best design. And granted, I would say the IP is helping with that quite a lot. But this one with the idea of having to take a specific vehicle, move across the country of whatever country this is supposed to be, and haul different sized animals from one area to the next sounds good in theory except that the game is so wildly unbalanced that, you know, the difficulty there just feels more RNG than it does with any actual, um, good difficulty design.
And that kind of brings the entire experience down. So, the main reason for that is you know, the the roll or the the round is going to be going, "Okay, you do three actions potentially getting these tokens here that can give you extra actions or you get a lot of kind of free actions to do." But um, you do your three actions then this row of of not row, this column of animal cards will tick down and you have to draw a new one. And within this stack, you're just going to get a ton of different types of animals that are going to range from large to medium to small that can only fit so many in any combination that can fit, but really the only the large animals can only fit in this trailer.
Uh and I'll get to this whole thing. The greatest idea in this game is actually one of the biggest flaws. Um but within this deck, there's also a time ticks on, which you could attribute to kind of being like the um the epidemic cards in Pandemic. And that will move this round tracker up, and this round tracker will cause you to draw event cards, and then clear out the animal shelters, and eventually get to these objectives. These objectives are how you win the game. And if it ever gets to an objective that you have not completed, then you lose. So, that in and of itself sounds perfectly fine, except there are multiple issues with both the vehicles in this game and this deck by itself.
So, I'm trying to figure out where to start because they kind of go hand in hand. So, every time that you are drawing a card, you are, like I said, you are spilling out animals into a given location. This Roan Canyon says, "Oh, these this cow and these two chickens are uh you know, in you know, whatever." They're probably burning because every single animal seems to be catching on fire. Um there's nothing else interesting about it. And I mean, to be fair, going back to the theme a little bit, I really like the theme, but the problem is is you're so flooded with all these animals that you get to a point where you're like, "Okay, really? A rabbit is trapped in a car. Look, we're going to go get the horse that's or the dog that's that fell down a well and it's paddling. We're going to go get that dog and we can we can let the the rabbit go.
But, the problem is is you lose if any one of these cards falls off. So, you have to constantly be saving these animals. And some people might be thinking, "Oh, that's terrible. Do you know what's one dog compared to you a pet dog to a pet rabbit?" They're they're equal. In real life, I agree. As a board game, it's constant flooding and very little mitigation. So, these cards are coming out. They're putting out these animals and then you have to be able to pop into a vehicle. That's the only way you can move. You can't trek across country to pick up an animal. You have to be able to drive. And these vehicles all have different uh uh spaces they can move, but if you have to haul a trailer, it lowers the movement. Which again is interesting.
So, you either are going by yourself or you're putting in these different colored uh people, which is also kind of weird. You as a player play as one of these characters, but then all of them are still out to potentially help you with a die roll. Like this cow and chicken one, you need to roll a value of eight on two dice. And you get pluses to that based off if you have a certain type of gear or if you have a certain person with you. So, you go there and then you roll these dice. Okay, let's say you roll the value you roll a five, but you had all three conditions, so you get your eight. And then you have to load them onto the car. Well, okay, it's a cow, so the only thing that can fit it is on this wagon. Oh, wait. That wagon's full.
So, I can't go there. So, the animals have to stay there. The only thing I could go get are the chickens, but you can't just pick up the chickens. You also have to pick up their friend the cow I with the parents that only have legs. And you might be thinking, "Okay, well, that's fine. How do you unload these?" Well, you have to go to an animal shelter. And the animal shelters have a limited number of space. Also, the cow will take up a majority of that. The horse will as well. So, you have to drive to the spot with the animal shelter, unload them. And you might notice there's only two animal shelters. And those will stay full until the time token reaches this spot for the small one or this spot for the big one.
And otherwise, if those aren't getting cleared, then you have to just keep them in there. So, if you don't have the ability or the time to be able to rush back and unload these to then pick these up, you have no way to unload these animals. And the problem that I have with this is you're constantly getting flooded with animals. They will constantly be ticking down. Your cars are full. Your shelters are full. And the only way, this is my one of my biggest issues, the only [ __ ] way to clear these out, and I have confirmation from this, is if you roll a time icon on the die to move the time track up. And the time track up is very punishing cuz you when you get here, you draw an event. We'll talk about the events, too.
But, if you're needing animal shelters to clear, there is no way you can actually do that. You know, maybe there's a event or a yeah, an event card. Not an event card, like a logistics card that can actually help you. But, if you don't top deck that or get lucky, then you can legitimately get soft locked from not being able to empty out your cars, empty out your animal shelters. And you can't just roll the dice and try and move time up cuz the again the only way that time moves up is if you roll this die. Oh, wait. No, there's actually another way. Shuffled into this deck are cards that time ticks on or something. And that's your only reprieve from not having more animals come out is by drawing a time ticks on.
But then, you might be thinking, "Oh, okay. Well, that's kind of nice." Except for some reason, the biggest thing that Matt Leacock put into Pandemic was stacking the deck you draw from with epidemics that they were roughly equidistant from each other. Yes, there was possible for you to draw two epidemics in a row, but for the most part, you had to Oh, hey, we're playing with five epidemics. Shuffle the the city cards into five equal decks and then shuffle an epidemic into each one of those. That's not in this game. This game just you just take all the animal cards and the time ticks on and just shuffle them. And it's entirely possible for you to Oh, man. I I think there's like seven or something in there. To time ticks on.
Time ticks on. Time ticks on. Time ticks on. Oh, okay, cool. So, now boom boom gets here event. Boom. Animal shelter gets cleared. There's no animals in there. So, we missed that opportunity. Oh, we you get here. We draw two bad event cards. Oh, we go here and Oh, I guess we didn't have the time to [ __ ] get the two icons we needed cuz the only way you can get icons is by clearing out animals. So, if you just aren't getting the right animals that give you the right icons that you need and you don't have the right person um to be able to just go get them. Like if you need these two purples, you could have the extraction specialist who as an action could just go get them. But, oh, we don't we we didn't have that one. We have the rope rescuer, the veterinarian, and the firefighter. So, I guess we're [ __ ] We can't just willingly get those. Oh, man, in this picture there are some, but there are some animals that just don't give you what you need.
So, you basically need things to line up. You need an equal section of those time tick song cards so you have a steady progress of having animal shelters cleared out. And if you just don't get those, then okay, well, we can't roll the dice to move time on. We're only drawing animal cards to be able to clear up. If you're efficient at clearing them and if you roll well, you know, hey, we need an eight. Man, I rolled two fours. Lucky us. That's awesome. Time didn't move on. Oh, wait, we kind of wanted to because now the cards are full and the animal shelters are full so we can't do anything with these animals. So, how do we how do we advance time?
Because eventually what's going to happen is if unless you get lucky and draw into a time tick song card, it's going to be animal. All right, we can't rescue them. Everything's full. Animal. Okay, we can't rescue them. Animals full or everything's full. Oh, animal. And you know, eventually a face-up one went down and we lost because the animal died or something. And that is just an insane design decision. And I've even had conversations uh where it's hey, there's a lot of room in those cars and you want to make sure the animal shelters are empty. Well, duh, obviously. Except you have no control over when these shelters get emptied. So, it's entirely possible that by the we you know, by the time you do roll around and hey, we finally have an empty large animal shelter. That's awesome. And time moved on to this one. Oh, great. Okay.
So, it gets emptied even though there's nothing in there. And even if it's some dumb-ass decision of having an animal shelter, let's say the animal shelter is right here. For some reason you can't you can't just be there and move them to the animal shelter. The the the animal shelter workers are just on break or something. So, you don't even get the luxury of hey, we can just kind of transfer them because you can freely transfer between people and animals as long as the car is there and and gear and all that. It is it it's mind-boggling that in 2025 when this game comes out that somehow this was never brought up.
Um maybe I'm the isolated incident and every game that's ever been played of this that's never happened, but the fact that it can happen and has happened is a problem. To hand-wave it away and think, well, you're the outlier. Well, I mean, not necessarily just because this feels not like a good designed difficult co-op game. And the only difference of playing a standard game to a simple game is there are these icons on the side for this animal here, which is uh that it it's kind of a more pressing issue. It's a two to that you need to roll, so it's, you know, relatively easy to do. But, the further it goes down the track, I know what they were doing thematically. It's, "Hey, this dog is probably stuck in the creek and it's drowning."
So, your it becomes harder and harder for the result as it goes further down. And I like that. I think that's kind of cool to have a more pressing issue of uh of the animal in distress. A good example again is they even tell you if you read the flavor text the the dog in the well is a card here. And oh, a dog fell in the well and it's swimming. It's going to get tired. So, is if we go right now, it's super easy to get. But, otherwise, if you wait too long, then now you need a seven or an eight. Um and this game could have easily easily been rectified by having those [ __ ] time ticks on cards stacked in here.
You know, seated somewhere in the deck instead of just shuffled in because the last game of this I just played, it was nothing. We drew 20 animal cards, 15 to 20 animal cards, and then all of a sudden, it is uh time ticks on time ticks on time ticks on, we lose because it finally goes boom boom boom, and we we just weren't able to actually we could have dropped off the stuff. We could have put in the tokens or spent the tokens, but uh or put the gear in their spots, but no, we actually there's no reason to do that because we have to try and rescue the animals. Oh, wait, we can't rescue the animals because they don't fit in any of our cars uh because you can only fit them where they actually fit.
And then the other mind-boggling thing about this is so yes, in Pandemic, the only bad thing that happens was the pandemic or the epidemic cards. And of course the outbreak and you know, you had the seeding of when an epidemic happened, all the discarded cards get shuffled and put back on top. So you had some information of okay, this place keeps getting hit. Let's quarantine it. Let's do something. Let's whatever we can do. Here, it's literally just random [ __ ] Random animals that are again being burned. But this place is like lit covered in gasoline. This is not water, it's gasoline. Everything's on fire. Um and and here, it's again just random animals.
Uh but again, the only thing that was bad was the epidemic that you could kind of predict or hope you could predict. You know, we've had like everyone's had two turns now. We haven't drawn one, so it's definitely coming up. And in here, the insane thing to me was when this moves onto this spot. And this is obviously the prototype board. I'm just it's just helping me explain the issues I have with it. So you you when it moves onto here, you draw a bad event. And again, it's all top deck [ __ ] that just clearly [ __ ] you. Oh, okay, sudden flash flood, the top most animal actually now you need the boat. Oh, okay. So now we have to drive all the way here and haul the boat over there.
But then, you go here and you have to draw two events back to back. And then three events. I mean, you're pretty much game's over by the time you get to the you know, this point for sure because what game would ever tell you to draw three bad things back-to-back. And they're not minor inconveniences. They're all horrible uh game-breaking events that just essentially tank it. You know, so a good example is again, in the last game I just played, we had we had this mission that was getting ready already to be to be completed. And you needed two gear down here, and you needed two logistics to be spent up in the top. And we had all that uh available, except because we got to this spot, actually I think it was this spot.
We drew a card that said, "No mission can be completed unless you get five uh playable characters at logistics." Or not logistics, animal shelters. They just had to be at the shelters. So, you had to now corral a bunch of people for no reason except to get rid of a a card like that. On top of the fact that it's it's just this feels designed to just be overwhelming and not fun. And that's my That's the takeaway that I get from this is, "Hmm, well, animal rescue seems like a hard job, which I'm sure it is. This sounds I mean, I extremely appreciate the people who do this. Um especially with someone who owns uh four dogs.
I really like the theme, and I love the fact that the flavor text, you know, really is kind of upsetting. But, the fact that you're just constantly overwhelmed with just [ __ ] makes it Oh, well, I'm no longer feeling anything except hatred towards this these animals. Um because the way Pandemic is designed, and even Fate of the Fellowship, and every other game of of this ilk has that roller coaster kind of feel of okay, things are getting really bad and then they you know, then you deal with it. Things are getting really bad, then you deal with it. This game This game is hey, things are getting really bad and there's no real way you can actually deal with it. It's as if you were on a roller coaster that only kept going up. You're like, man, when do we get the fun part of going down? Oh, when the roller coaster crashes is actually when whenever you get to go down.
And I just who I I [ __ ] I need to be a part of play testing cuz I swear play testers always feel as if they're going to be friends and family of these people. Oh man, well, you did such a good job. I'm so proud of you. And did did you have fun? Yeah. Yeah, you want to play again? Oh oh, well. Um it I just don't see how this was missed. And I've seen multiple forums and multiple people talk about this game being unreasonably difficult. And yeah, they could just cross arms really well, that's the point. Get good. There's nothing to get good. It's literally your get good is man, the time takes on cards are shuffled evenly. How lucky. Oh man, the logistics cards came out that were super situational and extremely helpful. How lucky.
Um oh, we're getting an adequate pace of rolling the time icon on the die. How lucky. I again, I like the vehicle concept and actually having to manage the different um the different vehicles. I and the fact that you have to be in them so you can't just take all the vehicles and leave one person stranded because they can't do anything. They can't just walk across the bridge. Um cuz Cuz the other thing is it would have been somewhat nice to have an action that was even if it was a burner [ __ ] action where hey, it takes your you get one last ditch move one space. That's all you can do on your turn. For some reason you were in a position where none of the vehicles were near you, so you just you walked. It took you all day to walk from Vinland to to Roan Canyon.
But you at least got to do something versus the fact of oh man, I don't actually have any vehicles near me. So I guess I'll do nothing on my turn except have a different animal. So and these aren't actually that bad. The missions you're trying to do with is literally just have a certain number of icons or a certain number of tokens to spend and a certain certain gear to be in a location. They're all very just they're all manageable to do. I just I mean again, they're not that interesting, but um and then the other aspect of this game that I actually kind of like is when you do rescue an animal, you're given these tokens and the tokens are very powerful of be a buying equipment, which this eventually just becomes useless but unless you need it for a mission.
The logistics you can spend to draw a logistics card. Again, typically used for missions. This one gives you a plus one to your die roll. This one gives you a whole extra action. And this one lets you re-roll a die. I don't even necessarily hate the dice on this game. Um but the fact that unless again, you are drawing the time ticks on cards, your only way of this moving is if you roll that icon. And sometimes again, I'm talking about how well we need animal shelters cleared to move things. The opposite is also a problem is if you aren't even able to rescue any of the animals and all you're rolling are these uh time ticks on. So, then it just move keep just moves on at a horrendous pace.
Um so, then it's basically, well, we're rolling really bad. Let's just reset. There's we're not winning here. So, let's just restart because this moved on. We already got a horrible event, and the shelter's cleared, but it cleared of nothing. Um we there was a good logistics card here, but it got re it got discarded. So, I I don't know what happened here. I don't know if this was meant to be, well, I don't I don't want to make Pandemic about animals, so let's uh let me try something different. Well, it [ __ ] sucks.
I really And I I so badly wanted to That's cute. See, I wanted so badly to to like it cuz I love animals and the writing. They named all the animals in this game. And even at the back of the rulebook, oh, this would have been a kind of a better Even at the back of the rulebook, it even talks about how to be your own animal rescue guide. Steps to take in a situation that you might find yourself in through a natural disaster or having a a kit. You know, that's amazing. That's such a cool concept uh to throw in. And I really really think that this theme could have worked if it was literally Pandemic, but about animals.
I would have been perfectly fine with that. Uh you could have even I mean, cuz there there's vehicles in I guess maybe a spoiler. It's been a few years. There's um vehicles and [ __ ] in Pandemic Legacy Season 0. So, the the the the animal or the animal thing the vehicle thing could have easily been implemented in a in a more true to pandemic form. Um you know, if there was actually instead of a you could even roll dice uh to try and save them because it's kind of funny if there's a there's a lone rabbit down in Romwell and you go there and you roll horrible uh and then you eventually get it and you can thematically say, "Well, it's a lone rabbit that's scared and you are you're on an island so you're just searching for it." You can really get into it, but the fact that the crux of this game, the difficulty aspect is so badly implemented in my opinion just makes me really scratch my head.
Um but yeah, as as a pandemic system this could have easily just been better. Get rid of the the the die thing or get get rid of the dice that have that have the [ __ ] hourglass on it. Um and have this you know, have this track here be a either an end of round thing. Hey, after everyone is gone move this up. So, it's it's a consistent thing that's [ __ ] moving and then have the time ticks on as a kind of an epidemic kind of thing where it advances on even further. So, you're it's it's still predictable on when it's going to happen because at the end of a round it moves forward or something.
And then have the time ticks on cards that now rush it further than you were expecting or something. Just giving players some agency instead of just wow, we randomly drew every single animal It's cuz it's possible for all the [ __ ] time ticks on cards to be at the bottom. Because you just shuffle them in. I It's They could all be at the top. They could be They could be five together and then two spread out. It's It's insane to see a game like this. And and then the the like equipment three different piece of equipment must be brought to Davinci City before the next mission could be completed. And the equipments take up It's a [ __ ] There's a shirt. There's a Here, I'm going to go back to the other picture. Well, the other picture didn't really have items. Um Actually, hold on. I can probably There we go. Nope, never mind. I was hoping I could zoom in instead of zoom way in.
But there's the Davinci City's in the middle and the equipment um takes up a slot. It's the one of the equipment is literally a shirt. It's like a dive suit or something. Why does that take up a whole slot that a dog would take? Um So, that means you have to now go out of your way. Oh, man, we're two steps away from the uh Here, I'm going to go back to this one. We're two steps away from this being completed and so uh now we can't We have the tokens to have We can't complete them cuz now we have to run around and put equipment in into a spot. Oh, wait.
All the animal shelters are full and all the cars are full. So, we actually can't put the equipment in there. Okay. I guess uh I guess we're we're [ __ ] So um yeah, that we we drew two event cards and two of those just basically screwed us and made it to where it's not even possible. Oh, wait, no, we can fit a few animals. We can fit, you know, these two cats in one of these cards. And I rolled two uh two hourglasses. Those moved on and we lost. This is a game that feels like it's the [ __ ] difficulty of Ghost Stories. Of out of your control, hope hope RNG goes your way, and I thought we were well past that.
Cuz I have played a ton of cooperative games in the past couple years that have been bangers that feel like they are designed with difficulty that if you lost, yeah, maybe some randomness didn't some luck didn't go your way, but the whole game wasn't luck. You could look back and think, "Okay, we made some mistakes here. We misplayed, we missed something, and boom, we lost. Cool. I can swallow that." I can't swallow a game that is randomly designed to either be right you know right you know work extremely well for you or not at all. That's not that's not worth it for me. And the other thing is is this game or this theme is implemented somewhat. You're not a specific animal rescue team, but you are saving animals in Endangered.
And Endangered is a way better designed game. So, if you like this idea of rescuing animals, maybe not from natural disasters, you know, like dogs being on a raft and or in a flooded zone, which again of the theme here of rescuing animals, it's awesome. But if you want to save endangered animals from poachers and horrible [ __ ] uh just play Endangered. It has way more variety anyway, so yeah, this one this one just really blew my mind on on just how these design decisions coming from a well-known designer who makes great cooperative games.
I just don't know what happened here. And unless I've been playing this game completely wrong, which I've asked specifically about the issues I've been griping about and it was confirmed by Matt Leacock himself, hey, it was designed this way, then I I do not know.
What What the hell happened here? So, I guess buy the game and read the back of the rule book just so you know how to become an animal rescue or plan for natural disaster for your pets, cuz that's the only value you're really going to get out of it. Um and then just another minor gripe cuz I'm not There I got very few positive things. You have a boat that you can drive around. Um it can cross water on its own, otherwise it can't cross land. Like why not make it the board look actually have water lines. You know, there's I mean, there's been games out there that have different types of vehicles that can move across different types of terrain.
Um why not instead of doing this generic ass AI you know, design looking AI looking design board, why not have it to where you have your different sections, but then you have roads, what actually look like streets that connect from one city to Hey, these are what the cars can drive on. And then have blue lines. Hey, this is what the boat can drive on. Give a Why not Why isn't there a plane? That can hold a few animals or even one big one that Hey, the plane can fly anywhere, but it can only hold one guy. Um just it it feels as if you there is also the theming wasn't even leaned in. I've I've made the few jokes, but I kid you not there's I mean there's a decent number of animals, but not a ton. Uh reptiles and birds are basically completely omitted.
Um but the theming for them is also black luster. They're either on fire or they're stuck in water. I mean there's other things that can happen that animals need rescue. It doesn't make it any less sad when something happens, but you you eventually you get annoyed with reading the flavor text cuz wow, another fire. Okay. Um I guess we'll go rescue it. And the dispersion of who is needed is also random cuz with the benefits of having a certain type of character, the firefighter or the rock climber, um that's all over the place. Sometimes I mean it is thematic on who you need.
Hey, the uh the dog that fell in the well, for example, you need the carabiner item and and a rope. Um so or having the not the item, the rope rescuer and having a rope gear helps a lot. Okay, that it is thematic, but it just feels some characters can just feel completely useless. And these are all literally the same. At least with Pandemic and other stuff, all the characters felt different. The the there's no point to having these. Um besides for the like, "Hey, the rope uh rescuer gives you plus two on a roll that requires her." But that's pretty much it.
And yeah, they do have the animal expertise animal expertise. Uh hey, they both get she gets a um a funding token. She gets what they call an expertise token. Um the extraction gets a logistics token. Riveting player powers. So, yeah, I I feel like I've [ __ ] on this game enough. I really really did not like it. Um and yeah, so on a scale of 1 to 10, I'm going to give Animal Rescue Team a four. I really think it is a below average game. I've already mentioned the game that has a similar enough theme of rescuing animals or saving animals.
Um that is just better in every way. Um I and then the things I do like about it are literally its theme and the idea of the vehicles, but again the vehicles are one of the things I have a big issue with. And I guess this is a re-implement Oh, that's right. It re-implements Thunderbirds. I've never played that. So, I I don't know. I've heard about it, but it came out Oh, that one came out in 2015. For some reason the art on it made me way older. But, well, probably never trying Thunderbirds cuz I really didn't like Animal Rescue Team. Um so, yeah. I guess that's it. Let me know what you think of this game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day this is for you.