Tidal Blades Heroes of the Reef - Should You Play? A Board Game Review
Transcript
what's inside this giant box tidal blades how it plays coming up
hi it's tyron and stella from people university today we are excited to talk about tidal blades look at these heroes of the reef thank you so we're going to start with overview of the game before we share you what we think of it yes tidal blades is a worker placement game and there's all these central boards they're all broken up into little sub boards and ultimately what we're trying to do we're playing as warriors and we're trying to prove ourselves the best in the reef and to do that we're going to be doing challenges in the arena this here which doubles as a dice tray is the arena of our area and so we'll be picking up these i haven't shown all of the cards that we face up at any given time because of space but essentially we will be gathering these challenge cards and then attempting to complete them by rolling the symbols that are shown on these dice that's ultimately where most of your points are going to come down to you can also fight against monsters who are challenging the reef and it's right it's done in a very similar way it's trying to roll these symbols on dice um so how does it work we've got is a fairly conventional worker placement with one small twist so we've got all these little worker placement spaces you'll move both you'll put your disk on a space and move your mini to that location that is blocked out for the rest of the round but your mini stays here because there
are some effects that will combo off where your mini is and so it's important to know where your where you last took an action effectively but otherwise you just place your disk you get the bonus that's printed underneath where your disc goes and then you do the action at the space you're at and those two things are going to give you dice shells fruit cards all sorts of things so you're always going to get a pretty good amount of resources coming in and then to finish your turn you attempt to do a challenge that matches the location that you're at it would have been on your hand yes so you'll reveal from your hand and then you'll roll dice and you'll try to resolve that effect and then when you do that's going to level up your character so each time you put a symbol onto a challenge you'll level up that symbol on your player board which will give you additional bonuses and eventually additional points the dice that you've got the dice that you've got will ultimately you've got active dice and spent dice and you can also lose dice as you go through it and i mean that's that's really the guts of the game you play it over four or five rounds depending on whether you're playing a quick game or a longer game you can level up your individual characters so one of these dials will let you go through your individual character
powers and take some of those so you'll be leveling yourself up that way and that adds some asymmetry to the game you can level up spirit which makes these cards more powerful and then you can level up some powers that give you more dice back each round or let you roll more dice in the in the challenges the dice themselves so anytime you go into a challenge you choose the dice you're going to roll you roll them and the danger die or the damage die i think that's called you pick out any symbols that will go on to your challenge and if you get an x you have to either spend a shell from your supply or you lose a die and then you just keep re-rolling and you can re-roll as many times as you want um until you're either out of dice because you've spent them all or until you choose to stop or until you've completed the challenge you also get some consolation for the amount of shells when you do spend a shell you're putting it onto a shield there's a little consolation there as well like every every four you can just give up on rolling and just set the diet to whatever you want something like that you can level up your dice so the middle dice are they have every symbol on them and then as you progress you can become more specialized in certain symbols which stacks the odds in your favor for completing certain challenges
uh you can go and fight the monsters which works in a similar way except you you get more points but you lose the dice that you use to fight them and if monsters aren't defeated they'll have negative effects for everyone who hasn't fought them so that can be an interesting balance in the game as well so why are we doing all this we miss that theme park we are warriors we are going everywhere there are three battle arena where we complete challenges before we go off and fight the monsters we're getting missions from the city of the city of time and we we do it um to pick up the quest and then we go around to pick up resources fight monsters and so on so i i do like that theme um because it's quite immersive uh but sorry back to you no i think that covers the game uh that is that is essentially how it plays uh it's all about getting dice getting an engine to get dice getting shells to help you with the probability and then powering through as many challenges or monsters as you can yep it's really got a really nice engine built what i like about it i know i use okay there are times where i'm afraid of die scared of dice almost that because i don't think they're on my side but not in this game because when you roll you can just keep rolling as long as you have the shell thing that you can put it there and at the end if you have four um at the basic one you can i can you can just discard that and then set one die face
to whatever you want which helps with the challenge and that once you complete the challenge you upgrade yourself and you're becoming better so you kind of like you refresh more dies at the end of the turn you can roll more dice um and so on so i like that engine building dice mitigation i do like the theme as well in this game um as the warrior theme and it's very immersive because look i mean look at this book it's a hardcover book comes with a kickstarter we've got a deluxe edition by the way so it tells you the story of the heroes and location um and look at this like if this is this location the boat looks good um i like the components i think tom and darth tower is um this is like the second and the third game um top game with components of 2020.
yeah i i personally have i have a personal preference for one central board rather than all these modular balls boards but i know that some of them flip over and the expansion adds a separate board so there's a reason for it and i can deal with that yeah it it just the first time it took me quite a while because we kind of like learn and play at the same time like what does this go what does it go but then there's like with this manual there's instruction we tried to watch a video i can't remember what it was and it's like oh that was too fast but then that's our fault as well anyway so what do you think karen i think the yeah we've both uh to some extent compared this game to lords of waterdeep which is all my line which i think is because it's a worker placement game where fundamentally most your points are coming by going out getting cards taking them back and completing the objective on it with resources and location and things like that so and i think it is a fair comparison and i think when i think about a worker placement game like this i do like i think it's a right level of tightness for a medium level game because you can always do the main action of the location you go to but often you do really want the bonuses like the extra shells that you need for mitigating your dice rolls or the extra the extra dice that come with some of the locations and it becomes an interesting puzzle and
something where you've got to really think what do other players want to be you know i really need this bonus but then i really need to get that bonus before i can do the challenge of that location so do you go to a location and have a worse attempt at a challenge because you haven't gone and stocked up or do you go and do the thing you really want somewhere else i think that that clicks together really well and it's also really tight as the game goes on and you get more workers yeah it is still dice rolling some euro gamers would be like oh dice but as i say it's not that hard to mitigate the dice roll that lies lost um with you know having enough shells or and then shells and getting the right sorts of dice that's correct um if you upgrade it this is like a nice game trace dice tray you can upgrade it with more a certain you know more probability on certain symbols the wild card the wild symbols as well and then certain monsters can only be fought by certain like upgraded dice it's very euro game friendly if you scared of guys i would agree with that i think when you look at when you look at games that have that fundamentally our role to resolve in most of the things that score you points there's a really smart uh probability economy essentially in this game you can mitigate you can build up to certain things and i haven't done the mathematics on it but it does look like you've got a very good
you can you can trust your probabilities essentially you can build up to something and have a pretty good idea what's going to happen but sometimes you're just going to roll badly and the shells you're going to have to have enough shells in in storage to do that sometimes you can push your luck you know the time we played i pushed my luck on a one in eight chance of it falling apart and it fell apart your fault and i was taking the risk i knew i was taking the risk yeah but that's not going to appeal to everyone and the fact that pretty much every player's turn is going to end with a little sort of dice rolling exercise which will take a few rolls and moving shells around and thinking i did find that bog the game down a little bit because it's a very independent thing that people are doing there right it meant there was a bit more down time than i would have liked so those are the those are the two things that are negative about what is still a very well designed dice mechanic let's see we just like squat minority why you know um why you like it you not like it but we play with our friends they also like it they actually want to buy it um but he probably won't get the deluxe version and he knows that he probably gonna get disappointed well that's what happened with formal right so yes and i i enjoy the building up your seo complete challenge because that's the main thing you do the more challenge you can play the better and you build up your engine as well
your dial so like this one for example you you know turn it up so that you can get to roll more dice and this one is there's a bonus card that you can use and then that combo of this one and it gets better again character cards as you increase your synergy which is this symbol you get more um benefits for your character so the asymmetric character cards like this one when you visit seattle of time um or the chronosium you gain one shell so extra bonuses or things like that there's also bonus when you you know visit a location with other players i mean it is competitive in terms of workplaces but then it's not too competitive because you can still go to a location and complete the challenge and do the action as well but not the bonus yeah there's a lot of pathways you can take yeah the monsters we haven't spoken in a lot of detail about the monsters as well but they they introduce an interesting element there's a track up the top here the the champion board where certain actions will move you up on here and that's another it's another way of getting delayed points and then there's benefits for leading that and things so yeah it it all all pans out to be very interesting going that way yeah for sure so i'll definitely try to get we have the expansion but we haven't played it yet so it adds another board and another resource yep that's the anglers cove expansion and can you bring me that box first so this
is a big box with a really big box it doesn't fit on any conventional shelf that sits on top of our shelves uh and this is what i like so maybe a little bit ocd but this tells you how to stack the components in so there i think a few others it's got it like wingspan or scythe and you need it because there's lots of game trays and it packs very uh very tightly in there yeah very tightly um i don't think the expansion will fit i don't know i haven't even tried it yet haven't checked yeah we've got the like again i said i've got the the components components beautiful the dolls are great um the minis are great the dice tray is amazing i think this is the most one of the most beautiful dice tray i've i've seen coming out of the board game itself not like a separately made and this is uh the the arena the shape of arena is like you fight in there and then it's like people sitting in there i just like trying to imagine it that's cool so cool one thing i would say about the comparison with lords of waterdeep uh is i don't think it's it's probably a lighter and less brutal action draft than lords of waterdeep but i don't think i would start with this as a gateway because there's a few there's more overall things going on than there are in lots of watercolor black city wise yeah so i think lords of waterdeep is still where you would go to teach someone work a placement um and more so than this com mission
what do you call it that objective mission completion yep yeah but i think what a fulfillment but i think a lot of people after they've learned that will be better suited to something a little bit more uh that still has some challenge in the draft but it's a little bit more gentle like this one so this game was kickstarter and tim eisner is one of my favorite designers i met him as well at one of conventions really lovely he designed games like the green masquerade and a few others um i can't think of any case under my head but i enjoy his game so that's another thing as well if you know do you get attracted to you know if you recognize the designer i think it's natural to you know you play a few of the designers designs and then like yeah oh straight away i want to play that so like this is one of them and you know um i think drew city games also good at making great components and the storybook so that's it uh that's tidal blade heroes of the reef heroes of the river turtle blades should you play you decide for yourself and let us know as well what you think of this if you have played or if you have any questions from the comment sections below um you would help us if you hit that like button hopefully you found this video somewhat useful and if you haven't already subscribed to us please subscribe to us you can also hit the nipple in the corner and hit the bell so you won't miss anything from us
i am on social media as well like instagram so hopefully we'll see you there we'll chat there um and that's it hopefully i'll see you in our next videos bye