Skip to main content
Loading video...

Mexica - Bringing a classic back to life - TCbH Review

Transcript 6:05

2002's Mexica is both a stone-cold classic and utterly emblematic of its time. Following in the wake of Carcassonne, which was a genre-defining tile layer, it set out to achieve similar ends but by inverse means. You're carving out different pieces of civic infrastructure to lay claim to and compete for points over, but instead of building up from one tile at a time, you're instead taking this entire map and dividing it into little subsections. And while it holds this classic status and has had multiple printings over the years, it's never quite found its core audience, not being as accessible as some of the other tile layers at the time and not quite as layered as the more complex contemporaries like Tigris and Euphrates. But now, with many publishers turning their gazes back to these tried-and-true games from the '90s and '00s, often revitalizing them with brilliant production and smoothed-out design, Mexica is just one of several titles that Play for Keeps is bringing back to the fold.

So, what is it? Every turn, a player takes actions to add canals and bridges to Tenochtitlan, future capital of the Aztec Empire, separating it into land masses of exact size that can be founded as districts based on the demands of randomized district tiles, a sort of boundary bounty set up at the beginning of the game. Importantly, before or after districts are formed, players can put out temples of various sizes in their color, which contribute to control of the district they're within. Once all districts are claimed and a player runs out of buildings, points are awarded based on player rankings. Then, the board stays exactly the same, but every player gets some extra buildings set aside in reserve, some new district tokens are put out, players do a second era taking turns until districts are founded or can no longer be made, then points are again awarded and the game ends. Conceptually, this game is very simple, but it's easier said than done. And I mean that practically as well as strategically.

One of its greatest strengths, but depending on your perspective, could also be a weakness is how particular it is. Each turn you're given six action points to spend, which can be one point per chunk of water or a bridge you're laying out, one point per movement of your dude, or one to four points to whip out one of your temples in accordance to their size, though zero action points to found a district, but it's important that your little dude-er is within the district even if the majority of other actions you take, aside from the construction of the temples and the districts, is ambivalent to wherever your worker dude is. And the possible permutations of your turn are staggering. Good play in Mexico really comes down to hypothetical arrangements of these water tiles and how far you can get your builder in one turn, with the tension often coming from not being able to do it all at once, but also not wanting to tip your hand too early as it's extremely easy for someone else to just boop, put a building out where they think you're going to surround. If Carcassonne is a cutthroat game hidden under an external cozy affair, Mexica outright wears its hostility on its sleeve, and it's fun.

It moves at a clip. The development of the board, with the towers especially in this new edition, gives it great table presence. And pulling off good turns feels exceptionally clever and rewarding, but it's also crunchy. Not complex, not complicated, but analytically crunchy. I like layered nuanced games, and I've been playing games since before Mexico was the bleeding edge of releases, but having a fully flexible six actions on your turn means you're going to spend a lot of time thinking, looking, counting, analyzing. And I'm honestly shocked there's not player tokens you can flip to keep track of remaining actions on your turn as inevitably every game of it someone asks halfway through their grand reveal, "Wait, was that four actions or was that five?"

Fortunately, no individual action is particularly complex in resolution, and when that happens you can backtrack, but these are some of the things that are part and parcel to this game. But that's also what helps it stand out. Like other recent very celebrated reprints of games like Raw or Brass, the productions have done a good job to maintain some of the edges that would otherwise be smoothed out in more modern design. Now, Christina, Mrs. TC BH, she straight-up did not like this game. She understood it, she respected it, she could see why the other people at the table were enjoying it, but this was something that is just completely out of her wheelhouse and not something that she'd care to play again.

Now, of note, the rest of the game group that I showed this to, largely consisting of people who have picked up hobby board gaming over the last 10 years, had a good time with it. It's just not one that I'm going to be convincing her to play a lot of in the future. So, if you like abstract games that are relatively rules-light but offer a lot of interaction with dynamic and flexible turns that reward careful analysis and consideration, all with a fresh coat of paint that makes it the best that it's ever looked, then there's a good chance that this classic is going to do it for you. And that's our review, but let me know, what is your favorite game that's at least 20 years old? Double points if it hasn't been printed in at least 10 years. And who's the publisher that you'd like to see take on that project? Put it in the comments. But as always, thanks for watching, thanks for supporting, thanks for doing all the things that help us grow. But above all else, just thanks for being such a great community.

You know I've been Jack for The Cardboard Herald.

Progress saved