Patchwork Review
Transcript
welcome to John gits games today I'll be reviewing Patchwork this is a two-player game where each player is attempting to build the best quilt in front of themselves by assembling a bunch of very oddly shaped and vibrantly Illustrated quilting tiles first I'll go through a bunch of turns to show you how the game plays and then I'll jump into my review here's a starting setup for patchwork each player gets their own player board five money we have a central board here which tracks the turns and then finally this big ring of funky differ Siz tiles that is randomized for every play on this board there are player tokens of each color and they start stacked on top of each other the way the game works is the player who is farthest back on the spiral track gets to take their turn and whoever is on top of the other if they happen to be stacked is a starting player so that means green gets to go first there are two different action options that are available to each player to choose from to evaluate their whole turn the first of these is grabbing a tile from the central ring here which is I think what our green player is going to do for the first turn of the game you'll notice this neutral white Pawn here it always begins to the left of this particular piece wherever it randomly happens to fall and the important thing about this Pawn is it dictates what tiles we're allowed to grab you can only grab tiles that are up to three spaces clockwise from this Pawn here so that means these three tiles are options for the green player there are two different types of currencies in the game there are buttons which also count as victory points at a one: one rate but there's also time which you'll see on these tiles as well as a little hourglass as I mentioned before the player who is farthest back on that time track gets to take their turn so if you spend a whole bunch of time going up in the track another player might be able
to take multiple turns before you get to take one again so looking at these three options we can see that the green player can't even afford this piece here it costs eight buttons and they only have five they can easily afford this one but this one covers a lot of area for five buttons and it has a button on top of it which generates income which I'll explain in just a little bit so I think our green player is going to go ahead and spend all five of their buttons for their starting move to grab this piece here tows can be placed anywhere on these player boards they can be flipped over and turned around in any different kind of orientation they want and they go ahead and place it down on the board and once they're happy with it that's where it's going to stay next up we move this Pawn here to the location where this tile once was and lastly we have to pay the time cost we know that tile took three time so the green player moves one two three up on the track and now we see that it's yellow's turn because they are farthest back on the spiraling board our yellow player now has different tile options because this Pawn moved we look at these three tiles here and we notice that this tile doesn't even have any button cost it just cost time and it has a button on it for income which I still have an play but I'll get to very shortly I think our yellow players is going to go ahead grab this piece here they can Orient it however they want maybe put it down right there on their board they pay no buttons because there are no button cost on here and then they go ahead and spend our three time we of course move this neutral Pawn up to the empty spot where that piece was and then we pay the three time we go one two three and we stack on top of other pawns if we land on the same spot the interesting thing here is that the pawn on top gets to take their turn next so that means yellow gets to go again looking at these three options yellow has a couple choices we have this really funky shaped one that can be kind of
hard to make fit into our area for later turns but it's quite cheap and we also have this one which will work quite well they can afford and has two different buttons on it is a very Hefty time cost of six but H yellow thinks they want to go ahead and do that so they'll place it down their board it fits nicely just like that we move the pawn up here and then we spend our four buttons to the bank so yellow now needs to pay 1 two 3 4 five six time and you'll notice that we crossed over this button on the track here and this is an income slot as soon as a player's Pawn goes over a button they immediately get buttons equal to the number of buttons that are on their player sheet looking at yellow's sheet we see three different buttons on their board that means they get three buttons from the bank and that ends their turn it's now Green's turn because they are farthest back on this time trck here but they're in a bit of a problem they spent all five of their buttons for the first action which means they have no buttons left because they haven't hit that income slot yet looking at the three tiles that are ahead of this neutral marker here we see they all require buttons so green can't buy any of them well fortunately there is a second option for an action that you could do on your turn and that is to Simply catch up on this player board and get money for it you take your pawn and you move it all the way up on the board until it's one slot ahead of the opponent and then you get one money for each of these spaces that you moved so green will go 1 two 3 four five six seven spaces and take seven money from the bank in addition to this green did pass this income slot here they only have an income of one but hey hey they'll take that so Green's turn is over they've now got eight money and it looks like it's
yellow's turn now because green was by definition forced to go one ahead from their opponent at this point I'm going to fast forward through a couple turns until we hit the next interesting thing that I want to show you all right it's our green players turn they're farthest back on the track they've got seven money so they can afford well all of these different options they're going to go ahead and grab this piece right here and put it down I don't know something maybe like that in their area that'll cost all seven of their money but when they pay their time something interesting happens this cost green six times so it goes 1 2 3 4 5 6 they of course get their income but more importantly they cross over this leather patch spot on the board the first person to go over the spot gets this leather patch which they immediately need to add to their board wherever they want in this case I think our green friend might put it right there and this essentially lets you fill in areas on your board that are just hard to get to based off of how the Pieces come in they can just patch in little holes and of course they get their seven income for crossing that spot all right time to fast forward a few turns again until we get to the next interesting thing I want to show you all right it's the yellow players turn and they're going to be taking one of these tiles but as soon as they do that something interesting is going to happen you may have noticed this tile hanging around it has a 7 by seven and then seven buttons on it this is a bonus award given to the player who creates a full 7 by7 grid first and this overall grid is 9 by9 we see that our yellow player is only this spot off from creating a 7x7 area so they can purchase this piece right here sided in just like
that that'll cost them the two buttons like normal and they get this reward they don't actually get the buttons for it they just put it in their area and this is going to be worth seven buttons or seven victory points at the end of the game for yellow okay so you can see that there are not that many pieces left and the game is going to end once both players make it all the way around the spiral to the very center of the board uh we're pretty close let's go ahead and fast forward get to the end game and then I'll explain how the scoring works okay the game is over you may have noticed that there is a button on the last slot before the center spot here you can overshoot this as much as you want you just end in this final space and that means you take income one last time as you end the game each player loses two buttons or points for each uncovered spot on their board so the green player here has 1 2 3 4 5 6 seven eight so 8 * 2 is 16 they lose 16 points our yellow player has 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 uncovered so they're going to lose 20 points and now we just add up the buttons on each side including this bonus TI here Whoever has the highest number of buttons wins the game and in this case and I swear I did not plan for this both players have 18 points in that case we have to go to the tiebreaker and that is whichever player made it to the center tile first which in this case is yellow wins the game so yellow takes the victory let's begin the review section by covering the first positive point and this one is that almost every turn of this game provides the player with something satisfying and interesting to do now of course one thing you can do is just jump your Pawn ahead and take money
for all those spots that is usually not very satisfying but at least 75% of the turns you're going to take there are tiles out there that you want to buy and you're going to buy especially once you get to the mid late game when you have tons of income you can afford almost every tile out there so you are thinking about what tiles are going to work best for your area I mean it's pretty common that at least two out of those three tiles are purchasable and a feasible option so you get to think about spatially how they're going to fit into your area but then you also look at your opponent's board and you look at the tiles coming up ahead and you say oh wow that tile that's five tiles away from the pawn my opponent really wants and they can afford so maybe I will buy a tile in such a way that it won't give my opponent the opportunity to grab that tile you know I'll only take one so it only shifts one and that tile is still four away and of course your opponent is doing this back at you and it just creates a bunch of interesting things to think about considering there's really only three possible tiles to purchase now this game can be played much more passively than that where you're just focusing on what you have in front of you and that is satisfying as well because you're just seeing this great little grid all fit together it's just it's a satisfying experience positive number two has to do with how elegant and easy to teach this game is the different mechanisms that are going on in the game just click together in such an easygoing way you have all these goofy tiles but they just snap together on this grid that you have in front of you in fact when you put this on the table and you put all the tiles out I would Hazard a guess that somebody who's never played the game sitting down can look out and within about 20 seconds have a pretty good idea
of what the whole game is going to be just from looking at it and then when you teach this game you will probably get through it in about a minute and a half to two minutes and you'll just go right into playing it I really like that you're not going to be spending a whole long time explaining rules and a bunch of side cases and there just really aren't any of those when you go over the leather um patch spot on the board well you just take it and put it in your area when you go over a button you count up the number of buttons you get and you take those buttons from the bank it just it all works together really well and it's really impressed me positive number three has to do with the overall production value and component quality of this game uh first of all none of the tiles are the same they're all unique and there is a huge variety of very goofy shapes going from tiny little spiky things to a big H that can go in the middle of your board and I just love how beautifully colored they are so that when you put them on your board you really feel like you have the this mismatched awesome quilt going on it definitely matches up with a theme that the box was going for just all in all you got all these little buttons for victory points and money they could have just had little coins with a number on it but no they're buttons that are sewn into the quilt it just it aesthetically makes so much sense and it's very pleasing and now for my one neutral point which has to do with that 7 by7 bonus tile that players can get by completing a 7x7 grid on their board first my first gut reaction to that tile was not really liking it it's it seems like this is a very elegant game like I just talked about with this weird little bonus tacked on um I've also seen that I've played the game four times now in
three out of those four games the player who has taken that tile has won by quite a large margin uh now of course one of those games that didn't happen it was me I took the tile and I still lost by quite a bit so I don't think that the tile is overpowered that's why this is a neutral point but it it rubs me a little bit wrong I feel like I get what they were going for it's another thing to shoot for as you're building your area you're like oh well I'm trying to be really efficient but I'm also trying to get that 7x7 grid to go and you're trying to hunt down those leather patches on that player board to fill in those pesky little spots to get that bonus and I get that but at the end of the day I don't like it that much I'm not going to play the game without it because I trust in the designer that this was something they played a whole bunch and they decided was needed in the game but ultimately I kind of wish it wasn't there so here would be the section where I tell you one or two negative aspects to game that I felt really hurt the overall gameplay experience for myself and for most people but I can't think of any for patchwork this is a really solid game so let's just move on to the next section and that would be replayability Patchwork is one of those games that presents everything it has to offer on the table the first time you play it it doesn't have alternate Victory conditions some are in the box and some are in the game no this game puts it all out there on the board but it randomizes all of those tiles every single time you play and that simple Act of randomizing that humongous number of very goofy shaped tiles really bolsters the replayability of the game sure every game you play is going to feel like the last game but the fact that the last
game was really fun makes that a good thing I could see this game being played a whole bunch like way past 10 times and that's just because it has satisfying things that you're doing you're filling in your little grid and it just it's just viscerally fun to just chunk these things in here and just feel proud about the fact that you made that work you might take a tile or two you're like oh man I just don't see how this is going to fit in but more often than not you're going to fill that almost entirely in maybe even entirely and you're like wow I can't believe I did that that totally worked and you just feel great and that feel great feeling seems to not degrade as you play the game over and over again so in general I'm very impressed with replayability and now let's discuss player count which is pretty simple because there is only one player count you can only play this game with two players and at first that bummed me out a little bit because I really enjoyed the game and I figured well if there's three of us here I'd like to play a three-player game of it but then I started thinking about it and there are so many tiles in the game for just two players if they had to add a third player the Ring of tiles would be so gigantic and they probably just run out of ideas to make new unique tiles and plus there's not much you're doing on your turn when it's not your turn so there' be more downtime as you had more players going around the table so it makes sense that this game was designed for two players and I'm really happy about that in conclusion Patrick has really impressed me when I first heard about this game when it came out last year didn't really grab me too much I heard it was two-player only and you're making quilts and I didn't think too much about it but then I saw a full playthrough video by Michael Winer on YouTube and I was like oh my gosh that looks so much fun that looks so elegant
and I went out to try and buy it and it was over $100 everywhere because it was out of print so I anxiously waited for the new print run to come out which was a month or two ago and I've been so happy to have this game in my collection now I played it four times and I've really enjoyed it every time whether I've won or lost and the people I played it with have really enjoyed it too it's just it's a great experience you teach the rules so quickly and just the way everything syncs up you just feel you just feel so satisfied with this thing that you've put in front of yourself it's kind of like like I can't believe I did that I was really able to make that work and wow there's only like five empty spots left on this board that feels awesome then again there have been times where you have like 10 empty slots on the board and your score is terrible but even in those cases I haven't been frustrated I just kind of felt like I will do better next time and I really want to play this game again so I highly recommend this game for pretty much anyone who is in situations where two-player games Can Happen honestly I'm to the point where I will actively try to play a two-player game of this in a game night with a whole bunch of people there because it's just such a good game it's so much fun to play and I want to introduce it to all of my friends if you'd like to become more involved with the channel you can directly support it at patreon.com jgames and I'd like to thank everybody who is already supporting the channel on patreon if you'd like to see more in-depth board game reviews like this one as as well as full game playthroughs and Vlogs please subscribe to my channel thanks for watching