I'm conflicted about this...
Transcript
Hello everyone. Welcome. I'm Robert and today I want to discuss Arkham Horror Remastered. Now for those that don't know, Fantasy Flight Games late last year announced the Vault Series and this is an initiative to basically bring back old games that have long been out of print and people were speculating as to what their first game would be and what games they were considering bringing back. Some people thought that maybe they would bring back Runebound second and third editions which are beloved and long out of print and a lot of the expansions for those games command ridiculous prices in the secondary market. Some people also thought maybe Lord of the Rings also G which also has the same issue, tons of expansions, difficult to find.
And finally this week Fantasy Flight Games dropped this nuke and they have announced a remaster of one of the most beloved board games of all time, Arkham Horror second edition. Now what is my experience with Arkham Horror second edition? So I am a bit of a Johnny-come-lately to this. I started this hobby in 2020 and I didn't get to play this gem of a game until a couple of years ago and I've only played the core set, played it about four times solo four-handed and I adored it. It's one of the best basically RPGs in a box in a way where you control a party and you have this amazing emergent narrative and it is just a magical experience. It has very interesting and unique mechanics and it allowed me to appreciate how other later games that I had played at that point took inspiration from this. So yeah, this is just some big Ameritrash stuff.
So obviously I wasn't there in the mid-2000s when this hit shelves and it made the huge cultural impact that it did, and it hit the uh board gaming world by storm. But, I can definitely see why people love this game so much. And, I did like it so much, in fact, that I got the Dunwich Horror expansion, and that was actually very recent because I kept an eye out for one that was decently priced and in good shape, and finally I got a reasonably priced one couple months ago, and I just integrated and sleeved all of it. And, I've been itching to play it. I just have a huge backlog. Uh but, yeah, now they made this announcement, and I am conflicted for a couple reasons. Let's start with the fact that um well, I had the idea in my head that they were going to do literal one-to-one reissues of these uh products, right? And, the biggest reason for me that I hoped that they would go with that approach is to preserve the aesthetic of the original.
Folks, one of the most amazing things about uh this old game is the aesthetic. It really is a product of its time, but it just has so much charm. I love the illustrations. I love the graphic design. And, it really gives the game so much personality. And, while the new graphic design and illustrations look really cool from the previews that they have given us, I am a bit saddened that uh this is going to get lost, and you're going to have to buy an old copy for this. And, if you want uh all the expansion content for this, you're still going to have to pay those ridiculous uh secondary market prices. Obviously, the other advantage of them instead having decided to uh do a one-to-one reissue of the product would have been that collectors who are missing expansions because of the high prices would have been able to complete their um you know, their collections uh so that they have all the expansions. But, yeah, obviously all of those hopes have been dashed. Now, the upside, though, is that, of course, they are remastered everything, not just the core set. They are going to remaster all expansion content that was produced. And they are even teasing new gameplay elements and much more to be revealed. Now, the second reason why I am conflicted is I'm trying to internalize or figure out if this is something that I even want.
Now, there are things that make me excited about this. First and foremost for me folks, it's those amazing dashboards. I love what they did here. I think this is a great change for adjusting your character stats and keeping track of their health. I love this. So, I think as far as quality of life upgrades, I can already picture this being amazing. And the other thing that excites me about this is the fully revised rulebook. Now, the learning experience of the original that I have wasn't the worst. There is a lot of files on BoardGameGeek that allow you to follow the turn structure. So, it really wasn't that bad. But I can see how this could use a bit of modernization to streamline the learning experience. And honestly, it's not that I was planning to buy more content. To be honest with you, I was very content with just the base game and Dunwich because I have heard that Dunwich is the one of the more essential expansions.
And that's a bit of my policy when it comes to expansions. I tend not to buy that many these days honestly. But I thought Dunwich would be a great way to round out the package a bit better. Now, I also want to comment on another concern that has been brought up because now every publisher is put under scrutiny when it comes to AI. And apparently, Fantasy Flight Games does not implement AI into their game. So, that's a good thing. So, we don't have to worry about the new art having AI usage. Now, I do have one other concern though. And that is how are they planning to price this? From what I understand, this is Asmodee's foray into uh the crowdfunding sphere. I don't know how predatory they are going to be when it comes to how this is going to be priced. I think one could speculate that considering how much people are willing to pay on the secondary market for this, uh they might use that as an excuse for uh commanding ridiculous prices for the all-in package of this, even though there's no miniatures or anything. I think the fanciest component about this is probably the dual-layer board. But, there's no miniatures. It's just tokens, a board, tons of cards, and a handful of dice. So, I'm really curious to see how they are planning to price this. Now, this is going to be a bit of an aside, but I want to comment on this comparison that I originally thought of making for this video, right?
Uh so, if you live in the US and if you go to Target or or Walmart, uh there are toy sections that if you walk by, you'll see that they have this like nostalgic toys like that are like reissues from toys that came out in the '90s and '80s, right? Now, I'm not a toy collector, but just from glancing at them when I walk by them at Walmart or Target, I was always under the impression that these were one-to-one reissues, right? Uh but, I was actually completely wrong cuz I wanted to make this comparison, right? Uh for this video with Arkham Horror of like a reissue of an old product, which Arkham Horror is at this point 20 years old. But, I was shocked to find out that uh when these toys get reissued, they have a non-insignificant amount of changes. So, they are not one-to-one reproductions. They have lots of adjustments made, uh more articulation, the packaging changes completely. Uh so, they are a remastered. They're not one-to-one reissues. But, there's a lot more reasons that I didn't think of for this. Apparently, from what I read, toy regulations have changed, packaging regulations have changed, so they can't just reissue these toys one-to-one.
Which in my head I didn't think that that could be such an inconceivable idea, but apparently that's much more difficult than I thought. And I don't know if that's going to be the modus operandi of the Vault series moving forward. I really was hoping that they would do some one-to-one reissues of things for the reasons that I stated earlier for the nostalgic factor of the art and also so that collectors can round out their collections, but from this announcement I think that we can kiss those possibilities goodbye. I just don't think that they're going to reissue any product without touching it at all. I thought that they would just do a reprint one-to-one of a lot of things, but yeah, from this announcement it just doesn't seem like that's going to be the case. So, my current stance is I'm really happy with my old version and I don't have an issue with how it functions. I love the art. I don't mind the fiddliness. I am excited for this, but I can't justify like buying. I think one day I might buy it on sale or trade for it like out of morbid curiosity. And depending on the pricing and the campaign incentives, who knows? I'm open to it, but right now I can't picture myself buying this anytime soon.
I still have a lot to enjoy just from my original set and its beautiful art. Now, one final thought that I wanted to share is that don't be surprised if this campaign is successful that it'll start a gold rush of FFG and even potentially other publishers from cashing in on the craze of remastering or reissuing older classic games. Now, I don't know of a lot of other publishers that have the caliber of back catalog that FFG has, but this has the potential of well, making FFG creatively bankrupt and not coming up with new innovative games and just relying on their old library. And on the side of video games and movies, there's definitely an issue of companies not wanting to take risk and just cashing in on nostalgia. But luckily, I don't think that that's the case in the board gaming industry. I think there's still a lot of creativity and a lot of innovative and cool ideas.
So even if this starts a trend of remasters, I think there will still be a lot of cool innovative board games coming out every year. But yeah, folks, let me know what you think in the comment section. Are you getting this? Are you avoiding it? And if so, please let me know why. Thank you all so much for watching. And if you have any comments, questions, feedback, go ahead and put them in the comment section. And if you enjoyed this content, make sure to like and subscribe, and I'll see you in the next one.