Carl Von Linné Review - Take it or Leaf it?
Transcript
Hello and welcome out to the Dice Tower. I'm Wendy Ye.
And I'm Chris Yei.
And today we're going to be reviewing Carl von Len.
This is a game from uh from Pink Trouidor.
And you'll notice that this game looks awful lot like the cover of Galileo Galile, which they also published last year, maybe the year before.
They call this the pink trouidor beige. This is the pink troop beige uh quadrology trilogy.
Pretty beige line.
Yeah. Yeah. I like this whole idea of having this line of of thinky crunchy euro games about his important historic scientists.
Yeah. So, Michael Ple is the designer for this. Um and this is kind of that like second in the line of uh Galileo Galilei uh but a different scientist. So, I'm going to go show you briefly how this is played and then we'll come back and share our thoughts. All right, strap in. This is going to be a brief overview of a pretty large game. Now, you do get one of these handy dandy little player aids. It's going to have a lot of information, but not all the information that you need. So, they put on the back of the rule book all the other icons that you need to know. Now, in this game, we are scientists who are trying to explore the natural world and collect a bunch of different samples and write books and do all these fun uh sciency things. [snorts] And we're going to be doing that with an interesting round and turn structure. So the game's going to take place across five rounds.
There's five little discs here. And this is going to be the turn order determination. Uh but once you've determined turn order and you're going through, you're going to have three possible actions that you can take. One action is going to be one times multiplier, one's going to be two times multiplier, and one's going to be three times multiplier. So when it is your turn, you're going to take one of your action discs. You're going to place it on one of these three spots and take the bonus that's underneath. And then you're going to take the action as many times as that is. So, for example, this one right here, I can choose a tool or crate. I'm going to grab a tool. And then I will take this action twice. I'll explain these actions later, but just so you know, uh this one under here allows you to move your little lens uh mover guy around here. And this is how you kind of upgrade your action spaces and get these fancier actions. And this one under here is going to be uh putting out your turn order marker. and that's going to give you a bonus. You're going to choose one of these three bonuses here and then that will determine turn order for the next round. Now, after everyone has taken their three turns, we end the round. We adjust turn order, all that jazz. And then we're going to clear off our board. So, we're going to pretend we took actions up here.
Anything that's down in this spot is going to become available. And then anything that was in the three times is going to scooch on down here. And then these ones will come back. Now, also at the end of the round, there's going to be a potential way to gain income. And then this little rudder here is going to turn and that will just affect some bonuses on one of the actions. So after you do that five times, five rounds, you count up all the points and see who wins. So let's talk a little bit more about what these little action tiles do. And we're going to use our handy dandy notebook for that right here. So first we have the explore action, which is the map action. And that is going to be down here in this area. You're going to be moving around. You're going to be getting benefits for hitting spots. So, the first time you come uh to any one of these locations, you're going to place these little tokens down and gain the benefits underneath them. And then you're going to interact with the space.
You can either take this little bonus at the top, or you can choose to take one of these tiles. Now, these tiles are important for future action. And when you place them, you get rewards based on any that are like pointing to or adjacent to where your guy is at the moment. So, just for an example here, I would go ahead and I would mark off this caterpillar saying I got it. And then I would go ahead and take the caterpillar as well to show I have that sample. All right, on to the next one, which is research. This is actually where we're going to be using these samples here. So, this guy can move around for every action point, one space. Um, he can go left, right, up, down, doesn't matter. He gets the benefit of whatever he covers up. And then the corners that are pointing towards that area he just went. So, this one here happens to move two on the green track. Whoop. And then this one here happens to let us get a letter available to us face down. Uh peek at that. It's a purple. Now, next on the list is correspondence. That's this little letter here. And for that one, you can either choose to take one of these letters or write them. Uh and you gain the benefit above them and then you have it in your hand. And then later after you've collected a couple of these, you can play up to two letters.
Now, if you play two letters, um if they're of different colors, you're going to put them in different columns. If they're of the same color, you're going to put them in the same column. You can have up to three together at once. Anyways, there's lots of specific rules on this that I'm not going to go into, but just know that uh you get to score extra stuff. Next up is our little flower action disc. And that I mentioned over here is this gardens area. And if you notice that there's some surrounded areas. So, there's little uh grids that look like this that are like six uh little pieces. There's grids that are four and grids that are three. And these are going to be area control. So, as you fill them up, as they get completely filled, then you'll do some sort of little area control game with them, um, and you'll score them immediately. You'll gain any bonus that's at the top, and they're just worth points depending on how many flowers are showing. There's also ways to flip over your discs. They cost a couple tools, and then you get benefits over here for flipping them over, and then they're always worth one more when they're flipped. Last, but not least, is the sale action. You're going to have a starting sale card and then you can purchase more for crates and money over here. And as you have sailing point, you're going to go ahead and move uh following the arrow single spaces and collecting the reward. So that's a crate right there. Uh this happens to be a dollar and that's what this little uh helm over here is. We see the little pips are pointing to a specific color.
When you go onto that color, you get that multiplied the amount of pips. So, right now it's only worth $1, but if I waited around to move that, it would be worth $3 for that space. Now, these are important because these you're going to try to move all the way down to the bottom for a onetime bonus. But later, if you are able to uh finish any of these book cards, which I'll explain here in a minute, they're going to actually be worth um income at the end of the round. So, if you want to keep getting this over and over again, get your boat down and get a book published. All right. So, what do we mean by publishing books? Taking a closer look at this. Uh, this requires a certain amount of samples and it requires a tool to take. So, on your turn as a free action, you can always just take one of those if you have a tool you want to spend. Uh, and then you have to collect samples. The samples we collect down here as we pass by these corners of these little critters. And then also, we need sketches, which we can get from various places on the board. We're going to spend those and they're going to give us points and they're going to give us some other bonuses like maybe moving up on tracks or doing some other things.
And then when they're completed, like I mentioned, they'll come down here for income. Now, I mentioned briefly free actions. There are a ton of free actions, including one that lets you spend $6 to take an action of your choice, but you're able to manipulate things around um get some more disc, get some more money, get some do some things that you need. Now, there are two types of cards that you have to use free actions for, and that's these ones that allow you to do your little ship action, and then the books up here, which allow you to do the bottom part of your ship action. So, just remember these cards require free actions to get. You don't really get them anywhere else. Now, another thing we see up here are these bluebacked samples. Um, and these are going to be endgame scoring if you meet the objective at the bottom. So, for example, if you have two blue sketches at the end of the game, this is worth five points. and then it immediately gives you one of those little caterpillar critters. These you can only get from the sailing cards. So, if you know this little blue space over here matches that back. So, if you choose to go over there, that is the way that you'll go ahead and get some of these endgame scoring cards. All right, so let's go ahead and talk points. So, points are going to be for these tracks that you move up. There's one time multipliers two times, three times, and then this single four time spot right here as well as other bonuses that you pass. And then there are first come first serve bonuses over here for six, three, or one points depending on who gets there first. Uh and those are going to be endgame scoring along with these going are going to be endame scoring.
You're also going to get points at the end game for the different colored letters that you've sent. So remember, single colors gives you a bunch of bonuses initially, but different colors gives you more points. Also, as you surround these completely, um, and you've gone to all the corners, these little critters are going to be considered completed. As they're completed, they're worth points depending on how many little icons they have in the corners. And finally, any flowers that you haven't scored yet, as well as just like a few resource things at the end. So, points come from a lot of different ways and a lot of different strategies that you can take in this game.
All right. So, uh there's definitely some DNA visually that tells me that this is kind of that second inline, right? We mentioned the beige earlier.
Um but then also that like long skinny board, the player powers, that board, um and even the the endgame slash in-game scoring tiles, the fact that you there's a certain amount of them and you use half of them face up and half of them face down. like that is a thing that I see too. I'm just kind of feeling these genetic consistencies
and it definitely feels like if you are if this is meaningful to you whatsoever, this feels like a game that is designed by a lot of the Italian squad of designers, the Flaminia Brasinis and the Simon Luchianis. Like it feels a lot like that. A lot of nested decisions, a lot of combos that combo into other things in this crunchy heady, you know, thinky euro game. And so if that's meaningful, that's a point of comparison that of designers that I really like their stuff. Galileo Galile felt that way. This one also feels that way, but with a completely different main driving mechanism, but a couple of great things that they carried over from the previous. In fact, to that point.
Yeah.
Where the endgame scoring things, some are face up over here, others are faced down here. I love that because then everything is represented in the game.
Yeah.
But just sometimes for like quicker Yeah. for different reasons that you're chasing it.
Yeah, because you can get massive points from those tracks if you're able to build them up, which spoilers, it is not easy. You have to focus in on the tracks. And um that's something that I noticed the first game that I played. Um I focused in on that a lot. The other players didn't. And I think there was a dispar like
disparity. There you go. That's what I'm looking for. Uh in scores because of that. Now, you can get points other ways for sure. I'm not saying that's the only way to win the game. Um, but I do think that that is kind of a key part to it.
And uh I love moving up a track. That is something I do love me quite a lot in a game.
There's tracks I will focus on them.
And there's yeah little rewards as you move up there, but mostly it's that big endgame scoring that really
I don't think can be overstated. Pretty significant.
It is. It is though the the specimens themselves, getting them completed, getting them removed from your board so that you can get more going around those that is also a lot of scoring. So, I mean, there's a variety of different ways to score at the end, which I showed you. Um, but yeah, there it's interesting to see what people lean into and how they use their actions. And I think that that is the big positive of this game is that there are variety different strategies. Not too many areas that you can lean into as they're clearly all represented. What there's like seven, I think, or five or six, seven. Um, and so you can focus in on a few of those or you can do a lot of everything or you can really hyperfocus, you know, on a couple. Um, so it's it's nice that there's a variety of things to explore in the game and so that replayability is there. I do feel like in terms of just kind of that rules upfrontness and everything and that ability of how much you can actually focus on stuff in the game, there might be a little too much. It's
there might be a
and I don't want to say like, oh, just get rid of that flower area, right? Because I think one of the things I respect a lot about this and Galileo are the the uh the touches of theme that they put in there. These games are clearly not just themeless abstract euros. Yes, there's that whole flower area. It's like, oh, area control for different like polyomino shaped things. If you put flower, if you put more flowers in there, that's abstract as all get out.
Sure. But he spent a lot of time actually like taking species from different parts of the world, planting them and seeing how they reacted in different types of soils and environments and blah blah blah blah blah. So, it was a big part of his study and research.
Yes. And so, I I love the dedication to the theme. I think that mechanically that part is one of the weakest and one of the things I'm I'm least interested. But I love moving around the map and I love collecting the samples and getting the sketches and thinking about if I go over here I get this instant bonus or that thing and then later I can re-trigger those instant bonuses.
It reminds me a little bit of like Voyages of Marco Polo, a game where you have that same like tight adventure, move around the map and try to collect all the sciency stuff or like collect all the the different things from different regions. I love that. And so I think ultimately there are as many different avenues probably because everyone likes a different thing more than others. I don't like the flower thing that much, but I love the map. Someone probably feels the complete opposite from me,
which you could get a ton of points from the flower thing, but it also feels like delayed rewards because you have to wait till those areas complete and fully fill in before they score. Um, yeah. I I feel similarly to you about there's just so much and I think the I think I have less of an issue that there's so much like variety wise that you can do because I really love variety in games. I think my struggle is is that mechanism of you can take one action, you can take two actions or you can take three actions. Figure out where they go. And um that sounded really interesting when I was reading the rules and I was like, "Oo, this is cool." Until, you know, someone took a three action, then it was a new round, and then they took the three action again because they went from last place to first place. And I ended up waiting like nine actions between turns and then I took a single action and I was like, I did one. Yay. Everybody else take your turns. Like that I think is the struggle. And so it sounded really cool, but I'm not sure that I loved the way that it created that down.
It feeds a lot of into that downtime thing. And and I love that system of the the weak, medium, and strong action discs that you get to use and and you can upgrade those tokens. And so you said to go, "Oh, this this token is phenomenal. This lens that I get to place, I think I'll put it in the three time obviously. Oh, but it has to go to this cool down." I do love that system. It is very fun when it's my turn. It's a lot less fun when it's not my turn.
Yes. And some of the actions just are quick, right? You pick up a letter and get a bonus and then you play two letters, right? And you get the bonuses. Those feel pretty quickly. But you move on that map and you're like, I move on the map and I'm doing this and I do this and it was my first time there, so I do that and then I'm going to get this thing and then I have to pay this and you're like, okay. And then
which orientate? Yeah. How am I going to place it on my board? Where do I put it?
Where am I going to put it? How I'm going to do it? Oh, I have to get that bonus because I was Anyways, it's a lot of like doing stuff. And they're like, and my second action, I'm going to do the same thing again. And it just feels like, you know, so much. And so, yeah, there's just there's that disconnect of the between the turns. And I played this at three. I played this at two. I can't imagine playing it at four. Wow. Um, and I just I feel like even at two, I still struggle just sitting there going, "Okay, I know what I'm going to do now. I'm just going to wait while you do the thing you're going to do."
And if you're like me, sometimes just sitting there like, "Okay, all right, cool. Wendy's finally done. It's my turn." Which was that going to be? So, I started I started when it wasn't my turn just like preloading my lenses in the action spots and like putting one higher than the other to remember do this next and then do this one. Yeah. because there is some player interaction in the game, especially in that flower area.
Sure.
Uh and you know with the map and revealing new things. Oh, you you swapped out the letters and stuff. So, there is still opportunity to say, "Oh, maybe I don't want to do that. Maybe I want to switch out to this."
So, the game gives you enough overhead strategy that you can just kind of plan out your whole round from the beginning,
but with I think the right amount of maybe I'll pivot now that there's something else out there. But it's not it's not doesn't lean too hard in that tactical like, oh, I can't even start planning my turn until the start of my turn. I don't think it's quite like that.
Yeah.
But maybe maybe more with four players.
Maybe more. So, when I think about like is this a good game? Is this a game I'm going to come back to? I think that that downtime between turns does make a significant impact in my score. However, this is still a game I'm going to recommend. Um, so if we go into final scores, I'm going to come in at a seven. I recommend this game. This is one that I think that it has a lot of very clever, good mechanics, and I think that that thematic tie-in, if you want to read all of that thematic tie-in text and stuff that's there in the rule book, I think it's very interesting, and I think that this is a nice little companion to Galileo Galile um, in that regard. Now, it's funny because a seven is approved and that means I liked the game and it was good. However, when I think about what this game could have been, this what I was hoping would be an 8.5 or a nine like Galileo Galile is for me. And so for me, this was a little bit of a disappointment. But still, when I step back and I go, okay, even with all the massive setup and all the massive teach and all that time of between turns, I still like this game and I would still play it again.
That's ve that's very very much where I where I sit. I think that if you don't have an issue with downtime, this game is going to be phenomenal and one of the best. If you are very sensitive to downtime, you might actively dislike the game despite the fact that you enjoy all the systems, the mechanical and thematic uh way that they all tie together. Uh, and so that's why I'm coming in at a seven as well because I do really enjoy the game,
but I'm it's pretty much going to be limited to playing two players for me because that is the max that I'm comfortable going with it.
Player count restricts that type of stuff doesn't always uh bother me, but even at two players,
I still sit there and go,
slow,
this is a little slow. and and yes, it picks up with familiarity, but there's just a lot to try to to lock down in so few turns in a game,
but those turns are very fun. So, that's why with all those things considered, a seven where you're both recommending it, giving you that caveat because how your sensitivities are to downtime is going to affect if you enjoy this game tremendously or if you dislike it.
Very much so. All righty. Well, thanks for joining us today. Yeah, that is a seven from both of us. So, a seal of approval. Uh, and yeah, I'm Wendy.
And I am Chris Ye.
And that's Carl.
Mhm.
Say hi, Carl.
Go uh appreciate binomial nomenclature.
Hey everybody, thanks for watching another video from the Dice Tower. Hey, you want to learn more about us, communicate with us, we have a Facebook group, we have a Discord channel, lots of different ways to get involved with the Dice Tower. can find that in our link tree link below. So just click that, it will take you and you can communicate with us on Facebook, join our Facebook groups. There's lots of cool things that you can find and become part of the Dice Tower. Thanks so much for watching. I'm Tom Bassel. Carl Lanaeus or Carl von Len known as also known after enobblement in 1761 as Carl von Len a Swedish biologist.
Oh, so he became nobleated.
And he became nobleated.
Oh, I didn't know you could nobilate someone.
You can get inated. Yeah,
it's fair. He is the guy who formalized binomial nomenclature.
Really? Yeah. The father of modern taxonomy.
Bomial nomenclature. After he was noilated.
After in nobilation. Yeah. Which is different than immolation.
Which is different than nomenclature elation.
Yeah. It's not that different though.
Nomenclated.
Uhhuh. Yeah.
Yeah.
That's a signature right there. Carl V. Len.
He actually wrote that online right there.
Yeah.
He logged in and he
he logged into Wikipedia and was like, "Oh, yes. That's my signature. Would it say he was Swedish? I don't know if that was a good Swedish accent or not. Oh, yes. Here's my signature.
You sound like the the Swedish chef. That
is not a good Swedish accent. Nailed it. Ry Burger.