Games of the Month - June '24
Transcript
welcome to Jong games this is my games of the month Vlog for June of 2024 and in it I'll be discussing the two best gaming experiences I had over the last month now these are excerpts from the exclusive opinions episodes that I sent out to the patreon supporters of this channel in fact I talked about 20 different games over the last month going out to the patreon supporters and this is just two of those games the best of those that I played at least as far as the fun that I had I do want to point out that I've actually put out 104 different exclusive opinions episodes now covering 504 different games over the last few years and if that sounds like something you'd be interested in digging into then you can get access to that by becoming a patreon supporter at patreon.com jongetsgames don't worry I have a big sorted spreadsheet so you can see all the games that I've covered and you can easily get access to those specific segments now speaking of those segments let's talk about the games that are being covered today the first of these is rebuilding Seattle I was actually sponsored to make a tutorial video for this game so keep that in mind but I have a lot of uh things to say about that game I really enjoyed my two plays of It kind of back toback over the course of that same week and the other game that I'm talking about is shut the books which is a trick-taking game designed by taishan zawa and I have a lot to say about that one it really impressed me I played that one a couple of times as well so without further Ado let's jump into those games the first game I'm discussing today is rebuilding Seattle now I'll start this off by mentioning that I was paid to make a sponsored tutorial video for this uh by Whiz Kids I made that last year and I remembered when I made that video
thinking this game seems pretty neat it has a polyomino puzzle kind of element to it but it also has a somewhat subtle timing element with these events in the middle of the table so as I said I made the video and then I was interested in playing it but I never got around to playing it and a few months later I actually decided to remove it on one of my shifting shelf segments because I just didn't think I'd get around to it and then R commented on my update Vlog saying that I was getting rid of one of the best games from last year uh and I was like okay well maybe I should reconsider if R is like going to bat for this game so it it got saved it was put back onto the shelf and another like five six months went by and then I finally got it played over this last week in fact I played it twice in the last four days and I really enjoyed it there's a reason I'm talking about it first out of the rest of the games that I'm discussing today now let's start by doing an overview of what this game is like remember you can watch my sponsored tutorial if you want to learn all about it in fact that's how I learned the game when I played this last Saturday I opened up the rule book and I was like wait what am I doing I turned on my own video watched it at 2x speed and then I taught it to my friend and we played it it was great anyway this is a game where you are rebuilding Seattle essentially each player has a polyomino puzzle in front of them so you're doing your own puzzling and the game takes place over three rounds and most of each round is spent during a build step where you are going to be spending money to get various pieces pieces that you then build into your area you start with a
6x5 tile with some pre-printed uh sub tiles on it there are six different color tiles that come in the game and each of these colors is associated with some different part of a city that's being built now you can expand your area by putting suburb tiles down you can buy them and you can also get them from a specific event and this gives you more room to put more tiles on top so there's a bit of a dual layer polyomino thing going on here the suburbs are 2x4 in size so they're not hard to puzzle together but you do have to be smart about how you are expanding out your city because there are these hexagonal icons on the suburbs that you don't really want to cover up so there is some puzzly nature there now again in the build phase this is where most of the game takes place the primary thing you're doing is spending money to make buildings now you can buy Cards there's a whole bunch of cards in the middle of the table in a two-player game there's one row to choose from and with every additional player there's going to be a new row of like eight cards something like that that you can choose from I played this at two players and I did play it at four players and it was a huge difference in the number of cards available at four now the cards cost money between $3 and $5 you spend that money you get the card and each card has a building piece that looks like a Tetris type shape that you're going to take from the supply it'll be in a specific color and then you place that out onto your board onto a suburb tile or your main tile the only restriction is you can't cover up a previous tile or previously printed tile that's it you can go way off to the side there's no adjacency rules with the
placement and then after putting that tile down we also get some sort of benefit from the card every card has two pieces to it with a tile and then an effect at the bottom that effect might be immediate letting you bump up your Cube on a quality track or it could give you more money during the profit phase which is essentially an income phase that happens after we do all this building or it might give you endgame victory points for specific situations like tiles and buildings and whatnot that you've built into your overall area so when you pay money to buy a card you're getting a a twofer essentially with the tile and the thing on the bottom and there's a huge variety of the combinations between the two frequently the colors won't match like you might get a tile that says you can put a pink building down and then it'll score you money for your blue buildings or it'll score you points for your gray buildings or something like that and after you do this the next person goes and you do not refill the market of cards so the overall Market is going to be diminishing as we go through the round there's also a law that you can enact and this is where a little bit of asymmetry comes into play each player has a different board in front of them which is largely the same with some subtle differences the quality tracks which I'm going to talk about soon might be slightly different and then the laws are different everyone has three laws that they can choose from and each round you can choose one of those laws as your turn although you don't have to the game I played last night I only enacted one law and it was in the third round the first two rounds I never got around to enacting a law because I was spending my turns doing other things now this build step ends once all six events have
happened and this is the other thing you can do in the build phase is you will trigger one event there are six events you always have all of them at every player count and this is realistically the game in a lot of ways like when people look at this on the table they're going to see a bunch of polyomino tiles uh puzzly action going on in front of the players and think that's a polyomino game and they wouldn't be wrong but I think it might even be a little bit of a mistake to say it's primarily a polyomino game when primarily it's a game about timing things versus your opponents like the puzzly nature of the polyomino is there but that takes nowhere near as much of your mental space as the process of thinking through these events now there are six events and three of them are essentially the same they just match up to different colors with the blue pink and orange which is thematically entertainment shopping and uh dining I think and when you do these events first of all the person who chooses the event no matter which of the six events it is gets a specific perk for being the person who's spending their whole turn doing this it might be uh a tiny little building it might be points it might be money that kind of thing then everyone around the table is affected by the event and again if it's the blue pink or orange event then what everyone does is they compare their blue pink or orange amount of icons in their City compared to their City's population now you have a track in front of you on your board so you don't have to like count this up every time you move a little little Cube over as you add more of these icons into your city and this is a fascinating part of the game because thematically I guess
you are incentivized to have no people that don't have things to do I guess you check the population amount and let's say you have 10 population and we're currently doing the blue event and you have five of the blue icons in your area you look at the difference between those two in this case blue is five spaces behind the population and then you score your blue track which is going to give you benefits like victory points and money depending on how far you've gone up that track but you lose the effect based off of the distance your cube is behind the population if your cube is at or in front of the population you just get the full reward you don't get extra benefits for being ahead but essentially the population is a problem in fact there are lots of ways specifically laws and whatnot that let you lower your population and that is a good thing in fact the game sometimes has you spend money to lower population which sounds weird at first but actually once you understand how the events work it makes total sense every population reduction is going to help you out with all three of those pink blue and orange events because moving that back once is essentially like moving all of those cubes forward once so yeah you gain these benefits it could be points it could be uh money it could be both and then you move on that event is flipped over and it will not be activated again for the rest of that round and remember this is a three- round game now the round ends once the six of these events is used and then we immediately move into the profit phase and then we move into an end phase and then we move into the next round where we gain more
population we gain 12 more population so it is really tough to keep everybody happy as that token is running away from us and then we start building again with all the new money that we got and then all the events are refreshed so we can do them again now I mentioned that there's different types of events the blue pink and orange are three of them and the other three get you other things in particular the graduation event has you count up the number of University tiles which are gray that are in your area and then you lose one population for each of those tiles again losing population is actually a good thing I think thematically they are satisfied because they're going off to college or something like that the next one is expansion and you count up the number of yellow buildings that you have and you get a free suburb for every single one of those normally you have to spend $4 for every suburb and that is expensive especially at the early stages of the game so investing in multiple yellow buildings might seem costly but it's going to give you a ton of these suburbs as the game goes on and that's important not only because it gives you more space to construct your buildings but it gives you more of those icons I mentioned briefly every suburb tile has three icons with a forest a ocean beach I guess and a mountain and the last of the events is Nature's Bounty something like that and depending on the round you're going to get stuff based off of those icons in the first round you just count up all of the visible Forest icons in your area and you get a money for those that could be be huge if you do that event in the middle of the build phase that might give you enough money to then do something else really expensive within that same build phase in the
second round of the game you don't get money for your trees instead you count up all of the beach icons and you lose one population for every one of those people and this can be enormous again because losing population is actually a good thing and then in the final round of the game you once again get a money for each of your trees and you get a victory point for every one of the mountains that shows up and this is just a huge part of the game like getting more suburb tiles means you have more of these icons to potentially score when that Nature's Bounty event happens and of course you're trying to avoid covering up these icons so that you get those benefits until the right moment um in the game I played last night immediately after the first round we scored the trees and we got one money each I just started covering up the trees because I knew that I wasn't going to care about those trees until the third round and I had a whole second round to deal with and I was like you know my short-term goals mean I need to put these tiles down I'm going to cover up trees instead of the beaches because I want those for the second round and the mountains because every Mountain you cover up is a victory point and sure covering up a tree after that first event means that's one less money I get in the third round but by the third round I'm probably going to be rich anyway because of other things that you can combine as you were continuing through the game just a really fascinating thing to consider now again every time you do any of these events everyone gets subjected to them so if I do the event that gives me free suburbs for every one of my yellow buildings everyone else also gets a free suburb for their yellow building so I'm sort of helping them out you do get a perk again if you're the person to actually select that event uh in the case of that one you can buy a suburb for $1 an extra suburb which is nice but you really have
to consider the effects that you are putting on everybody else and this is a really fascinating part of the game I'm going to start talking about my feelings of it because that's most of the game right there having the most points is how you win and in the two-player game that we did the very first game I was lagging very far behind my opponent he was getting so many points for the different tracks and whatnot I was really worried about it but then I crushed it with the endgame victory points um with the cards that I was Drafting and also there's these big Landmark tiles you can put down but I'm trying not to go too much into those specifics and I ended up winning by a small margin I I caught up in a really big way so there's like midgame points that you can get for scoring those tracks of course and then also lots of points you can get at the end then last night I played a four-player game it was my second game and the first game for uh everyone else around the table and once again I was lagging behind lagging behind as I was actually investing big time into universities right from the very beginning of the game I got a bunch of these so that I was losing more population than everybody else which I thought was going to help me be more competitive when it came to the Quality tracks to get more stuff from them this went pretty well for the first two out of the three rounds in the game uh in the second round actually I remember when I scored the pink track you can choose to either take victory points or money and it was 20 uh my final score in the first game was 103 points so I'm sitting there thinking about am I really going to say no to 20 victory points which is like was 20% of my score the last time I played this but if I had 20 money I could get both of my landmarks
out which again are just big Point Rich uh tiles that you can place down ultimately I decided to go for the money and I think I regret it but I went for it and so I was really lagging behind in the victory points in this play but I figured I'd catch up in the third round of the game because my population was like 10 less than everybody else it was so small and this is when I made a mistake when I went into that third round I was actually the first player and I was tempted to do the event for the graduation immediately if I had done that I had I think six Universities at that point so I would have been able to reduce my population by six or even seven because that's the perk of being the person to activate that event which would have gotten my uh population close enough to my markers to actually get some points for these things but I got greedy and I was like well other people they have way more population than me so it it matters a lot more to them that they lower their population in a graduation event than I do so I'm going to wait for them to do it and I'm going to do a bunch of you know engine building as it was the problem is I was forgetting to consider that that no one else really had invested in graduation at all or in the University tiles one opponent had two of them everyone else had one because you start with one and then I had six and there's no world where any of them are going to actually pull that event before they have to which is going to be really late and what ended up happening is I didn't do that so my population was still pretty high because I had the potential to lower it more than everybody else but I hadn't actually pressed the button yet and then my friend Dave activated the
pink uh event on his first turn right before I could take another turn and this was hugely painful because the pink track is the one that I had pushed my quality uh Cube up the most on and this is the one where I was able to take 20 points or 20 money in the previous round I figured well next round I'm going to take the 20 victory points what ended up happening is I got like two victory points or four victory points because I hadn't lowered my population yet and Dave got nothing like his Cube was nowhere near in fact I think nobody else got anything but he astutely noticed that if I was able to lower my population that much before that event happened that I would get a ton more points and he was never going to invest in pink anyway he was never going to get points no matter when that event happened so he activated the event when it was terrible for me um I was like oh man okay well I'm going to do this other thing and get ready for the blue event and uh but it took a couple turns for that and then it got to Dave again and then he did the blue event again right before I was going to be doing something that bumped up my blue quality track twice and so congratulations me I got like two bucks and two victory points and I was like oh my gosh this is where the game is I'm just getting taken apart here because I'm missing the the tempo like I I I was so punished for not doing the university uh action the graduation action to lower my my population right there at the beginning because that was my advantage that was a huge Advantage I had on everybody is how many of these universities I had and I wasn't able to use it so most of the uh Point scoring events happened before I actually got that benefit and I lost this game by one
point to Dave it's just oh like it wasn't actually frustrating it was a wonderful time I really enjoyed it but it was intellectually frustrating because I I knew that I had messed that up and like I said I wasn't beating myself up about it it was like you know well fought and also like kudos to Dave like I was being greedy essentially by waiting and he was punishing me for being greedy so I'm just learning more about the game and I also think it's a really cool anecdote about this game to really show that you know the game is in the events and the timing of when those events happen sure you're going to put a ton of polyomino tiles down in front of you there is some puzzly things there um some decent things to think about especially as you're trying to dodge those icons but the game is in the events and knowing when the right moment is to spend your turn doing an event or to know when it is the smart thing to do to not do the event and let somebody else potentially go for it you must do an action on your turn so the tempo of each of these build phases is people spend money people spend money and then they kind of run out of money so people start doing events which might give people money and then people have money so they keep spending the money and eventually people just run out of money and they're forced to activate events even if they don't want to and that pushes the end of the game so I've talked about this one quite a lot honestly a lot more than I initially expected to but I've really enjoyed it I I can see why R told me to put this game back on the Shelf I'm not sure if it's one of the best games of last year for me but it was certainly the the most fun of the six new games that I played over the last couple of weeks and I'm really happy that I got to play it at the two
player count and the four-player count to see the difference it plays up to five and that seemed like a mistake to me in fact I wanted to play a three-player game but a fourth player showed up at the game night and I wasn't going to say no and I'm really happy that happened because I can now say that this was pretty Snappy even at four players I was worried that the the markets were going to be just overwhelming and it was a lot honestly the four player game was a lot of boards and cards and markets all over the place the pretty skinny tables where we were playing at that time that's not the the photo that you're seeing if you're watching the video version of this that's the two-player game but I taught this game and then we played the full game in like 90 minutes like combined with the teach maybe maybe it was a 100 minutes with the teach but that is very reasonable the turns seemed pretty Snappy as we were going around and around the table and I think if everybody had played it once before you would probably Lop like half an hour off of it I think this is a surprisingly subtle game I'm I'm really impressed with it again I'm quite biased I was paid to make a video for this but I think it's cool I like polyomino games in general and they can often times feel very multiplayer solitire as you are just building your own little puzzle in front of you but I really liked how you have to pay attention to what other people are doing and what they might want to do and what they might want to take because those have huge ramifications on your situation that you have in front of you and you might end up losing the game by one point because of it this uh that second play was also a situation where as I said I had very little points um going into the end game in fact I'm pretty sure David La me on
the victory Point track which is a 50o track so I was like well over 50 points behind Dave who would end up winning but I got a monstrous amount of points at the end of the game through my end game scoring and it was ah it was so close for brief flicker I thought I had them but not quite anyway that's rebuilding Seattle it was uh a really good time uh just the highlight of the games I played over the last couple of weeks I've enjoyed it at both those counts I I might still shy away from five players that seems like a lot but I would happily play it at four players or less at some point in the future and hopefully I actually make that happen some more all right let's move into the second game I'm talking about today and that is shut the books now this is a new design from taishan zawa a pretty famous uh trick-taking designer from Japan um various things like maskmen is probably one of the more popular ones but he is very prolific in fact he designed lose which is another trick taker I'll be talking about later on in this episode now shut the books is brand new it just released at the Tokyo games Market uh the spring one anyway and I played it online using playingcards.io with a very rudimentary proxy of the game that's what you're looking at if you're watching the video version of this and this game is really really good I'm going to start that off before I actually expl explain how it works I didn't know anything about this going in except it was taishan zawa so I'm curious to try uh because generally he designs games that have interesting ideas I don't always love the scoring in those games but there's usually cool ideas and this game is one of the more straightforward taishan zawa designs I
can think of especially as far as like its main gimmick but it still works so well now I've played this twice both times we at three players and the setup's a little different I think with four players but in a three-player game there are for suits and the numbers on those cards go from 1 to 12 I'm pretty sure so you're going to deal out this deck of cards and each player in a three-player game has 16 cards in their hand then bidding happens now bidding happens in order you know one player then the next player clockwise around the table and much like a game 99 which I really like you bid with the cards in your hand so you have this hand of 16 cards and you take cards from your hand and you put them face up in front of you to Mark the bids for the tricks that you were going to be winning this is a must follow pretty straightforward trick-taking game when it comes to that you know if I play a spade you have to play a spade the best Spade wins unless somebody played a trump card in this game Trump was always hearts at least with the version that I played so the trick play is straightforward where is the gimmick it is in that bidding because when you're putting these cards face up in front of you you're not saying oh I put three cards that means I'm going to win three tricks you're saying I'm putting three cards out I'm going to win three very specific tricks it's essentially like jumping through hoops uh and funnily enough there's another game I'm talking about in this episode that's similar to that what this means is if I put a 10 of clubs down as my bid then that is me saying I am going to win a trick with a 10 or with a club so later on once we've put all of our
bids out face up on the table and we start doing trick- taking if I win a trick with any club I'll take that trick and I'll put it in front of me and then I'll will have the option to flip over that t of Clubs because it was essentially Satisfied by me taking that let's say this is my only club that I bid and I have another strong Club in my hand maybe I don't do that instead I try to angle to win something with a 10 to flip over that t of clubs instead of going for the club for example now of course as you are bidding you're taking cards from your hand and you're putting them face up in front of you and they're no longer in your hand so you have an interesting tension there because you can short suit yourself very easily in this game but it's a double-edged sword because let's say you have like three clubs and you just put all three of those out there now you have no clubs in your hand therefore you can't win anything with clubs to actually satisfy those tricks so you better be positioning yourself to win tricks with the specific value of those cards each card that you bid can be satisfied in one of two ways and if you just proceed to short suit yourself then you are lowering your chances to actually do that and this is a Precision bidding game if you exactly hit your bid which means all of your bid cards are face down and you didn't take any extra tricks that did not actually match any of your bids then you get four points that's great if you took one extra trick that didn't match one of your bids or you took no extra but you have a bid that wasn't actually satisfied then you get two points and then every time you miss after that it's going to be negative points so essentially if you are two off your bid you lose one point
whereas if you're one off your bid you get two and if you're exact you get four now there is an asteris to this and it's an element to the game that I have not really used even though I've played twice and that is that if somebody plays let's say a club again and you don't have any clubs but you do have hearts which is Trump and you play that heart and then you play the best Trump you win that trick that means you could satisfy one of your heart bids or you could satisfy a card that matches the value of that heart that you just played or you could satisfy a bid of the originally LED suit so coming back to that example where you put all of your clubs out there so you're short suited on clubs technically you could satisfy some of those Club bids by winning with a heart by playing that over somebody else's Club so it's possible but it's going to be something that's kind of hard for you to angle for I played two full games of this and I don't think I've seen a single person satisfy a single bid in this way I think it's an interesting probably higher level element to the game that I'm not really at because I'm still very new to this and I floundered a lot and I've come in third place both times I've played three player games of this one so that is essentially the core idea of the game but one thing that you might have spotted if you were thinking about it as I was talking is that I never told you how many cards you could bid and that's because it's variable you could bid zero cards which means you think you are going to win zero tricks and guess what you still have 16 cards in your hand or you could bid up to a maximum of five you could not bid six so if you bid five tricks then that is five of your 16 so that means I might bid five cards which means I have 11 cards
in my hand and you might bid zero cards so you think you're going to win zero tricks and you have 16 cards in your hand so we have an asymmetric hand size and we keep playing until one person runs out of their cards which means If you bid less than your opponents you have more wiggle room there are going to be cards that you don't play in that extreme example where I bid five cards and you bid none the round is going to end and you're going to have five cards left in your hand so that gives you a lot of flexibility to try and Dodge all the tricks that you were obviously trying to dodge because you bid zero now that is essentially the game uh it's my understanding the theme of this one is like your uh students at a magic college and you open up some books that you shouldn't have and demons are coming out so now you're opening up other books to try and fight the previous demons the theme doesn't really matter but that's why the game is called shut the books realistically this is just a fascinating incredibly clean incredibly smart brain twisting classic trick-taking game and honestly I love it even though I've come last both times I've played it is just incredibly smart um I mentioned before that this kind of reminded me of 99 which is a three-player only classic trick-taking Style game but in that one everybody simultaneously bids three cards and it's always three and then after that you can choose to reveal your bid or not in this one you go in order so if you're the last one to bid you can see the values and the number of cards that people have put out to bid in front of you and you can adjust what you want to do based off of that and if you're the first one to bid it could be really tricky because you have no idea what your opponents are
going to be gunning for you know maybe you bid five tricks and then they both bid like one or zero and you're like oh my goodness I'm G to play every one of my cards and they're going to have so many extra cards to be flexible to try and load me up with all of these tricks that I don't want to win and then you go over now from a scoring perspective it seemed like it worked pretty well and generally I'm frequently unhappy with the scoring in taishan zawa designs usually that that they're the weakest element of the overall game but it worked pretty darn well for this game honestly my biggest problem with the scoring in general is just a standard thing for seemingly a lot of trick takers that are coming out of Japan or just General and that is that the game ends once you play a number of hands equal to the player count so play three hands then the game is over I know a lot of games do that and it's fine this is really just a pet peeve of mine I enjoy a little bit more Nuance to my game end conditions there's probably something you could bake in here like once somebody hits X number of points positive or negative then that triggers the end of the game something like that could be integrated relatively easily I think and honestly I don't really have anything else to say about this except it was really fun and it it was one of those games that felt like how has this not existed already it's one of those designs where you're like nobody thought of this why didn't I think of this I've been trying to design card games for a couple of years and this incredibly simple idea never actually occurred to me and it's just brilliant it works so incredibly well I'm looking forward to playing this one with more um hopefully i' I'd love to try it with four players I think it's a three or four player game as of now who knows if it'll get
developed more in the future or picked up by anybody but I will say this game is getting a decent amount of Buzz amongst the rabbit hole denisons of the trick taking community that I hang out with online I've seen a lot of people who've played a lot of trick takers who say that this is their favorite taish shinzawa game which is a lot I mean taish shinzawa is kind of like the Leo kavini Riner kinesia of the the card game scene he designs a lot of games and a lot of those games take very interesting swings at how things work I mean again I'm going to talk about another taesan zawa design later in this design with a very strange swing that we're going to get to when we talk about lose but yeah shut the books is just very good it's to the point where I've been trying to find like the rules that somebody's printed or translated online because this was just taught to me I want to put this out and proxy it and bring it to game nights because I want to show this to more people I want to figure out a way to maybe not come in last but yeah from a just clean trick-taking perspective this game is very very good all right that's going to complete this peak behind the curtain at those exclusive segments and I can already tell you I'm pretty sure I know what at least one of the games I'll be talking about in next month's game of the month Vlog is going to be the reason I didn't talk about it today is because I haven't actually recorded the opinions episode for that one uh I'm really looking forward to it and I'll have a lot more to say about it when that comes around but for now I do think this episode's coming to a close and again if you have thoughts about any of the games I talked about please leave a comment down below as always I'd like to thank everyone who's been supporting this
channel including these producer level patreon supporters if you too would like to directly support the Channel and the creation of future videos just like this one then please go to jungus games.com Support also if you enjoy this video then please click the like button for down below as well as the Subscribe button for the channel thanks for watching