Logic & Lore 2nd Edition & Variance Expansion Review
Transcript
A couple of years ago for the review we did for its original Kickstarter, I charged logic and lore with straddling the line between puzzle and game, which to be fair, a lot of the games that we love are great because they scratch that particular logistical deductive part of our weirdo gamer brains. But Weird Giraffe's game of numerical star alignment veered more in that direction than most. Using claimed questions, you show pairs of cards to your opponents and interpret the results to hopefully align your own cards faster than theirs, acting both as Oracle and rival soussayers. And it turns out that it's really good. And the finished product is stunningly gorgeous with a bevy of alternate modes to increase challenge or even reduce complexity. But for the reprint of logic and lore, weird giraffe has introduced the expansion variance which preserves the overall the core conceit of the game but sort of flips the script in how you go about it or rather rolls about. Pick your metaphor here. [snorts] Let me explain. But first, let me get to a disclaimer. Weird Draft Games is owned by Carla and Nick Cop, who I met through the Cardboard Herald almost a decade ago. We're friends. We hang out at conventions.
They visited us in Alaska. They are awesome humans. And while I would have no problem criticizing one of their games directly to them or to this audience, it felt important to disclose we're friends. Make of that what you will. Okay. So, as of now, being that this is a prototype and components and even rules are subject to adjustment. What do you get in this box? There are six standard polyhedrals ranging from D4 to D20, a mat, some mice, some notes, some letters, and some rules. This is the equipment you need to play two more gamey variants of this um well game, and to better puzzle out the stars, whether playing with the expansion modes or not. In both new modes, you have a central board with dice around the perimeter that are used to ask more numerically related questions about your cards. In star sprite mode, this is just picking a dice, returning your previously picked one, rolling it, showing two cards, then asking your questions until you get a hit. Are either of these aligned? Is this card the dice value? Is either higher or lower than the value? Is the sum higher or lower? Etc., etc.
Importantly, you acrew dragons for using different dice and spend them to modify your role. Star sprite is cool, but in earnest is less logistically pure than the base game, but just shy of enough gameplay hooks and leverage to really feel like you're capitalizing on the dice. On the other hand, Starflight mode feels like the real deal. This is why you're coming to this expansion is now my favorite way to play this game. Dice are arranged as discussed, but have already been rolled and fixed in their precision. Your precocious pawn is a scurrying mouse that moves one or at the cost of a crude dragons more spaces to turn clockwise around the board to a new dice, re-rolling all you left behind.
And the face of your arrival defines your questions. The same types of questions that you ask in the other mode. It's just now they're more defined, more in front of you. you can make more strategic decisions about what you want to do and what you want to pass up, helping you deduce, define, and ultimately arrange the stars. The fixed nature of the dice at the start of your turn, the fact that you acrew more dragons as you complete a circuit and then can spend those dragons, either to move further along to the more desirable dice or manipulate the results of the dice that you end up choosing. It gives you just the right amount of leverage. A lot of input randomness, but not output, which works perfect for this kind of game. I'll admit in the original game, the strategic rationale that defines what's a good move versus another can sometimes be a little bit hard to intuit it. And so this honing of options and just kind of nudging you a direction and giving you some good levers to play with really elevates the game for me. The base game is still more pure, but this ticks some boxes for my goober gamer noggin. The last thing that it adds is actually a useful tool that can be used whether you're playing with the expansion materials or not and honestly probably should be and possibly will be
included in future editions of the base game. And that is the number tracker. A complement of letter tokens are at your disposal, which as you ask questions, you can label a card, then make notes, eliminating possible values. I love math. I love numbers, but my ability to hold this information in my brain as I maneuver cards and ponder possibilities is questionable. Notes are a godsend. So yeah, if you like beautiful abstracts, number puzzles, or just like living that celestial vibe, Logic and Lore is a fantastic game that has been at least fascinating, if not a full hit with pretty much everyone that I've shown it to. Now, if you want something that has a few more gamer hooks and you want the to just kind of hone the options down, maybe bring the decision space down from the infinite heavens into something that's a little bit more manageable, then variance is going to be your jam.
That's our review, but let me know what is your favorite numerical deduction game. I mean, I can think of at least a couple others, but I'd love to hear your perspective. Put it in the comments below. And as always, thanks for watching the channel. Thanks for supporting the channel. Thanks for doing all the things that really help us out from liking, subscribing, commenting, talking about us out in the interwebs or checking out our Patreon. But above all, thanks for being such a great community. You know that I've been Jack for the Cardboard Herald.