Skip to main content
Loading video...

Everdell Farshore Review: Just a re-themed Everdell?

Transcript 28:03

Hello everybody welcome back to board game Buzz my name is Carly and today I'm going to be sharing my thoughts on the new everdel farshore everdel farshore is actually a brand new Standalone game that is set in the world of everdale actually plays very similar to the original everdoll game just like in everdale players around the table will be competing against each other fighting over resources which then they will spend those resources trying to place Critters and certain constructions into their own personal cities which will then score them points and whoever has the most points of the end wins there are a few differences between everdale farshore and the base game everdel though so before I get into my final thoughts let's jump over and I will do a very quick overview of how the game plays so obviously this is a ginormous board and I'm sorry but the stand that I currently have for my camera does not go high enough to kind of show everything so I'll just try my best to kind of briefly explain and kind of show the game as best as I can to kind of help explain it for new players so this is currently the setup for a two-player game we have the crabs which I have set up right here and then um the second player who's playing as the puffins which I have set up right here on your turn players must perform one of the following actions the first action that somebody can do is placing a worker

as you can see off to the side here each player has a certain set of workers that they can use throughout the game and like I said the first action is simply placing a worker so for example if the crabs were to go they could potentially go here to this location and then receive what is listed so this shows two seaweeds so they would gain two seaweed for that oops that was three okay two seaweed all of these locations here up at the top and down here in the ocean area um give you certain resources and these resources which we'll talk about later will then be used to spend to move constructions and critters into your own personal Tableau so for example this location you will gain a sea Stone and then a card this location would give you two mushrooms down here in the bottom of the ocean area if you were to go here for example you could choose any two resources these side locations here do something different so this Lookout allows you to discard cards and then draw to your hand limit and the docs right over on this side of the board allows you to discard cards to gain certain resources there's another spot up here at the top of the board called the dunes and when you go here if you have the listed requirements for these map tokens you actually get to gain these which give you points at the end of the game so the way that these mapped files are scored at the end at the end of the game are actually pretty interesting um so what how they're scored is each map token is showing you the amount of

points that it's worth at the end of the game um but then it is actually timed by the number of maps that you have collected throughout the game so this one is worth two this one is worth two and this one is worth zero so right now I have a total of four points but again it's Times by the number of maps that I've collected so it's actually Four Points times three so this if the if the game ended and these were the map tiles that I was able to collect then I would also collect 12 points for this at the end of the game the next action that you can choose to do is playing a card all of the cards throughout the game have a certain number of resources that you must spend in order to place that card into your own personal City so for example if you were to wanting to place this deck then you would have to spend two mushrooms in order to then place it so let's pretend that our player 2 wanted to place this in into their City they would need the resources required so two Driftwood one seaweed which they have they will spend those resources back to the supply and then place that card inside their own personal City there are five different card types found throughout the game so let's quickly go through what each of those are the first type of cards are the green production cards these activate once when played and at the beginning of Spring and Autumn when you prepare for those Seasons these production cards usually generate some sort of resource for you the next card are the blue governess cards these activate as described on the card usually granting bonuses when you play cards or perform

or perform certain actions next are the brown traveler cards these activate only once immediately when played next are the red destination cards you place these cards in your Tableau and it actually creates a new spot for you to place your workers on the next are the purple Prosperity cards these cards usually allow different ways to gain points at the end of the game these are the cards that you will be purchasing slowly adding to your Tableau in front of you building out your own Seaside build Village keeping in mind that your village can be no bigger than 15 cards there are also common and unique constructions along with common and unique prototypes you can have multiple copies of any common cards within your seaside village but you can only have one copy of a unique card in your city so for example these two cards I could place one but I cannot place the second one because it's the copy of a unique Critter so I can only have one of this in my Village another thing that happens in this game is at the beginning of the game each player receives three of these anchor tokens what these allow players to do is in any construction that you have previously built that is currently in your seaside village you have the opportunity to place this anchor token on that City and then move in a card that matches the same type of card it is being able to move it in completely for free so you basically have three cards throughout the game that you are able to

move in for free without paying its cost as you are placing Cards into your personal seaside village you want to keep in mind what is showing on these windrows tokens that are at the top of the board the moment you place a card that matches either one or both of the tiles that are showing you actually Advance your sailboat along the outside of the track so for example if I were to place a common either Critter or construction into my personal seaside village I will advance my ship one space if though I was able to place a common card with this green production symbol on it I will actually Advance my ship two spaces along this track as you are progressing your boat down this track if at any moment you pass or stop on this little treasure symbol here that means that you actually get to collect one of those from the supply these can act as wild tokens at any time filling in for any of the resources that you collect throughout the game or if you choose to hold on to it it'll actually be worth two points at the end of the game so players are going to be going back and forth either placing a worker or playing a card and when it gets to the point that all of their workers are deployed and they cannot Place anymore or they don't have any more cards that they're able to play into their city and they can't do anything else then they have no choice but then to pass on to the next season when players prepare for the next season a couple things happen the first is that they come back to the

board and Co retrieve all of their workers that they used the next things that happen are actually listed up here at the top of the board so as people move into spring they will come up here collect their one worker and then activate all green production cards that are currently placed inside their seaside village as well the player who is last to move into spring gets to reset these wind rose tokens when players prepare for summer similar stuff happen again they grab their token collect two cards from the bay and then the last player again resets the Windrose tokens and actually sinks two of the islands that are located below the bay when this occurs the active player chooses what two islands they would like to sink then as characters move into fall again they will collect their token activate all green abilities select two cards from either the deck or the bay and then the last player again resets the wind rose tokens something to note about preparing for seasons is all players do this as they desire or want to so technically as I mean technically a player could be all the way in Autumn while a player is still in spring so this just kind of happens not not all the players have to move throughout the seasons together it just happens as each player decides to the end of the game is triggered when all of the players have reached the end of autumn they are out of actions and they cannot perform anything else if a player has passed

they can't be given any more cards or resources and all of their workers will actually remain on the board continuing to block locations until the end of the game players will then tally up their points and whoever has the most points wins I really hope that overview gave you a really rough idea of how the game plays if you are familiar with the base game everdel then you will basically go into this game already kind of knowing the basics and how to play like I just said this game is very similar to everdell I'm going to try my best to review this as a standalone game but obviously I mean there will be a lot of comparisons to the base game everdel just because they are so similar so I usually like to start off on reviews with things that I personally really liked about the game so the first thing that I wanted to talk about which was the biggest thing that stood out to me while I was personally playing this game over the many rounds that I played was that I feel like this game it is much easier and quicker to get points than in everdale I still remember the very first time I played everdell I am I I think what I scored my very first play of everdel was around 30 points it might have even been closer to 20 eight points it was definitely no more than 30. and I remember finishing the game and being like okay that I like I all that worked for like 30 points like I wish I would have gotten more points my first game of this just to kind of put it in comparison I scored 101 points and my husband scored

116. um and that was just my very first time playing this game and the reason why is because there are just so many more ways to gain points the first which is obviously the biggest it is this track that goes around the entire board throughout the game as you are placing Critters and constructions into your own personal City every time you match these wind rose tiles that are placed at the top of the board you get to advance your ship along this track therefore earning you more points and not only earning more points but if you look along the outside of this board there actually are little treasure chests and so every time that your ship passes a treasure chest or lands on a treasure chest you actually get to collect one which like I talked about earlier these can count as two points at the end of the game team or they act as little while tokens I really really really love having these as a resource token I felt like especially the first couple games I played I actually used these quite a bit as that wild resource instead of for points because I found like I was able to grow my city quicker and earlier in the game therefore getting an earlier engine going that helped me a lot in the end game this track that goes around the outside of the board is huge and offers an insane amount of points if you happen to make it to the end it can be worth 60 points alone just by moving your ship up this track which is insane to me another big way to score points are right here

at the dunes at these Dunes when you come and place your worker here you are actually able to collect these little map tiles provided you have the necessary buildings or Critters built into your city at the time but you can collect these and these can be worth a lot of points of the end of the game like I talked about in the overview so these map tiles up here at the top of the board ever Dell had something similar there were little cards that you would place on the top of the everdel tree and as you collected like for example the dungeon and like the ranger then you could collect that um little little card which would then score you points at the end of the game the reason why I like these map tiles more and because I think these are more effective is because it's actually easier it's much easier to get these map tiles than it is to get those little cards in everdel because instead of requiring two very specific cards it act they actually just require types of cards so for example this one in order to claim or collect this map tile you just need four production cards within your city doesn't matter what kind of production cards it just needs four production cards and there's quite a bit of these tiles and so I I feel like the dunes even though there is something similar and everdel it's simply just easier and more rewarding to collect these Doom cards I also feel like in the deck itself there are many cards that allow you to collect just simply collect points and lots of cards that give you

end of game bonuses and I feel like there are more of those in this game than in everdale so overall I feel like points in general it's just much easier and quicker to get points I kind of talked about this already but I really really like these windows tiles it just kind of gives you something else to look for and it's like it's almost kind of like a second little puzzle as you were trying to figure out how to get the most points and what cards work together within your city you're also kind of in the back of your mind thinking okay I have to also like if I'm able to play for example a common um production card in my Valley then I would be able to I'll be able to advance my ship then I'll be able to collect that treasure token which my ship lands on which then I'll be able to use that treasure token either as points at the end of the game name or to collect this certain card in the bay that I really want so these wind rose towels it's nice because it gives that little extra puzzle which I really enjoyed another thing I really love is how in the Bay Area if you draw a card that is a duplicate to another card that's already in the bay instead of placing it beside that card and kind of clogging up a spot you actually place that duplicate card on top of the other one in the bay it is so nice because it you always know that you will at least have eight different cards in the bay at all times it makes it really really nice and it's also kind of nice because if there's a card you really want and you're worried that somebody else is going to take it but then a duplicate of it happens to come out and you get and it places on top

well at that point you're like okay well I guess I don't need need to get that right this second because if somebody else gets it I know there will be another one there waiting for me so um I really like that mechanism of placing duplicate cards on top top of other ones in the bay I really enjoyed that another thing that this game introduced that I was actually really skeptical about when I was reading through the rule book The First Time were these little anchors so if you're familiar with the base game everdell and everdel when you are building out your personal little Forest every single construction for the most part actually matches with a particular type of animal so let's pretend you have the shop already placed you already paid for it it's already built in your city if you happen to get your hands on the shopkeeper you can actually move that shopkeeper into that shop or into a space in your city for free because you already have the building the specific building built for that Critter so it's a way to get more Critters into your personal Tableau for free and I absolutely love that puzzle in everdel I love being like all right I have the farm if I can find the husband or if I can find the wife I can move them in for free that way I don't have to spend my resources on that and so just that puzzle of trying to find those matches I love in everdale so when I read about these anchors I was a little bit skeptical but as I was playing the game I actually really liked it and I was really surprised because I really went

into it fully expecting to hate it and I actually really liked it and the reason why was because I felt like if you were able to play your cards correctly even when you're in Winter which I always kind of struggle like the very first season of the game you you start in Winter and I always kind of struggle getting you know an engine started because I always like getting um some sort of an engine started so then when I move into spring like all of my green ones will then activate um and so because of this though because of this little anchor I was actually able to start my little engine quicker and earlier in the game because you weren't looking for specific matches this just opens up the game so you're able to have a little bit more flexibility with the cards that you are moving into your little city so as far as the things that I liked about the game I really did like a lot about it and I kind of went into it understanding that it was just going to be kind of a different version of everdel and I really like the base game everdel so it makes sense that I would like this game as well however because of the nature of reviews I do want to go over a little bit of of the issues that I personally had with the game and things that potentially others might not like about it and I'm going to start with the biggest thing first because this is something that a lot of people are currently talking about and so I just kind of wanted to share my thoughts on it too but the biggest thing for me is that this is really just a simple re-skinning of everdale when I first

heard that there was a new game that was coming out that was set in the everdale world I was so excited and my mind started going to like all the different stuff they could do maybe this one would be tile placement maybe this one could be like a deck building maybe this could like I just had all of these thoughts of what they could do with this everdale world because everdell is such an iconic beautiful world so I was so excited to see what they were going to have with it and when I opened up the box and I saw the beautiful artwork I was like oh this is going to be beautiful and then I flipped it over and when I saw the image on the back and I saw this board and the Lighthouse at the top I first thought was oh it's just everdel I feel like they're kind of taking the Ticket to Ride root a little bit with this in regards to just reproducing the same game just with different artwork and maybe a few tweaks um but that my first thought when I saw this was truthfully it was a little bit of a disappointment because I was really hoping for a new game there are slightly different things that this game offers versus everdel but really you're doing basically the exact same thing so that was a little bit of a disappointment to me truthfully another thing that I really didn't like is this lighthouse the everdale tree for me yes it's not it's not really purposeful for the game you really don't need the everdale tree but it does look big and it does look beautiful and having the space to hold

stuff at the top is nice I personally never play everdel without the tree because I feel like it's just like kind of like a show stopper it just comes right off the top of the board and it just looks beautiful this lighthouse let's see if I can put it here for perspective um I this is even more pointless than we ever tell tree there were multiple instances where me and my husband were playing and we this accidentally got knocked and all of the critters fell off and then we would go to set it back up and these little boards are so tiny oh see right there I have no idea why they designed this this way and they made this so tiny they could have made this even just a little bit bigger um and it would have kept these animals on it's to the point that I would really never take this out and set it up I would much rather just take all the little characters and it's annoying too because half of the characters you can't even see like for example like you can't even see that I just put two up there and so if you are sitting around the table usually people don't like to sit on this side so people will kind of sit over here you can't even like see over here like I don't understand why it was created this way honestly I would much rather just set them at the top of the board and just not even bother setting this up now the next thing I want to talk about it's definitely just

a me thing I'm sure some people won't care too much but for me I prefer the card artwork in the base game everdel than this and here is why um I feel like the artwork in everdale everything just feels so foresty it feels so cohesive all of the characters feel like you would go and see them in the forest in this game the artwork on many of the cards in my personal in my personal opinion feel rather plain um and especially because this is an ocean game like you would think that they would incorporate more ocean animals or more ocean scenes there are many cards in this game that don't even feel like an ocean at all in my opinion and I went through the deck and I actually organized I actually took out the cards that had ocean animals in them first is the rest of the deck so let me show you that so this is the huge stack of cards that come with the game I went out and I took out the characters that were strictly um strictly ocean animals and this is the stack so for comparison these are the cards and these are the animals that are strictly ocean animals and you would think that for an ocean game like they would just have at least at least half at least have like half the ocean creatures and the other half

be land creatures um but I feel like that a lot of the creatures that are in here are actually similar creatures that were already in everdale and I wish that they would have changed that up a little bit more like they have a lot of birds they have um they have squirrels and beavers and just characters like hedgehogs characters that you already see kind of in everdel I I wish that they just would have Incorporated censuses in Ocean game I wish they would have Incorporated more of that theme into the cards and more I don't know it just something about the card artwork even though it is beautiful it didn't pull me in as much as the everdell card artwork does another thing about this game is I felt like there were too many how do I say this I feel like in a weird way there were almost like too many resources and again for new players and people who have never played ever doubt this might make this game more approachable for them but for me I wish it would have been a little bit tighter in regards to the resources that you get because on the board you have the four main resource areas but then you also have four areas here in the ocean that you can go to as well and so I feel like those are eight places and these areas in the ocean are very powerful like you get lots of stuff here in the ocean and then on top of that as you are bringing your boat like I talked

about earlier as you're bringing your boat around you're actually CR collecting treasure chests which can be used for wild resources so there are a lot of ways to gain resources in this game and if you're a player who really enjoys that and likes that then that will be very approachable for you and this will actually be a good thing for you for me it felt almost like I wish it would have been a little bit tighter I wish it would have been like a little bit more how the base game everdel is in regards to I'm like okay I've gotta play this card so then I can gain this when I when I transfer to the season which then I can use for this like it's definitely more of a puzzle in everdale which I really enjoy and which I love this it feels it feels almost like these resources are just kind of given to you and it doesn't feel as tight so when I come into this scoring this game it really it's really really hard for me scoring it and reviewing it and kind of going over the pros and cons because inevitably I have to have to have to compare this to everdoll it is just so similar that there's no way that I can look at this game without comparing it to everdel so for me everdel is an 8.5 um I really I really love everdel and truthfully truthfully I'm gonna give this one the same rating I'm going to give this one an 8.5 as well and the reason why is because it really is it feels just so much like the same game for me if you are a new player who has never played any form of

everdel before then I mean you could do one of two things one you could do this version because it's going to be slightly easier and more approachable but if the forest theme is really drawing you in then I would do ever done so for me if you're a new player really just pick which theme draws you in more whether it's the ocean theme or it's the four theme keeping in mind that this one might be slightly more approachable if however you are a seasoned player who has played everdel and you own everdel the question kind of comes down to is do you should you feel the need to own this game and I'm gonna be brutally honest here I don't think you do I don't think that this game is giving you anything else that ever Dell doesn't already give you and I think that especially for seasoned Gamers I think the the puzzle of everdell is a little bit more hard-hitting than here so I feel like this is kind of more for newer gamers-ish I'm not saying it's super easy compared to everdel because it's really not but there's just certain aspects um about this game that make it more approachable for new players so there you go those are my thoughts on the new everdel for sure huge shout out to tabletop Tycoon for sending me this copy to review overall again I do really really like the game but if you do already have everdel then I don't necessarily feel like you need to add this one to your collection as well let me know what you think in the comments below if you agree with me disagree with me and if you have played

this game what you personally liked about it thank you so much for watching we'll see you next time I'm gonna very quickly shift here let me just show you how stink and bright this sign can get okay so let me show you okay so this is this is ten percent this is 20. 30 40. it's a hundred percent okay look how bright I'm not sure if that's coming across but it is stinking bright so I'm just gonna I'm just gonna leave it at 10 percent my videos

Progress saved