Skip to main content
Loading video...

Great Western Trail Board Game Review - Still Worth It?

Transcript 9:32

hello welcome back to the channel and this is a channel where we give you reviews playthroughs unboxings I generally like to talk a lot of bics but tabletop gaming in general in this video we're going to be talking about an Alexander Fister classic we're going to be talking about Great Western trial and in this game you will be Hing your cattle along the Great Western Trail you'll be trying to get them to Kansas City where you'll ship them off to different towns hoping to get enough victory points that will allow the win the game so in this video I'm going to be giving you a very brief overview of the rules of tenue what we do like what we don't like and we're com back and with tell you whether or not great w and trout it's still worth your time and bother when is it 2015 can't believe this game it's 20 2016 8 years old so remember if you are new here then please consider subscribing to this Channel with the like button YouTube [ __ ] see you after this bollocks so great western tra is an action selection game you will be moving your dude around the board taking different actions and eventually you'll get to Kansas City where you will sell your cattle to different towns via railroad yeah so each player is going to get a player board with some discs on it taking these discs off of the board to reveal different bonuses and maybe different actions and each player is going to get a hand of Catt cards you see that there's different categories of cow each cow has got a color and each cow has got a number the higher the number the more valuable the moal yeah so in Phase a you'll be able to move your blow or blet up to three spaces a

space is considered to be a piece of cardboard you've either got an action tile you might have some hazards like floods or desert or rockfall or you might want to trade with the Native Americans yeah you come across a hand symbol on the card then you'll either have to pay the bank if it's a private to that belongs to another player and you'll pay player a bit of money right once you have come to a standstill then you will take the action that's associated with that tile yeah if it's your own to then you could take the action on that tile or if it's a neutral tole do that as well but if it's a private to of another player then you can't take the action that's on the to you have to do an auxiliary actions auxiliary actions are the actions on the left side of your player board at the beginning of the game you only be able to take one of these but if you manage to get some discs off of your auxiliary actions then this will unlock double auxiliary actions and even more auxiliary actions [ __ ] love auxiliary actions basically auxiliary actions will give you a massive boner so some of the action Toes that you can use are you might want to discard exactly one gy Kettle card and gain $2 then you'll be able to perform the action hire one work pay the actual cost and you'll be able to perform the action hire one worker paying $2 more if you want to hire a worker you'll look across at the really boring spread sheet with those ugly mug faces on it you'll choose one of the workers and you will pay the cost and you'll put it on your player board you got three different types of workers you got Cowboys that will help you buy more and better cows you got Engineers that will help you move your little Choo Cho train along the choo choo track and then you got Craftsmen or women or crafts people that will help you build more buildings AKA action Tes yeah so you might want to even move your certificate marker one space forward or gain one objective card and the general objective

display certificates are used when you get the Kansas they basically give you extra money and eventually when you get to Kansas City you will refresh the workers's spreadsheet and then you will reveal your hand cows you remove any duplicates and then you'll add up the value of your cows and you'll get that much money right and dependent on the value of the cows you'll be able to ship these moo cows off to that sea so if you had a value of 13 you'll look at the chooo track and you'll be able to flog them to any with a value of 13 or less you'll take one of your discs you'll plun it on the town and if you get one put it next to another disc of yours you'll get the bonus or the penalty that is on the board here there's also train stations that you can get to going to the sidings you can choose to upgrade the station you'll take an ability might be an extra certificate or it might be some money or something like that so keep doing this every time you refill up the worker spreadsheet the little cross disc will move down one space and when it drops off the board everyone will have one more turn and you'll add up all your victory points based on the scoring criteria that that I'm not going to go into cuz it's boring as [ __ ] and the player with the most points will be the winner of Great Western Trail so what do we like that Great Western Trail so the first thing that we really like about this game is the fact that you get to choose your actions yet you get to choose which action tile you put out on the board because at the beginning of the game there is a sparse collection of neutral tiles yeah it's like going to a breatharian buffet there's only one space where you can build buildings that always causes a bit of frustration but the fact you got nine different buildings in front of you and you can upgrade existing buildings to make it even cheaper means that effectively if the action that you need

isn't on the board then is your fault yeah because you could have built it so the game gives you a wealth of different options and there is a sense of progression when you're building these buildings right so that's good so the second thing we like about Great Western Trail and it relates to the building of building thing that I said a minute ago and that's that when you put a tile out of the board you've got to think carefully about where you going to put it you got put it in a place that's going to benefit you because some of the tiles allow you to move your cowboy a few spaces forward so therefore you can chain actions together but also you can put it in spaces where it's going to [ __ ] the movement capabilities of other players yeah where you can only move three spaces at the beginning of the game if you plun a couple of TOS in somebody else's path then they're going to have to Wade through your [ __ ] before they can get to where they want to be and that will slow them down it might even force them to go through the floods or even through that bleeding desert yeah so not only can you choose which actions you put down but where you put them is also a juicy choice so the final thing we really like about Great Western trout is a rare example of a highly thematic Euro game yeah usually games of this ilk don't have any theme at all it's like pasted on if you think about castles and burgundy some Geer looking out of his window onto nothing really this game actually makes a lot of sense yeah you're going to be getting Catt you're going to be Hing them through the landscape taking different actions and eventually you're going to get a Kansas where you're going to flog them yeah so there's a linear style to this game it makes sense you're going from point A to point B and doing [ __ ] in between yeah it's not just some random [ __ ] so Mr Fister has thought carefully about how this game is going to work how we can translate the theme into mechanisms or perhaps vice versa so don't like that

Great Western Trail so the first thing I don't like about it this game represents painfully slow progress especially at the beginning of the game you're going to be tearing your [ __ ] air out thinking I can't do anything that the fact that you've only got one space where you can build [ __ ] means that actions at the beginning of the game are going to be coming in very very thin on the ground yeah and your deck is going to be comprised of [ __ ] cows yeah it's going to be very difficult to a get the Cowboys you need to get some decent cows into your hand quickly and then you're going to be cycling through the [ __ ] deck cursing your luck when that one value cow comes out of your hand yeah and you don't really know when your big juicy rump steak is going to make an appearance so that you can get those lucrative bonuses through the railway track there are a few ways to mate that you can discard your cards there's a one way I think of discarding cards permanently at the game but still it feels as if you are waiting through a [ __ ] quagar at the beginning of this game yeah so second thing we don't like about Great Western tra is that the hazards and the Native American track can get blocked up really quickly I've always scratched M and thinking why the [ __ ] is it there every round you're going to be putting either a TP out or a hazard out and they're going to Stu up real quick and people just aren't going to bother going down that route it should have been a shortcut but there's no real incentive to take a hazard tile or a Native American Tile unless a it's worth a load of money or B you just happen to have an objective card and if no one's got that on their objective then no one's going to take it and that route stays blocked yet so it's a bit of a andrum as to why it's in here so the final thing we don't like about Great Western trout is that the deck building

element is kind of weak yeah like we've already said it takes ages to cycle through your deck and there's not really much going on with it is there there's not really any action cards you can bung in there and it's just going to be a lot of chaos really I know you can put an objective card in there and then you got the option to play it or keep it in your hand for final scoring to avoid the penalty if you don't manage to fulfill it but it would have been nice if there could have been some other stuff bunged into to the deck may be something that allows you to cycle through the deck quicker cuz that's the main bug bear with this and if you unlucky just to have all those [ __ ] cows come at once and you'll pushed into Kansas then you're going to end up having to go to Kansas City and taking the minus 6 victory points yet and that is a real bummer so sometimes there are colder sack options you can only drive in one way and you know for well you're going to be [ __ ] driving out the other way don't you so to summarize is Great Western Trail still worth your time and bother eight years8 years after it was first released so we're going to say maybe maybe not Great Western trout seems simple enough move your bloke and take the action but the problem comes with not being able to do what you want to do when you need to do it resulting in action deference right and this means that the game moves at a snail's pace until its third and final Act having said that the fact that you can choose exactly what actions you need and hurt your opponents in the process as a much needed player interaction salvages the game from the pit of soulless Euro so there you go that is great western remember if you're new here please consider subscribing to his Channel with the like button and all that YouTube [ __ ] see you next

time

Progress saved