Skip to main content
Loading video...

Garden Lake Review: Quick Take with Tom Vasel

Transcript 5:33

Garden Lake is a new tile laying game from Uve Rosenberg. This is his 2000th tile lane game. That's not true, but he has done a lot. Uh from very complex games, if he's frozen to much simpler games, uh like the the his the spring autumn summer series, New York Zoo, he's known for this. So, this is another one with the koiish pond as the background. That doesn't mean it's bad. Let's take a look. Each player gets a board. And in the middle of that board, you can put one of these gardens or you can just use the one that's preprinted here. You'll put 16 of these random pieces around your board in this kind of shape. And on your turn, you may take the piece that's on either end or the piece from the players next to you, the one that's closest to you, which by the way is a little confusing sometimes. Like this you, this one's closer to the person my left and this one's closer to the person on my right, I think. Maybe I should have it like that. I don't know. But you figure it out pretty soon which end you can draw from. Once you take these pieces, you can put on the board anywhere you want. Once you put it somewhere, uh, you can flip it to either side. You're done. and it can ever move again. And this is gonna be tricky because these pieces are all sorts of funky shapes. But there's a couple things. If you form a line all the way, I'm not going to do it right now, but if you form a a horizontal or vertical line, then the tile that it is touching, so this one here, let's say I filled that one, I

would get this tile. I can use it right away or save it. You can only ever save one tile at a time. Every tile is double-sided. shows fish on one side and uh little lily pads on the other. Also, if you cover up these shapes here completely, then you will get a tile that matches that shape or this one. And again, you can put these wherever you want, adding them to your board. This is going to continue. You'll be taking these tiles. There's some rules. If your tiles run out, you can draw more from the bag. And also if you're using one of these boards here, there will be pieces on these that if you completely surround the different pieces on these boards, then you can take that matching piece. There are these special pieces here that will go on there and just fit on the board. So if I surround this completely, then this just comes out and fills in those spaces. Anyhow, the game ends. And when you're going to get a point for every complete rowing column and then for every group of lily pads and or fish that is seven or more, you're going to get two points. Whoever has the most points is the winner. Wow, those tiles are an assault for me. I have difficulty with those tiles. In fact, when we first got it, the first game of this I played, I was playing with my my family and I said to my son, I said, "You know what?

These tiles are hard. I completely understand. Do not expect to fill your whole board in." And indeed, I did not fill my whole board in. He did, though. So, that's me being a big dummy because as you put these pieces in, if you cover up that stuff, you get the other little tiles and put them in. And and that's that's cool. The groups of seven is a trickier rule. I don't love that rule because you're already trying to put these things in this board and then I'm like, I'm going to put together a group of goldfish. Okay, that has seven now. So, I don't want to add any more to that, but I'm also combining that with these pieces. And then that whole U shape that you put or a C or whatever the letter is. And you can take one from either person. So, I'm looking at that. It makes it hard to work ahead because a tile that I might take, you might take.

So, I can't really plan on what tiles are out there until my turn, which slows the game down a bit. Now, I say all this, the game works fine. It is another tile game for Muay Rosenberg. Does it stand out amongst his other ones? No, not not not for me anyway. It's intriguing. These are weird shaped tiles. The idea of covering things up to get the little tiles that are so easy to fit in your board and fill things in, that's great. And I'm sure other people will enjoy this more than me. But I thought this was just okay. It's a 6 out of 10 for me. Again, it's not a bad experience, but it's also not one that I'm going to go back and go, "Oo, that sounds fun. Let's play it again." So, this is one though I think that mileage may vary. I think other people may like this more than myself. Although I would argue strongly that whether you like this or not, in a few years no one's going to remember this one unfortunately because there's so many out there. And in my opinion, the tail games he's done that are very good um like Cottage Garden and so on. Those have kind of faded with time has gone by and I think those are excellent games. So if I don't think it's excellent then why why would I get this over one of the other ones? I think in my opinion, New York Zoo is probably the pinnacle of the style. Why would I not get that one? But maybe you like koi ponds and maybe the idea of these tiles being crazy tiles really appeals to you. Then you'll want to check out Garden Lake.

Progress saved