The Great Wall - Board Game Review
Transcript
welcome to allies or enemies this time we are looking at the great wall a one to four player game by camille sanex cesla robert plazovich and lucas flordarczyk the great wall puts players into the shoes of chinese generals begrudgingly working together to build the titular great wall and protect their lands from genghis khan and the mongol horde it is part worker placement part kind of tower defense game that has an absurd amount of table presents especially with the 3d wall but this game is so much more than just a cool wall so before we get too into the looks let's look at how it plays the great wall is played over six rounds of worker placing and wall defending with each round broken into four seasons in the fall players will choose their command cards which dictate what they and others can do in the round and then they resolve those cards in command track order command cards have some combination of placing clerks and fighting the horde clerks are placed on the bottom half of the board and they do things like gathering resources hiring overseers which are like supervisors who get you more resources hiring other clerks and advisors hiring and deploying soldiers and building the wall these last two are especially important for winter in which all players need to defend the wall against the coming horde which basically means shooting them with
archers and then comparing the horde attack to the wall defense then spring and summer are kind of a break where you refresh advance and gather income for the next fall and winter after six rounds you compare who has the most honor and the greatest general is named the great wall plays from one to four but it should be noted that each of these counts feels almost like a different game at three or four players there is a lot of begrudging semi-cooperation as players need to fill all worker spaces in order to gain the benefits for most spaces if only one color clerk fills the whole action that generally gains shame which you don't want so you do need to work together the same goes for building wall sections as those are built with both your own goods and those gathered from the pool of donated goods which were donated to gain honor and of course there is the actual fighting of hordes as the saying goes it takes a village to kill invaders with pikes and arrows with two players this feels a bit different as the neutral read clan is added this is a neutral clan that both players kind of share and can be used to help fill slots and grant advanced actions and it makes the game feel maybe a smidge more cooperative though still very competitive it is a simple solution that actually works pretty well finally the solo mode has a player competing against the ai controlled general who is powered by a solo
specific command deck there is a lot of variation in this box first and foremost are the generals players will only use one of these each game with each one granting a very different asymmetrical power these all make a big impact on your strategy and there are more of them than you will likely ever use and when you add in the even bigger deck of advisor cards the combos are near endless also the game will always unfold differently based on which horde cards come out when especially the ones with special powers as well as how and when players use their various command cards because other players command cards let you do things on their turns you will find yourself adapting your strategy nearly every round the game also has a fully cooperative mode with its own decks of cards including events and tasks you need to complete for the emperor this version of the game feels more different than you might think but we warn you that it ups the complexity and difficulty quite a bit so it might be something that you put aside until you have the base game down awaken realms are known for their quality production but the great wall might be their best one yet the highlight here is the three-dimensional wall which is such a brilliant touch and adds an actual physical barrier between the two halves of the game
the minis are also fantastic with different sculpts for each of the clans with plenty of personality to go around and it is pleasing how they populate the wall in the coming hoard cards the cards are all top quality with terrific art and the resources and bits are all nice as well especially the wound markers the only tricky here in an otherwise phenomenal package are some of the icons which are sometimes chosen for style over substance and aren't always as brain-free as they could be especially the various units in the overseer icons the rulebook is also famously unhelpful although this has thankfully been updated for the latest edition of the game and a pdf of the new version is available online the great wall was kind of a surprise for us from a distance it looks like more of a combat game but it's heart it's really about resource management and worker placement it's just that one of the areas where you're placing your workers happens to be a giant battle with a 3d wall which is to say we liked it more than we thought we would this kind of balance between competitive and cooperative is famously hard to pull off and great wall does it really well there's a begrudging cooperation in everything that you do there is a shared goal but also a lot of opportunity to do it better and more honorably than your opponents it should be noted however that this system comes
with a fair amount of complexity some of which is made harder by a not very good rules book and some tricky icons and while it looks terrific those looks do come with a hefty price tag especially if you ante up for the expansions but for players who want a challenging work replacement game with an interesting semi-co-op push-pull and a bit of a tower defense style battle this game is a unique experience that's definitely worth playing and that is it have you played the great wall what did you think and are there any other semi-co-op games that you might recommended please do like and subscribe and hopefully we will see you all next time for another game