Enchanted Ivy Review - No One Said That Managing Expectations Was Easy
Transcript
Hey, I'm Alex Ra from Board Gameco and today I'm reviewing Enchanted Ivy from AllPlay. Enchanted Ivy is a solo game that's going to give you a series of puzzles to play through and a cat. The cat comes in the box, not actually in the box. This is a prototype all rules and components of the exchange, and I'll have a link to the crowdfunding campaign down below. I should also note that AllPlay, who publishes this game, they are a channel sponsor. While they are not sponsoring this video, they do sponsor the channel in general. Please take any potential biases into account and decide if you value my opinion on this or not. I will attempt to be as I'll attempt to be as true to myself and my opinion as possible, but you have to decide if you still trust what I say. With that said, let's go ahead and dive into this. This is a solo game. You're going to be playing through a bunch of scenarios. It's not really a campaign. There's like things you can unlock a little bit, so like a little rogue light adjacent, but not really. I believe the game is going to have 10 scenarios if I'm not mistaken. There are four in this prototype and each one is a set of of a puzzle that you have to go through. It's going to give you specific guests that you are trying to put into the wall that you build. It's going to tell you how many cards you need for the shape that you're building out. It's going to tell you how many points you need and any special requirements that you are attempting to see. You can get a good sense of how this plays out if you watched the playthrough on the channel.
I did a playthrough together with Meg. Yes, this is a solo game, but also like many solo games like this, you could plan and optimize together and try to figure out if two heads are indeed better than one, as you attempt to get all the goals. With that said, the way you play through the game is you're going to take two cards. You're also going to take a guest from the bag of guests, again, the ones matching the scenario. So, I'm going to take two guests from the bag, and every turn, you're going to place one guest and two cards. Now, you are trying to build a shape. In this specific scenario, you're trying to build, let's go ahead and show you over here. In this specific scenario, you're building out. Let's see. This shape over here. Again, prototype as far as that goes. No, not that shape. Not that shape. Over here. Next page. Where is this? Over here. One page. There we go. This is the shape we're trying to build out for the scenario. These are the the scores you're trying to get. And these are the goals you are trying to get. So, let's go ahead and try to build out that shape. And again, you could adjust as you go as long as everything you do makes it so that the shape is still viable. Now, if we have over here the washer, the washer specifically wants to have gaps between her and the next guest. So, you want to see empty spaces between her and the next guest on that wall. Meanwhile, the the alchemist over here, this one wants three points per white or blue flowers in the alchemist column. We're going to try to work our way towards building out the washer. We know that the alchemist wants cards in its column. So, we're going to take the washer, put it out over here. We're going to put the washer this away. I almost inclined I'm inclined to play through the whole game. You know what I'm going to do? what I'm going to do for funsies over here. There is a full playthrough on the channel, but I'm going to start doing the first few of these so you can see how to play and then when I'm done with the review, I'm going to finish playing it out because
it's fun and I want to see if I can actually do it. With that said, we placed the washer down. We placed her in uh one of these balconies over here. You're going to place one card face down and one card face up as far as the way the balconies are presented. And that's going to be our starting row. Meanwhile, we're going to hold on to the other guests. Then, we're going to draw one more guest in the bag and two more cards. You always have two cards you're placing and one guest. And these are reversible. They have the same shape configuration. The only difference is whether you have the balcony or not. Everything else is exactly the same. The fire breather wants three points per wall or empty space diagonally adjacent to the fire breather. Now, we also know that again, we know we're kind of building in advance. We know the alchemist wants to be in a space with white or blue flowers in the alchemist column. So, I think we're going to try to place this like this. Is that a good spot to go? Cuz if we do that, we are working towards that. We're going to have this over here, but we might not have the others. We're going to try to make this work. We'll see if we can. So, we're going to place that like this. And we're going to place the fire breather out in their column. The alternative is we could just place the alchemist in that column and worry about the fire breather later. That might make might make more sense. So, we're going to place the alchemist down over here like so. Hoping to connect it later. We could possibly connect it now if you want, but I also want to work towards is there a better way to do it this way? This way might be better because it opens up that way and that way. We already have the down coming that way. We're going to do that. Let's take one more turn and then you'll get a sense of how this plays and we'll dive into my thoughts and opinions and all that. So now we have the butterfly whisperer. She wants two points per flower type in the butterfly whisperer's row. So she wants flower variety. And also this scenario has a specific goal where between the
alchemist and the butterfly whisperer, you want to score 15 points and you want them on the same color. So we do want to put the butterfly whisperer on blue. Fortunately from our next cards, we do have blue coming up. Now this is where it gets tricky because we do want I think I'm going to put the butterfly whisperer down here. I kind of want to, but I don't at the same time because the tricky part here is this. This would be very tricky to make that work. We can't do this over here. So, this has to be Did I already mess up a little bit? I think I already did mess up a little bit as far as the way that goes, cuz this could be row two, but we can't build this into row three. We could have above you in row four. Nope. Nope, we can't. This would have to be the top of that row. I think I already messed up a little bit, but not necessarily the worst. Let's place this out somewhere else over here. We do want this to be in that row or column because that will give us that. But then if we're doing that anyway, we could put her into here, which would give us a nice variety of flowers, but this would make it impossible to score. So, we don't want to do that. Instead, I think we do want to go down here like so. That's actually not bad. That's not bad at all. And then we're going to place her down into here.
So, she's going to go over here and try to score for flower variety on this row instead. That's basically what we're doing here. We're going to take a break right now. We're going to stop. But the basic idea is you are trying to build the shape that you need based on the specific scenario requirements. You're also trying to optimize the score. In this case, we want 65 points for the minimum score and 80 points for the hey, you're really good at this game score. And then you also want to complete both goals. There are two different goals in play as far as how you're trying to make it all come together. That's basically what's going on here as far as the game goes. I'm going to go ahead and dive into my review. If you want to see a full game play out, the basic idea is you're going to have 18 cards for this scenario. You're going to place all of those. You have 10 guests. you're going to be placing nine of those 10 guests. Each guest has a different way that they score. You also have ivy. Ivy is going to be the fact that you want to create connected paths of ivy because the fewer paths of ivy you have, the fewer groups of ivy, the more points you score. So, if you have separate groups, you get less points. Fewer groups, you get more points. And you're trying to balance all of that while also placing down a door as well that will score you points. And that's going to be how you play Enchanted Ivy. Which is a good time to dive into my thoughts and opinions on this, my review, what I like, don't like, and all that. I really enjoy this game. This is exactly the kind of optimization puzzle that I like. It has you trying to get to a certain level of score here while making it very hard to do so. Meaning getting all four goals, which you don't actually have to, by the way. The way the game is structured is you can get this goal, this game, that goal, this game. For me, my personal challenge is getting all the goals in a single game. That's what accomplishment is in this. And I have found that it takes multiple plays to get there. It is not something you do on your first play.
It's not something you do on your second play. So far, only one of the scenarios have I gotten all four goals. And I think it took me like six plays to get all four goals in one game. But there is this process of like learning the combinations. You're like, "Oh, this one wants that. That one wants this. This one needs to be next to guests. That wants to be away from guests." And as you start to chart out the pathway and learn from your mistakes as you make mistakes in it, you start to get better at trying to optimize. And each scenario is different, which is another thing I like about the game. I like that the game is scenario- driven. As much as a good solo game with like here's a puzzle, try to optimize your score can be fun. I particularly enjoy solo puzzles that give you a scenario constrictions, restrictions around how that scenario works. You're using these guests, you're building that shape, and you have these extra goals on top of it. Those are consistently my favorite solo experiences. Things like Calico, Cascadia, uh, for for Northwood. When you have not just a core system, but you have specific scenarios around that core system, that keeps me diving back into it because I want to beat every single scenario. I want to try to optimize and challenge myself and go through and get get them all done and make it hard enough that I feel accomplished when I do so. If there's 10 scenarios and each one gives me six plays before I get it right, before I actually finally get all four, that's what hard mode is. And that to me is 60 plays of the game before I want more scenarios. I I before I need more scenarios. This is a challenging solo experience that you can play cooperatively as well as you're trying to optimize the various needs of a lot of different guests as you're trying to make it all work and every game is going to play out a bit different. I thoroughly enjoy exactly the type of game this this is. Not to mention the presentation is charming and lovely.
It's like very very cute. It's cute artwork. It's cute artwork. It's a great package. It's a solo game. Everything about this is exactly the kind of thing I like. As far as what I don't like, there's nothing that I don't like in the game except for the fact that I want there to be more scenarios already. I'm already looking at this and thinking 10 scenarios. That's what 40 to 60 plays, 40 to 70 plays depending on how depending on how well I do it. And the plays aren't that long. You can play through a full game of this if you're depending how fast or how optimized you're going. You can play through a game in 10 minutes. You can play through a game in 20 25 minutes. It's not that long to go through it. And especially when you're doing those repeat plays. I would say each scenario is probably around an hour for me to get to the maximum goal. I've only done one so far, but like I've only gotten to the all four in one one scenario. But because you're playing through rapidly because you learned it already, you keep going faster and faster. It's probably about an hour to an hour and a half of play time before you master a scenario. And because I like what this puzzle is doing, I want there to be 20 scenarios.
20 is like enough. I can deal with 20. More is even better, but 10 just feels like a little too few. So, my biggest complaint is the fact that this type of game, as much as I enjoy a solo experience that gives you scenarios, the the other side of that equation, when you drop the what's it called? Um, you're waiting for the other shoe to drop, is that the expression? With the other shoe dropping in those types of things, is that there is a sense of completion that makes you a little more reticent to jump back into it. Meaning if you're playing a typical solo game, you play it, you you you you win or you lose, and you come back and you do it again. Even if you win, you come back and you do it again. When you have scenario specific goals to go through, there is something that feeds into that completionist mindset that when you do complete it, it can take a long time before you jump back in. Going to things like Calico, when I finally did beat all 10 snares on Calico, I kind of stopped playing Calico solo for about 2 years until I felt, okay, great, enough time has passed. I'm going to do them all again. So I do go back to it, but because of that sense of completion, I do almost want more content. So I feel that full sense. And Calico has 10 scenarios, but Calico is also a competitive game, so it gives you more gameplay out of it. I I want I want more gameplay out of this already. As far as I can see others not liking, the biggest thing is just going to be first of all, you have to like the style of game. If you don't like this kind of solo puzzly optimization, then it's not for you. And the other thing is luck is definitely a factor. And this is similar to things like Calico, for Northwood, all of those. the order that things come out, both the cards and the guess absolutely play a part in how likely you are to be able to optimize around the scenario goals because you can play the best game possible. If things come out in order that doesn't serve you, that is going to play a part and that means you're
playing both strategically to try to optimize, but you also at the you're also at the victim of how things play out. So, it's luck driven, strateg it's strategy driven, luck dependent, if that makes sense. As far as final thoughts on Enchanted Ivy, I love it. This is exactly the kind of puzzle I like. I was not super excited about this one because I didn't know what to expect when I first heard about the whole campaign. I knew there was Mountain Ghost Legacy, which by the way is part of this campaign. Uh, but then I heard about a solo game and I was like, "Oh, fun. I'll play doing a nice little solo game. I will absolutely try it out." I was intrigued, but I wasn't excited because solo games are a dime a dozen. What's the chances that this is going to be the type of game that lands with me compared to just being a good game? Allplay makes a lot of good games. Some of them really land with me, some of them less so. But I absolutely adore Enchanted Ivy. I think this is a it's it's doing exactly the kind of solo puzzle I like. I'm going to give this a 4.5 out of five.
There's a part of me that wants to go all the way up, but I'm not ready to do so yet. Part of that's that I need more content. Also, this prototype only has four camp or four sessions to go through. So, I've only played through the four sessions it has. I've already done all of them multiple times already, but I need more time. For right now, it is a 4.5 out of five. If you like solo puzzles, if you like any of the games I mentioned, this is definitely one you should check out. Speaking of the games I mentioned, you should definitely check out uh like I said already, Calico is very much the kind of vibe I have when I play this that optimization puzzle as I try to make it all work and realize I slowly can't and then play it again and again and again until I master the scenario. Very much gave me vibes of that. I'll also say that while I didn't enjoy this other game as much, you might enjoy I think is it called the Lonely Inn? Oh my gosh. I I No, not the Lonely Inn. It's from Buttonshy. Ugly Griffin in. Is that what it's called? Ugly Griffin in. I think it's called Ugly Griffin in. From Buttonshy Games is a small little game, a 18 shot 18 card game, but trying to make all the guests need fit into it. I believe it's called Ugly Griffin in. It does kind of have the same vibe. I didn't enjoy that one quite as much. The nature of you kind of have this cascading aspect of people leaving and coming all the time, which is a little different, but it does kind of hit those same notes. So, there's a decent chance that if you like one, you'll like the other. For me, I was fine with that one and I love this. So, it's both a recommendation and also a little less so for how it worked for me personally. In any case, and until next time, I'm Alex Radical from Board Game Co. Hope you found this video helpful and as always, I hope you have a good one.
I'm just waiting for enough time to pass and then I'm going to go keep playing. Okay, let's play the game. So, we need two more cards. Uh, we need one more guest. We currently have the fire breather. We also have the um this [snorts] one is the botus. Four points per surrounding space with the same flower color as the botist space. What's funny is if you uh watch the gameplay with myself and Meg, purple is exactly the color that came out with the botist as well. Now, I think based on the way we built this board, we kind of have to have this as our empty spot. So, we could have the botist down here. The cat goes there obviously, but we could have Hey, Calico. Hey, Calico. Hey, Califer. Calcifer, how's it going? Where do you want to go? Oh. Oh, you want to go around? Okay, that's fine.
Uh, we're going to put the botist down over here, I believe. [snorts] Well, we want to make sure we can trace a pathway. This one does not work. This one does work. But then if that's the case, we need to make sure it's accessible. Oh no. Oh no. Because we need to have a pathway of flowers. But this this can go like this. That works. That does work. Again, cat comes with the game. This is a different cat that comes with the game, obviously. All right, two more cards. Let's move this up a little bit just so we have it all on camera. I know the shape we're building towards. I know that we need the cat to score optimally. I know this is not going to work out the way we want. This is game two of this specific scenario. Trying to achieve perfection. So, we have this over here, these two. We want white and blue in this column.
We want Oh, we got we have Oh, this is supposed to go over here. I forgot to put that there. Okay, so you want purple flowers around you, which is going to be hard. You're not going to get a lot of points out of that. We have the monk as well, which is not great. Now, we could put something up here, but I don't think I don't think that we could put a the thing up there. That's not bad, actually. But we really want to have the the the white should be in this column here. Now, we could actually just do the following. We could we could build that there. H [snorts] let's see if we build this here. This would work. Nope, that's not going to work. Not going to work. So, this won't group this up. I want to get one patch of ivy. This won't work as well here.
So, once it's not working as well here, it is not crazy to go have this be up top cuz that works nicely. But then this h well this can go up top here if this will cooperate. This could cooperate. We're not sure. It might cooperate. It might. So if we place that up there and we place this guy over here. We still need this to come around, but I think we can make it work because then we're going to try to trace a pathway from the cat all the way around in a circle basically. So we have our next two cards coming out. We have one more guest in the bag. Uh we have our painter. This this painter over here is interesting. Uh, we do ideally want to put something down here. Purple would be great. Does this work? Whoops.
That one's not great because it leaves this disconnected. But if we go here, then that could be connected. We can flip this around like so. But we want we want we want white in that. We need to have the the flower colors and things going on. So, if we place this here, this is not going to score. This isn't going to score, but I think it's still No, we want white there. We want white there, which means this can't go over there. How many purples are there? If there's 20 cards, there's got to be more purples. I don't know. Well, we got a purple over here. There's three purples. There got to be more. I don't I think it's four of each color if I'm not mistaken, but I don't know the two that were taken out. So, this might be our last chance to get a purple here, but then we can't get the the color we want over there. So, let's go ahead and continue this process of trying to figure out [snorts] because we have the fire breather. The fire breather could go down over here, but then we need to have this like so that could work if the fire breather goes over here.
That's not the worst. Not necessarily the best, but not the worst because we still have the possibility we don't have we'd only get three more, which means this would be one, two, three for nine points and then one, two, three for six points. That would be 15. We're not optimizing as well as I'd like. Is there a better way to optimize? If we go here, if you go like this, that could theoretically work. And then you go like this. That leaves this cut off. But I don't think that's necessarily a problem as long as we can come around and connect it. That's a big if. But you know what? We're going to go for it. We're going to go for that if. We're going to see if we can do that. Make that if work. Although I guess this can come out this way if we do it that way. So we're going to put the fire breather down here. That gives us a different color disparity.
We're going to draw two more cards because effectively we're trying to get different colors in this row. So every additional point we get, like you really want to get as many points as possible. We have the fool. Three points per wall or empty space above the fool in their column. Now, this is important because we do want to kind of get we want to get color disparity, but we also want to get white flowers here and connect that. So, that was helpful as far as this going over here. Uh, but we don't necessarily need it to be empty in this case. But placing this down over here, it would deny the full points, but it would give us a chunk one, two, three points, which is not bad at all. But we'd have to put this like so, and that would create a different grouping. Now, we could hypothetically pair it up later, so it might be worth doing anyway. I think I think it's worth doing anyway.
So, we're going to place the fool over here because again, that way we can still have a chaining group of the cats coming around in theory. And the fool is going to score a lot of points. We may have forced ourselves to create two groups of ivy. We're going to take another token out. We have two more cards. We're only placing two more. Uh-oh. If we do one here and one here. Oh, we're not going to be able to do it. We're not going to be able to do it. Okay, fine. So, we messed up again. So, this this is good. This shows you that it's really challenging to get it all to work. So, we want to put these in one of the columns. If we messed up anyway, if the cat's not going to be in play helping us, then it is in our best interest to try to have if we do this like this, then this won't be grouped up, which I don't want that. I want this grouped up because I want the painter over here ideally. So, if we place this like that, um, we who do we have? We have the the Raven Keeper. Oh, we do want the Raven Keeper up here. Ideally, that's a good place for the Raven Keeper. So, if we're doing this here, that's not grouped up versus that is grouped up. So, this is a good place for the Raven Keeper to go.
But, it does mean that this is now all we're going to have two different groups no matter what. We can't make it so there's not two groups. I don't love it. I don't love it. The alternative is we ignore the Raven Keeper. We sit there and we put down the blue down here with the painter. It's going to cost us some points, but I don't see a way around it. The other way is we do this down here. That's a possibility because then we can maybe connect it later depending what we draw. Um, and then this one over here would go anywhere that would not hurt us. Is that possible? We could put it down over here like so, which is not crazy, honestly, because it limits the negative points we get from there. And it's still connected. But no matter what, it's definitely going to be separate at this point. We're going to we're going to have two different groups no matter what we do. All right, let's take our last token for the bag. And we have the Ravens keeper. And we have the cat. And we have our last two cards, which oh no, we're not going to be able to do color disparity on this row.
That's a darn shame. That is a darn shame. But the cat can at least get 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 eight points, which is not bad for the cat to get. Better than the Ravens keeper. So, the cat won't get us the grouping of going in a circle, which is what we ideally wanted, but it still can help us. So, what's the best way to make sure we don't uh lose out? We're going to have another grouping. We're going to have another wall. No, no, no, no, no, no. Okay, so I don't think it matters at this point. So, we're just going to place it like this. We are now going to have three groupings of ivy because we have one group of ivy because this is not connected over here. They're they're not linked. So, one group, two groups, and the rest are all No way. No, I messed up. We have four groups. This is another fourth group of ivy. This is not connected either. So, I really messed up. And then this does go around like that. Okay, so four groups of ivy.
It is what it is. We're going to place the cat out, not the ravens keeper. And we're going to score. So, let's go ahead and score this for the alchemist. The alchemist. Oh, and the door. I should have placed the door down. I'm going to place the door down and say I did. I should have done that. I knew I was doing. So, I'm going to place it down. Um, actually, now that I think about it, if I if I recall correctly, I may not have scored the three points in the uh gameplay for the door. Maybe I did. Anyways, I think I did actually. Alchemist. The Alchemist is going to score um one, two, three because it scores blues and whites in this column. That's nine points. The botist is going to score for having purple around it, which is only once. So, four points plus nine is 13. The butterfly whisperer is going to score six points. So, because it's three different colors and that's two points per collar in his column. So that's 6 plus the was 9 + 4 is 13 + 6 is 19. The cat is going to score 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8. So 8 uh plus my 19 is 27. Uh the fire breather scores for empty spots which is only this one over here. Three.
So we're at I need to stop trying to use my head. We have which I'm going to keep doing my head. 9 + 4 is 13 + 6 is 19 + 8 is 27 + 3 is 30. We are 30. The fool scores for empty rows or columns, three points. So 33. That brings us to 39. The monk is going to score six. It's eight points minus two for each one around it, which is this guy over here. So it's going to be six points. So 39 plus 6 is 45. The painter scores four points for the guest facing it. I'm actually just choose a direction over here. And the three points to the next one. So that brings us from 40. I said I wasn't going to do wasn't going to do this, but I did it again. We were at 39 + 6 45 + 7 for the painter is 52.
So we have 52. Uh the Ravens keeper didn't score. The washer is going to be Did I mess up the washer? No. Oh, I didn't put a guess there. I don't know. I don't think I get points if there's I think the washer needs to have a guess. So I messed that up. This is not the best. So I think I've had 59 or whatever it was plus four groups of ivy, which is eight. So like I got like six. I I did badly. I did badly. The washer this I was supposed to have a grouping over here. I specifically wanted to have like a 9-point washer. Um and I did not. So I can't do that now. Um I failed. I did get the basic minimum score and I got the um alchemist and butterfly goal which is 15 points between them with the alchemist and the butterfly whisperer being on the same color flower. And that I did. Um but that's the exact same thing we did in the game play. So yeah, I did the exact same goals again. I still didn't get 80 and I still didn't get the cat scoring seven points with it ending next back to where it started.
You kind of want to have like a a tracing of guess kind of in a circle around uh back to where it started. That's that's that's another gameplay. It's challenging. That's game two for mission three. And um still only got two out of the four goals. In any case, until next time, I'm Alex Radical from Board Gameco. I hope you enjoyed this uh this video review as well as a bonus gameplay at the end. And until next time, I hope you have a good