Aquatica: Discussion
Transcript
viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for aquatica and its new newest expansion cold waters uh so this was a game that uh has been highly talked about at least mainly through the dice tower as you can see it's a dice tower essential for both the base game and the expansion uh and i've heard other reviewers that were talking highly of it and if anyone's watched my channel for a long time whenever you whenever i start talking about what others think i tend to end up disagreeing um this is an okay game i don't think it is i don't think it's bad but i don't think it's like amazing either yeah uh it is it has a cool it has a cool gimmick with the sliding up cards yeah it has the freedom to do some pretty cool combos which i like and i will say when you and i play that i hated this at two like that's why we didn't record it because i'm like there must be something missing here uh in a two huh a person yeah a third person honestly um and i think three feels really good this game wasn't overly long because the game doesn't have enough depth i think to have it be really long it was about an hour um but at two players it was too short like because whenever you play the matrona um you discard that card so this deck kind of goes through uh really quick you go we played
with the goals uh which come in the base game uh and that just felt like they were super simple to get and i was like i didn't get to really do anything at two but three felt like a pretty good um good pacing but yeah it is okay for me what do you guys think yeah i thought it was all right i wouldn't say it's an essential by any means um but yeah yeah yeah nothing really nothing really like stuck out other than like the aesthetic of the game the aesthetic is really good the art it made me want to go upstairs and watch like deep sea stuff right like shark i think it's shark week maybe or it was i think it was last week maybe something that yeah it's a new week now yeah sharks yeah the art is absolutely fantastic i mean we mentioned at the beginning of the run through the the art between the two boxes is radically different that is more realism well not obviously it's more dark gothic like creepy and this is just very vibrant uh for it but they kept the cards the same for the art which i like it's not like so drastically like oh this is very much the expansion right uh so it's cool like i think it's a neat theme but granite the theme could be anything yeah it's an abstract game with athena pretty much yeah brett what do you think um i agree pretty much straight down the line as i was so for me i equate it you know as as someone who has not played hundreds of games i i equate its mechanical complexity to
be something like terraforming mars in the sense that um there's just several different ways to score points and you have to balance some resources it's not nearly as complex sure um i was about to say that i'm like no it's nowhere near as hard it's it's a strip it's like a stripped down version of terraforming mars and it makes sense to me um which is not again not my i don't like it when there's several different ways to score points okay um that you have to keep track of because i had absolutely no idea where i was i thought i was doing pretty darn good and then i found it no i'm just a waste of time you would have done good had i not literally looked over and been like oh you have no ways to score i'm going to end the game and you have the ability to do that yeah which is something that i actually like you know you can control the outcome to an extent right each player has an equal opportunity to either delay or let's rush through it yes which i like that as well there's um summer does that uh and a few other games where players dictate the speed of the game yeah um together and it becomes kind of a strategy of its own like it ended up being where i was like huh because i remember when you and i played with at two players you were kind of doing the you were going for the locations i'll let you score other locations and you were kind of getting an uh an engine going where you were popping off uh a little bit well i'm trying to go for the really big points and i'm like okay he's going too quick and i saw you doing that again and i'm like i if i get one more turn that's the thing is because the person who ends it does get another turn so i'm like okay i know the only thing you can do is get
your card back uh so it ended up kind of working out yeah so the odd thing for me is it just feels a little too short for as many options as there are to consider and as much stuff as there is to balance kind of over pretty quickly and i wouldn't want it to stretch on much longer right but it feels like for this level of thinking and planning and there's lots of different options that didn't really come up and i never even bothered recruiting any of these guys um yeah we'll talk about those then yeah it just feels a little a little too short sure to really get something going interesting uh yeah because i didn't feel that way at all like i felt you are limited based off of your options like if in in my case i when i was recruiting i only had the one way to recruit because i never got someone that let me do it even though there's literally a card right here that lets you recruit uh but you're typically your actions are only limited by your cards which i like that has a kind of um mission red planet feel where everyone has the same deck of cards uh but the way your strategies are dictated based off half the order you play them so you only have one way to score and you have to find someone else that lets you do it so you have multiple ways to score recruiting the same way and with the expansion that added the tribes that when you were you were recruiting it was either get another card that's going to help you later or go for points uh but but both i mean that still lowers your mantas yeah and
yeah i was feeling it because i was like oh god i have so much ways to get money but i only have one way to recruit and i used it at the beginning of my that's about the bottom of my discard pile so i have to burn a turn really to get your card back that's kind of the like the pain and there's always any time that there's that mechanic where your actions are dictated by a deck uh or by a hand of cards there's always one words like trying to plan out your turn because you want to burn your turn really because you're just refreshing at the optimal time where your opponents are kind of doing the same thing so i'm not wasting because this game because it is so short uh or a decent a length at best really spending it spending your whole turn to get just get your cards back can hurt yeah um because if you want to set up okay i need this card that lets me buy a location i really or conquer a location i really want that one can i do it in the time that you guys also have to get cards back uh otherwise i'll get my cards back okay i really want that location and okay great you got it all right so now what do i do i do like that um that level of thinking in a game i don't find this game nearly as complex i wouldn't call this a gateway game by any means it would probably be the next step yeah there's not unlike terraformer there's effects
there's like paragraph cards for abilities and things like that that do tie into each other hell even uh fantastic factories that's what it's called even that has kind of a lot more going on in terms of an engine builder yeah this one your effects are there's like five five effects and two resources it's almost it's a slight deck builder it's a hand builder really and i like that you have the locations like you get a little bit of the combos it's not you don't go through the motions like i do this lets me take this your turn like you actually have like some strategies with the locations you want to pick in terms of okay this is going to give me i can move i can use this manta to move this up which can give me more power which and i can use power which allow me to uh increase that now i have the eight i need to be able to buy that location which is going to be eight points so i like it uh cat you have any any further insight on things that you liked did you like the hand management did you like the scoring did you like the locations i like the location did you like the gimmick is of course this board that lets you slide up into it yeah but you can see and strategize what's going to be happening yes yeah i actually did i did like that i did like that part um which is cool but that's not why i play a game but did
what'd you say about rhinos though it's from ace ventura just the way you said neato when you think you're right yeah i just don't remember him saying like that it's kind of yeah it's because he's like taking off his clothes and he's like it's kind of hot in these right yeah he uh yeah because he has a fan and it's like i freaked out it's getting burnt the mother ryan who was giving birth is like what dumb family thinks that they just give birth up their butt yeah well and then yeah oh it doesn't look anything like a baby rhino but it's uh boy it's giving birth anyway yeah back to the that's how the first alien came to earth um yeah we've lost me um yeah i think the one problem i had though with my with my hand management as i was i was so focused on just like getting locations right that i sort of accidentally said it needs a hand and that is that is your ultimate way of getting points i mean that's kind of the theme around it is is exploring exploring the locations and and using up the resources at those locations i mean once again the art is beautiful like i don't know who did the art i never end up really looking it up but the artist is uh fantastic in this i mean the art honestly does give this
game more than just a pasted on theme really like this could have been generic art and it's like the game the game works perfectly fine no matter what the theme is images of fish yeah like i mean that's a lesser gamer's geometric exactly now the way the original game was was you had goals now brett and i are the only ones that have actually played with the goals you have these ones that were just um uh regulars but then you have randomized tokens that you cover those up with um i don't remember exactly what i think uh this the top one was have eight character cards in your hand yep um and it was kind of once again that was a race that was one of the end game conditions was a first one to have eight character cards you take a mountain you put it on there boom that's eight points someone else gets to do it it's gonna be uh less points um oh these are gold tokens well anyway uh the bottom one five locations i think probably five locations scored probably uh in your score well no because that's a score pile oh okay and then you have uh two mantas or something like that or maybe this is filling up actually having five at once yes that's kind of what i was thinking i'm thinking that it was uh but those yeah those are in advance oh here we go uh eight character cards five locations on your player board three or more locations in your score pile and have two or more wild mantas
so cat can't really talk about this but what do you did you which mode do you like more did you like the goals or did you like the the tribal uh to be honest i don't really remember when we played before it was a while ago cool yeah it was a while ago and i didn't even really put any thought into those guys so all right have a hard time talking about that okay so i put i will say no thought into the truth at first i really don't like the idea of having to give up one of these few wild tokens that you can reuse having to give it up permanently in order to actually score winning points you don't like that um at first i don't feel like it but again the game is short enough that it's not as big a handicap as it seems yeah i mean these are these are incredibly useful at the beginning of the game like character cards that you get cards you get locations and you're comboing off that these are otherwise yes if these were the only things you had and it's like uh like i really need the one that lets me raise up a location so oh i guess we'll get rid of this one um so it does work yeah that's just didn't feel right at first what's interesting about the goals is i mean there's variety with both there's a deck of level one uh tribes and deck of level two cards so you're gonna have a different combination and you have uh tokens goal tokens that will randomize how that so i like that yeah uh the goals are interesting because they're easy at least these ones for the basic game are relatively easy these goals in particular you don't have to strive to to get right they will most likely
naturally happen you will i mean i think everyone had at least three uh scorecards yeah so it's just kind of a race this becomes a race it becomes a race for this for and i mean it's a set of eight points no matter what the difference between the two really is this is the race for first player for more points this is a race for it to be cheaper yes because this becomes more expensive for each person's manta on it but not a lot only one only one um this plays up to five now uh with the expand oh okay yep it was original in the four expansion makes it one to five okay and um so yes it could go up this this level one the glu the glutinous could be ten coins yeah if but at that point you wouldn't pay tank ones for four points right um and give up one of your mantas but yeah it does make it a little bit uh more expensive uh i think they're both fine i the goals are are a perfect way to play kind of gives it you don't have you don't have text and you have special abilities with those you only are getting using those to get the points so they're a little more viable you know people have to remember okay so this one gives me a special ability as well as points this one gives me scoring objectives as well as an instant ability uh so this is definitely more complex than the goals and you can't just nice for people who've enjoyed playing this and something more want something more uh but you also have the advanced way to play with the bass game you have the tokens that you shuffle it's like oh
instead of the eight character cards now you need three or more wild mantas okay uh whatever like but they're still the same goals for the same people so once you achieve it there's no more thought this one once you achieve it you're still planning yes yeah so the expansion added these tribes that added cards that there were two sets essentially one set was victory points like flight victory points and an ability of uh passive ability that you always have um and then the other set was kind of end game goals oh at the end at the end of the game if you have a set of you know each location i was like holy [ __ ] i almost did i didn't even plan on doing that um that would be eight points and so it gives you short term long term although again i'm not sure that this game at least the way that we've been playing it has is long term enough for those long long-term goals to really be strategic not to yeah not for them to be like amazing or or it would be more reactionary yeah oh i have i i have a complete set i should recruit that you need a blue one oh sorry you're right i know i needed i actually needed a red one no there are five okay there is a there is a red one but there are five sets yeah um but typically i mean i was honestly surprised the reason why i even explained why i was getting the points i got was because it was you had so many it was a massive it was a point swing yeah uh it was i think i had 40 something you had 20 and i was like oh i
thought you were way closer um i thought it was a [ __ ] loser in case um oh this would have gotten me 15 just for two of them and 20 if i got all three of them out so that would have tied us if i had gotten all three of these scored yeah and you'd get anything else right because i only got uh nine points off of these two yeah but even then yeah so i mean typically if if you were able to score the scores would be a lot closer that yeah you're not going to get a bunch of points off of this or what's not a high scoring game no so it only takes two or three to right and honestly with these you actually have a little bit more ways to play because i didn't even think of this at first with the goals those are just a flat you did this boom here's here's uh you know flat points like let's say the y's for example eight victory points for each set of five different location types if you're wondering if you want to go for that you're not going for these long ones you're going for the free ones that are oh free boom and you're go you can probably get two maybe three full sets i mean you'd have 15 cards in here but if you just went for the cheap ones like you would be able to and that would that would be 24 points which wouldn't be nothing yeah you'd be getting jack [ __ ] from these but you'd have 15 of them so it does allow for way more variety with the tribe so for me i actually like both um but if i if you want the more complex complexity yeah the the cold waters expansion is
great it adds more to the game like more if you're if you already love the base game then yeah cold waters is a no-brainer in getting yeah um so yeah i mean you guys didn't even touch this how come i already said it with my cards i was focused on getting locations and i just have a hard time keeping track of all the different ways to score points so i honed in on the one that i knew would work and hoped that that would be enough but i also in the back of my mind i was going i wonder how balanced it is or do you really really need to get into those yeah oh this changes the yeah this changes what sorry i was kind of wondering that at the beginning too like i wonder if we even need to bother that we definitely wanted to do that i did this for the run through because we had the expansion and because i knew with the cards getting shuffled in you might not see oh what what what cards do the quadco cold waters bring in this was a very obvious change um but yeah i mean i would honestly say pretty balanced like i mean i had i had i had one of each type this one um i could discard one character to to you know delve one and then also this one was an instant that just let me move up three uh but and i so i got nine points like i had 42 that put me i'd have like 33 3 yeah not a huge swing but a difference maker yeah not critical but
generally important right yeah it's like of course whenever games like this are or things like this are added to a game generally you want to do dabble a little bit in it yeah because there's no other ways to get points besides your locations in in the with the goals it was just yeah you're gonna do it you may not get all the points you know you may not get max eight points but at least you'll get three you'll get something here if you don't touch the ball you get nothing you get nothing you lose good day sir um so actually yeah the more i the more i'm talking about it at first when we were done with the game i was kind of like i was like oh yeah okay yeah i was like this is okay strongly okay um this is a hard just flat line this is a great mediocre but yeah the more about as great as mediocre the more the more i'm talking about yeah the more it actually has a little more depth to it and for that for this game making me make a pun it is a [ __ ] one but i honestly i think it's because i like the expansion i like what it whether that's i like the tribes yep um so yeah yeah that is aquatic you guys got anything else that you want to say nothing but i want to hear you rate it not only playing the game but also talking about it because those were different ratings in your mind oh um for the record though ivan tozowski has a phd in cultural studies
oh cool yeah so anyway yeah initially yeah so that's just a little bit about that's a little bit about ivan oh actually i will say this rule book is not great okay uh i don't really care for it just the way because there were two things that i was like i'm missing it when it talks about hey you can explore resources it mentions like moving up to use them which is obvious now hey these are just for i can do this as an action yes as many times as i want um but you but then there's another effect on cards that let you quickly advance but you don't get the stuff that's not really explained they went for hey we want people to like just kind of jump in but it's a relatively kind of thick rulebook and i mean each page is really dedicated to one action but i think that a little bit more clarification would help for example maybe or examples yeah there's there's a few in here but it's not it's not the worst rule book but it's definitely not the best yeah um i'm not sure that we played it that you could move these up multiple times the first time yeah because we just didn't catch that was possible right we thought you had to use the effect to move it up and that's how you got the stuff yeah yeah yeah and that and i was like that doesn't work and i really wish they had a player aid player aid to tell you what the i mean
there's there's there's probably one online but i don't it's games aren't fixer-uppers i shouldn't have to you know or they're not i shouldn't have to do your job for you yeah um like in here you have like a page dedicated to what goal tokens do what reference sheets and what effect or what resources and effects are um because then the expansion that adds that copy ability and it says you can't copy resource you can copy effects and it's like oh okay well is this card the one that says i get plus two power for it for conquering that particular location is that an effect or is that a resource it sounds like both and in the rulebook it does state that that's listed under under resource yeah so just i mean very little things like that but yeah on a scale of one to ten this was initially a five it was a five the first time we had played it as well at two um but i think i'm honestly gonna talking about it more and kind of analyzing some of the you know intricacies that the expansion brings in and it does do cool kind of engine slight engine light engine building combos um i'm getting seven so that will be that's my score that's six more than i was gonna get no i'm gonna give it a six though okay slightly above average yeah neat uh i would say the base game six but with the expansion seven okay yeah awesome yeah that's that's a good way of putting it um because i was doing it all as a whole the expansion does
make the game better uh and yeah so awesome okay so that's our thoughts on aquatica and the expansion cold waters let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time i do this for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it that's for you