Cat In The Box Card Game Review
Transcript
this episode of brains on games will talk about cat in the Box a Quantum trick taking game welcome to brains on games I'm Dr Brian McDonald in this episode we are going to talk about cat in the box which is a trick taking game and you know I love trick takers that comes from bezier games here is the box with the cat on it cat in the box is a game for between two and five players the box says ages 14 and up but you know 10 year olds can figure this one out if they're familiar with trick taking games even probably nine-year-olds could play this one and games play in about half an hour let's take a deeper look at cat in the Box cat in the box is a light game in terms of its strategy and complexity uh and it's a game where you're trying to be the player who has the most points at the end of the game you earn points by winning tricks it is a trick taking game and by the placement of your player tokens on This research board and I'll explain how those get placed like most trick taking Games you start by dealing out an even number of cards the next thing that you get to do though is you discard one of them so you play one face down in front of you so there's one card in your hand that doesn't get used and then you predict the number of tricks you think you're going to win and you do that by putting a token on your player board like this so if red thinks that
they're going to win three that's where that token is going to go these recessed player boards are double-sided and depending on the number of players the cards in your deck are going to vary depending on the number of players so we planted a three player count and that meant that the highest number that you're going to see in the deck it goes up to six and with four and five players it can go up to nine once you've dealt out those cards and you predicted how many of those tricks you're going to win then you start playing cards now the first player to lead in a game of cat in the box is the the person who most recently encountered a cat and they're going to play a card from their hand here's where it gets tricky though okay this is a trick taking game and that means that you've got a trump suit and that's going to be the most powerful suit in the game all the other suits are pretty much the same so red is Trump all the other suits have the same weight so it's different from that game Thrones of Valeria that we talked about a couple of episodes ago where each suit has a different Rank and higher ranks can Trump all the lower ones the the blue and the yellow and the green are all the same rank it's only the red that's going to be the Trump but it does get tricky because all of the cards in your hand are black and this is why they say it's a Quantum game you read the rule book and they talk about this as being an experiment rather than a card game but all of the cards in your hand are black and the color or the suit gets determined or observed as you play the
card so if I were the red player here and I had a six in my hand and I wanted to play a blue six I would put it beside the blue and then I would put my token on the blue six to show that nobody else can play a blue six of course there's only going to be one blue six in the deck there are lots of sixes though in that deck but nobody else can play blue because that's already been taken up on the board there needs to be a space on the board for you to play a a card so I could play a green one if I were Blue by putting it down there and then I would put a green a token on the green six like that now of course the way that you play trick taking games is that if you have a card in your hand that's the same suit as the one that's been LED you have to play that card you can't play a card from a different suit unless you have no cards of that color in your hand now which is weird with this game because all the cards are black so I I could play I I don't have to play a blue card if that's what's been LED I could play a red one if I want to win that trick because red is the Trump suit but to do that I have to show that I have no blue cards in my hand so if I play a card from a different suit from the one that's been LED I have to take this token off my player board and that's the one that I put onto the research board up here what does that mean well what that means is I've got an X here on Blue I can no longer play Blue
cards for the rest of the game so none of my tokens can go in this row now strategically I've won that trick I'll take these cards into my in front of me if I'm the blue player they go face down in front of me that's going to potentially earn me one point at the end of the round but I might get stuck as this board fills out because I cannot play anything in this row so the timing of when you decide I'm going to play a card from a different suit is tricky because you might want to win the the trick but you you don't want to be stuck with cards in your hand that can't be played so the winner of the trick is going to be the one that leads the next card and maybe they'll play a you know a yellow four and then I'll take that token and put it on the yellow four and then the other players are going to play it continues that way until each player has only one card left in their hand so you're going to be able to hang on to one card that doesn't have to be played but the round might end early if a paradox is created now what is a paradox well if a player gets stuck and they cannot play a card from their hand then everything stops nobody wins that round so that trick doesn't get taken and instead you start counting up points because the round is over the player who caused the Paradox the player who was unable to play a card on the board because the spaces were filled up for the cards that they had in their hand that player is going to get negative
points for each trick that they've won so far in the game so 513 I'm not getting plus three points I'm getting minus three points everybody else gets to add one point for each of those tricks that they won now if they also predicted the correct number of tricks if the red player here won three then they get bonus points and those bonus points are based on the placement of their tokens on the board you look at the largest group of adjacent tokens and you get one point for each of those so in this case if I've won three tricks and I've got my tokens laid out like this I would get three points plus one two three four additional points so the bonus points can jump up pretty quickly now the other thing I would say is that if if the blue player caused it Paradox even if they did win the right number of Tricks they don't get those bonus points so they don't get anything added on it's only a negative based on the number of tricks that they won so you can you can dig yourself into a hole if you're not careful about how you play those cards onto the board and that's the game you continue playing rounds until each player has had a chance to be the first player once and then you add up your points or subtract your points on your score pad here that comes with the game and then the player with the most points is going to be the winner now what skills are you working on when you play a game like cat in the Box well this is one where you do have a spatial component unlike most trick taking card
games there is a visual spatial problem solving element to this because you're looking at creating a group of tokens that will earn you bonuses at the end of the game on top of that though you might start out by trying to win your three tricks but then you have to lose the rest so that you can get that bonus you might be trying to lose you might be trying to win you might find yourself having to adjust your strategy because the card that you wanted to play has been filled up on the board it's a game where uh you need to be flexible in your approach and you're you're constantly adjusting your strategy I think on the Fly and when we're talking about flexible problem solving that is an example of fluid reasoning pattern recognition is a good example of a fluid reasoning skill and and you are kind of trying to figure out uh some patterns here in the way people are playing and and you're creating those patterns on the board as well so it's a fluid reasoning game with the spatial component so what are the final thoughts though about cat in a box well look it's a trick taking game so automatically it's going to earn some points in my book because I love that mechanism you've got great compo opponents you've got these recessed player boards in the deluxe edition at least you've got these great tokens that are translucent and have some you know this one has apples and there's beakers and I could pull out the other ones here but it's just going to make a lot of noise uh so so you've the components are wonderful the artwork on the cards I
really like these cats sometimes you've got sleeping ones and so and they've got little splotches of color even though they're mostly black so the artwork is great it is sort of a joy to play and it's a game that reveals itself to you as you play it at first you might be playing it like a pretty traditional trick taking game but it doesn't take long before you realize a few things about it first you start to recognize the importance of I need to place my tokens in a certain way on this board but also you might start to notice that a lot of this game is about trapping the other players it's not necessarily just about earning your bonus points and making sure your things are laid out properly you need to trap the other players so that they cause that Paradox and you need to do that at the right time so that you've already got your hands have been won it's it's easy to to get stuck in the Paradox trap because you've got these four suits so you know they're only going to be four fours that you can play on here however there are more than four fours in the deck there are more than four sixes in the deck so you know players are going to have cards that they will probably not be able to play and you can very quickly get stuck in a paradox because all the fours have been filled up and all I have left in my hand are two fours and another card that doesn't have a space that I can play oh the the only four that's available is blue and I've already showed that I have no blue
cards left in my hand so it it's so much about avoiding getting caught in a paradox but catching the other players this is a trick taking game that that definitely has more of a take that sort of element than uh Thrones of Valeria for example which does have those take that but Thrones of Valeria which I talked about a couple of episodes ago Thrones of Valeria is a trick taking game where each card that you play is giving you some bonus so there is a lot more focus on one of am I getting in addition to how am I how am I targeting the other players hear it's so much about catching the others in a paradox and not getting caught at least in the games that we played what are the downsides of cat in the Box well this is a great trick taking game but you do find yourself sometimes getting stuck like you're playing cards that don't necessarily Advance your plan you're just trying to get rid of them or you're stuck there's no other thing you can play you're not going to win the trick that you wanted to win or it's just a card that's useless to you so you're not getting necessarily a bonus each time you play maybe the bonus would be oh I can make my my token group a little bit bigger this turn or create a second group but uh it's it's not one where like with Thrones something is happening that's beneficial to you with each card that you play with this one sometimes you might just be forced to
play a card and that's sort of what you're trying to do to the other players force them to play a card that's going to mess them up I would rank this in in terms of my you know I do love trick taking games but I would rank cat in the Box as being similar to the crew now the crew is another great trick taking game it's it's a Cooperative game where you've got certain missions that you have to do and you're winning or losing tricks um so the crew is a fantastic game and I I Feel The Cat In The Box ranks itself right there with the crew for me Thrones of Valeria is still the highest one it's still my favorite trick taking game because I love that you get bonuses every time and each play is like you you know everybody's going ah what did you do oh you messed me up uh and when we played together we did play a bunch of games of Cat in the box but you know my son and his friend were beginning to ask okay we take Thrones out again because we like that one a little bit better so we like this game a lot doesn't quite make it all the way up for us uh to to the Thrones level this is much more about the take that the sabotaging of the other players plans uh and if that's a mechanism that you really like then this is going to be right up your alley and like I said with the great components it is a joy to put this out on the table and that in a nutshell is Cat in the box so before we wrap things up though I just have a couple of housekeeping things that I wanted to take care of today one is a correction last episode we talked about the Wolves and the main
downside for me of my copy of the Wolves is that there was no paper rule book I had to download a rule book and read it from my tablet well I've gotten a couple of comments on that video and there is in fact a paper rule book That's supposed to be in the box but somehow that was left out of my copy so the Wolves does have a paper rule book or is supposed to have a paper rule book in the box so my comments about that in the last episode aren't correct I didn't get that copy but if you go out to the store and pick up a copy of the Wolves it probably will have a rule book inside the number two thing I wanted to mention is that last week I got a whole bunch of games in the mail a whole pile of things came in over the holidays and so I put a poll up on YouTube asking you know is there a game that you're interested in hearing more about and the winner of that Apple was undaunted Stalingrad that's going to be what I'm learning this week that's going to be the video for next week undaunted Stalingrad is what we're going to talk about the undaunted games are deck building war games so they've got that historical World War II Focus but the Stalingrad game is a campaign game so your your deck and your cards are going to evolve as you play through each Mission so undaunted Stalingrad is what we'll talk about next time if you have any questions or comments or suggestions you can leave them in the comment section below the video or you can email me at Brian brainsongames.ca brainsongames.c is the website that's where future episodes ago the previous ones are up there already brains on games is the Twitter handle
and the Facebook page and the Instagram feed so we're all over the place and if you enjoyed this video and you want to be notified of future ones you can head on over to YouTube and click that subscribe button thanks for joining me and hopefully I'll see you next time