Skip to main content
Loading video...

Keyflower Board Game Review - Still Worth It?

Transcript 11:03

hello welcome back to the channel this is a channel where we give you reviews play throughs unboxings we generally like to talk a load of bollocks about tabletop gaming in general and in this video we're gonna be talking about a 2012 euro style tile line game we're going to be talking about key flower and in this game you'll be bidding on tiles placing them into your village you'll be using your tiles or maybe your opponent's style to give you victory points that will allow you to win the game so in this video i'm going to be giving you a very brief overview of the rules we tell you what we do like we don't like and then we'll come back and we'll say whether or not key flower is still worth your time with bother 10 years after it was first bloody released it seems like it was released yesterday so remember if you knew it please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment in that section down below hit the like button and all that bollocks and we'll see you after this bollocks so key flower takes place over a certain number of seasons spring summer autumn and winter you're going to sort the tiles out into piles depending what season icon they've got on them and you're going to chuck all the meeples in the bag except for the purple meeples hello future mia just a look at this and i've made a mistake i've mistakenly mistaken green maples full purple meatballs for some bizarre reason it's not on color blind it's probably just that i'm a [ __ ] idiot but then you

knew that stop [ __ ] about crack on who are so a little bit special below me you're gonna reach into the bag and give every player eight random colored meeples you're going to give them a player screen and you're going to give them free winter tiles from the pylon so the way this game works is that each tile has got six sides right and depending on where you're sitting on the table you'll have a side of the hex allocator if you've got six players every player is going to have a side of the hex allocated to them right and you do this in like a logical manner if you have got any kind of logic whatsoever so first thing you're going to do is you're going to set up the new season right you're going to set up the boats we're going to stick a load of meeples on the boats right you're going to set up the turn all the tiles which you can bid on in order to go first second third fourth in the next round we'll draw new season tiles and in the winter bit of this select which winter season tiles you're going to want to use from your hand right so there's only two things you're going to be doing in this game you're going to be either bidding on a tile that's in the central display or you're going to be using a tile whether it's your own tile or your opponent's tile right if you're going to be bidding on a tile you'll take one of your meeples and you'll place it along the edge of the hex your edge of the hex what we were talking about a couple of minutes ago if you've got a memory of a goldfish you're going to remember either but you'll stick it next to the side of the toilet is allocated to you there's a couple of things you've got to remember here is that if there's already a meeple on the tile or if the tile has already been bit on you have to follow the color so if there's already a yellow meeple on the

tile then it stands to reason you're gonna have to put a yellow maple on the side right so you also gotta remember that you've got a bid at least one more than the previous bit and there can never be more than six meeples on a tile at once and if you get booted out you can use that meeple to increase the bid somewhere else or start a new bid on a toll that don't have any bits right so if you want to use a tile you can either use your own tile or you can use somebody else's you'll just place the meatball on the tile and you'll take the action associated with that tile so you might have the fare and this allows you to convert one red meatball into two green meeples all you might have to store and this converts one blue worker into one green worker one thing about this is you can pay the relevant resources to upgrade atari and you flip it over and then it becomes a more powerful version of the previous thing right so if you have upgraded the hiring fare it allows you to turn one tool in the free tools and likewise if you upgrade the mason then you can trade in one pickaxe for free gold right so it's in your interest not only to bid on these things but also to get resources to upgrade them as well right so if you want to use a tile that is some distance away from your starting tile you can use what's called transport which is the donkey symbols to transport goods to that tile so say if you wanted to use a tile that required a couple of stone right and you've got stone on your starting hex you can use the transport donkeys to move that so many spaces like one hex per donkey so once you are done you'll do a little bit of cleanup any unsuccessful bids all the meeples will go back to you any successful bids they'll go back into the bag likewise if

somebody else has bid on the tiles in your village you get to keep those meeples right so if you have a load of attractive tiles in your village then you're going to be able to gain more nipples and stick them behind your screen right so next thing you're going to do is you're going to resolve the turn all the tiles depending on how many players are there's going to be a certain number of these and whoever wins the number one turn order tile will go first second third fourth and all that sort of [ __ ] yeah and then any of the tiles that you want in the auction you'll be able to expand your village it's got to be like for like so it's like carcassonne or archipelago where you've got a match to rain types as you place it and you'll keep doing this you'll keep going through all the seasons until you get the window and then you'll get to choose at least one of the winter hexes you can put into play and then you'll do a bit of final scoring right you'll be able to exchange a purple meeple which is like a wild card meeples you can use a purple meeple as a green red or yellow maple or whatever you want to do you can exchange these meatballs for a skill token or a resource right and you'll score each village tile you get the victory points that are on the tile and then if you haven't used any gold you get one victory point for that and whoever has the most victory points at the end of the winter round will be the winner of key flower so what do we like about key flower so the first thing that we really like about this is that the auction system is done really really well it's not going to be very messy is it because you'll be able to see exactly who's bid what and when and the thing is is anything you bid isn't actually wasted you're going to be able to take them off if you get outbid and you'll be able to either start a new auction or you'll be able to add to an auction that you have already got meeples involved in right so reminds

us a little like the auction mechanism in psychiatrists where if you're kicked out you have to go somewhere else and that can disrupt the plans of others and where there's always so many tiles in this game to have a look at you're going to be second guessing where your opponents are going to be going if you kick them out right say you might kick them out one toll and then they'll come back and bite you in the ass on another one so the second thing that we really like about key flower is that when opponents use your tiles you get to keep the tiles that they dump there and where you always have to put more meeples on the tiles than there were there previously it may be the case if you've got some lucrative tiles then people are going to want to use them and you end up with a huge posse of maples on the tiles right and this also works against you right you might end up gifting other people meeples right if they have the lucrative tile so this makes the auction of the tiles that much more important you're going to have to make a decision as to whether or not it's going to be more beneficial for you to block your opponent or whether or not it's going to be more beneficial for you let them have that tile when you take something else so the final thing that we like about key flat is that the bidding in turn order is a very very important mechanism this because it means that you get first dibs on the new tiles that are going to come out each season but it also means you're you could be taking valuable meeples away from yourself that could be used to buy the really really powerful tiles that are in the center of the table right so this game seems to be about choices and decisions there's these agonizing choices in this game should i be doing this is this going to benefit me more than this both options are lucrative and fantastic but it's trying to weigh up which one of those

more lucrative options is going to be the best and most efficient so what do we like about key flower so the first thing that we don't like about key flowers is it's a massive table hog especially with a high plague house and usually these days we normally play with five or six people at the table right so when you're playing a six player game it's gonna take up the whole of our five foot table and even then there's not going to be a lot of space left over so just bear this in mind that if you are thinking about playing key flower with high play accounts say five or six you're gonna need a big table don't try and play this on a [ __ ] bistro table all right so the second thing that we don't like about keyflat and this leads on from the previous point about being a table hog is that if you are playing with the massive sprawling six player five player game then it's gonna be very difficult a for you to see what your opponent's tiles are and b it's going to be very difficult for you to remember them all because there's going to be loads and loads of tiles to remember right so it might be the case aunt mabel has maybe got the mason and you really need that you can't really see what she's got you can't really remember because you're thinking about what uncle derek has got over there that does seem to be a lot to take in a lot to remember a lot of variables a lot of icons to remember and it can muddle your brain somewhat so the final thing and the thing that [ __ ] me off the most about this game is that the rule book is too dense for a game of this sort of simplicity i mean there's not very simple games that you're going to be either bidding on at all you're going to be using at all right that's it obviously there's a few more nuances

little fiddly rules to remember but the rule book is massive it's a big chunky [ __ ] off rule book with dense text loads of examples and i just found myself getting lost in there and that makes the game a complete bastard to teach it's not set out in a logical way the best way to teach this is to go on the internet and get a rule summary and just go through that it's a one page rule summary the breaks are going down right so really the rule book is sort of throw away it's just too meaty too chunky and it reminds me of dog food so to summarise is key flower still worth your time with bother today and in the future so we're going to say yes absolutely being fans of eurogames this is well now one of our favorite toll line games of all time right it's got a fun and innovative auction system that presents you with some really really interesting choices to make it can sprawl across a table and with higher play accounts this can make it very difficult to remember what all the tiles do and that sort of might mean that you slip up when making those critical decisions but with all that aside this is an enduring euro game that plays up to six and that's one of the reasons why we like it so much because it really does slot into those higher player accounts that we seem to be knocking out these days so yeah the goddess key flower highly recommended eurogame if you like that sort of thing remember if you're new here consider subscribing to this channel eh leave a comment in that section down below like this video right bollocks and we'll see you

next tuesday

you

Progress saved