Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Isle Of Cats - Board Game Review

Transcript 5:53

welcome to allies or enemies where we look at board games and how they work for two players this time we are taking a trip to the iowa cats a one to four player game designed by frank west that has players trying to rescue cats from an exotic island before they are all murdered by the evil pirate vesh which is both super cute and kind of hardcore the isle of cats is a tile placement game that is a bit heavier than you might expect though there is a lighter family mode we should also point out that we are using the kickstarter version which has a few upgraded bits but let's talk about that after we look at how it plays isle of cats is a polyamino tile placement game if you don't know what that means think tetris but with cats each player has a boat that's broken into several sections and they're given five rounds to fill these sections with cats what adds a level of complexity and a few twists however is that the normal tile placement mechanics are mixed with cards each turn you will draw seven cards when you're going to take turns drafting and passing these cards around the table these might include baskets to catch cats boots to speed up your cat catching cards for special oh shacks cats and treasures and a particularly interesting type of card which is lessons lessons are basically score cards and they come in both private and public versions they give you goals like having a certain number of cats in one color or

filling certain rooms with cats or having so many treasures and once chosen they're put aside until the end of the game for scoring it's an interesting evolving point system that's easy enough to understand but you're gonna need a game or two to really get the hang of how to effectively manipulate it the blend of tiles and cards makes for some slightly thinky choices and a rewarding puzzle but if you want to pare it down a bit there's also a family version that takes out a bunch of that complexity and mostly just focuses on those cats i love cats is a great looking game whatever version you have the tiles are thick the cards are quality and the art is fantastic all of the cats look majestically disinterested in the best possible way a lot of touches go over and above like the wooden cats use to mark the chosen color of oshak's or the island board or the different sea creatures on the start boards and of course the spot for actual cats inside the specifically reinforced lid the one tricky is that the five fish token really does look like three as mentioned we splurge for the slightly fancier version that adds wooden fish larger player markers and a few extra stacks of rule cards but the cardboard fish and regular cats work just fine if you want to save 20 bucks card drafting games tend to work a little bit different as two-player experiences and that's no different here in a three or

four player game you feel a bit more free to choose what you want whereas with two you're often gonna be trying to keep cards away from your rival you'll also obviously see less cards during a draft which can be good or bad depending on what you draw and what your opponent draws other than that however most of what you're doing is collecting and placing cats which is kind of an individual experience and with fewer players there are fewer cats in the market each round so your available ratio of cats to person isn't really going to change we have so far only played with two and while it might be a smidge more dynamic with more we definitely have not felt like we are missing anything and there's also a solo mode with various difficulty levels if you do want to take on the ai there is something about laying down and connecting tiles that is inherently interesting i don't know why but humans love putting shapes next to other shapes and isle of cats is no different filling the ship with a bunch of different shapes of cats is really satisfying and remain satisfying for quite a few plays what isle of cats does well however is adding the layer of cards and because you will draw different lessons or goals each game and because you'll end up with half a dozen or so by the end of the game your aims will always be slightly different and so will your game it's a bit of nice built-in variation that works really well

the isle of cats is a quirky idea that most will want to love even before they play it the good news is that the gameplay more than lives up to the theme it does a great job of carving out a niche alongside games like barron park by adding a bit more complexity and a few twists that make for a different enough experience to warrant adding it to your collection even if you have a few of these polyamino games already the lesson system and card drafting might be a touch tricky to effectively use it first especially for people who are newer to these kinds of games but it shouldn't be too far of a reach and it's a great step up for anyone with another tile placement game under their belt it's almost certainly a bigger experience and a bigger box than you were expecting and that is it if you've played the isle of cats let us know what you thought did you also spring for the kickstarter stuff and what other tile placement games are you playing right now also please do like and subscribe and hopefully we will see you all next time for another game

Progress saved